Home server build - 2.5"HD for OS?

ottozylch46

Weaksauce
Joined
Oct 7, 2009
Messages
77
Not an expert in this field, would like anyone's opinion on if I am thinking about this correctly. In putting together a media server for home, would it make sense to use a small, 2.5" notebook HD for the OS so that it could be tucked out of the way somewhere so that it does not utilize one of the storage bays?
Or, for whatever reasons, I should just stick with the standard 3.5" HD?
Not looking to go to SSD yet. This server would probably be running 24/7.
Greatly appreciate your input.
 
There is nothing wrong with a 2.5" drive for WHS. Personally, I'd put in a Seagate Momentus XT hybrid drive if you need to buy new anyway.
 
Okay, thanks. Didn't think there would be a problem, thought I'd ask to double check.
Was more concerned with having it running 24/7 and the reliability of them for the next year or two. It would be positioned to provide cooling, obviously, just didn't want to take up an extra drive bay if I didn't have to.
 
If my 24/7 running laptops with HDD time out disabled is any indicator, 2.5" drives can easily last "the next year or two". They aren't exactly cooled within the laptop either..
 
Thanks much.
In this situation, server just serving media files, do I want to stick with a 7200rpm drive or would a 5400rpm suffice? I would be using Win7 Ultimate as a OS.
 
Well for WHS I believe somewhere around power pack 2 they fixed the new file always landing on disk 1 problem, so now the new files just land on whatever disk they will reside on. So shouldn't be a big deal for file server stuff.

On the other hand I would like to see the OS on the fastest disk in the box. I have two 7200rpm drives so I put the OS on one of those, the rest are a mix of 5900/5400rpm drives but frankly with the age differences I doubt there is much of a difference either way. For you though I wouldn't put a OS on a laptop drive though especially when you have other faster options. But that's only really based on speed differences between the drives, nothing at all barring you from using the laptop drive for the OS. Heck you might even consider a CF card for the OS like they do for EXSi systems.
 
Back
Top