HELP VM system vs. ABS system

FAAmecanic

n00b
Joined
Oct 21, 2006
Messages
34
Hi All!

I have a hard choice to make. Im looking at buying either a ABS system or VM system. My confusion is based on price for similar based systems. VM I know comes HIHGLY recommeded...but ABS seems to have good reviews both here in the [H] website and in other gamer sites as well. And VM is siginificantly higher in price.

Here are the two systems Im looking at:

ABS Ultimate X9 II

Mobo: Intel BOXD975XBXLKR 975X 775
CPU: Intel Core 2 Extreme X6800
PSU: Enermax Liberty ELT620AWT 620watt
Memory: 2 Gig Corsair TWINX DDR2 800 PC6400
Graphics: NVIDIA eVGA 8800GTS 640MB GDDR3
Sound: Sound Blaster X-Fi Platinum
HDD: 2 Seagate Barracuda 320GB (640 GB total) SATA 3 w/16M cache
Optical Drives: Sony 16X DVD ROM, and Samsung 18X SuperMulti Dual layer DVD burner w/lightscribe
OS: WinXP Home SP2

Total Price: $3050 (shipping included in price)
***********************************

Velocity Micro Gamers Edge PCX

Mobo: EVGA nForce 680i SLI
CPU: Intel Core 2 Extreme X6800
PSU: 700 watt Seasonic M12
Memory: 2 Gig Corsair DDR2 800
Graphics: NVIDIA eVGA 8800GTS 640MB GDDR3
Sound: Sound Blaster X-Fi Platinum
HDD: 2 WD SATA 3 w/ 16M cache 320GB (640 GB total)
Optical Drives: Lite-on 16X DVD ROM/48x CD RW, and Lite On 16X DVD +/- RW/CD-RW
1.44 Floppy Drive
OS: WinXP Home SP2

Total Price: $3690 (includes Shipping)
*************************************************************

My take is ABS reviews well (with some minor gliches on the Quad core system that [H] reviewed...but that is bleeding edge and not even available yet). VM seems to have excellent customer service as well.

The only thing I hesitate on is ABS only lets me select INTEL mobo with this system... not to sure about intel mobos.

Basically the question is ....is the VM worth the extra $640?? For that much more I could get a second Video card with the ABS PC. I think I read Intel chipsets dont do SLI very well so in that case I could get 2 ATI X1950XTX cards in a crossfire and still come out at $3520 (incl shipping).

I respect [H] posters (and especially the communtiy managers) opinions very much.... would love to have your input before I plunk down (and give the wife a heart attack) this kind of dough!

Thanks in advance!
 
I'd go with the VM - it has the 680i, which IMO is one of the best mobos around currently. It also has a slightly better PSU.
 
Riddlinkidstoner said:
680i isn't worth the $600 price difference.
but the support is IMO :p Being able to talk to Chris or Randy is an INCREDIBLE advantage.

Id go with the VM. although i definetly wouldnt go with the x6800... (im an overclocker, what can i say?)
 
Ok...didnt know the ABS X8's had the Intel 680i (or the ASUS P5N32-SLI SE Deluxe) available, not sure which would be better, the intel 680i or Asus mobo). Changes from above post in BOLD


ABS Ultimate X8 III

Mobo: eVGA NVIDIA nForce 680i SLI
CPU: Intel Core 2 Extreme X6800
PSU: Thermaltake toughpower W0117RU 750 watt
Memory: 2 Gig Corsair TWINX DDR2 800 PC6400
Graphics: NVIDIA eVGA 8800GTS 640MB GDDR3
Sound: Sound Blaster X-Fi Platinum
HDD: 2 Seagate Barracuda 320GB (640 GB total) SATA 3 w/16M cache
Optical Drives: Sony 16X DVD ROM, and Samsung 18X SuperMulti Dual layer DVD burner w/lightscribe
OS: WinXP Pro SP2

Case: Gigabyte 3d Aurora
Liquid Cooling: Gigabyte 120mm Galaxy II

Total Price: $3378 (shipping included in price) or for $3377 I could get 2 eVGA Nvidia 7900 w/ 256mb ea. in SLI
**************************************************

Again a tough choice. I dont doubt VM quality (and versus Falcon or Voodoo they are Way cheaper). But with ABS having good reviews here and other PC geek websites...I have a hard time justifying the VM price tag. If ABS had bad reviews or customer service then I could see the VM being worth the extra $$$.

Opinions?
 
0mega said:
but the support is IMO :p Being able to talk to Chris or Randy is an INCREDIBLE advantage.

Id go with the VM. although i definetly wouldnt go with the x6800... (im an overclocker, what can i say?)

How well does the 6700 OC? And wouldnt that void the VM warranty or anything (if I did the OC...)

I usually build my own systems (built at least 10 or so), and do have experince in OC'ing... but my current PC is about to byte the dust (ABIT IC7 mobo where the chipset fan falls off and clunks on to your vid card.. I have resoldered the anchors a few times...but that is another story). And Im running a PIV 3.4e right now that just will not OC on this mobo. And my current job is sucking up so much of my time...I just dont have time to build another PC>
 
0mega said:
but the support is IMO :p Being able to talk to Chris or Randy is an INCREDIBLE advantage.

Id go with the VM. although i definetly wouldnt go with the x6800... (im an overclocker, what can i say?)

ABS is no slouch in support either :D

True VM reps view the forums more often than most but that shouldn't be the base of your decision. $600 is not worth nearly the cost for a motherboard, not by a longshot. Give me further details on the case design and maybe we can talk more but as he said, overclocking will void the warrenty with both companies so really the 680i is a moot point.
 
FAAmecanic said:
Total Price: $3378 (shipping included in price) or for $3377 I could get 2 eVGA Nvidia 7900 w/ 256mb ea. in SLI
**************************************************

Again a tough choice. I dont doubt VM quality (and versus Falcon or Voodoo they are Way cheaper). But with ABS having good reviews here and other PC geek websites...I have a hard time justifying the VM price tag. If ABS had bad reviews or customer service then I could see the VM being worth the extra $$$.

Opinions?

I would DEFINITELY go with the 8800 over the 7900GT SLI setup. There's no question there.

It is a tough choice. If they were within $100 of each other, I would recommend the VM. Since the difference is more like $300, I'd be tempted to go with ABS, who we've also seen great stuff from.
 
Thanks for your responses all.... definately helping me weigh my options. And the difference in price is more like $640 for the VM vs ABS X9 II. Its $300 diff if I go with the ABS X8 III which has water cooling.

Im really leaning to ABS. Question now is do I go with the Intel 975 mobo, the ASUS P5N32 - SLI, or the eVGA NVIDIA i680 (122-CK-NF68-AR) mobo.....
 
FAAmecanic said:
Thanks for your responses all.... definately helping me weigh my options. And the difference in price is more like $640 for the VM vs ABS X9 II. Its $300 diff if I go with the ABS X8 III which has water cooling.

Im really leaning to ABS. Question now is do I go with the Intel 975 mobo, the ASUS P5N32 - SLI, or the Intel NVIDIA i680 mobo.....

I'd highly recommend going with the 680i board - the P5N32 just doesn't hold a candle to it.
 
ChrisMorley said:
I'd highly recommend going with the 680i board - the P5N32 just doesn't hold a candle to it.


In terms of what? Overclocking is a moot point here.

Feature rich? Maybe...cool black PCB? Definately :D
 
Riddlinkidstoner said:
In terms of what? Overclocking is a moot point here.

Feature rich? Maybe...cool black PCB? Definately :D

1) More features in the BIOS
2) MUCH better cooling
3) Better memory compatibility (at least with the various Corsair flavors we use)
4) Higher FSB support
5) Higher memory frequency support
6) Quad-core support
7) And yeah, it overclocks MUCH better

Lemme just say that we're much happier with the 680i as our flagship motherboard for SLI as compared to the P5N32-SLI.
 
ChrisMorley said:
1) More features in the BIOS
2) MUCH better cooling
3) Better memory compatibility
4) Higher FSB support
5) Higher memory frequency support
6) Quad-core support
7) And yeah, it overclocks MUCH better

Lemme just say that we're much happier with the 680i as our flagship motherboard for SLI as compared to the P5N32-SLI.

Thanks Chris.... I appreciate the HONEST input, even though I am comparing you to a competitor.

I still havent 100% made up my mind yet. My wife brings up a good point, it is worth it to pay more money if you KNOW someone will stand behind thier products. I just have to look at my budget and decide :) (as well as get over the shock of my wife telling me its OK to spend MORE money :D )

Thanks again guys... now Im off to price two specific configurations between VM and ABS... wish me luck ;)
 
FAAmecanic said:
Thanks Chris.... I appreciate the HONEST input, even though I am comparing you to a competitor.

I still havent 100% made up my mind yet. My wife brings up a good point, it is worth it to pay more money if you KNOW someone will stand behind thier products. I just have to look at my budget and decide :) (as well as get over the shock of my wife telling me its OK to spend MORE money :D )

Thanks again guys... now Im off to price two specific configurations between VM and ABS... wish me luck ;)

One last piece of advice - if I may. No matter who you decide to go with, the price increase of going with the X6800 is the equivalent of a second 8800 GTS. If gaming is your primary concern, you might want to go with the E6700 and SLI instead of an X6800 with one card. (Or to make it more complicated - go with an E6700 with single 8800 GTX)

;)
 
ChrisMorley said:
1) More features in the BIOS
2) MUCH better cooling
3) Better memory compatibility
4) Higher FSB support
5) Higher memory frequency support
6) Quad-core support
7) And yeah, it overclocks MUCH better

Lemme just say that we're much happier with the 680i as our flagship motherboard for SLI as compared to the P5N32-SLI.

Again, most of your points are moot. :D

Quad-core support definately and better cooling. Memory too.

Is it worth the extra $600?

If you were willing to shell out $1000+ for a Quad-core maybe.
No reason to have better memory if overclocking voids the warrenty..
Cooling would only be important to people anal about temps @ stock speeds.

My suggestion is to go to ABS because the features of the 680i cannot really be taken into consideration considering buying an OEM computer is mainly for the warrenty. I -could- be wrong about the overclocking voiding warrenty but as far as I know, ABS will hold better value overall.

However, if you intend to overclock after the warrenty is up or want to down the line, by all means hit up Velocity Micro :D

Btw Chris I was checking out a VM machine at BB today and looked at the LL PC-60 case lookalike....does LL manufacture cases for you or do you just follow the example of high quality stuff?
 
Riddlinkidstoner said:
Again, most of your points are moot. :D

Quad-core support definately and better cooling. Memory too.

Is it worth the extra $600?

If you were willing to shell out $1000+ for a Quad-core maybe.
No reason to have better memory if overclocking voids the warrenty..
Cooling would only be important to people anal about temps @ stock speeds.

My suggestion is to go to ABS because the features of the 680i cannot really be taken into consideration considering buying an OEM computer is mainly for the warrenty. I -could- be wrong about the overclocking voiding warrenty but as far as I know, ABS will hold better value overall.

However, if you intend to overclock after the warrenty is up or want to down the line, by all means hit up Velocity Micro :D

Btw Chris I was checking out a VM machine at BB today and looked at the LL PC-60 case lookalike....does LL manufacture cases for you or do you just follow the example of high quality stuff?

Hmmm, I thought you were asking about why I thought the 680i board was a better board than the P5N32-SLI. Those were my reasons. It's flat out a better board, no matter who you buy it from.

And to answer your last question, Lian Li does manufacture our chassis with the modifications that we spec out.
 
ChrisMorley said:
One last piece of advice - if I may. No matter who you decide to go with, the price increase of going with the X6800 is the equivalent of a second 8800 GTS. If gaming is your primary concern, you might want to go with the E6700 and SLI instead of an X6800 with one card. (Or to make it more complicated - go with an E6700 with single 8800 GTX)

;)

Ok OK....UNCLE :D Between my wife saying VM rocks for responding in such a positive manner to my questions (she was VERY impressed that VM would answer my questions even though I was looking at a competitor...as I AM also) , and my looking again at a similiar 680i ABS PC and it was only about $200 less than VM... Im going with VM!

I also didnt like how I was FORCED into a Liquid cooling system with ABS if I wanted something other than the stock Intel HS/FAN and a mobo other than the Intel D975XBX (which didnt do that well in reviews). And my last two rigs I built the Intel HS/FAN would BARELY keep the CPU under max Thermal. And in fact my 3.4E started to throttle and had to buy a Thermalright XP70C heatsink....

And you just answered my next question Chris. I was going to ask what the benefits would be (vs. cost) in going with a Intel 6800 vs. 6700.

This PC is for gaming...big time gaming (been a gaming nut since the Commodore Vic20 days :rolleyes: )

Anywho...I think a 8800 GTS SLI is a bit much for my wallet. But here is what I think I will be ordering from VM:

Case: LX-W Black Case
Power Supply: 700watt Seasonic
Motherboard: eVGA nForce 680i
CPU: E6700
CPU Cooling: Arctic Cooling Freezer 7 HS (Artic Silver 5 ROCKS!)
Memory: 2048 Corsair XMS2 DDR2-800
Video: eVGA 8800GTS (no SLI...need the price to come down some on the card..then add :) )
Video Tuning: Basic 3d (What does this include Chris?)
Audio: Soundblaster X-Fi Platinum (what is the advantage of this over the xtreme music other than a front panel and remote?)
HDD: 2 x 320GB WD SATA 300
Optical Drive 1: 16x Lite on DVD =/-RW/CD-RW Dual layer
Optical drive 2: 16x Lite On DVD/48x CD-RW combo
Floppy: 1.44
OS: MS XP Home SP2
**********

I hope if I wait until tommorow to order I can get this system before Christmas! But I would like to have those few questions in bold above answered.... mainly the question about the different Sound Blaster cards (Xtreme music vs. Platinum).

As far as the RAID goes...I just hate the idea of if one drive craps out... you loose everything.

OH and one more question...IF I decide to go with a 8800 GTS SLI configuration...are the Nvidia drivers ready to handle these in SLI? I have read that the 8800 series wasnt quite ready for SLI prime time?

Any other suggestions for me...keeping in mind this is for Big Time Gaming (and MS Flight Simulator X... it runs like a DOG on my current rig).

Thanks again for your help everyone.... this has been a hard choice...but like the [H] posters have said...VM's service seems to be the best. And once I spec'ed out 680i systems between ABS and VM...there was only a difference of $100 or so.
 
Looks like an easy choice! Best of luck.

I was trying to catch a view of the VM box at my local Best Buy in the Philly area but no dice.
 
go with HDD 1 as a 250, same with HDD 2, the 2xAnything are raid'd i believe, and the 250's are much cheaper (3 250's is cheaper than 2 320's)

if SLI GTS's are too much, just grab a single GTX then :) cheaper than SLI GTS, but better than a single GTS
 
0mega said:
go with HDD 1 as a 250, same with HDD 2, the 2xAnything are raid'd i believe, and the 250's are much cheaper (3 250's is cheaper than 2 320's)

if SLI GTS's are too much, just grab a single GTX then :) cheaper than SLI GTS, but better than a single GTS

The thing I didnt like about the 250's is they are SATA 150 with 8m cache. The WD 320's are SATA 300 with 16M cache.... not sure how much of a difference there is between the two performance wise (max 150 MB/s transfer rate v. 300 MB/s...seems pretty big to me).

And in looking at the VM website... you can choose each HDD individually, or you can choose to have them RAID'ed.

I may just grab the GTX.... but the price offset will be greater because VM recommeds a 1000 Watt PS :eek: and the LX-e case if you SLI them (which I plan to do no matter if I go with the GTX or the GTS).... Pretty soon we will have to have our Graphics cards in thier own case if they get any bigger!
 
FAAmecanic said:
The thing I didnt like about the 250's is they are SATA 150 with 8m cache. The WD 320's are SATA 300 with 16M cache.... not sure how much of a difference there is between the two performance wise (max 150 MB/s transfer rate v. 300 MB/s...seems pretty big to me).

And in looking at the VM website... you can choose each HDD individually, or you can choose to have them RAID'ed.

I may just grab the GTX.... but the price offset will be greater because VM recommeds a 1000 Watt PS :eek: and the LX-e case if you SLI them (which I plan to do no matter if I go with the GTX or the GTS).... Pretty soon we will have to have our Graphics cards in thier own case if they get any bigger!

The GTX is long enough that with even one you must select the LXe or LXe-W chassis - it's just too long for the regular LX.

I've personally tested a Kentsfield with 8800 GTX in SLI and 4 HDD going full tilt and have found it to be rock solid over a 24 hour period. However, we're abiding by NVIDIA's recommendations when it comes to PSUs, but you definitely don't need a 1KW for a single 8800 GTX.

As per the Platinum vs. other flavors - yeah, it's basically the front panel connector that is the difference. It doesn't get interesting until you look at the Elite Pro which actually has higher quality DACs and the 64mb X-RAM (market gimmick or not.) If you don't think you'll need the extra connectors on the front, you may want to consider saving money and going with the XtremeMusic.

As to HDDs, I believe we offer the 2500KS with 16MB cache and SATA300 as an option, if not, I can make sure to add it to the configurator.
 
PinataUT said:
Looks like an easy choice! Best of luck.

I was trying to catch a view of the VM box at my local Best Buy in the Philly area but no dice.

Yeah I only saw ONE VM machine there (Which was amazingly reasonable in terms of price/performance. Equipped with a 7900GS even...which kicked all the nearby HP's and emachines).

Chris, you should start shoving all those other crappy OEMs out of the way and really shine center stage man! It'd be easier to convince people to buy Velocity Micro because in my local best buy, your nothing but a little tag inbetween two overpriced HP Media Centers. I'd like to see VM a more trusted name in the average gamer consumer market instead of the "Big 3" :confused:

Only reason I saw it was your little VM arrow in the center of the LL case.
 
Wait...whats that sound... (whsss whss whsss)...oh thats the sound of VM emptying my bank account :D :eek:

Here is what I FINALLY settled on:

GAMERS Edge PCX
Case: LXe-W Black Case
Power Supply: 700watt Seasonic
Motherboard: eVGA nForce 680i
CPU: E6700
CPU Cooling: Arctic Cooling Freezer 7 HS (Artic Silver 5 ROCKS!)
Memory: 2048 Corsair XMS2 DDR2-800
Video: 2 x eVGA 8800GTS in SLI (Chris you can thank my wife here...she talked me into it :) )
Video Tuning: Basic 3d
Audio: Soundblaster X-Fi Xtreme Music
HDD: 2 x 320GB WD SATA 300 (Chris... no option on selections for 250 GB SATA 3 HDD..)
Optical Drive 1: 16x Lite on DVD =/-RW/CD-RW Dual layer
Optical drive 2: 16x Lite On DVD/48x CD-RW combo
Floppy: 1.44
OS: MS XP Home SP2
********************************

Now the wait....Ohhh the agony :p

Thanks again Chris and everyone else!
 
FAAmecanic said:
Wait...whats that sound... (whsss whss whsss)...oh thats the sound of VM emptying my bank account
Here is what I FINALLY settled on:

GAMERS Edge PCX
Case: LXe-W Black Case
Power Supply: 700watt Seasonic
Motherboard: eVGA nForce 680i
CPU: E6700
CPU Cooling: Arctic Cooling Freezer 7 HS (Artic Silver 5 ROCKS!)
Memory: 2048 Corsair XMS2 DDR2-800
Video: 2 x eVGA 8800GTS in SLI (Chris you can thank my wife here...she talked me into it
Video Tuning: Basic 3d
Audio: Soundblaster X-Fi Xtreme Music
HDD: 2 x 320GB WD SATA 300 (Chris... no option on selections for 250 GB SATA 3 HDD..)
Optical Drive 1: 16x Lite on DVD =/-RW/CD-RW Dual layer
Optical drive 2: 16x Lite On DVD/48x CD-RW combo
Floppy: 1.44
OS: MS XP Home SP2
********************************

Now the wait....Ohhh the agony :p

Thanks again Chris and everyone else!

SOLID rig, I'm jealous. ;) If you want 250's you can call our sales department and they can make the adjustment...
 
ChrisMorley said:
SOLID rig, I'm jealous. ;) If you want 250's you can call our sales department and they can make the adjustment...


LOL.. Im sure you get to "test" out the newest configurations for VM dont ya!! :p

Im ok with the 320's, looks like I can always use the capacity... With programs like MS Flight Sim X taking up over 14 gigs of space..Im sure programs are just going to get bigger!
 
Back
Top