HD 4870 or HD 4830 X2 ?

msarp

Gawd
Joined
Jul 21, 2007
Messages
702
Hello, I have a 4870 that a friend is interested in. I am thinking of going with the new HD4830(2) series in Cross Fire for pretty much the same cost as a 4870.
I play TF2 and now Left 4 Dead. I play at 1600x1200.

Would it be a good move or should I stick w/ my 4870 ?
Thanks
 
why not do 4850 x 2? get 2 of them as open box from newegg for like 130
 
If I already had the appropriate motherboard and power supply, like yours, I'd be tempted to install two 4850s and sell off my 4870. I'd try to find a Newegg open box special or some such deal, like the previous poster mentioned. I would spend the extra cash to get the 4850s, as there is no way would I go with 4830. I wouldn't do it for those Source engine games, either, considering the 4870 can perform well enough to turn up a lot of AA/AF on them.

That being said, I would do it for a fun experience, but, again, only with cheaply found 4850s. 4850s usually beat up on the 4870 512MB by a decent enough margin to consider the upgrade.
 
At 1600*1200, keep your 4870.
The 4870X2 upgrade would make much more sense at 2560*1600.
 
At 1600*1200, keep your 4870.
The 4870X2 upgrade would make much more sense at 2560*1600.

The 4870 X2 is not an option, I'm not sure why that card got thrown around. He is debating between his current HD 4870 and 2 HD 4830's
 
why does everybody with two slots think they have to use them? one single fast card is always the way to go for less problems.
 
From what I've heard, some game seems to have problems with CF/SLI, so the best bet is to stick with one card. IMO at 1680x1050, a 4870 is just fine. The minor performance boost in some games is not worth it compare to the headaches you will have in others.
 
I got a 4870x2 and am very impressed so far in Crysis of all games. Smooth gameplay Very High 2xAA. I'm noticing a huge difference in gameplay coming from a GTX260 at least.
 
agree with most everybody here, at 1.76mp you don't need a dual card solution. a 4870 is about perfect.
 
Thanks guys for all your advice. When I was approached about selling my 4870, I had not considered it but like most of us, the "Upgrade Bug" got my attention. I started reading about the 4830 and how good it performed in crossfire .
I agree with all of you on the 4850x2. That would be a better upgrade!
Considering the Steam based games I play(Valve) , I probably would have done the upgrade if you all said "Go for it" !
Thanks for all your thoughts. I probably will keep my 4870. I do not overclock and so far no game has given me a problem.
 
Back
Top