help me choose a video card

iroc409

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jun 17, 2006
Messages
1,387
I just got rid of my X1900XT Crossfire setup, and am looking for its replacement. I have been planning on going to a Crossfire 3870 setup, but I thought I would see what everyone thinks. I play on a 24" widescreen, have a quad, and just bought 8GB of DDR800 (to upgrade from 4).

I have thought about doing a single 3870, Crossfire, maybe Crossfire 3850's, or even going to Nvidia. I have an Intel chipset, so SLI is out (plus I don't like Nvidia chipsets).

What would be any of your recommendations? I am looking for either similar performance from a single card, or of course better performance. I am willing to spend up to about $500 for the solution. I could use a motherboard upgrade as well, so saving money and upgrading the motherboard certainly isn't out of the question; I'm looking for performance-per-dollar but also just raw power in general.

Thanks!
 
I've always used ATI in my primary machines, I guess I'm just wondering if dual 3870's is overkill and there is a "good enough" single-card solution. Thanks for the input though! Dual 3870's is probably what I will still go with.
 
if you can spend the money i would go with dual 3870's because the performance of 2 3870's is better then 1 8800GTX or 1 8800 Ultra.

or another choice would be going with 2 8800GT's.

i would personally go with the dual ATI 3870's because they are cheaper.

Bestbuy has a 3850 for $160, maybe go dual those? what do people think?
 
since poster already has a crossfire capable board, i would suggest dual 3870's. if you can get them within msrp it is more than worth the purchase. a lot of posters are going around quoting benchmark scores about 3870cf out performing 8800 ultra/gtx, truthfully the theoretical performance is there, but during live game play the performance is kind of choppy. my best example is in cod4. on the last stage, you parachute into a snow covered forest. when you turn to face the forest, you're treated to snowflakes fluttering around in your field of vision. in cf the recorded frame rates are higher, but the game feels slower than when the same scene is run on a single 3870. hopefully the next ati patch will speed things up. again, i believe both 3850 and 3870 cf can out perform a single premium nvidia card, but for now that is only true in benchmarks.
 
Back
Top