Harvard Law Prof Attacks RIAA Lawsuits

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Harvard Law School professor Charles Nesson is stepping up to defend a Boston University graduate facing a song-swapper lawsuit and his defense not only challenges the basis of this specific lawsuit but all others like it. You go, teach!

Nesson argues that the Digital Theft Deterrence and Copyright Damages Improvement Act of 1999 is unconstitutional because it effectively lets a private group — the Recording Industry Association of America, or RIAA — carry out civil enforcement of a criminal law.
 
saw this earlier today. WOO HOO...and who better to do it right? lol
 
Too bad the gov't won't see it that way. This guy will probably be smacked down :(

I hope not, but probably
 
to quote star wars

RIAA: Your powers are weak, old man.
Charles Nesson: You can't win, RIAA. If you strike me down, I shall become more powerful than you could possibly imagine.

if he is struck down the riaa turns one professors project into a crusade. can you imagine major law schools taking on this crusade!
 
The outcome of this case doesn't really matter so long as it gets into the news.
 
Sadly, as long as the RIAA remains the greedy, selfish, short-sighted collection of executives it is now they will just find newer ways to go after music sharing and try to fix the symptoms and not the underlying problem. Maybe this Harvard law prof will succeed, maybe he won't, what's clear is that the RIAA will go on showing the world how dumb they are.
 
The outcome of this case doesn't really matter so long as it gets into the news.


It will get some press, but not as much as we might like. Think about the who it is that owns the networks. Yep, the same sort and in some cases the same people/companies that run/own the movie and recording industries.
 
I bet that this case will be settled out of court with RIAA paying a "small" fee to the Prof.
 
I bet that this case will be settled out of court with RIAA paying a "small" fee to the Prof.

Most people teaching at Harvard do so because they are set for life. And I'm if the guy was driven by money, he would be taking the case probono. :rolleyes:
 
I'm not suggesting that he was driven by money but that is what usually happen when a single person goes up againt a big organization.
 
I bet that this case will be settled out of court with RIAA paying a "small" fee to the Prof.

He is not bringing a claim against the RIAA.... He is wanting to get the courts to invalidate a statute. This will not be settled out of court and even if somehow he does decide to drop this the damage has already been done as there will probably be other lawyers willing to pursue this after he raised the idea.
 
I'm not suggesting that he was driven by money but that is what usually happen when a single person goes up againt a big organization.

He is not bringing a claim against them. Even if he wins he will not get money for this.
 
Back
Top