Help w/ Build

Hexus0

Gawd
Joined
Feb 28, 2005
Messages
590
Hey everyone, well I've been out of it for a while, but I'm kind of back! I offered to build a computer for my friend's younger brother. He says that he's going to be using the computer for school, music, internet, and light gaming, so I figure he doesn't need anything insane. Although I'm not up-to-date on all the parts, I haven't put together a rig for a while and I miss putting one together. I remember reading about the Intel Core 2 Duo processors when they came out and how they seemed to overclock and just did a lot better then AMD. Then the follow-up came when AMD dropped the prices on the processors and seems like Intel has followed along (I guess?), so its becoming even more confusing for me. To make it simple, $800 budget, I have an Antec 430 NeoPower PSU and a Lian-Li PC-61 that I think I'm going to offer him, so $800 with no PSU or Case.
 
all from newegg.

also, keep in mind this is before the july pricecut of intel processors.

the price is actually lower than this!

Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 (Perpendicular Recording) 250GB 7200 RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s HD
Item #: N82E16822148144

-quiet, fast, good amount of storage.. what more could you want?

EVGA 640-P2-N821-AR GeForce 8800GTS 640MB PCI-E
Item #: N82E16814130071
-Great Performance, enough said.

SUPER TALENT 2GB (2 x 1GB) DDR2 800 Memory
Item #: N82E16820609226
-Dunno how well it OC's, but its good stock... and cheap

MSI P6N SLI-FI LGA 775 NVIDIA nForce 650i SLI ATX Motherboard
Item #: N82E16813130082
-Good Mobo, used it mehself for a couple builds


Intel Core 2 Duo E6420 Conroe 2.13GHz LGA 775 Processor
Item #: N82E16819115016
-Retail ofc so you dont need to buy a HSF
-pretty good processor, buy it if you HAVE to get this immediately, else wait a couple weeks and get an e6600 for a similar price as this now.


Grand Total: $830.96 - $30 MIR from EVGA

im 96 cents off... but im sure you can manage that ^^
 
The 430 watt is pushing it, and it's an Antec, so it will likely die in a year for no apparent reason. Throw in a $50 XClio Goodpower or something and avoid the headache.
 
SippieCup said:
EVGA 640-P2-N821-AR GeForce 8800GTS 640MB PCI-E
Item #: N82E16814130071
-Great Performance, enough said.

The guy said "light gaming," and you're blowing pretty much half the total budget on a ridiculously overpriced and overpowered video card when none is called for? My god...

For a video card that can do a lot and has DX10 support, this card would work just fine and is close to 4x less expensive give or take $30:

EVGA 256-P2-N751-TR GeForce 8600GT 256MB 128-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 Video Card - Retail $115

The choice of memory is ok, but he could do better and save a few bucks in the process. Fry's regularly has Patriot 2x1GB 4-4-4 sticks for $69 or less, with free shipping also, so it's another thing to keep an eye out for.

Hard drive is ok, but you can probably get more space for the same price given the day of the week; Newegg and Fry's usually go at it pricewise with Fry's taking the edge with more space/less prices, and free shipping most of the time also so it's worth checking into.

Personally I wouldn't build an Intel machine on anything but Intel hardware, so that mobo wouldn't fly for me myself. I would not guess that overclocking is a concern whatsoever with this machine since the word "light" was used and the apparent owner is going to be needed/using it as a solid box. In light of that I'd suggest the Intel BOXDP35DPM LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail mobo, a solid choice if their ever was one. It's pure Intel hardware and it just works, period.

For the CPU, the one listed above is fine, and with the price drops as mentioned the E6600 becomes even more attractive in 3 weeks roughly so hold off if you can.

Because of the unnecessary video card listed, that leaves what, well over $200 for options like a kickass 18x Lightscribe DVD burner, a decent soundcard (if that's not a big deal, the Intel mobo has onboard sound that works just fine - 24 bit/96 KHz stuff ain't all it's cracked up to be anyway, and Creative and Vista don't mesh very well even with the latest drivers), and other goodies like blank media, etc.

Oh yeah, the cost of the OS too needs to be factored into this, but you'll figure that out. Vista Home Premium is enough for anyone and you can get it at Newegg, the OEM system builder edition, for about $115 these days. And upgrading to a slightly better power supply, like a 500 or 550 watt model, will also help in the long run as the poster above stated.

Just suggestions...

If you've been away for awhile, as you stated, then you need to know one thing that truly matters:

The Intel Core 2 Duo is the best processor ever made, aside from the Core 2 Quad which is 4 cores. AMD has nothing that can touch them now, and the future is somewhat grim for AMD throughout the rest of this year and possibly into 2008 unless they've got some magic rabbit up their sleeve and they're about to set it free.

Even if you were to build this machine with the lowest C2D (Core 2 Duo) processor available, the E4300 at 1.8 GHz, it'll stomp the daylights out of any machine you've probably built in the past. They're really that powerful, and as the clockspeeds go up, they just get faster. The E4300 for roughly $115 these days can be "pad modded" with some simple materials you can get at any car parts store (windshield defroster kits, do a Google search on "pad mod e4300" and you'll get more info) and that bumps the stock speed of the processor from 1.8 GHz to 2.4 GHz instantly - that makes it run at the same speed as the E6600, but it has 2MB of total L2 cache whereas the E6600 has 4 total.

The person you're building this for isn't going to notice the difference between 2MB of L2 and 4MB, I promise you - only in benchmarks would it matter. All he'll notice is "HOLY FREAKIN' SHIT THIS THING IS FAST!!!" and that's what matters, right? :)

Hope this helps...
 
Wow you guys are amazing! :eek:

Thanks for all the help! :D

I'll be putting this stuff together and going through it and come back with something to update you guys with!
 
The guy said "light gaming," and you're blowing pretty much half the total budget on a ridiculously overpriced and overpowered video card when none is called for? My god...

For a video card that can do a lot and has DX10 support, this card would work just fine and is close to 4x less expensive give or take $30:

EVGA 256-P2-N751-TR GeForce 8600GT 256MB 128-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 Video Card - Retail $115

The choice of memory is ok, but he could do better and save a few bucks in the process. Fry's regularly has Patriot 2x1GB 4-4-4 sticks for $69 or less, with free shipping also, so it's another thing to keep an eye out for.

Hard drive is ok, but you can probably get more space for the same price given the day of the week; Newegg and Fry's usually go at it pricewise with Fry's taking the edge with more space/less prices, and free shipping most of the time also so it's worth checking into.

Personally I wouldn't build an Intel machine on anything but Intel hardware, so that mobo wouldn't fly for me myself. I would not guess that overclocking is a concern whatsoever with this machine since the word "light" was used and the apparent owner is going to be needed/using it as a solid box. In light of that I'd suggest the Intel BOXDP35DPM LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail mobo, a solid choice if their ever was one. It's pure Intel hardware and it just works, period.

For the CPU, the one listed above is fine, and with the price drops as mentioned the E6600 becomes even more attractive in 3 weeks roughly so hold off if you can.

Because of the unnecessary video card listed, that leaves what, well over $200 for options like a kickass 18x Lightscribe DVD burner, a decent soundcard (if that's not a big deal, the Intel mobo has onboard sound that works just fine - 24 bit/96 KHz stuff ain't all it's cracked up to be anyway, and Creative and Vista don't mesh very well even with the latest drivers), and other goodies like blank media, etc.

Oh yeah, the cost of the OS too needs to be factored into this, but you'll figure that out. Vista Home Premium is enough for anyone and you can get it at Newegg, the OEM system builder edition, for about $115 these days. And upgrading to a slightly better power supply, like a 500 or 550 watt model, will also help in the long run as the poster above stated.

Just suggestions...

If you've been away for awhile, as you stated, then you need to know one thing that truly matters:

The Intel Core 2 Duo is the best processor ever made, aside from the Core 2 Quad which is 4 cores. AMD has nothing that can touch them now, and the future is somewhat grim for AMD throughout the rest of this year and possibly into 2008 unless they've got some magic rabbit up their sleeve and they're about to set it free.

Even if you were to build this machine with the lowest C2D (Core 2 Duo) processor available, the E4300 at 1.8 GHz, it'll stomp the daylights out of any machine you've probably built in the past. They're really that powerful, and as the clockspeeds go up, they just get faster. The E4300 for roughly $115 these days can be "pad modded" with some simple materials you can get at any car parts store (windshield defroster kits, do a Google search on "pad mod e4300" and you'll get more info) and that bumps the stock speed of the processor from 1.8 GHz to 2.4 GHz instantly - that makes it run at the same speed as the E6600, but it has 2MB of total L2 cache whereas the E6600 has 4 total.

The person you're building this for isn't going to notice the difference between 2MB of L2 and 4MB, I promise you - only in benchmarks would it matter. All he'll notice is "HOLY FREAKIN' SHIT THIS THING IS FAST!!!" and that's what matters, right? :)

Hope this helps...

All true, but the build above this one is a better build in my opinion (SippieCup's build), and very near to budget. Who cares what the split card to other components is? And who says he'll stay a light gamer once it's an option.
 
The problem is that "better" is a personally subjective thing, hence your saying "you think <xxx>" or even better "in my opinion." A video card that costs nearly half the entire working budget does not necessarily make the overall end result "better" for a number of reasons, especially price and how the money is spread across the system. The one I suggested would bring up the lower components to be more adequate and balanced across the board (no pun intended) instead of having a massively expensive and overpowered component stuck in a mediocre box.

If you put a Corvette engine in a Yugo, you've still got a Yugo.
 
is his monitor decent? does he do a lot of burning cd's, video editing? is he into pc gaming or does he use consoles or doesn't play games? Ask him if he would like high quality video, or what. If he does light gaming, why not build a system for $500? not like he needs to spend the extra $300, and that can be invested and make more money.......

Why spend more than needed?

buy a cheap x2 dual core (socket am2)
a cheap mobo that comes with a dual core but make sure its stable
a good 400-500 watt psu
u have a case
a 7600gt or 7900gs
2gigs of ram for vista
windows vista

you'll prob spend about $600, why spend the extra $200
 
is his monitor decent? does he do a lot of burning cd's, video editing? is he into pc gaming or does he use consoles or doesn't play games? Ask him if he would like high quality video, or what. If he does light gaming, why not build a system for $500? not like he needs to spend the extra $300, and that can be invested and make more money.......

Why spend more than needed?

buy a cheap x2 dual core (socket am2)
a cheap mobo that comes with a dual core but make sure its stable
a good 400-500 watt psu
u have a case
a 7600gt or 7900gs
2gigs of ram for vista
windows vista

you'll prob spend about $600, why spend the extra $200

Well thats the main reason why I came here. I know the AMD processors are really cheap, but the question would be if they're worth it over the Intel Core 2 Duo's? I Have a PSU and Case so we're good for that, I figured 2gb of ram (and DDR2 is super cheap), so we're left with a video card, board, processor, hard drive, and a DVD-RW (most likely). I'm going to configure out some stuff and see what I can do, both AMD and Intel.
 
There's nothing AMD has to offer that beats a Core 2 Duo on price to performance ratio, period. Even putting the E4300, the low end C2D, up against a high end AMD processor these days simply gives the AMD chip something to fear, seriously.

If you want high performance for a decent price (aka "the best bang for the buck") it'll be a Core 2 Duo machine without any doubt. The rest is variable, but as far as the CPU goes, it's C2D or nothing.

"And that's all I have to say about that..." :)
 
Back
Top