Help with HDTV capture

Joined
Jan 16, 2006
Messages
5
My apartment building gives us free cable. We are not supplied with boxes but simply plug into the wall. I get many SD and HD channels and was wanting to build a HTPC to be able record both. Are there any tuners on the market that can receive and record HD channels via simply coaxial cable input?
 
It's a network tuner. You plug then into the same router and it streams the HD feed to your HTPC. The drivers for it make it look like a regular ATSC tuner to the HTPC so most PVR apps will play with it.
 
Im not sure my wireless is fast enough for that.

What about this one coming out in a couple weeks.

http://www.hothardware.com/Articles/ATI_TV_Wonder_650_Combo_PCI_Express_Review/

Don't know much about it yet, other than from that review.

Supports QAM through it's own mendia player, but I'm not sure how it works through MCE and Vista since Vista decided to NOT support HD through QAM if I remember correctly ????????????????????????

it should allow you to watch one channel while recording another.
 
Vista doesn't support QAM unless you pony up the cash for a CableCard Vista OEM systems and those start at about $2000... in which case I would think that you'd rather use the CableCard tuner then a QAM one (and I'm not even sure if QAM tuning is allowed for anything other then the CableCard tuner).

Now, MS is supposely betaing a "QAM Powertoys" that would enable QAM tuning for Vista....

Otherwise, currently, the only way to get QAM into MCE is through the tuner I linked to earlier and thats because the HDHomeRun wraps the QAM signal in a MCE friendly ATSC wrapper.

And, the 650Combo (they should have totally changed the name to something like "660 or 670") only does one HD channel and one SD channel. Unless you throw in another card theres no way you'll be recording two HD channels or two SD channels at the same time.
 
Just FYI: mythtv supports QAM and has for a very long time. For free. It's a PITA to set up, though.

-q
 
Good thing I still have XP for now! Can't wait to get a QAM card. However it sucks that if I change to vista it will not work... Guess I'll have to pick it up for now, and rent a cable box if I change to vista to get my HD fix. (Thanks MS). Router option doe snot sound good for me, you can't stream full HD over 54mbps wireless from my understanding, but good luck if you have a wired network, the setup looks interesting. I don't really understand how you can change channels etc if it is in the other room though....
 
Good thing I still have XP for now! Can't wait to get a QAM card. However it sucks that if I change to vista it will not work...
XP doesn't support QAM either. The only way to get QAM (in Windows) is either through a bundled (crappy) viewer app or through the method I already posted above.
 
interesting so I guess that review was just complete BS? My Only hope for HD then is a cable box? maybe I will jsut buy my old CRT TV back then...It's not worth purchasing a seperate tuner unless I can run it through the comp.
 
interesting so I guess that review was just complete BS?
I have no idea WTH your talking about. That preview didn't even mention QAM tuning (the dude was pulling HD via ATSC) so I don't see how that qualifies as "complete BS."
My Only hope for HD then is a cable box?
Oh. Now I understand, you don't what QAM tuning actually means.

QAM is a simply a way of getting those ATSC HD channels over your cable line instead of having to use an antenna. You're not getting ESPN in HD. You're not getting Scifi in HD. The only thing you're getting is the network channels (ABC, Fox, CBS, etc) that are already freely available with an ATSC antenna but through your cable line instead. The reason why QAM doesn't work properly on the PC is that most cable providers encrypt part or all of their QAM signals (for no real reason, cable cos are just asses like that) and their encryption screws up PC tuners (so you get nothing). TV QAM tuners have the needed parts there to decode this signal in hardware while PC tuners do that in both software and hardware. As I understand it it's been a PITA the getting the software part working correctly which is why QAM isn't fully supported on all PC tuners.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/QAM
 
I have no idea WTH your talking about. That preview didn't even mention QAM tuning (the dude was pulling HD via ATSC) so I don't see how that qualifies as "complete BS."

Oh. Now I understand, you don't what QAM tuning actually means.

QAM is a simply a way of getting those ATSC HD channels over your cable line instead of having to use an antenna. You're not getting ESPN in HD. You're not getting Scifi in HD. The only thing you're getting is the network channels (ABC, Fox, CBS, etc) that are already freely available with an ATSC antenna but through your cable line instead. The reason why QAM doesn't work properly on the PC is that most cable providers encrypt part or all of their QAM signals (for no real reason, cable cos are just asses like that) and their encryption screws up PC tuners (so you get nothing). TV QAM tuners have the needed parts there to decode this signal in hardware while PC tuners do that in both software and hardware. As I understand it it's been a PITA the getting the software part working correctly which is why QAM isn't fully supported on all PC tuners.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/QAM

But it supposedly IS fully supported on this upcoming tuner (other than decryption). If not then it is complete BS. I know what QAM is to the extent that my old TV's internal tuner picked up all kinds of HD on QAM (digital stations). Also at the time no1 would believe me that I could do this! The TV said it had a Digital TV Tuner, i don't remember anything about QAM, and it said it had an OTA HD Tuner. Lucky for me I got HD over digital as well. Of course just like I read about they would often switch all the channels around causing me to re-program the TV and find them on new stations all the time. But I DID get them. This TV is 3 years old now! It surprises me that cable cards still cannot get a grasp on this.

I know that if I get a cable box I can decode ALL HD stations, including the encrypted ones as my landlord pays for the HD plan (I just don't have a box and sold her my old TV so I have n0 TV right now)

It would be much more practical for me to get a tuner card since the majority of what I would like to watch comes on while I am at work, that and I have a 37" 1080p for a monitor anyways so the computer is only a foot away. Of course, the auto programing to record the shows while I am away may not work anyways due to the company switching the station around all the time anyways. It WOULD definately save me some space and allow me to pause tv though!
 
But it supposedly IS fully supported on this upcoming tuner (other than decryption). If not then it is complete BS.
ATI isn't the first to market with a tuner that is QAM capable, there have been several in market for the last two years that could do it. I never said there wasn't, I said it was difficult because of the encryption BS. Even if a tuner is QAM capable that doesn't mean it can decrypted one of those encrypted signals. Hell, one of the first QAM capable tuners was DVICO's Fusion 3 and that's considered old now.
I know that if I get a cable box I can decode ALL HD stations, including the encrypted ones
And you won't be able to input it into your PC. If you're moniter has component then it's possible. If it supports HDCP then it's possible to connect it to your moniter over HDMI or DVI. Other then that having a cable box does nothing for you unless you have a moniter with component in or HDCP as long as you don't have a TV.
 
ATI isn't the first to market with a tuner that is QAM capable, there have been several in market for the last two years that could do it. I never said there wasn't, I said it was difficult because of the encryption BS. Even if a tuner is QAM capable that doesn't mean it can decrypted one of those encrypted signals. Hell, one of the first QAM capable tuners was DVICO's Fusion 3 and that's considered old now.

And you won't be able to input it into your PC. If you're moniter has component then it's possible. If it supports HDCP then it's possible to connect it to your moniter over HDMI or DVI. Other then that having a cable box does nothing for you unless you have a moniter with component in or HDCP as long as you don't have a TV.

The Westinghouse is actualy a 1080p TV/Monitor, it has no Tuner. So it would work for sure through either HDMI or Component (Honestly my cable signal isn't spectacular to begin with so either owuld probably work hah. The PC is plugged into it through the DVI. I want to be able to record to Disk & Save space though, because my shows come on while I am at work. Not concerned with encrypted stuff so much, I just want HDTV and regular TV again. Is there a card you would recomend for this or should I wait till ATI launches their new one this month with the dual tuners?
 
As far as I am able to tell there are currently no cards that can dual tune HD shows. What I mean is I want to be able to record an HD show while watching another HD show at the same time. Did I miss a card that will allow me to do this or are there any on the way?
 
As far as I am able to tell there are currently no cards that can dual tune HD shows. What I mean is I want to be able to record an HD show while watching another HD show at the same time. Did I miss a card that will allow me to do this or are there any on the way?
There are two of them but the second one had some major issues.
http://www.pcalchemy.com/product_in...ked-digital-hdtv-tuner/cName/hdtv-tuner-cards
http://www.pcalchemy.com/product_in...v-receiver-pci-express/cName/hdtv-tuner-cards
. Is there a card you would recomend for this or should I wait till ATI launches their new one this month with the dual tuners?
Just to be clear: ATI's new 650 Combo is a hybrid tuner, it's not a dual tuner at all. A dual tuner is able to tuner two similar channels at once, ie: two ATSC or two NTSC channels.

Hybrid tuners are able to tuner both ATSC (and possibly QAM) and NTSC at the same time (hence the use of the term "hybrid"). Since it can't do two ATSC or two NTSC channels it's not a dual tuner.

Now, theres nothing stopping ATI or any other manufacturer from making a dual tuner 650Combo (IMO if anyone did it would be god-like) but thats been the situation since they introduced the 550 tuners.

Either way, heres a good assortment of HD Tuners: http://www.pcalchemy.com/index.php/page/1/cName/hdtv-tuner-cards/sort/3a

But if you really want QAM then go with the tuner I linked to in my second post like I've been saying this entire time.
 
There are two of them but the second one had some major issues.
http://www.pcalchemy.com/product_in...ked-digital-hdtv-tuner/cName/hdtv-tuner-cards
http://www.pcalchemy.com/product_in...v-receiver-pci-express/cName/hdtv-tuner-cards

Just to be clear: ATI's new 650 Combo is a hybrid tuner, it's not a dual tuner at all. A dual tuner is able to tuner two similar channels at once, ie: two ATSC or two NTSC channels.

Hybrid tuners are able to tuner both ATSC (and possibly QAM) and NTSC at the same time (hence the use of the term "hybrid"). Since it can't do two ATSC or two NTSC channels it's not a dual tuner.

Now, theres nothing stopping ATI or any other manufacturer from making a dual tuner 650Combo (IMO if anyone did it would be god-like) but thats been the situation since they introduced the 550 tuners.

Either way, heres a good assortment of HD Tuners: http://www.pcalchemy.com/index.php/page/1/cName/hdtv-tuner-cards/sort/3a

But if you really want QAM then go with the tuner I linked to in my second post like I've been saying this entire time.


yes, but i want qam and I want in internal tuner. I can't hook that up to my router because my router is wireless in the living room? I doubt I can stream HD wireless at less than 54 mbps. And if I could my connection would take a serious hit. I believe this device would require me to upgrade my entire wireless network? how does the remote controll work? I would have this in the living room and the PC in my bedroom, wouldn't that render the remote useless? Site does not provide much info on it and the unit without the remote is out of stock.

Would this be just as good as ATI's tuner?
http://www.pcalchemy.com/product_in...-upgrade-kit-mtvpemcer/cName/hdtv-tuner-cards

or maybe this one, at least I have heard of Hauppage before?
http://www.pcalchemy.com/product_in...tion-mce-remote-bundle/cName/hdtv-tuner-cards

What is better about the upcoming ATi card than the hauppauge? or is the hauppauge better?

Aren't Hauppauge cards usualy better than the ATi equivilant or do I have that backwards? I have no TV for over a month now, and I need to get something, but if i shoudl wait for the ATI I will, otherwise I am ready to buy the Hauppauge
 
So to clarify then. If I get this HDHomeRun tuner I can dual tune HD channels (record one while watching another) and simply connect it to my computer via a network cable to a second network card? Vista Home Premium will then have no issues with play back and recording?
 
So to clarify then. If I get this HDHomeRun tuner I can dual tune HD channels (record one while watching another) and simply connect it to my computer via a network cable to a second network card? Vista Home Premium will then have no issues with play back and recording?

My friend says no, but I would like to know too :)
 
Yes. I know several people who are using it like that (removing their tuners and just adding in another NIC to directly connect this to it).
 
very interesting, this could finaly be a use for my dual 100 megabit onboard lan lol. So this setup is actual y"better" than the internal solution ATi is releasing since this will allow you to record one HD station while you watch another? Any disadvantages other than it taking up more space?

not trying to threadjack but I need a tuner bad no TV for over 6 weeks now and I have a 37" monitor with no tuner :(

I'm almost ready to bite on the Silicon Dust True Dual Tuner. But what remote to buy with it? How exavtly do these PC remotes work? Right now it looks like to be really happy I would need this tuner plus a $300 logitec remote? The one thing why I keep looking back at the ATI even though it is not a true dual is because for the same price it will include a remote (I think?) This thing actualy does hardware decoding right it's not going to kill my CPU to view HD television?

Too bad this device was never released :(
http://www.anandtech.com/tradeshows/showdoc.aspx?i=2662&p=1

It's almsot like the HDhomerun but with some cable card support. I suppose I will have to get the HD Homerun for now, a cheaper remote Maybe the logitec 880, and just plan on upgrading to a tuner that takes a cable card later down the road. (Does not matter my cable company does not have cable cards right now anyways)
 
Right now it looks like to be really happy I would need this tuner plus a $300 logitec remote?
What? Why would you need to buy a $100 or more Logitech remote just to use this to watch TV on your moniter? Your software is what tells the tuner what channel to record, the software is whats running the show. If you're just using it to view TV then you can use VLC; if you want to record stuff then go to it's home page and check to see what software packages work with it: http://www.silicondust.com/wiki/products/hdhomerun

For more on it: http://www.engadgethd.com/2006/10/30/engadget-hd-review-hdhomerun/
This thing actualy does hardware decoding right it's not going to kill my CPU to view HD television?
ATSC (or QAM) HD is broadcasted as a Transport Stream (TS) file which is just a fancy way of saying "high bitrate MPEG2" and any modern video card supports hardware acceleration of MPEG2 files. Unless you have something very old it's not going to kill your CPU but no, it doesn't do decoding in hardware since it's unnecessary.

Also, when buying a TV tuner there are three things you need to do: 1.) Do your home work and understand what your buying. 2.) NEVER base a buying desicion on what kind of software is bundled with it cause I guarantee you that 95% of the time the bundled software is utter crap (and yes this goes double for ATI's stuff). 3.) NEVER buy a tuner based on whether or not it comes with a remote for the same reason as you never buy one because of the software that comes with it. Again, 95% of the time the remote that gets thrown in is utter garbage.

You're buying a TV tuner first and foremost. You need to find a tuner that does what you need while also having solid driver/software support as well as picture quality. If it happens to come with a decent extras package then thats simply icing on the cake.
Too bad this device was never released
http://www.anandtech.com/tradeshows/...spx?i=2662&p=1

It's almsot like the HDhomerun but with some cable card support. I suppose I will have to get the HD Homerun for now, a cheaper remote Maybe the logitec 880, and just plan on upgrading to a tuner that takes a cable card later down the road. (Does not matter my cable company does not have cable cards right now anyways)
Yes it was and it's an utter travesty. MS released it several months back.
http://www.engadget.com/search/?q=Cablecard
 
I was going say this one but I see they're raping you for it.

http://www.pcalchemy.com/product_in...trol-for-windows-xp-mce/cName/remote-controls

On a related note I am selling a pretty good remote: http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1215464

I suggest the MCE remote especially if you're going the route of a Harmony. If you want a Harmony you'll need to get an IR receiver if you want to use it with a PC cause they don't come with one. The MCE receiver works with several PVR apps as well as the Harmony so you're covered.
 
Crap, as stupid as it sounds I didn't realize I would have to run a differnet OS for MCE. Guess I will try beyond TV or maybe SageTV. I'm a newb to all the TV card stuff. I was hoping to use this device on my regular computer as I will not have a designated HTPC (why bother with one if my PC is only 1 foot away?) And ouch that remote is quite expensive when all is said and done I might as well go with the logitec 880 or 890.

Since my TV has no tuner, but my PC is right next to the TV I figured I could get the same effect. I have a TV remote though which is kind of a stupid remote since there is no tuner...I guess i won't get one of their $20 remotes and i will just wait it out. Finger is on the buy button!

editSite Crashed while ordering :( not a good sign!
 
Yes. I know several people who are using it like that (removing their tuners and just adding in another NIC to directly connect this to it).



So what is the process for getting MCE to recognize the video stream via the NIC and not a TV card?

Also, when I run the scan on my TV to pick up channels it picks up 70 analogue and 45 digital. So my understanding is now that on top of the HDHomeRun for the digital side I will still need an analogue tuner for the other 70 channels?
 
So what is the process for getting MCE to recognize the video stream via the NIC and not a TV card?

Also, when I run the scan on my TV to pick up channels it picks up 70 analogue and 45 digital. So my understanding is now that on top of the HDHomeRun for the digital side I will still need an analogue tuner for the other 70 channels?

From what I read, both tuners have to be set to digital or both to analog, so depending on yoru needs you way need another tuner. Wow 70 analog thats crazy!

I don't have mine yet, and unfortunately I dont have MCE either. Do I smell another upgrade. Trying to wait untill Jan 08 to upgrade to vista.
 
Back
Top