High Tech Goes Low Tech with NetValve

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
Yep, you too can now control your internet bandwidth and not even know a DOS command. Introducing the NetValve. Steam not required.

Check out the video.

And if you want your own, there is an indiegogo campaign. It has so far raised $20 of its $50,000 goal. Yeah, they are not getting my money either. File this under "cute."

Fun fact: Did you know that Mike Kane, the main inventor behind SpeedTest.net, designed the current HardOCP site?
 
clockwise, gets faster, clockwise again, even faster...then counter-clockwise, faster still.....finally all the way clockwise....shuts down!

hmmm..#fakenews


/s
 
That's pretty funny and a good take on "Internet Pipe". I like the idea, but would never want that. No reason for it???
 
$80 for a piece of pipe with a $5 openwrt router inside. Or worse, 100% software based and a $1 pico andrio
 
$80 for a piece of pipe with a $5 openwrt router inside. Or worse, 100% software based and a $1 pico andrio
Shit better then my company. We pay $300 for a 4" Dia X6" long and won't spend the $1000 for a pipe cuter and let me make it for 1/10 of the cost.
 
The video seems fake to me, the speed started to go down again and the guy hurry and turns the knob to go down.
 
No reason for it???

Yeah, I'm trying to figure out what practical application this could possibly have. Why would you ever want your internet connection running at anything but full bore?

Maybe if you have data caps?
 
Now if this actually worked to stop spam e-mails, they might be on to something.

Envisioning an "incident" in which the IT department has 4 guys rushing to the valve, straining as hard as they can to stop the flow.
 
Ha! I invented something just like this years ago (as a joke) drew up fake blueprints and everything, and posted it at work. Mine was called "The Gig Spigot" though. :D
 
Yeah, I'm trying to figure out what practical application this could possibly have. Why would you ever want your internet connection running at anything but full bore?

Maybe if you have data caps?

For when QoS policies are too hard. :p
 
For when QoS policies are too hard. :p

But, this won't solve QoS issues... If one or a few connections are gobbling up bandwidth at the expense of others, turning down your overall bandwidth will make things worse, not better...
 
But, this won't solve QoS issues... If one or a few connections are gobbling up bandwidth at the expense of others, turning down your overall bandwidth will make things worse, not better...

It was a joke, but yes. You'd need several of these, several VLANs, and separate all of your commonly high-bandwidth services out over them. Then you would limit the bandwidth per-service inside the local area.

A single one to the outside would only really help you save on caps/overages, or help the ISP.

And, if we're being realistic, then this is actually very useless. What it is though is fun/funny. :D

Or, another example where it could actually be useful is if your house uses a wired network (mine is both wired and wireless) and you put this in line with the connection to your son's room (I'm projecting a bit here) because he's streaming movies, playing games, and sucking down bandwidth like a maniac, while you're trying to do something marginally more important in another room. (Like install any recent id software game in Steam) :D My service is 200Mb, but I could still see cranking this down on my son sometimes.
 
But, this won't solve QoS issues... If one or a few connections are gobbling up bandwidth at the expense of others, turning down your overall bandwidth will make things worse, not better...

Just have to put a shaped filter in there; gaming bandwidth is square, web is circular, so just expand or contract which you want to prioritize. ;)
 
It was a joke, but yes. You'd need several of these, several VLANs, and separate all of your commonly high-bandwidth services out over them. Then you would limit the bandwidth per-service inside the local area.

A single one to the outside would only really help you save on caps/overages, or help the ISP.

And, if we're being realistic, then this is actually very useless. What it is though is fun/funny. :D

Or, another example where it could actually be useful is if your house uses a wired network (mine is both wired and wireless) and you put this in line with the connection to your son's room (I'm projecting a bit here) because he's streaming movies, playing games, and sucking down bandwidth like a maniac, while you're trying to do something marginally more important in another room. (Like install any recent id software game in Steam) :D My service is 200Mb, but I could still see cranking this down on my son sometimes.


Fair enough.


I stopped using QoS at home recently after I started using a VPN service on my router.

I used to use a combination of FairQ and Codel but when I started tunneling all WAN traffic through my VPN, the bandwidth was less reliable and thus more difficult to QoS properlyat without sacrificing too much of it.

Then when I recently got upgraded to gigabit, I just turned it off all together. No need anymore :D

FB_IMG_1506550599561.jpg
 
Fair enough.


I stopped using QoS at home recently after I started using a VPN service on my router.

I used to use a combination of FairQ and Codel but when I started tunneling all WAN traffic through my VPN, the bandwidth was less reliable and thus more difficult to QoS properlyat without sacrificing too much of it.

Then when I recently got upgraded to gigabit, I just turned it off all together. No need anymore :D

View attachment 37799

I actually don't use QoS at home at all either at this point. Just not worth it most of the time. I use it a little bit at work, but mostly the way it is here, we can pretty easily separate out different workloads almost entirely using separate networks/VLANs. (which is much nicer than QoS if it works for what you have going on) I'll call it "long term manual QoS" :p
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top