Hating On Project Natal

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Holy cow, the PNH (Project Natal Haters) seem to be out in force this week. First it was the story that the system couldn't recognize people with dark skin (here), now the rumor is that you need to wear a red jumpsuit when you play. Microsoft says that is obviously not the case, the red jumpsuits were a decision on the part of the Late Night with Jimmy Fallon producers. Here’s the video.
 
Cameras have a hard time distinguishing between objects which have a low contrast? you don't say.
 
so Natal only works on white people wearing red jumpsuits and turtle necks?

How about height, weight, eye and hair color?

Does it also only work on people that are 5' 8" - 6' 4", 150-170lb, blue eyes and blonde hair?
 
Natal only works in the 1980's?!

HOLY SHIT!

:p hehe

People hate on Microsoft whenever they can. It was only a matter of time before they started bashing Natal.

I really think that stuff like Natal could be THE top reason to extend the PS3 and 360's lifespan.
 
I heard a live TV stage with dozens of very bright lights and people in the crowd is the optimal location to play with an IR sensing camera.


So I hear.
 
JIMMY FALLON IS NOT FUNNY!

There, somebody had to say it.

Back on topic. With a name like "Natal" I expect people to make fun if it and talk smack about it.
It also lags too much to be of any use in a game where timing is everything, like the Breakout game they had on demo.
 
I really don't think this is going to do that well. There's nothing wrong with holding a controller. Show me where this offers a real advantage to any game and I'll be impressed. The concept is cool, but I am not excited at all.
 
That Burnout game seems like it would work well enough, but nothing beats a real wheel, pedals, and gear shift.. besides a real car of course, hah.

If the suits weren't required, then why would "the producers" want them to wear them?
 
I want to tear it up in a Star Wars game with this thing. grab me a cheap lightsaber and I'm Obi-frakking-Wan!


Star Wars Kid will finally be vindicated!
 
Well IF this ever hit's the streets the Youtube vids of people spazing out on will be epic.
 
I wonder what happens when you put your dog in front of the camera..?
 
That Burnout game seems like it would work well enough, but nothing beats a real wheel, pedals, and gear shift.. besides a real car of course, hah.

If the suits weren't required, then why would "the producers" want them to wear them?

Here is a thought, if they WERE required, then why wasn't everyone at E3 forced to wear them?

Jimmy or his producers thought they were being funny. However as pointed out he isn't.
 
I really don't think this is going to do that well. There's nothing wrong with holding a controller. Show me where this offers a real advantage to any game and I'll be impressed. The concept is cool, but I am not excited at all.

Yeah ok the millions of Wii owner doesn't agree with you.

Sitting on your ass and using controllers is becoming a thing of the past.

Keyboard/mouse however is here to stay. :D
 
I wonder what happens when you put your dog in front of the camera..?

Well if it was my dog it would have to a game about licking your balls constantly..because that's all he seems to do. :D
 
I want to tear it up in a Star Wars game with this thing. grab me a cheap lightsaber and I'm Obi-frakking-Wan!


Star Wars Kid will finally be vindicated!

everyone said the same crap about the wii when it came out. Want to know how the sword battles would really turn out? Watch Olympic fencing, it's just not going to happen.
 
I saw a whole bunch of guys on the side of the road playing Pick Up Trash, the first and yet unknown release for Natal. Oh wait, I guess that was prison work group.
 
everyone said the same crap about the wii when it came out. Want to know how the sword battles would really turn out? Watch Olympic fencing, it's just not going to happen.

Yeah I have Star Wars Clone Wars Lightsaber Battle for the Wii. It's boring as shit. You don't swing it as you'd swing a real lightsaber. You make combination swings to make it do what you want (ala Street Fighter - up up thrust A B for example).

I expected to be able to swing the lightsaber freestyle.
 
A man can dream. It's one step closer.

And what's wrong with fencing?

Have you watched it? It's frantic and lasts 10 seconds if that. Sword fighting doesn't work the way it's shown in movies and without any sort resistance (think when swords clash) it's going to be even more rediculous
 
Am I the only one that laughed at Natal when I first saw it presented at E3? No, it wasn't due to the fact it's a blatant ripoff/improvement on the Wii's idea of gameplay. No, it wasn't the fact we'll need to wait several years to own it when the 360 is already an aging system (Xbox 1 life was only ~4 years). No, it wasn't the quirky and obvious tearing/intersecting graphic glitches during the presentation. No, it's not any of the rumored racism (be it against blacks or non-oranges).

It's one simple thing:

Microsoft sucks. If Vista and the Zune weren't proof enough of this, just buy one of these suckers when they come out and you'll quickly find yourself to be the sucker. It's not like another company hasn't been trying for years with this idea. Why would Microsoft, of all corporations, be the one to succeed.

Will I be buying this? Natal, I'm sure.
 
Keep in mind that that with that new sensor coming out the wii controller will have better response so you will be able to swing the controller more like a real sword and have it act that way.
 
The best part is that Microsoft and the fanbois were laughing when the Wii and the motion controller were first introduced. Who's laughing now?
 
I just about passed out from all the excitement of imagining the following:

Project Natal

PLUS:

1. Mass Effect games - biotic powers, elbows and rifle butts in your enemy's face, throwing grenades ... holy crap.

2. Star Wars Games - dueling with light sabers, light saber throw, force lightning, force grip, the list goes on ... holy CRAP!

3. Sports games, anyone?


If they employ this right, and it works well, some of these games are just going to be amazing. It would be nice if they ported it to the PC, too. PCs can be a lot more powerful with today's new hardware. But I don't see them ever porting it to the PC ... Would be amazing, though.
 
"Not available in your country due to copyright restrictions."

Uh, wat?

I'm in the US. Fooking DMCA.
 
Am I the only one that laughed at Natal when I first saw it presented at E3? No, it wasn't due to the fact it's a blatant ripoff/improvement on the Wii's idea of gameplay. No, it wasn't the fact we'll need to wait several years to own it when the 360 is already an aging system (Xbox 1 life was only ~4 years). No, it wasn't the quirky and obvious tearing/intersecting graphic glitches during the presentation. No, it's not any of the rumored racism (be it against blacks or non-oranges).

It's one simple thing:

Microsoft sucks. If Vista and the Zune weren't proof enough of this, just buy one of these suckers when they come out and you'll quickly find yourself to be the sucker. It's not like another company hasn't been trying for years with this idea. Why would Microsoft, of all corporations, be the one to succeed.

Will I be buying this? Natal, I'm sure.

Umm, vista works fine, Zunes are great products, and Natal has zero problems with black people, although many idiots on the internet seem to believe that it does in the face of all of the evidence.

Your post was missing M$ though, cmon man, you should be clever with that much M$ hate.
 
Have you watched it? It's frantic and lasts 10 seconds if that. Sword fighting doesn't work the way it's shown in movies and without any sort resistance (think when swords clash) it's going to be even more rediculous

All of those hands on raves about the new sword fighting with wii motion plus in the new wiisports games must be lies then right?
 
I don't know how Project natal works.. but if it uses Infrared signal there should be no problem with dark skinned people in general. That sort of reverse counter racism is laughable and speaks of the ignorance of the person making the claim.
 
1. Mass Effect games - biotic powers, elbows and rifle butts in your enemy's face, throwing grenades ... holy crap.

2. Star Wars Games - dueling with light sabers, light saber throw, force lightning, force grip, the list goes on ... holy CRAP!

3. Sports games, anyone?

My only hesitation about getting too excited. Regardless of how it looks... Lack of physical feedback. Kicking air or kicking a real soccer ball are two totally different things.
 
Umm, vista works fine, Zunes are great products, and Natal has zero problems with black people, although many idiots on the internet seem to believe that it does in the face of all of the evidence.

Your post was missing M$ though, cmon man, you should be clever with that much M$ hate.

I'm going to avoid starting a flame war here and will just provide facts.

I knew that the "racism" Natal thing was a rumor hence why I mentioned it as such (and saying non-oranges is clearly sarcasm).

No M$ (that is for you, mon amie) operating system has had as many and as significant problems, all around, as Vista. I won't even bother with links because I would just be pulling links that support me.

The Zune sucks. It does. I do like the Xbox 360 though, that's why I own one.
 
I'm going to avoid starting a flame war here and will just provide facts.

I knew that the "racism" Natal thing was a rumor hence why I mentioned it as such (and saying non-oranges is clearly sarcasm).

No M$ (that is for you, mon amie) operating system has had as many and as significant problems, all around, as Vista. I won't even bother with links because I would just be pulling links that support me.

The Zune sucks. It does. I do like the Xbox 360 though, that's why I own one.

Gee, you sure showed me.
 
I just about passed out from all the excitement of imagining the following:

Project Natal

PLUS:

1. Mass Effect games - biotic powers, elbows and rifle butts in your enemy's face, throwing grenades ... holy crap.

2. Star Wars Games - dueling with light sabers, light saber throw, force lightning, force grip, the list goes on ... holy CRAP!

3. Sports games, anyone?


If they employ this right, and it works well, some of these games are just going to be amazing. It would be nice if they ported it to the PC, too. PCs can be a lot more powerful with today's new hardware. But I don't see them ever porting it to the PC ... Would be amazing, though.

Its cool but IMO you still really need a proper controller for lots of kinds of games. A combination of Natal and the motion controller prototype that Sony showed would be ideal.

Body and voice recognition combined with a controller with buttons that can be pinpointed down to the millimeter in 3D space, that would be cool.
 
I really think what would make Natal absolutely fantastic would be the addition of several of these for you to hold and wave in the air while playing. It would really add a new, previously-unseen depth to the world of gaming.
 
My only hesitation about getting too excited. Regardless of how it looks... Lack of physical feedback. Kicking air or kicking a real soccer ball are two totally different things.

They can integrate feedback into hand controllers - but that will only get you so far. If you want feedback like kicking a real soccer ball or punching a real face would provide, but in a game situation, perhaps the game interface you are really seeking is a holodeck.

I'll see if Scotty can beam you up and let you use his sometime.
 
They can integrate feedback into hand controllers - but that will only get you so far. If you want feedback like kicking a real soccer ball or punching a real face would provide, but in a game situation, perhaps the game interface you are really seeking is a holodeck.

I'll see if Scotty can beam you up and let you use his sometime.

Like I said... While some of those games seem cool on paper, once you actually play them I think you'd get tired of kicking air around after awhile. It's more strenuous to kick air than kick an actual ball.
 
Back
Top