Help me bridge two networks with wifi

tucansam

n00b
Joined
Apr 16, 2012
Messages
12
Gang,

I have a wired network downstairs, and a wired network upstairs. I need to get the two talking, and I can't run wires. I have a pair of POE adapters, and they suck. I can't use coax cable, its not in the walls. I have to use wifi (or some wireless tech).

The wired networks are GigE, and I need the wireless bridge to be as fast as possible.

I tried a pair of Ubiquity Unifi APs, and it turns out that they do not have this functionality, which is unfortunate, because they are hands down the best wifi APs I have ever used.

I have an old Linksys b/g wifi router with dd-wrt on it, and it will do bridging, but slowly.

I suppose I can drop $400 on a pair of Netgear Nighthawks and install dd-wrt, but that's quite an expense.

I've looked at a single Nighthawk with a "wireless extender," but the reviews of said extenders are hit or miss as far as reliability goes.

I need both LAN segments to be up with 99.999% reliability, and I need speed (desktops upstairs connecting to servers downstairs)

I do have wireless clients in the house that need N (and eventually AC) connectivity. One Unifi AP downstairs gives me 99% signal through about 75% of the house, which is amazing.

Looking for suggestions. A pair of Nano's looking at each other through the ceiling/floor would work, but they don't have the speed. I'd love something in the AC range. I don't need a router, I just need at least one AP (for clients) and a way to get a segment bridged upstairs.

I appreciate your time.
 
Hmmm, did you get the UAP-AC (square shaped instead of round)? If not, a quick look at the datasheet, says there's a 'wireless uplink' feature, which I would think would do what you want.

Otherwise, any chance you have in-wall wiring for telephone that you might be able to re-purpose? Maybe only feasible if it's homerunned somewhere, but if it's at least Cat3, you can probably run 100M if there are two usable pairs, and if all four pairs are there, you can try for gigE, it can work on cat3 even though it's not in spec.

If that doesn't work, I think you should be able to pick up any two routers (or access points), provided at least one has the 'wireless client' feature. I have done this in the past with WDS bridge mode, if you do that, be sure to get matched hardware (it's been a while, so maybe standards compliance is better).

Client mode would likely be a better experience, as wireless clients wouldn't connect to the far router, and then have the far router repeat the packets over the air.
 
Thanks man.

I have UAPs, the UAP-ACs don't have the uplink functionality (yet, its in beta and not working at all as per the Ubiquity forums).

I spent all night trying to get the uplink feature to work on my UAPs, and couldn't. Posting to the forums, was told that they won't act as bridges.

I understand the client mode concept, trouble is, every mfg seems to call it something different (client mode, wireless bridge, wireless extender...). Maybe my google-fu is weak, but aside from some dd-wrt and tomato posts, I can't find a lot of sophisticated wireless bridging docs using the latest specs.
 
Gang,
I need both LAN segments to be up with 99.999% reliability, and I need speed (desktops upstairs connecting to servers downstairs)

When you absolutely positively need three-nines reliability, you use wired connections, accept no substitute.

That being said, why not just buy a DDWRT compatible router and put it in client bridged mode?
 
When you absolutely positively need three-nines reliability, you use wired connections, accept no substitute.

As soon as we buy the house and own it, this is what I will be doing :D

That being said, why not just buy a DDWRT compatible router and put it in client bridged mode?

Would love to based on the research I've done, but all of the AC routers and APs I've looked at have very mixed reviews. Before I drop $200/ea on a pair, I'd like to know they'll be solid from a reliability standpoint. I would love to hear suggestions on which AC (1300mbps+) routers are NOT of the flavor that require frequent reboots etc.
 
Thanks man.

I have UAPs, the UAP-ACs don't have the uplink functionality (yet, its in beta and not working at all as per the Ubiquity forums).

I spent all night trying to get the uplink feature to work on my UAPs, and couldn't. Posting to the forums, was told that they won't act as bridges.

I understand the client mode concept, trouble is, every mfg seems to call it something different (client mode, wireless bridge, wireless extender...). Maybe my google-fu is weak, but aside from some dd-wrt and tomato posts, I can't find a lot of sophisticated wireless bridging docs using the latest specs.

The uplink feature doesn't work like that. It's only for creating a wireless mesh. Basically turns it into a repeater. You can't then use the ethernet port to bridge the network.
 
I used to do this at home with a Dlink DIR-825 wireless router downstairs and a Dlink DAP-1522 upstairs. The DAP-1522 can run as a bridge or as an access point. Both of these operate 2.4 / 5.

This last weekend I bit the bullet and just ran cable upstairs after using the above setup since January 2012. I used a 200 foot cat 5 cable and a some cable clips that pound into the wall. Even after to switching to wired I see no difference in my latency in the game we normally play online.
 
As soon as we buy the house and own it, this is what I will be doing :D



Would love to based on the research I've done, but all of the AC routers and APs I've looked at have very mixed reviews. Before I drop $200/ea on a pair, I'd like to know they'll be solid from a reliability standpoint. I would love to hear suggestions on which AC (1300mbps+) routers are NOT of the flavor that require frequent reboots etc.

Do you have phone jack in the room? If so you might be able to re-purpose the existing cable:

10/100 VDSL2 Ethernet Extender Kit over Single Pair Wire - Extend your 10/100Mbps network by up to 1km over Ethernet or RJ11 phone lines: http://www.amazon.com/StarTech-com-...&qid=1399326566&sr=1-1&keywords=vdsl+ethernet

I don't have any direct experience with the above, but it's rated 4.5/5 stars at amazon.
 
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I bought one of these TP-Link AP/AP-Client devices linked below a few years back. I needed to give two desktop PC's on the third floor of my town house access to a wifi AP (a D-Link wireless router) on the first floor. I wired the 2 PC and the AP-client together with an ethernet switch and the AP-Client bridged the Upstairs LAN to the downstairs LAN.

I was actually surprised how well it worked given how cheap the device was. I kept it around after I moved my PCs downstairs, it turned out to be handy way to add wireless capability to any network device.

TP-LINK TL-WA500G eXtended Range IEEE 802.11b/g 54Mbps Wireless G Access Point
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I can't say enough about the ubiquity stuff myself. I've had great luck with a pair of nanostation loco M2's over the last year...never rebooted them once...if only I could say the same for some of the Microtik stuff I have to monitor. My main connection to a fiber link about a mile away is soon to be upgraded via a pair of nanostation M365's.

Anyway, I'd get a couple of nanostation M5's and set one in Bridge mode under the network tab and Access Point with a tick in the box for WDS (transparent bridge mode) under the wireless tab. Set the other in Bridge on network tab as well and Station (WDS) on the wireless tab. I'd also recommend a static IP for each radio and make sure you specify your gateway IP and DNS IP's to make everything smooth.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I can't say enough about the ubiquity stuff myself. I've had great luck with a pair of nanostation loco M2's over the last year...never rebooted them once...if only I could say the same for some of the Microtik stuff I have to monitor. My main connection to a fiber link about a mile away is soon to be upgraded via a pair of nanostation M365's.

Anyway, I'd get a couple of nanostation M5's and set one in Bridge mode under the network tab and Access Point with a tick in the box for WDS (transparent bridge mode) under the wireless tab. Set the other in Bridge on network tab as well and Station (WDS) on the wireless tab. I'd also recommend a static IP for each radio and make sure you specify your gateway IP and DNS IP's to make everything smooth.

M5 =5Ghz...depending on what's in the walls it might not cut it.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top