High Quality 22" vs. Low Quality 24"

berndawg3

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
245
Hey everyone, I'm new to this forum but I've read tons about some monitors and this is by far the most informative place for information. Anyways, onto my dilemma...

I'm planning a build for about a couple months from now and I'm just trying to plan out as much of it as I can. I really want to get a 24" monitor that would be used for gaming, programming, some PS, TV, and PS2 (until I get a PS3). It will be for my dorm room in college. I recently tried out an LG L264WP-BN that I picked up for $320 (Floor Model) at BB. When I got home, I found a stuck pixel that I was unable to fix, so as hard/sad as it was to return such a good deal, I did. I was very impressed by it coming from my 17" Sony LCD. Now I'm back to square one. I really would prefer a non-TN panel, but I will primarily be viewing my monitor close to head on. I just don't want the dark top and light bottom. I was very interested in the Gateway FHD2400, but the horrible BLB scared me away along with the glossy screen. I also was interested in the HP w2408h until I found out it had a glossy screen. So now, in my $300-$500 budget in a monitor, I'm looking at the Samsung 245BW, BenQ G2400W, or Westinghouse L2410NM. I am constantly finding mixed reviews on all of them, so I'm beginning to wonder if I should give up the extra resolution/inches and go for a high quality 22". Are the viewing angles of TN panels in 22" better than in 24"? I never hear many complaints about viewing angles in 22". Also, does the resolution make a big difference? Is it noticeable? Does the larger dot pitch make for a muddier picture? And finally, If a 22" is recommended over any 24", which one would it be? Sorry for so many questions in one post!

Thanks,
Andy
 
There is no such thing as a high quality 22" monitor (except Lenovo's high def iteration, but thats probably not in your pricerange).

Your options should be a high end 20", a low end 22" or a low end 24"

I would cross the 22" off that list and move onwards. So, you've got 20 and 24. Frankly, if you can squeeze it, I would find a 24". The resolution is fantastic and you've got 1080p capability for the future.

Buy used and get a nicer 24" then you would be able to find new for $500.
 
Which 24" would you recommend? I'm a bit afraid to buy a used monitor because they're pretty fragile and I don't want to get screwed on someone lying about dead pixels. And if it has to ship, let's just say I'd rather not have UPS kick it all the way to my house :)
 
Which 24" would you recommend? I'm a bit afraid to buy a used monitor because they're pretty fragile and I don't want to get screwed on someone lying about dead pixels. And if it has to ship, let's just say I'd rather not have UPS kick it all the way to my house :)

Let them kick it all they like. Then demand original retail for it when it shows up broken.
 
Out of the 245BW (or 2493HM?), the G2400W, and the L2410NM, what would you all recommend?
 
Out of the 245BW (or 2493HM?), the G2400W, and the L2410NM, what would you all recommend?

People seem quite happy with the G2400W at another forum I frequent, and I do think that both the size and res of the 24 are desirable over a 22, which will look small very quickly.

The Benq is a TN panel, which means it's major disadvantage will be vertical viewing angles, but it's hard to get people to accurately describe how much of a problem that is.....me, I bought a 8 bit panel and avoided the whole TN "thang".
 
Yeah, I still think I'd miss the extra resolution. Which non-TN panel did you buy? Would you recommend the Westy over the others?
 
I'll take up the minority position here. The high DPI of the 20" and 24" monitors makes text too small for me to comfortably read. The 22" has adequate text, but they only come in TN. Hence why I still have a CRT monitor. No company wishes to produce a product for my demographic.
 
I've been doing some more reading and I'm thinking I'd like to choose the Samsung 245BW or the Westinghouse L2410NM. I can't get the BenQ locally and I know with my luck, I'll get a dead pixel. What would be recommended for TV/Gaming/Photoshop out of these 2?
 
Yeah, I still think I'd miss the extra resolution. Which non-TN panel did you buy? Would you recommend the Westy over the others?

I'm in Australia, so I don't know anything about WH.
I bought an Acer 2616W{black frame}.

I think that vertical viewing angles would ruin things for me, so that's why I bought a 8 bit panel....image quality was important to me, and I didn't want to suffer from contrast shift whilst watching HDTV etc.

My view is this.....if you use the LCD a lot, you'll quickly forget about the extra you spend on a 8 bit vs 6 bit panel.
 
I'll take up the minority position here. The high DPI of the 20" and 24" monitors makes text too small for me to comfortably read. The 22" has adequate text, but they only come in TN. Hence why I still have a CRT monitor. No company wishes to produce a product for my demographic.

I would've agreed with you during the first few days after I bought my 26, but you get used to it, in fact, I wouldn't mind having the 24's dotpitch on my 26:)

Because I planned to watch HDTV and DVD's on my LCD, I bought a 26 instead of a 24 preferring the extra size, but I now feel that "ultimately", more res would be better.....maybe not 1600p, but that's my opinion on that matter.

I'm comfortably typing this from 800mm.
 
I have owned 3 24" TN monitors

Gateway FHD2400
Samsung 245BW
HP 2408H

I personally believe, 24" is to big for a TN. Sit right in front of the monitor, and you can see the top of the screen is slightly darker than the rest, its because of viewing angle issues. Besides that though, the FHD2400 looked the best, but it had bad backlight bleeding. The 2408H looked slightly better than the 245BW, but it was a glossy screen and cost $100 more. So I would choose the 245BW if you can get it for $400... Otherwise I would go for a 22" because it seems to be the best size for a TN..... Which one is still a hard decision though...... Viewsonic VX2255WMB is a decent choise so is the Samsung 2253BW. If you can get a w2207 DVI version with samsung panel thats your best bet.
 
I also was interested in the HP w2408h until I found out it had a glossy screen
Also TN so image brightness will vary unless looked from upward andle:
http://www.proadviser.de/en/monitore/review/2007/review-hp-w2408h-part8.html

In 22" wide size only non TNs are "standard" resolution Eizo S2231W 1920x1200 resolution Lenovo L220x.
Both of them have been made for serious computer monitors so they have only DVI and D-sub connectors which makes connecting them to also other things than PC harder.

Here's review of many recent 22" TNs:
http://www.behardware.com/articles/689-7/22-inch-lcd-monitors-the-3rd-wave.html
Compare viewing angle shots to these.
 
Is the Westinghouse L2410NM quite a bit better? I believe it's a cheap MVA panel, how does that stack up against the 24" TN's?
 
Back
Top