help with upgrading to a video editing 3D software RIG

firas

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 29, 2006
Messages
2,458
my friend wants to upgrade his current rig, he wants to upgrade the CPU, Motherboard, RAM for now and set a $1200 budget for those 3 parts
the rig will be used for video editing & montage, 3D graphics software

he will buy all the parts from the local stores so no need for web links, and he don’t know how and don’t want to OC!

initially I told him:
CPU: Intel Q6600 or Q6700
Board: Asus Maximus Formula
RAM: 4GB DDR2-800 (OCZ, Corsair, Crucial, G.Skill, GEIL, A.Data, Mushkin, PQI, Patriot, CAS 5 or lower) mentioned by silent-circuit but this doesn’t match his budget!
an extreme CPU will be over his budget not to mention that he’ll never take advantage of that unlocked multi, and I don’t think DDR3 is a wise option cuz I doubt that it’ll offer him any extra performance

thanks
 
go with the Q6700 & 4GB Corsair XMS Dominator or Crucial Ballstix.
Can't comment on the mobo, but looks like a good board
 
$1200 for just those three parts? If you really wanted to, you could get the job done with just half of that amount.

Stick with the Q6600 if you can find it, and only get the Q6700 if you can't. The higher speeds don't justify the higher price tag on the Q6700 (and the performance differences are marginal). For better cooling, I would recommend getting one of the following CPU coolers (if you can find one of them):

Cooler Master GeminII RR-CCH-ANU2-GP HSF - $30 & 120mm Yate Loon D12SL-12 Case Fan - $3.50 x 2
Scythe SCNJ-1100P Ninja HSF - $36
Tuniq Tower 120 HSF - $45
Thermalright Ultima-90 HSF - $46 & Panaflo FBA09A12M 92mm Fan - $3
Thermalright Ultra-120 Extreme HSF - $57 & Scythe S-Flex SFF21E 120MM Case Fan - $14

There is no true performance benefit that you would get by choosing an X38-based board right now. Stick with a P35 board, like the Gigabyte GA-P35 series, the Abit IP35 series, or the Asus P5K series (and choose the appropriate board based on which onboard features that you need). A P35-based board would run just as well as an X38-based board but would cost less.

Any of the above brands of memory listed in your OP would work fine. Just try to get the cheapest kit you could find. But keep in mind that you need a 64-bit OS to utilize all of that RAM; 32-bit operating systems can only read a total of 4GB -- RAM minus any amounts of memory from add-on cards (e.g., video cards) -- in your system.

And I would reconsider the "local stores only" option if I were you. If you're willing to wait a few days, you could find some deals that would make buying all of these parts online, even with shipping costs added, cheaper than buying retail from the store (plus taxes). But it's only a suggestion....
 
And I would reconsider the "local stores only" option if I were you. If you're willing to wait a few days, you could find some deals that would make buying all of these parts online, even with shipping costs added, cheaper than buying retail from the store (plus taxes). But it's only a suggestion....
that’s not easy for him cuz he’s in the middle east, it’s possible but not easy to do

Stick with the Q6600 if you can find it, and only get the Q6700 if you can't
he can find both, I told him to stick with the Q6600, but I think he’ll go for the Q6700 cuz as you can see the price difference is not a big issue for him though he knows the extra 200mhz doesn’t worth that additional $$

as for the CPU cooler he’ll just pick the most expensive cooler he can find cuz CPU coolers is rare to find at his local stores and there isn’t a lot of types to choose between

There is no true performance benefit that you would get by choosing an X38-based board right now. Stick with a P35 board, like the Gigabyte GA-P35 series, the Abit IP35 series, or the Asus P5K series (and choose the appropriate board based on which onboard features that you need). A P35-based board would run just as well as an X38-based board but would cost less.
I’m totally aware of this but what can I do, the dude wants to spend money

I hardly convinced him (I’m still not sure if he’s convinced) to drop the X38 based mobo with DDR3 support + 4GB DDR3 RAM idea!, he even wanted to pick SLI mobo though he won’t use 2 graphic cards
 
Ahh well... he's been warned. Its his money, let him spend it. At least he didn't make an uninformed decision.
 
CPU: Q6700 doubles the Q6600 in pricing, yet the performance between them is insignificant (link). Nothing beats the Q6600 except an overclocked Q6600 (save $1000 CPUs)

Mobo: Regardless of its looks, the $260 Maximus Formula doesn't offer any extra performance, upgradeability, or even overclockability over P35 boards. Unless your friend needs a lot of ports, he will be fine with a $100 P35-DS3L, not even IP35

Tell your friend there are better things he can waste his money on.
 
I keep trying to tell people that right now the DFI Blood Iron P35-TR2L is probably the best deal for a P35 board you can get.

Price seems to be $100-120 (no rebates), it has 6 SATA ports and RAID, it has good OCing options, it's fairly well laid out.

So long as you don't need Crossfire, it's got you covered.
 
Back
Top