How Crytek Doomed Crysis 2 For the PC

Question for anyone:

When you first started the game and checked you graphic settings, what was the default setting, High, Very High or Extreme? What card are you using?
 
Despite Ubisoft black listing them they refused to back down on their low score of Assassin's Creed (interestingly they were one of the few that didn't have to backpedal on their review when they realized the game wasn't very good).

Wouldn't you say this leads to an inference that professional reviews in general are not trustworthy but that perhaps that particular magazine may have been?

I think score clustering is the smoking gun. Don't you find it suspicious how there's such a tight consensus here that Black Ops is an 80%-90% game? There is practically NO deviation and they do not reflect a normal range of human opinion:

http://www.gamerankings.com/ps3/960188-call-of-duty-black-ops/articles.html

Yet user scores are pretty evenly distributed at every score:

http://www.amazon.com/Call-Duty-Bla...dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1

Black Ops of course had tons of money behind it. Then you have a game like Deadly Premonition with NO money behind it.

http://www.gamerankings.com/xbox360/943397-deadly-premonition/articles.html

There is nothing even remotely approaching a consensus here and I think the reviewers shared their true feelings on a game they had no financial stake in. IGN gave the game a 2/10, while some others scored it much higher. There is no consensus among users either, but they skew strongly to 5/5 star reviews.

http://www.amazon.com/Deadly-Premon...dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1

To me it seems extremely fishy that professional reviews of Deadly Premonition would follow a normal range of human opinion reflecting various tastes, but all of them think the exact same thing about Black Ops. I could easily see the possibility of someone rating Black Ops a 6/10 and it being a legitimate, non-bashfest review that treats the game fairly while discussing its many flaws. Yet for some reason, giving Black Ops a middling score is completely outside the scope of their consideration, and they've already decided that it will score between 8 and 9.5 before they've even played it.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Wouldn't you say this leads to an inference that professional reviews in general are not trustworthy but that perhaps that particular magazine may have been?

I think score clustering is the smoking gun. Don't you find it suspicious how there's such a tight consensus here that Black Ops is an 80%-90% game? There is practically NO deviation and they do not reflect a normal range of human opinion:

http://www.gamerankings.com/ps3/960188-call-of-duty-black-ops/articles.html

Yet user scores are pretty evenly distributed at every score:

http://www.amazon.com/Call-Duty-Bla...dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1

Black Ops of course had tons of money behind it. Then you have a game like Deadly Premonition with NO money behind it.

http://www.gamerankings.com/xbox360/943397-deadly-premonition/articles.html

There is nothing even remotely approaching a consensus here and I think the reviewers shared their true feelings on a game they had no financial stake in. IGN gave the game a 2/10, while some others scored it much higher. There is no consensus among users either, but they skew strongly to 5/5 star reviews.

http://www.amazon.com/Deadly-Premon...dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1

To me it seems extremely fishy that professional reviews of Deadly Premonition would follow a normal range of human opinion reflecting various tastes, but all of them think the exact same thing about Black Ops. I could easily see the possibility of someone rating Black Ops a 6/10 and it being a legitimate, non-bashfest review that treats the game fairly while discussing its many flaws. Yet for some reason, giving Black Ops a middling score is completely outside the scope of their consideration, and they've already decided that it will score between 8 and 9.5 before they've even played it.

You'll like this little article: http://www.1up.com/do/blogEntry?bId=6228583&publicUserId=5379799 It actually touches on your concerns.

I'm not saying all pubs are trustworthy. I'm saying all of them aren't paid off. A healthy amount of cynicism is wise when reading anything. The thing is you can't say "they are all paid off" just like you can't say "they are all trustworthy". It requires a lot of time and effort to get a feel for which reviewers (not publications, specific people) you believe you can trust and who's opinion you hold as something worth paying attention to (even if you almost never agree with them).
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
^^^Good analysis.

Game reviews have always been questionable since the rise of marketing budgets.
Even user reviews can be influenced by how the "majority" views the game i.e. Crysis 2.

You'll have to be personally interested in a game and take a chance on it to see if you like it or not. Buy retail copies if you want to try games out, trade them in or resell them to gain some of your investment back. You're basically force-feeding yourself when you buy a digital copy, in a way you have to like it because you're stuck with it.
 
^^^Good analysis.

Game reviews have always been questionable since the rise of marketing budgets.
Even user reviews can be influenced by how the "majority" views the game i.e. Crysis 2.

You'll have to be personally interested in a game and take a chance on it to see if you like it or not. Buy retail copies if you want to try games out, trade them in or resell them to gain some of your investment back. You're basically force-feeding yourself when you buy a digital copy, in a way you have to like it because you're stuck with it.

You don't have to like something when you buy it digitally, but it does hurt a bit when you don't. Not that it matters since you can't resell 90% of the PC games released these days anyway.
 
You don't have to like something when you buy it digitally, but it does hurt a bit when you don't. Not that it matters since you can't resell 90% of the PC games released these days anyway.

Yep, Sometimes it pays off and sometimes you bought a turd.
Used to have my eyes glued to Gametrailers when I had a console. Then I started to notice them spiting out questionable reviews.
All the numbers are below 8.0 but somehow the game gets an 8.2, even MSG4 got a very low score for story and I thought it was one of the best told stories on consoles at that time.
 
Yep, Sometimes it pays off and sometimes you bought a turd.
Used to have my eyes glued to Gametrailers when I had a console. Then I started to notice them spiting out questionable reviews.
All the numbers are below 8.0 but somehow the game gets an 8.2, even MSG4 got a very low score for story and I thought it was one of the best told stories on consoles at that time.

I was never a fan of GT's reviews. They were written by multiple different people and yet all scripted and read by one person. There was no personality to them at all. Nothing to indicate who the review is. Also GT's staff are some of the most ignorant moronic people working in games journalism.
 
I never thought crysis was that good in the first place, gameplay was kind of dull and the graphics were cartoonish, much preferred far cry 2

You do realize that Far Cry 2 was not a Crytek product right? People keep mentioning Far Cry 2 but it had nothing to do with Crytek, it didn't even run on the same engine.
 
You do realize that Far Cry 2 was not a Crytek product right? People keep mentioning Far Cry 2 but it had nothing to do with Crytek, it didn't even run on the same engine.

And as a result it was a ginormous piece of shit.
 
You do realize that Far Cry 2 was not a Crytek product right? People keep mentioning Far Cry 2 but it had nothing to do with Crytek, it didn't even run on the same engine.

QFT. Though Dunia is heavily inspired by CryEngine 2. It's what the 4A engine is to X-Ray.
 
And as a result it was a ginormous piece of shit.

I doubt Crytek would have made it good. FC2 had a lot of great ideas and had a ton of potential. It still looks good. The game is just insanely boring, poorly set up, and the checkpoints respawn way to quickly making the game frustrating.
 
I doubt Crytek would have made it good. FC2 had a lot of great ideas and had a ton of potential. It still looks good. The game is just insanely boring, poorly set up, and the checkpoints respawn way to quickly making the game frustrating.

It was also too open. You have no clear sense of direction. The unreliable weapons idea was interesting but overdone. Everything you picked up for much of the game was a rusty piece of shit that jammed during combat. Yeah the game looked good, but lacked substance. Having to drive everywhere was annoying too.
 
It was also too open. You have no clear sense of direction. The unreliable weapons idea was interesting but overdone. Everything you picked up for much of the game was a rusty piece of shit that jammed during combat. Yeah the game looked good, but lacked substance. Having to drive everywhere was annoying too.

Yeah its really too bad. An open world FPS is a great idea, but after FC2 it seems the idea has kind of died out.
 
It's also doomed on the consoles. Mediocre multilayer, short lackluster SP story (that starts halfway in), and most importantly no franchise recognition. They are going to be more disappointed with the performance of this one that the last one.
 
I find this complaining really perplexing. Yes, it is complaining.

Crytek games have ALL been terrible. They've ALL had pretty dull, clinical gameplay. They've had the same setting (until Crysis 2). They've had the same story (blah blah blah, terrorist-esque guys, blah blah, ALIENS OUT OF NOWHERE OH HOHOHO clever "plot" twist) that's been garbage.

I wouldn't be surprised if the majority of the people whining about the graphics not bringing your system to its knees are the same people that always preach that graphics aren't everything.

"Man, those console games sure have such basic stories and gameplay, why don't they ever do something different?"

"WHAT?! Crysis 2 doesn't have unplayable graphics settings and the same shit story and gameplay?! You sold us out Crytek!"

And Crysis did not revolutionize a damn thing in gaming. The only people that really know about Crysis are the ones that want epeen meters. What settings can your box run Crysis at?
 
Wow so I played a good part of the single player. I can run this maxxed out on my rig at native resolution! I'm happy. Games looks nice but feels a bit "consoling" with the close-up view and all. But they did DX9 justice here... I like how the guns shoot. I'm getting used to the suit mechanics, but it RUNS FREAKIN GREAT!

I do see how people can say... in certain areas... that crysis1 looks better than crysis2. But still looks gorgeous. Anyway, my 2 cents...
 
I call BS on this thread. This seems like a lot of panicking, a lot of complaining and a lot of judgement off a crap demo.

First...credentials: I own this game since launch, i have beaten the SP, and have played a few hours of multiplayer. PC in sig, played on Extreme setting with average 50FPS never dipping below 45.

This game was rushed. Simple....we can all agree right? It doesnt have DX11 like promised, its menus (for example the video settings) are consolized, the multiplayer was broken (up until the 1.1 update released yesterday) ranked match servers wouldnt start, and people with dual GPU's (like the 6990) and i think even people with SLI/CF are having screen flickering issues (until 1.1 update fix).

BUT its almost all been fixed in a week. To me thats as close to "perfect out of the box" as you can get. They listened to their forums and removed auto aiming, tomorrow a DX11 patch is being released so go back and look at the game then, it will be gorgeous i bet, and they are (in that patch) adding the standard PC video settings (so no more "normal, extreme" etc settings).
In under a week they released the 1.1 patch which fixed the multiplayer, the flickering screens, and a bunch of other things.
So as far as " Crytek F*ed up crysis!!!! they sold out!!!!" its lame flaming BS. What they did was make a good game, they have in under a week patched it to being a great game, possibly with the DX11 patch the best looking game for PC (like crysis 1 was for PC).

In reality, the issues with this game are simple, and much like most games. A decent multiplayer, but released in a time of First person shooters being a dime a dozen. So its hard to stand out, compared to back when Crysis 1 was released, it was a fairly newish cool take. Guns yes, first person yes, but awesome suit, interesting story? Yes.
So a decent multi-player, and the single player? Eh...i really enjoyed it, and if i had to guess id say it took me 20 hours. Maybe 15? Idk. But it was fun, it wasnt all flash no substance (cough COD cough). It had issues, such as SP wasnt as fun until i could upgrade my stealth so it didnt suck all the energy in 5 seconds.
Overall my biggest issue with the single player was the story was average and the story telling/linear understanding was below average. I finished the game yet i still feel somewhat confused and underwhelmed and in need of a good 10 page wikipedia read of what the story is.

In the end though, if you bought this game day 1 and rated it day 1, it would be a 5 outta 10. Broken MP, fun SP but below average story/plot. If you bought it day 7, and rated it day 7, i think the overall rating should be a 7.5. I want to say 8, but no game with the Plot this game has deserves more than a 7.9. It wasnt stupid, it wasnt BAD, it was just...not deep, not meaningful, not substantial.

So overall, multiplayer? funnish. Singleplayer? Fun. PC specific graphics and settings? good, tomorrow with DX 11 patch? Probably great, maybe amazing. Give this company some credit, they patched almost all the issues in under 7 days of release, and the game will get a big graphics boost in under 7 days of release as well. Like i said, only thing better than that is it being perfect out of the box, and how many games do that now adays?
 
So we should just expect mediocrity now, right? And if no one complained about the issues with the game, do you really think they'd get fixed?

Lol with how the video game industry is going? The same way the american auto industry and the movie industry has gone...yeah expecting mediocrity should be the norm, and hopefully we are surprised and happy when a excellent game does come along. Do i want it that way? No, i want quality games all the time, but where theres money and business, theres cutting corners and low quality work.
Complaining like some on the crysis 2 forum is good, and yeah there should be complaining and "hey mod here are some issues ______, please fix!" But flaming like most of this thread? No.
 
Crytek isn't hurting,Nathan,you must have the console version,admit it. I call BS on you.
 
Lol with how the video game industry is going? The same way the american auto industry and the movie industry has gone...yeah expecting mediocrity should be the norm, and hopefully we are surprised and happy when a excellent game does come along. Do i want it that way? No, i want quality games all the time, but where theres money and business, theres cutting corners and low quality work.
Complaining like some on the crysis 2 forum is good, and yeah there should be complaining and "hey mod here are some issues ______, please fix!" But flaming like most of this thread? No.

This thread is actually pretty tame. You should see the thread in the gaming sub-forum, especially because the double standards are even more evident...
 
If it only took a week to fix, why not release it that way? Damn. It would only take 6hrs of beta testing here to get the issues addressed and then fixed. Could have avoided all of this fire.
 
BUT its almost all been fixed in a week. To me thats as close to "perfect out of the box" as you can get. They listened to their forums and removed auto aiming, tomorrow a DX11 patch is being released so go back and look at the game then, it will be gorgeous i bet, and they are (in that patch) adding the standard PC video settings (so no more "normal, extreme" etc settings).
In under a week they released the 1.1 patch which fixed the multiplayer, the flickering screens, and a bunch of other things.

I don't have a big problem with them patching the game right after release. Games are so advanced these days you almost kinda expect it. What i have a problem with is WHAT they patched. These are simple, stupid things that never should have made it into the retail product. And the DX11 thing...yeah, that's pretty sorry.



I find this complaining really perplexing. Yes, it is complaining.

Crytek games have ALL been terrible. They've ALL had pretty dull, clinical gameplay. They've had the same setting (until Crysis 2). They've had the same story (blah blah blah, terrorist-esque guys, blah blah, ALIENS OUT OF NOWHERE OH HOHOHO clever "plot" twist) that's been garbage.

Your opinion, nothing more. If I told you my list of all the popular games that I thought were total rubbish ( ie.- M.E.) we'd have to start a whole new thread for all the bickering. One man's shitty game is another's man's treasure.
 
Crytek isn't hurting,Nathan,you must have the console version,admit it. I call BS on you.

Nope PC version, and i dont think i ever said crytek is hurting. Not exactly sure what you mean by that.

If it only took a week to fix, why not release it that way? Damn. It would only take 6hrs of beta testing here to get the issues addressed and then fixed. Could have avoided all of this fire.

I imagine theres a deadline, and then the product is taken from crytek and put into production, and from that point on anything they need to fix is considered Post-release and will be a patch. Like deadline is Dec 31 and from that point on the product is done, they go into post-release mode where they test the game and find things to patch, they then prep a patch so once it releases 2 months later, on day 1 they have a patch. Then the community finds more things wrong and 2-4 weeks later patch 2 comes out.
I presume it to be that way, i have no evidence it is.
 
I personally think there aren't "advanced" graphics menus because they just dont need them with DX9. It'd be interesting to see how far back we could go and get playable frames using the different settings. Even with everything on low, Crysis ran like shit on even medium range hardware.
 
Your opinion, nothing more. If I told you my list of all the popular games that I thought were total rubbish ( ie.- M.E.) we'd have to start a whole new thread for all the bickering. One man's shitty game is another's man's treasure.
It certainly is my opinion. But can you dispute the points?

Did Far Cry 1, 2 (not technically Crytek), or Crysis have different settings from each other? Nope, all tropical forested island.

Did they have dissimilar plot lines? Nope.

Was the story exceptional in any of the games? Nope.

Was the gameplay good? Ehhh, depends on who you ask. But they've all been remarkably similar.

I might even go so far as to conjecture that they're all plausibly builds of the same game (or idea). They built Far Cry 1, then decided to redo it later and change what they didn't like, or update it and call it Crysis.

This is a double standard. A lot of the people crying foul moan about console games being the same old stuff recast in new molds, that gameplay surpasses graphics every time, etc etc. are now the same people moaning that Crysis 2 isn't pretty enough. But then when it is pretty enough and crushes your system, they'll moan that it is intolerable to play games on low settings. The game just isn't enjoyable unless it's at 1920x1080 with 16x adaptive supersampled mega anti aliasing (because those jaggies that you don't notice unless you're looking for them are hideous!) and 32x anistropic filtering, anything else degrades the experience! :rolleyes:

IMO: play the game at whatever settings you can and just enjoy it. The game still looks pretty good.

Some of the elements of Mass Effect were pretty wooden. Every time you report something nobody believes you and rolls their eyes, then tells you Saren was a charasmatic leader and convinced you, despite mounting evidence, for example. But it's a character driven story game with pretty strong characters. And a pretty rich and diverse world to explore. You may not enjoy it but it's a well executed game that at least dares to try something different a little bit different in the sequel.
 
Back
Top