HDD PCB swap. What to know?

greengolftee87

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 15, 2008
Messages
274
I have a 1TB WD external laptop drive that is unresponsive. Normally I would take it out of the case and hook it up to my desktop to diagnose this problem. However, this external has the USB controller built right into the PCB. Damn. So I ordered another one, the exact same model number and revision number as the original PCB. Post swapping the boards I can hear mechanical sounds but am unsure what it is. It almost seems like there isnt enough power to get the drive spinning but the original board in the same USB port could. Is there anything else I can try to get this replacement to work? Thanks.
 
I have a 1TB WD external laptop drive that is unresponsive. Normally I would take it out of the case and hook it up to my desktop to diagnose this problem. However, this external has the USB controller built right into the PCB. Damn. So I ordered another one, the exact same model number and revision number as the original PCB. Post swapping the boards I can hear mechanical sounds but am unsure what it is. It almost seems like there isnt enough power to get the drive spinning but the original board in the same USB port could. Is there anything else I can try to get this replacement to work? Thanks.

PCB swapping no longer works for HDDs.
Rather to explain why, I recommend you go to hddguru.net forums.
 
Probably need to transfer the ROM....but i would post on hddguru.com before doing much else.
 
Can you give a 2 line summary of why it doesn't work anymore?
The firmware is modified regularly to keep track of SMART data, optimizations, bad sectors, spare space among other things.

Since the firmware is different from stock, changing PCBs won't work unless you can copy the firmware and that requires special tools.

It might be possible to repair the PCB by replacing damaged diodes or resistors which are the more common failures.
 
The firmware is modified regularly to keep track of SMART data, optimizations, bad sectors, spare space among other things.

Since the firmware is different from stock, changing PCBs won't work unless you can copy the firmware and that requires special tools.

It might be possible to repair the PCB by replacing damaged diodes or resistors which are the more common failures.

Yea but if you just transfer the ROM chip, you dont have mess with any firmware issues.
 
Back
Top