Hooray for Insurance!

Filet MP

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 19, 2000
Messages
129
I just heard from the insurance company that there’s a check on the way to me to cover damage of my primary towers (lightning). Guess its time to build a new box. My intent is to use the box for gaming as well as work. I’d like to buy into hardware that will serve me well for 3-5 years if possible.

I was considering the following configuration,and would love to hear what you all think:

ASUS P5AD2 Premium
Intel 3.6 P4 560
PC Power and Cooling Turbo Cool 510 Deluxe Express
Crucial 1 GB PC-4200U DDR2/533
300GB Maxtor Diamondmax 10 plus (16MB cache)
Sony DRU-700A
Creative Audigy2 ZS

Areas that I need some help in include:

1.)What kind of case should I put this in? Pretty is not as important to me as easy to work on. I’m also not looking for a LAN friendly box, as I have a laptop for that.

2.)Can I scrap the Audigy in favor of using the onboad sound the ASUS mobo provides? Is there that much of a difference? I’ll not likely use the system in 5.1/7.1 configuration anyway due to space limitations.

3.)Is the P5AD2 the crème of the current PCI-X mobos? Is there another option that would eclipse it?

4.)I think I want to get a 6800 Ultra as the video card for this rig. Which brand do you suggest, and why?

5.)On the memory front, is there a huge difference between DDR2 (667) 5400 - 1 GB (2 pcs 512) Corsair and the memory quoted above?

6.)To RAID or not to RAID. Should I get 2 of the drives and run them in RAID 0?

7.)Are any of the above listed components sub par for a high end gaming / work machine? If so, what would you replace?

8.)I usually deal with New Egg, but see that Monarch has some decent prices on items as well. Is there any vendors you guys give high marks to, or any that should be avoided at all costs?


Any other advice or words of wisdom are appreciated.
 
5k :eek: damn your one lukcy person. why not go for AMD FX 53 939. btw what insurance company you have?
 
first, if you can wait until christmas, do that and get an nforce4.

since you can't do that, tho, try a dual opteron workstation config. 2 240's until dual-core comes out, a 6800 agp, scsi. life is good. duallies are your friend(s). :D
 
Slacker, tell me more of the AMD offerings - I've been mainly an Intel guy in the past, but have no concrete pref. except for wanting the faster of the offerings. I've been seeing big numbers posted on Anand, but have no idea what I should be looking for.

I have State Farm insurance. They were really cool about the whole thing, and its only taken a week from the storm until they cut me a check. Highly recommend them for homeowners insurance. Car insurance is a different story...but I digress.....
 
OK,

Now I'm confused. After I started researching your suggestion, it seems as though I'm finding both the AMD solution (and in some cases) the high end ATIs topping my original specs.

If anyone would care to help me understand which way to jump, I'd really appreciate it.
 
amd is currently the platform of choice. it is as fast as intel, more upgradeable, and cheaper. this means you can get more iron per $. a 6800 ultra is really the top of the line (as much as i hate to admit it - ati !!!!!! here) and any brand is really a good choice. I'd personally look for cool&quiet, but your preference may vary.
i recommend duallies for top-of-the-line performance, some people have used the msi k8t to good results, another possibility is the tyan k8w series, these are the 'workstation' versions with the agp slots.

amd is the better platform because of the way it's designed. everything is on its own "bus" - HT for memory, another HT for southbridge, a pci for other stuff, so everything can talk at once. intel has one big bus, so when cpu talks to memory or to ethernet or sound or whatever, everything else has to be quiet. it's like a party line instead of giving everyone 2 phones. amd chips currently have 3 or 4 hypertransport links at 1.5GB/s each (iirc) and intel has one 800mhz fsb. you do the math.

the other advantage to dual opterons is the embedded memory controllers. as mentioned earlier, each chip has its own memory controller (occupying a HT link). when you have two chips, you therefore have 2 memory controllers. intel's memory controller is on the northbridge, so you don't get 2 with 2 cpus. this allows amd to get quad channel memory with 4 sticks and a numa aware os. numa means the os knows which memory is "closer" to which processor.

for games, a dual processor rig won't go 2x as fast, but what it will do is load balance. if you have a game like ut2004, where graphics is one thread and audio is another, the graphics will execute on one processor, and the audio and any system tasks on the other proc. this yields about 15% gain on 2k4. if you don't believe me, try turning off audio (to simulate it going to another processor) and watch the framerate climb.

so, buy an amd duallie. w00t.
i'd get something like
- a Tiger K8W (S2875ANRF) ($229_
- 4x512 CMX512RE-3200LL ($178 x 4)
- 2x242s ($238 x 2)
- 2 seagate 200sata's ($128 x 2)
- lian li case of your choice ($150)
- dvd burner ($100)
- monitor either cheapo 19" or a good $1k lcd (look around) ($200 crt, $1000 lcd)
- good sound card (again, look around) ($100)
- 2 zalman 7000alcu's ($35 x 2)
- kb & mouse if you need
that's 2293 by my math with crt. well within budget.
dang, i wish I had $5k to buy a computer... :rolleyes:

good luck with your purchase, whatever you decide.
 
btw how many rigs do you need to build? also is the check cashable? i mean you can spend like 2k and the rest put in the bank
 
I like the idea of the pentium 4 3.6. It's the only chip that will support future proof stuff like DDR2 and pci-e. That ASUS mobo is the best of the best, but get an x800XT becuase you'll want the pci slots next to the video card, since I believe there are only 2 pci and 2 pci-e(or maybe 3pci-e?). gig of RAM is nice. Get a chieftec dragon case. Their huge and not as expensive as the Lian Li's, and they have great airflow and look pretty nice.
 
Back
Top