Highpoint 2320 vs. Areca 1220

truffle00

2[H]4U
Joined
May 16, 2001
Messages
4,088
I am looking at building a new fileserver/HTPC gaming machine. The original thought was that I would build just a fileserver. However, I accidentally bought more DDR2 RAM that I have no use for in my main machine, I have a spare E6600 that goes to 3.6 no problem, and 4850s and 4870s are cheap and I wanted to send sound to the TV via HDMI anyway, so a gaming machine it is.

My main system will have a Velociraptor and two 1 TB Seagate drives, connected to the HTPC via gigabit ethernet.

The HTPC will use a Raptor X as the OS drive, and will have 5 x 750 GB Seagates in RAID 5. Both will be using Vista 64.

I will likely create the files on my main system then send them over ethernet to the HTPC. I'm guessing I will be limited to 30-40 MB/sec, right? I will only be using the RAID array on the HTPC to view files, so I don't see any intensive access there.

Given my use, is it worth it to go with the Areca? I'm not sure I need the speed that hardware RAID provides.

I thought I read something somewhere about the Highpoint using some proprietary system for managing the drives. Don't all RAID cards do this though, so that you can only read the RAID using cards from the same brand (and maybe even the same model)? Is this really a downside to the Highpoint?

Finally, if I am gaming and other people are accessing the RAID to watch movies on their computers, will the Highpoint give me problems because it is only software RAID?

A RAID card like this is probably an investment and not something that I will be swapping often, if ever. At the same time, if I don't have to spend the extra $200 that would be swell. Thoughts?
 
not worth the extra $$$ for areca, buy the rocket raid 2320 it will do everything you need and is less then half the price. With 5 drives in raid5 you will have more then enough disk bandwidth to saturate the gigabit net.
 
How is the compatibility? Is one easier to use, or does one have less problems in general?
 
arecas are way more fussy about motherboard compatibility, aslo the rocketraid 2320 is x4 pcie the areca 1220 is x8 (x4 is more then enough bandwidth for 8 hdds in raid 5)
 
Back
Top