I'd suggest getting something constructed of aluminum & w/ a built-in fan. My preference is also a 3.5" enclosure w/ both USB2 & firewire. If mobility of the external HD is not important, the extra bulk & need for external power source when using a 3.5" HD shouldn't be an issue......Personally, I got the AMS Venus DS3 from newegg.com
I use a cheapo CompUSA brand USB 3.5" enclosure. Even with USB 2.0, I'm only getting like 20MB/s or so off of it. But, it's only used to store anime, MP3s, and other random stuff, so it works great. Anything that I REALLY need speed for (My 8GB DVD ISOs) I throw on my internal SATA drive (Probably not an option for a laptop )