help me out with my mobo selection

Joined
Aug 6, 2004
Messages
2
So I am fairly noob and what I have learned came in the past week. So forgive any stupid ignorance.

I am piecing out a computer and the mobo is where i am stuck...

Here is what I have:
XP-Mobile 2400+ (35W)
Scythe Samurai for cooling
1x512 Crucial BallistiX pc3200
MSI Radeon 9800 pro 128mb
VGA silencer for 9800pro

Now for the mobo. I am down to 2 choices. Abit NF7-S v2 or the DFI NFII Ultra Infinity.
I am sorta confused about the various chipsets. What is the difference between nforce 2 SPP that the abit has and the nforce 2 Ultra 400 that the DFI has? Does it have to do with Dual channel capabilities?? If I want the added benefits of Dual channel, should i get the DFI board because both the website for abit and newegg say noting about supporting dual channel. (I know i dont have 2x512 yet, but the wallet is only so big. There will be another BallistiX stick in the mail within a month or 2) So I want dual channel.

Also, if anyone can link me up to a very comprehensive understanding of the nforce 2, not 3, chipsets, I would be most appreciative.

Thanks in advance for anyones help!!!!
Chris
 
bump for the morning. I want to buy my stuff today and I need to resolve mobo issues. Please give me some advice if you can.

Thanks
 
i like my lanparty; new bios fixes EVERY issue and makes it more stable at higher fsb and fixes cold and warm boot issues
 
DFI Infinity - only 10/100 Ethernet but has 4x SATA
DFI Infinity B - Gigabit Ethernet, 4x SATA, looks good, some extras with the board, but with AL650 sound
NF7-S - 10/100 Ethernet, 2x SATA, but has SoundStorm.

If you are comparing the plain Infinity then I would do the NF7-S. The Infinity B is a lot more expensive, but has the features mentioned above. So then you have to decide if you would rather have better on-board sound, while sacrificing the looks and the extras, or if you want the looks and extras and will live with the lower end sound or get a sound card.

Brian Taylor
 
Hello n00bie.

I shall answer the unanswered chipset questions for you. (small history lesson).

The first nForce2 chipset to launch was the nF2 "SPP", which was "dual channel" and officially supported the 200,266 and 333 FSB's (nearly all could do 400mhz unofficially). This went on for about a year and was paired with both the MCP and MCP-T southbridges.

Then, nVidia wanted to compete with VIA"s low cost, and replaced the "SPP" with 2 new chipsets, the nF2 Ultra 400 and nF2 400. The former is basically the "SPP" chipset with official 400mhz FSB support. The latter is the SPP with 400 mhz FSB support but only "single channel" memory. This review gives you a good comparison on the differences between the two chipset: http://www.lostcircuits.com/motherboard/asus_a7n8x-x/

Basically, all the board you mentioned have DC support (as do most on the market that anyone would consider). I'm not a huge fan of BFI *cough* ahem... DFI product... but they sure have made a splash with their Lan Fiesta and Infinity series motherboards.... I don't like the power header placement on Abit's NF7 series boards, as you have to drag your mains over your processor..... I do like my Asus board's layout, and I like Shuttle's AN35N (for the budget minded folk).

In terms of the rest of your system, especially since you're on a budget, you may want to make the following considerations: Go with standard issue RAM, but go for the gig- the BallstiX from Crucial are running about 140 bucks now.. where you can pick up some Corsair Value Select from ZipZoomFly for 'bout 80 delivered (512mb quanities). Performancewise, you'd be much better off with 1024mb of Cas3 RAM than you would be with 512mb of Cas2 RAM. (Which keeps you off the CAS999999 virtual memory... :D)

Additionally, you may wish to invest in the Athlon 64 platform, as the prices are falling on them. The 2800+ is down below $150 (well.. at least wholesale is getting there), and boards can be had for under $100 for an nF3 250Gb based mobo--- heck, i'd trade the 512 of ballsticks for 512 of crucial value select and an upgrade to the A64 platform... then get the next 512 later on down the road....
 
Back
Top