having hard time deciding

v1rtu0s1ty

n00b
Joined
Jan 28, 2005
Messages
23
hey guys,

I need your input. I have narrowed down my selection to FX5700LE and FX5900SE. I'm really can't go beyond $140. I'm planning to buy this card for 2 factors, 30% game and 70% HDTV via DVI out to my Mitsubishi 48".

Any recommendation will be helpful to me.

Thanks,

V1rt
 
I was investigating this sort of range for a friend who has to have PCI and is on a budget. I didn't find a decent comparison to tell for certain, but, I was under the definite impression that the 5900SE is the better card. In my experience, it seems like it's better to get one of the crippled high end cards as they have more potential once you start overclocking and that sort of thing (if you care to OC.)

Well, it might help to know what sort of gaming. If it's low end games like UT2K (that's right, UT2K has VERY low video requirements believe it or not, it's more a balance of video/cpu than most games these days) then it may not even matter much and it might just make sense to go with the cheaper. If you plan to go with higher end games and are more serious about quality and all, you need to be looking at which performs better after overclocking/etc.
 
5900 is higher end than 5700. However, 5900SE is a crippled version of the 5900. Thus "crippled high end." To cripple them, typically they do things like cut pipelines, decrease the memory bus, use lower clock speeds -- usually with chips that can't handle the normal clock rate of the non crippled version, etc.
 
Er, no, I was saying that, the 5900SE can theoretically have the potential to be better.

IMO, you should do some searching and try to find some direct benchmark comparisons though. Can't hurt to know for certain.
 
I went to newegg today and 5900SE is out of stock. :(
I can't wait anymore. Looks like I want to buy FX5700 but I don't know if it's a good choice.
 
No, 5700 sure not ...
The 6600GT series have a very good High Definition TV encoder, so my tip would be to gather some more money (that would be 30 - 60$) and buy one. Also, they're very good with newer games, not like 5700 ...
As for brands, Leadtek is what I suggest.
 
Oh, oops I didn't look at prices recently... When I investigated this stuff for a friend was a fairly good while ago and there was no 6600. Yeah, the difference between the 5700 or even the 5900 and the 6600 is off the scale. DO NOT buy a 5700 or 5900 if it's at all reasonably possible for you to get a 6600. I'm not kidding. The 6600 can compete with the Radeon 9800 Pro.

EDIT: If it is impossible, here's where you can find a 5900SE on newegg: http://www.newegg.com/app/viewProductDesc.asp?description=14-133-101&depa=0
 
True indeed.
But though, for what are you using HDTV? Satellite or for stand alone components (dvd, etc.). Because for satellite I'd strongly suggest you to look at the SkyStar 2 DVB pc card, that is around 60 Euro. There are some programs that transmit HDTV via sat. on Astra (19 Degrees East), HotBird (13 degrees East), Sirius (5 degrees East).
For more details www.lyngsat.com
Of course, there also tuners specially for HDTV ...
But if you really want to buy a video card, try to take a 6600GT by all means ...

* EDIT *

Nazo, 6600GT is over 9800Pro, at least the tests says this ...
 
Aryiam said:
Nazo, 6600GT is over 9800Pro, at least the tests says this ...
Didn't say it wasn't. However, in this pricerange, he won't be looking at the GT, he will be looking at the non-gt. Now, I'm saying that the non-gt is probably at least even with the 9800 Pro, quite possibly still better. (What is ATI doing? Geez.)

Anyway, I do agree that you may well find a higher quality HDTV tuner if you buy that seperately, but, more importantly, it won't be a limiting factor when you want to upgrade that video card in the future since you can just keep the seperate HDTV encoder.
 
Just a bit of info for you. You can currently pick up the Geforce 6600 256mb card for 145 shipped from Newegg. I'm assuming ofcourse that you are looking pci-e. This should fit your budget, and will give you th most bang for your buck. Hope this helps.
 
If you don't mind buying used cards, you can always see if you can pick up a used 9700Pro or a 9800Pro. They are good cards, and kick the crap out of the FX line, and, as their aged technology, you should be able to get them for a steal.
 
DamienThorn said:
If you don't mind buying used cards, you can always see if you can pick up a used 9700Pro or a 9800Pro. They are good cards, and kick the crap out of the FX line, and, as their aged technology, you should be able to get them for a steal.

If by "FX line" you mean the FX 5x00 line, yes. If by "FX line" you mean the FX line in general, no. The 6600 series and 6800 series both beat the crap out of the 9800 Pro even, and the 6600 GT is cheaper than the 9800 Pro...

Now, used, you might find a 9700 or 9800 for a cheaper price, and they will be better than anything less than the 6600. Theoretically it might be possible to find a used 6600 or 6800 somewhere for a decent price too, so if you are looking at used, you should check that too.
 
Nazo said:
If by "FX line" you mean the FX 5x00 line, yes. If by "FX line" you mean the FX line in general, no. The 6600 series and 6800 series both beat the crap out of the 9800 Pro even, and the 6600 GT is cheaper than the 9800 Pro...

Now, used, you might find a 9700 or 9800 for a cheaper price, and they will be better than anything less than the 6600. Theoretically it might be possible to find a used 6600 or 6800 somewhere for a decent price too, so if you are looking at used, you should check that too.

By the FX line, I did indeed mean the 5x00 line.
 
Ok guys, I have decided to go with GeForce 6600 or Geforce 6600 GT. The reason, PureVideo technology is offered both on 6600 series. Ok now, the price difference between the two is $40+

If I get GeForce 6600, how much am I really missing if not getting the GT?

Please send me some important points.

Thanks,

V1rt
 
Nazo said:
If by "FX line" you mean the FX 5x00 line, yes. If by "FX line" you mean the FX line in general, no. The 6600 series and 6800 series both beat the crap out of the 9800 Pro even, and the 6600 GT is cheaper than the 9800 Pro...
...


it's a common misconception, FX line is ONLY 5x00s, 6x00s are simple GeForces (no FX affix). So ur correction is in itself incorrect :D
 
actually, I've modified my post.

I want to know which brand that has a 6600 GT chip will be appropriate for the amount we are paying for those. What I mean here is that, I might be getting brand z but it's not stable. So on and so forth. There are the AGP brands I have seen at newegg.

GeForce 6600 GT(Rosewill) $199
GeForce 6600 GT(eVGA) $213
GeForce 6600 GT(Leadtek) $216
GeForce 6600 GT(MSI) $222
GeForce 6600 GT(XFX) $235


Thanks guys!
 
:eek: :eek:

ROFL!!!! Look at that heatsink!

Anyway, I've personally never heard of Rosewill. I have heard of Gigabyte, PNY, MSI, etc... Look at the prices... You can get a better deal on many of the other brands. Here's the one I'd probably choose for myself:
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=14-127-147&depa=1

I also liked the look of this one:
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=14-125-156&depa=1

EDIT: Oops, I'm sorry, those are PCI-e... Here's some AGPs:
MSI (IMO, usually pretty reliable): http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=14-127-150&depa=1
eVGA (usually a pretty good brand): http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=14-130-220&depa=1
Gigabyte: http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=14-125-168&depa=1

Sorry about that. Anyway, it's probably better to spend just a bit more to get a brand people actually have heard of as you can probably count on it being more likely that if anything does go wrong you have better support, etc. Oh, and, lol, I'm tempted to say go LeadTek with my own experience, but, really, they aren't any better than the others.
 
Giga-byte, the price of this card tempts me so much :)
I'm actually getting a gigabyte nforce3 250 as i've heard that gigabyte mobos are nice.

Any comments on the 6600 gt gigabyte?

Thanks for the links too! :)
 
Just hope you mean the second links. Sorry about giving you PCI-E links like that d-: Anyway, here's the full search:
http://www.newegg.com/app/searchPro...DEPA=1&bop=and&description=6600GT&srchFor=agp

Anyway, the Gigabyte looks good, in fact, I do believe inside the GPU hsf there might be real copper when I looked more closely. However, the MSI looks like it could possibly be covering the memory chips with that heatsink. It may just simply be sitting over them, but, even then that might have some vague effect of helping heat disspiation ever so slightly. Now, stock that's not necessary, but, I assume you aren't afraid to get down and dirty and start overclocking that thing, yes? Of course, you might consider changing the hsf later anyway, and, the 6600 is a whole different animal as far as OCing goes from what I'm using right now, so I don't know exactly the limitations and all of what you can do with that thing. I do know that with the limited memory bus, you're probably going to want to squeeze whatever you can out of that ram on there. Based on all this, I would personally go with the MSI. However, I have heard mostly only good things about Gigabyte, and, as you said, they make darned good motherboards (they make a nforce 2 that can run a FSB of 250!) I'd consider that a good second choice, or, if you are going to change the hsf, maybe even first. Don't forget you have to worry about that AGP bridge on there too though if you are going to be modding and ocing.

EDIT: Reading some reviews on there. Lol, I bet if you scratch that HSF the scratch will be silver colored. However, it may be copper plated, which is still pretty good. The gigabyte looks to me like it has real 100% copper though.
 
I really didn't understand when you wrote this;

Don't forget you have to worry about that AGP bridge on there too though
if you are going to be modding and ocing.
​

What is that bridge? Is that something that I should buy?

Also, I'm also considering the eVGA 6600 GT since gigabyte is not available at newegg currently. :( What do you think about that brand?

Lastly, I want to utilize my existing full atx case that has 300W power supply but 3 huge quiet fans(given by a friend :) ). Is the power supply enough to drive that card? I read some issues having under powered ps. Please let me know too.

Thanks.
 
Hmm. I know you can't have less than 300W for certain. I'm thinking you might really need more like 350 for a modern video card. Someone else feel free to jump in and correct me if I'm wrong. I do know that ideally you want something that is TRUE 350 or better. Well, there's no harm in trying I suppose, it shouldn't break your card or anything, though you would end up unable to use it or it would be unstable or something. If you start up the system and get this horrible loud high pitched sound, it means that there isn't enough power to even boot up with that card, of course, you'd have to be currently sitting right at the limit more or less for it to do THAT. If you do have to upgrade, I can personally recommend the ThermalTake Silent PurePower very nice for a good price. They aren't perfect, but, are extremely good, and better than most you'll find for that cheap. I've been using this one a good while now without a single problem, and, to be honest, I'm running it on a dirty line... (That means there's a lot of other junk in the same circuit adding some interferance and causing the voltages to fluctuate a bit.)

eVGA is a pretty good brand. I've heard a few cases of it being less than great, but, for the most part I've heard good things. I notice that, like the Gigabyte, the HSF doesn't cover the memory chips. Mind you, this is to be expected in a 6600 series card, I just thought it seemed like a sort of added bonus in the MSI. Well, lol, if nothing else, the heatsink looks interesting enough with the Doom 3 logo and all. Bragging rights or something I suppose.

Oh, and the AGP bridge is the chip on the latest nVidia cards that allows them to design the cards for PCI-Express, then slap a little chip in there to make the card work in an AGP system rather than doing what ATI is currently having to do and make two different versions of the same card. Technically two versions are better, but, the bridge solution is a boatload cheaper to mass produce. If you look at those pictures, you'll note that there is a little rectangular area beneath the GPU with a passive heatsink (sometimes connected to the GPU hsf for better heat dissipation.) That is the AGP bridge chip. I haven't ever used or even seen in person a card with one, so I don't know just how sensitive they are. It may well be that overclocking your card has no effect, but, I would assume that with your card running faster, a little bit more strain is going to be put on the bridge. Probably not much, but, it's something to consider. Also, if you start to get some kind of heatsink upgrade, you have to be sure it's made to actually fit on there. Eg, one for a PCI-E version of the card may not fit right with that bridge. Probably any hsf made to fit one will be made to fit the other as well, but, it's something you should be careful of just in case.
 
I am not saying to buy it, but I am recommanding the card from Leadtek. It sure is quiet, and very powerful ...
I have one and I am very pleased of it. (Tried a Gigabyte one and it seemed under it, but this is only my opinion)
 
I don't want to sound biased, but, lol, all I can say is LeadTek must have put one heck of a high quality GPU in my card... Before voltmodding, it oced up to in the area of 386MHz, and the next card up is 350, so that's not bad at all... After voltmodding it, it jumped up to 425 as being nice and stable, even able to manage 450 in things that don't use the full power of the thing like Doom 3 does, and the next card after that is 400 stock, so it just gets even better. And that stock cooler is the best of all the stock coolers to my knowledge (max load was under 60C for me with it before I voltmodded -- don't know what it would be now.) The memory jumped from 700 stock to in the area of 866 (yes, I like nice numbers, ok?) which isn't super-special, but, it's not exactly bad either. I didn't expect the memory on this thing to reach GT speeds. I believe the idea is that a considerably worse type of memory gets put into the lower end ones, hence the fact that GT has 1GHz ram, and the next one up after that only increases to 1.1GHz.

But, like I said, that's biased. Plus, this is a completely different card, so it's hard to really say what they'd be like. Don't buy based on my opinion, but, maybe do look at things such as the heatsink like Aryiam said. LeadTek seems to be known for their heatsinks. I didn't want to say anything until there was an opinion from someone who actually had used one.

EDIT: LeadTek link: http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=14-122-206&depa=0

I noticed that the PCI-Express models all have the memory chips uncovered. Seems that AGP bridge absolutely requires them to move things over so that the memory gets closer to the GPU. Too bad. All those PCI-Express models have the potential to add heatsinks to the ram. Well, the LeadTek's GPU hsf definitely doesn't directly touch those memory heatsinks. It looks to me like they just stuck the same one from the PCI-E models onto the AGP model. I'll bet just about all of them did that. Right now, I'm most inclined to say get the MSI. If you look at the shape of that HSF, it's quite possible it is covering the memory chips. The PCI-E version of that same card by MSI CLEARLY is designed to cover the memory chips as well, so I'm inclined to say they've simply made an adaptation to do the same thing on the differently shaped AGP model. Better cooled memory will theoretically overclock more to some extent, so I still say you probably want to try to go for something like that. However, if you plan to upgrade the HSF later yourself, you should just look at the components, and I'm inclined to say LeadTek seems to have made an effort.
 
Nazo said:
the fact that GT has 1GHz ram, and the next one up after that only increases to 1.1GHz.

Actually, only the PCI-Express have the memories at 1000 Mhz. The AGP one has 900 Mhz :(

Though, don't know how much they can get, didn't try to overclock it yet. Since everything works very good, why doing it right not? o_O
 
I will do the decisioning of different brands tonight. I have one last question and this is very important to me. All 6600 GT agp cards I've seen in newegg and zipzoomfly look the same. However, some vendor mentions HDTV output and the others dont. All cards I've seen has a DVI out interface. So I don't know what evga or xfx is claiming about. Any clarrifications on this please?

I was thinking that these vendors were saying HDTV output because of the cable adapter they added in their package. Any clues? :)

Please let me know. I'm gonna scratch my credit card tonight. :D

Thanks guys for all the important information.

V1rt
 
Yes, they are using an adaptor. Look carefully, see that s-video looking plug? It's actually a proprietary connector with any number of pins based on whatever the manufacturer had in mind for the card to do (I've seen some with 7, some with 9, even some that just use plain ordinary s-video, but remap the pins, which I was able to eventually splice into something usable rather than having to buy a cable for it.) Typically each one is different, but, perhaps nvidia finally stepped in and set a standard -- but, I wouldn't count on that. Don't buy based solely on if they have the adaptor included or not though. If it has the capability but doesn't include an adaptor, you can always buy one seperately (which may also be on newegg.) Anyway, what it comes down to is, if they don't say it on the page there, there's no way to know what kind of outputs they have on those video cards short of digging through all their product information (meaning you may have to visit the homepage) and making certain.
 
I asked about HDTV output to Nvidia support. They told me that all those 6600 GT cards support HDTV out on VGA via the component (Y Pb Pr) or DVI. :D

It's a marketing term that vendors write to attract consumers. Like the eVGA, they have the converter to component cable which is ok. But for some people who doesn't like to read tons of reviews, mail to mailing list, post to forums, contact vendors, they won't waste time investigating on it. I'm not saying that evga is bad, it's just that, it's confusing.

Well, I got the all the info from the horse's mouth. All I have to do now is decide which card I really like. :D

I will be picking from these cards tonight: evga, msi, xfx and leadtek. And also, I found out that zipzoomfly offers free shipping. I don't know if they offer it to graphics card too.

Lastly, about the heatsink. Are you saying that if it is covering the RAM, it's better?

Thank you guys. ;)
 
v1rtu0s1ty said:
I asked about HDTV output to Nvidia support. They told me that all those 6600 GT cards support HDTV out on VGA via the component (Y Pb Pr) or DVI. :D

It's a marketing term that vendors write to attract consumers. Like the eVGA, they have the converter to component cable which is ok. But for some people who doesn't like to read tons of reviews, mail to mailing list, post to forums, contact vendors, they won't waste time investigating on it. I'm not saying that evga is bad, it's just that, it's confusing.

Well, I got the all the info from the horse's mouth. All I have to do now is decide which card I really like. :D

I will be picking from these cards tonight: evga, msi, xfx and leadtek. And also, I found out that zipzoomfly offers free shipping. I don't know if they offer it to graphics card too.

Lastly, about the heatsink. Are you saying that if it is covering the RAM, it's better?

Thank you guys. ;)

I'd go with the leadtek because, as I've mentioned before, they make qualitiy cards. I've owned several of their products, and they've all OCed like champs. Concerning RAM, it is better if it's cooled, simply because heat is bad for electronics of all kinds. If you're not going to be OCing, then I guess heatsinks on the RAM isn't as big a deal, but anything that might extend the lifetime of a videocard is always a plus in my books!

 
Ok. Here is what it's concerning me now. Will I ever see a difference when playing a game between the 2 config below?

Athlon 64 2800+ and 6600 GT card

or

Athlon 64 3000+ and 6600 GT card

?

I want to save about $25 to $30. Please let me know your thoughts on this.
 
I haven't investigated the A64s much, but, from what people are saying, it sounds like you really want the 3000+.

Are you buying a whole new system? If so, you can always save money on some less important parts. For example, you might actually want to not jump to SATA just yet (my dad and his friend have had nothing but troubles with it.) Everyone jumps to grab ultra-fast harddrives, but, really you need enough memory and just to heck with the harddrive. More than anything else, the harddrive just needs to large enough to hold things.
 
Thanks Nazo. By the way, I'm going with XFX 6600 GT due to mail-in-rebate which brings down the price to $184. I've read some reviews and it was good. I also went to XFX site and they modified their heatsink and fan to lessen the temperature by 10%-20%
 
Back
Top