Harddrive speed important - ripping blurays

AP2

[H]ard|Gawd
2FA
Joined
Jun 25, 2007
Messages
1,570
i just finished putting my file server together and i need to purchase some harddrives now. my main goal is to rip blurays and to archive my music collection. how important is the harddrive speed if im ripping straight to the storage drives? os is on a small 60ssd.

any insight would be great!
 
Any modern hard drive is more than fast enough for Bluray ripping and playback. The fastest Bluray drives won't even come close to the read/write speeds of a hard drive.
 
The question is where is your final archive / resting place? Will you have to transfer it over a gigabit network? If so, you would want a drive that can saturate a gigabit network (about 110-125 MB per second) any modern hdd can pretty much hit this speed initially until it starts getting filled up and files are written closer to the inside of the spindle (slower) so if you are an impatient person (like myself) and want to perform operations as quickly as possible, I rip to a ssd initially then send it over the network to my file server (my software seems to not like ripping to a location directly over the network at reasonable speeds) so really it just depends on your configuration. SSDs and raid arrays can definitely read and write data at much faster rates than a lone hdd. So just depends if your process will utilize that speed
 
but you could also get 2 drives in a raid 0 or even a raid 1 with a good controller for cheaper and far more space that could max out a Giga network...

as said, will this be their final resting place?

Do you plan to do any conversion or just keep the raw files on HD?
 
My server will be strictly used for ripping and archiving. I will not be transferring large files (ie. bluray rips) over the gig network, but on occasion some small music files.

i plan on purchasing 3 of these.
SAMSUNG EcoGreen F4 HD204UI 2TB 32MB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822152245

What would be the best way to set these up? i would like some sort of redundancy.

Thanks again!
 
My server will be strictly used for ripping and archiving. I will not be transferring large files (ie. bluray rips) over the gig network, but on occasion some small music files.

i plan on purchasing 3 of these.
SAMSUNG EcoGreen F4 HD204UI 2TB 32MB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822152245

What would be the best way to set these up? i would like some sort of redundancy.

Thanks again!

Your only option based on your parameters for using 3 drives and having redundancy across all three is a RAID5 configuration, you will have 4TB usable space with 2TB dedicated to parity in that sort of setup with 3 TB drives. That setup will survive one hdd crashing. Good choice on the HD204UIs as well.
 
raid 5 and 2T drives do not go nice if they die... your talking a very very very long rebuild time if your not using a high end controller and possibility of another drive dieing due to the hard load put on drives in a raid rebuild.

if you going with larger drives, MIN raid 6 i suggest.
 
No need for RAID. Just keep the three HDDs separate. No blu-ray rip will go faster than 30MB/s, and even at the HDD's worst (right at the hub), your HDDs will be able to write at 60+ MB/s. If you want to rip up to 6 discs at a time, rip two to each HDD.
 
raid 5 and 2T drives do not go nice if they die... your talking a very very very long rebuild time if your not using a high end controller and possibility of another drive dieing due to the hard load put on drives in a raid rebuild.

if you going with larger drives, MIN raid 6 i suggest.

I agree on the RAID6, however based on his parameters of three drives, it wouldn't be practical or possible, especially if he is using his motherboard as storage controller.

If I was using just three drives, despite being large 2TB drives with long rebuild times, I would much rather have some redundancy using RAID5 than none. Ripping a bunch of DVDs or Blurays take a LOT of time to recover from if you lose them all.
 
Bandwidth requirements are surprisingly small. I encode my Blu-Ray rips at 1920x1080 @ 18Mbits. This ends up only requiring about 3-4 Megabytes of bandwidth in order to stream. DVD rips at 720x480 @ 2.2Mbits and that only requires 300-600KB of bandwidth to stream. So what I'm getting at is that ANY modern 1TB or larger drive will be just fine speed wise.

Faster drives will have a bigger advantage when it comes to seeking within the file. For instance I have a 2x1TB setup for FRAPS and can seek 1920x1200 uncompressed video in almost real time. Where as if I copy it to my less then 1TB drives and try to seek, it gets choppy.

For the music though, I would really recommend a SSD just for music. This is what I do for iTunes. I have a dedicated 120GB for music (only have about 60GB of music) and use "mklink /D" to integrate it all. This way you never have to wait for the HDD to spin up when starting music and when you skip to the next song its instantaous. Its a pricy option (though I use an older SSD, you don't need a modern SSD at all for music), but it is very seamless.
 
must say i got my music on a 2T drive and my music switching between tracks is instant, but i also have just under 1T of music, many many years of collecting, which i need to clean out!
 
Back
Top