Help me decide between 2 builds

RedCt

Weaksauce
Joined
Sep 1, 2006
Messages
64
Yes - another one of those threads ;) I'm trying to decide between 2 builds - 1 AMD and one Intel. I'm not using my build for much heavy work - only light gaming like WoW and some stuff like Company of Heroes and the occasional game of BF2142. I'm also using the build for the typical office/internet stuff and some occasional Photoshop work. I plan to do some light overclocking - maybe up 200-400Mhz, that's all. The two builds are below:

AMD -
ASUS M2N-E
Athlon X2 3800 w/Zalman CNPS9500
2 GB of OCZ DDR2-800
250GB Hard Drive (not sure what kind yet, recommendations?)
Not buying the 7600GT anymore. I'm buying the cheapest video card with the build and am going to use eVGA's Step-Up program with a card off NewEgg.

Intel -
Core 2 Duo E6400
Gigabyte GA-965P-DQ6
The rest will stay the same

Personally, I'm favoring the AMD build. The main reason why is it's cheaper than the Intel build (by about $300). Also, you should know that I'm _not_ building this myself - I'm ordering from AVADirect after seeing the good reviews they got from [H] and other places.
 
The parts comparison isn't equal, though. The AX2 3800+'s intel counterpart would be the E6300, and the Asus M2N-E's intel based counterpart would be the P5B-E, which is significantly cheaper than the DQ6.

Anyhow, I'd go for the Intel build... drop to the E6300 and a cheaper P965 Express based mobo. For the HDD, go with a seagate 7200.10 model.
 
When I change the mobos and CPU down, there is still a difference of about $150. Plus if I upgrade the AMD CPU and mobo to the Intel equivalent, there's still a price difference of about $175. Because I'm on a budget and the things I'm using the computer for, I'm having a hard time finding reason to get the Intel. Any more suggestions?
 
"eVGA 7600GT KO (until the nVidia 8xxx gets cheaper)"

I would have said go with the AMD if it wasn't for this. If you are interested in the dx10 cards do yourself a favor and get the best CPU you can afford or at least a platform that you know you can upgrade to better core duo or quad processors in the future.

The dx10 cards (if the 8800gtx is any indication) will need the best CPU you can give them.
 
Go with the intel. And don't forget a good power supply.
 
anonuser said:
"eVGA 7600GT KO (until the nVidia 8xxx gets cheaper)"

I would have said go with the AMD if it wasn't for this. If you are interested in the dx10 cards do yourself a favor and get the best CPU you can afford or at least a platform that you know you can upgrade to better core duo or quad processors in the future.

The dx10 cards (if the 8800gtx is any indication) will need the best CPU you can give them.

Ignore the 7600GT thing. I'm going to order with the cheapest video card available with the computer and buy a card off of newegg and use eVGA's Step-Up program. Just found out about it :) Seems like a really good idea.
 
Since you're on a budget, you should build it yourself, lol.
 
Back
Top