how do mobos just randomly die?

SticKx911

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Mar 14, 2004
Messages
3,208
my setup was working 100% yesterday. today I come to it completely powered down...I rarely shut it off I just let it sleep. I turn it on and walk away (my bios takes forever to load). I come back and the screen is blank. no I get no post, no bios, no display...nothing. I did try 2 other video cards...so I'm now glad I invested in the 2 year replacement warranty.

sorry, just had to rant.
 
wow, I am an idiot. long story short, my board is up and running again...

long story long...
when I put my system together my 4pin power connector was blocked by my radiator so I had to splice the wires and tuck them in. I am impatient and the job was poor, but it worked. I suppose crappy wiring jobs always have a way of showing themselves. While waiting on ASUS to call me back I figured if I were to be out a board for a few weeks I'd at least try everything I could. so I took it apart and redid my 4 pin connection. It's still not perfect as I do not want to solder to the board and ruin my chances for being able to replace it in the future if needed, but I think I did a much better job with it this time. I got lucky the wiring job didnt short the board, so lesson learned...the difference between a good job and great job is usually just a few extra minutes, and they're totally worth it.

sorry to clutter the forum with my dumbness at times.... ;)
 
haha, I had a friend that was trying to figure out where the fan noise was coming from in his pc, so he stuck a skrewdriver in to stop the fan on the psu but hit a heat sink and shorted it out. Guess you got lucky nothing shorted out. Electricity is fun.
 
In the past the most usual form of a dead motherboard was cheap capacitors. With the solid capacitors being made today, that is usually not an issue. Other things can be overheating and static electricity just to name the most common problems.
 
In the past the most usual form of a dead motherboard was cheap capacitors. With the solid capacitors being made today, that is usually not an issue. Other things can be overheating and static electricity just to name the most common problems.

I agree, add using cheap power supply doesn't help the matter either.
 
unclean power from the wall will destroy power supplies, especially cheap ones, which can then take out more pieces down the line. usually the elecrolytic caps on the mobo either overheat or dry out and fail.
 
I agree, add using cheap power supply doesn't help the matter either.

I completely agree with you Man! This is an area were many people "cheap out" when building a system, or purchasing a proprietary system! Many of the manufactures were notorious for putting crappy power supplies in the cheaper systems that were sold for 4 or 5 hundred bucks.

I'm going to go with it's likely a power issue.

Ah, sure could be! I would suggest that testing the wall outlet for proper ground and testing the + voltage rails on the power supply for proper voltages be the next very important step:eek:
 
haha, I had a friend that was trying to figure out where the fan noise was coming from in his pc, so he stuck a skrewdriver in to stop the fan on the psu but hit a heat sink and shorted it out. Guess you got lucky nothing shorted out. Electricity is fun.

He shorted out a heat sink?
 
Oh yeah, Cheap PSU or cheap capacitors (not solid tops) are generally the first thing I look for when I think bad mobo. Next is Heat, Heat, Heat!
 
no they are not energized....if a heatsink is energized, it's because of a problem elsewhere, heatsinks are heatsinks, not conductors by design

a heatsink is insulated by thermal paste/adhesive which keeps it stuck to the chip, there's never a metal to metal connection unless it is to a ground

the fan guard is also only connected to the grounded body of the psu

if your friend closed a circuit by touching the fan guard to something else in the power supply it was not the heat sink, it was probably the mosfet that is being cooled by the heatsink, but he actually touched the mosfet leg, not just the heatsink

Well, these guys seem to think otherwise, but I guess they're wrong too.


EDIT: damn they're saying it again here: http://www.jonnyguru.com/forums/showthread.php?t=4449
 
Last edited:
Well, these guys seem to think otherwise, but I guess they're wrong too.


EDIT: damn they're saying it again here: http://www.jonnyguru.com/forums/showthread.php?t=4449

well that would be the first i heard of it, i stand corrected, at least based on the Johnny Guru discussion......it does make sense, you would get better thermal conductance if you dont insulate the connection....but it's awfully unsafe and not "typical" from what i know......i guess if they are not exposed it's considered ok
 
Thermal compound alone will not insulate a heatsink from the device it is attatched to. You can get insulated mounting kits but afaict they cost money and reduce thermal performance so they are only used when there is actually a need to isolate the heatsink.
 
I have only had something like two boards just go out on me in my 5 years of experience.

My friends AsRock P55 Extreme went kamikaze and the VRMs blew up. I ended up buying his RMA board and it has been running in my rig perfectly.
 
nobody_here said:
no they are not energized....if a heatsink is energized, it's because of a problem elsewhere, heatsinks are heatsinks, not conductors by design

a heatsink is insulated by thermal paste/adhesive which keeps it stuck to the chip, there's never a metal to metal connection unless it is to a ground

the fan guard is also only connected to the grounded body of the psu

if your friend closed a circuit by touching the fan guard to something else in the power supply it was not the heat sink, it was probably the mosfet that is being cooled by the heatsink, but he actually touched the mosfet leg, not just the heatsink.
I don't know what got shorted here, but I've seen old PSUs from Leadman (Powmax), Delta, Enermax, and Antec (SmartPower by Channel Well) with heatsinks connected to high voltage DC from the big capacitor, and I traced out the circuit boards of two of them, including the Antec (accidentally shorted heatsink to case, no damage). Apparently heatsinks are connected to high voltage DC because it's a low impedance path to ground that helps block transistor noise, but they're not connected directly to ground because that could be dangerous if the PSU is ever run without an earth ground (the thin insulators on the transistors aren't considered safe enough for shock protection). AFAIK, Seasonic and Fortron/Sparkle never connect heatsinks to high voltage.
 
well that would be the first i heard of it, i stand corrected, at least based on the Johnny Guru discussion......it does make sense, you would get better thermal conductance if you dont insulate the connection....but it's awfully unsafe and not "typical" from what i know......i guess if they are not exposed it's considered ok

It is pretty typical, I accidentally touched the heatsink in my old xbox 1 and it shocked me, hurt quite a bit.
 
Back
Top