Hands on IPad

You can rent and buy movies and TV show episodes right on the iPad. Yes, it costs money, but it's also commercial-free.

There's also the DVD/Blu-ray-to-iPad route as well. Getting content on the iPad with Handbrake, DVD HD Decrypter/AnyDVD HD and iTunes isn't difficult at all.

When it comes to media support, Windows is second to none. Kind of funny that you mention a Windows only tool, AnyDVD HD (I own it and love it!) to get play back on an iPad. This does kind of go to my point of Apple fans giving up functionality. With a Tablet PC you can get native BD support and play back assuming you have a BD drive in it. If not like you said you can rip it. On a TPC however you wouldn't need to transcode code it, you can play the FULL 1080p ripped version natively.

Not trying to belabor the point just that you have SO many more options and tools on Windows for digital media.

I think the distinction that needs to be made is that there is functionality and there is functionality you actually use. The typical user may not need the functionality of a comparatively expensive Windows-based tablet and may only require the functionality the iPad offers. Rather than buy a Windows-based tablet that's more expensive, the iPad might seem the more logical choice.

This is a valid point. However how would one know if they needed a particular function until they actually try it? Everyone on a forum like this has found useful tools through trial and error. Sure you may not need certain functionality but more options give one more opportunity to discover tools that can be useful. Everyone on a board like this finds useful stuff all the time by trial and error.

Watch the keynote (or some of the iPad hands on videos on YouTube). Kindle for Windows is a competent e-reader, but there is some appeal in being able to interactively turn pages and having an attractive "bookshelf" feature. I have a reader app for my iPhone that offers similar functionality and it works pretty well. Makes reading books more "fun".

Saw that and its pretty for a while. Been using the Kindle Reader on the PC and what's cool about it is that I can read on my TPC then go to my desktop and pick up where I left of. That's FAR more use than animated page turns and my guess is that even the average Apple person would trade the animation for the ability move from the iPad to a MacBook seamlessly.

All that said there is a Kindle client for the Mac coming and the Windows version is going to pick up the eye candy, its only in beta right now.


The iPad is for that person. It's not for you -- you've made that obvious -- but for the person who might need or want a more simplistic, straight-forward device. And relatively speaking, it's inexpensive assuming you don't need/want the overpriced 3G-enabled version (which is ridiculously priced).

Once again valid points. But its not like plenty of people already use Windows all the time. For most its more familiar than the iPhone so in some ways a TPC is simpler simply because its just the same Windows you already use. Sure the iPad is built for touch and all but you've got to deal with Apple restrictions such Flash, getting stuff only from the AppStore, jailbreaking, etc. So that ease of use and beauty does come with its on set of headaches.
 
Kind of funny that you mention a Windows only tool, AnyDVD HD (I own it and love it!) to get play back on an iPad.
There are counterparts on OS X as well, such as MacTheRipper. It's not as if bypassing DVD copy protection is a Windows-only affair ;)

However how would one know if they needed a particular function until they actually try it?
Well, let's take the lack of a USB port as a for instance. If you have no intention to, say, upload photos from a camera via a USB connection, you know that you don't need the functionality of a USB port on a tablet device. In time, you might reconsider the idea, but at the time of purchase, it's potentially an unneeded feature.

Sure the iPad is built for touch and all but you've got to deal with Apple restrictions such Flash, getting stuff only from the AppStore, jailbreaking, etc. So that ease of use and beauty does come with its on set of headaches.
Yep, no device is perfect. No matter what OS a tablet is running, there are going to be certain pitfalls to running that OS on that tablet, whether it's iPhone OS, Android, Windows 7, Linux, etc., etc.. What's important is that each user choose the tablet best suited to his or her individual requirements and preferences.

No Widescreen = Fail
It'll do widescreen...technically. I'm disappointed it's not a 16:9 display, but at the same time, it's not that big of a deal (at least not for me).
 
ill be buying one for my grandmother. grandmas first internet.

and the textbook e-reader might make me buy one as well.

i find netbooks too shitty for web browsing, and laptops too cumbersome, yet i own both.
 
No Widescreen = Fail

For you maybe... pretty sure apple was thinking e-book in mind and 16:9/16:10 looks awkward reading. Looked at the dimensions of the ipad and the ratio is roughly the same as a 8X11 standard piece of paper. I love blanket statements without regard to any thought whatsoever. I take back what I wrote earlier.
 
Really on the fence on this. I love my touch, but do wish it was bigger and faster. But $300 for a slight speed increase and a bigger screen? Grr don't know
 
For you maybe... pretty sure apple was thinking e-book in mind and 16:9/16:10 looks awkward reading. Looked at the dimensions of the ipad and the ratio is roughly the same as a 8X11 standard piece of paper. I love blanket statements without regard to any thought whatsoever. I take back what I wrote earlier.

You're forgetting something. This is a tablet you can rotate it so it can also be 9 or 10 to 16. That's perfectly fine for reading.

I use the Kindle PC reader on my desktops and tablets and personally for reading it works fine in landscape or portrait modes. Reading an eBook or web page pretty much work the same if the text auto flows.
 
Really on the fence on this. I love my touch, but do wish it was bigger and faster. But $300 for a slight speed increase and a bigger screen? Grr don't know

What are you going to use the device for? If you don't have an answer for this then you'll need to find one which actually once you get it it you might find one.

I actually love to you my tablets to read and surf in bed. And if I'm having a hard time sleeping I go to c-span.org and pull up a Congressional hearing and use it like a TV to help to sleep. I put an ear plug in one ear opposite the side my head is on the pillow.
 
Well Im talking about widescreen purely from a video pov. The Ipod touch lets you watch a movie with out the black bars bordering the image. The Ipad will not let you do that...not a real biggie, but it certainly would look nicer. And also i Hate that flash isnt supported.....Theres nothing worse than looking something up and the site is flash based and there is nothing visible. Happens all the time on mobile devices.
 
Well Im talking about widescreen purely from a video pov. The Ipod touch lets you watch a movie with out the black bars bordering the image. The Ipad will not let you do that...not a real biggie, but it certainly would look nicer. And also i Hate that flash isnt supported.....Theres nothing worse than looking something up and the site is flash based and there is nothing visible. Happens all the time on mobile devices.

This is what I don't get. You could get away with lack of Flash on a phones up until now because it sucked on ALL phones though that's going to change this year. But for a full screen device that touts itself as the ultimate web browsing experience? It ain't going to fly.

Apple is headed for a real PR problem here unless they plan to write an app for every Flash site on the web and I don't see how thats possible.

Tons of people are going to buy this device not understanding this issue and its going to piss people off. I GUARANTEE that something is going to give here.

Telling angry customers that Flash sucks is not going to make them happy customers.
 
This is what I don't get. You could get away with lack of Flash on a phones up until now because it sucked on ALL phones though that's going to change this year. But for a full screen device that touts itself as the ultimate web browsing experience? It ain't going to fly.

Apple is headed for a real PR problem here unless they plan to write an app for every Flash site on the web and I don't see how thats possible.

Tons of people are going to buy this device not understanding this issue and its going to piss people off. I GUARANTEE that something is going to give here.

Telling angry customers that Flash sucks is not going to make them happy customers.

I guess we'll see what is stronger now, people's love for Adobe Flash and the content it provides or Steve Jobs and/or the Cult of Mac.
 
The Ipod touch lets you watch a movie with out the black bars bordering the image.
The touch has a 1.5:1 aspect ratio display (480x320). To my knowledge, no movie's ever been filmed (or released) in that aspect ratio. Most movies these days are 2.40:1 "Scope", with others being 2.35:1, 2.39:1 and the occasional 16:9 presentation.

On a well-backlit display, the black bars are somewhat mitigated. On the Zune HD's OLED display, for instance, if you're in a completely dark room watching a movie, the black bars completely disappear. The same is probably true of the iPad's LED-backlit display.

I don't get the 4:3 display, and I'm curious as to why they went in that direction, but I don't really think it's going to detract from the experience in any meaningful way either. It makes the thing look slightly stupid, yeah, but as far as actually using it goes, I don't think it's of any real consequence.
 
Not trying to belabor the point just that you have SO many more options and tools on Windows for digital media.

Could have fooled me. I haven't been posting anything iPad for about 10 days. What do I see when I think about it again? Heatless still in every iPad thread hawking his $2000 5LB tablet.

Your level of obsession is impressive.
 
I know there's a bunch of people hating on the iPad because of it's limited functionality and features but for me... a power user... it's perfect when I'm sitting on front of my tv surfing the web. After sitting at my desk at work all day typing on a computer, there are nights I don't want to be near my comp..

Totally agree. I got interested first after seeing the price, but since then I find myself doing things on my desktop and wanting an iPad to crash on my couch and check it out. I have some PDFs I keep meaning to read, but sitting at the desktop to do it, doesn't appeal at all. I was reading .CBZ comics and thinking how PERFECTLY suited they would be to iPad.

I see a lot of fixation on one or two things it can't do (usually flash) while failing to consider a multitude of activities it will be superb for.

I have gone from figuring I might someday get one, to hoping to try one right after release and buying it right away.

I want it now....dammit.
 
Could have fooled me. I haven't been posting anything iPad for about 10 days. What do I see when I think about it again? Heatless still in every iPad thread hawking his $2000 5LB tablet.

Your level of obsession is impressive.

You're numbers are off. The tm2 with all the options weighs about 4.5lbs and even only the most tricked out will cost ANYWHERE near $2000. My unit, with almost all the options, finger print reader, web cam, 3G, 6 GB RAM, dedicated GPU, faster CPU, was only $1650 with taxes and shipping. You could could get a build with the same horsepower but fewer bells and whistles for about $1100 and that price is dropping a little bit every day.

.
 
I was reading .CBZ comics and thinking how PERFECTLY suited they would be to iPad.

Been doing this on my tablets for years, just read an old DC series from about 10 years ago or so, Kingdom Come, very good series I thought. Yes, it is cool and would work fine on an iPad as well I'm sure.
 
Been doing this on my tablets for years, just read an old DC series from about 10 years ago or so, Kingdom Come, very good series I thought. Yes, it is cool and would work fine on an iPad as well I'm sure.

Like I said. You obsession is impressive. You are in multiple forums hawking your obsession. I am amazed you still at this in so many threads.

I am interested in a lightweight (1.5lbs) inexpesive ($500) reader, not a 5lb $1000-2000 brick.

These are not in the same market.
 
Like I said. You obsession is impressive. You are in multiple forums hawking your obsession. I am amazed you still at this in so many threads.

I am interested in a lightweight (1.5lbs) inexpesive ($500) reader, not a 5lb $1000-2000 brick.

These are not in the same market.

Cool. I simply corrected your errors and agreed with you about the comic reader.

Is a MacBook Pro 13 a brick? The tm2 weighs the same. There are plenty of people that carry MBPs all day long and I doubt they think they are bricks.

If you wan an iPad then get an iPad. I am simply correcting your errors and mischaracterizations of something you've never seen is all.
 
Last edited:
Is a MacBook Pro 13 a brick? The tm2 weighs the same. There are plenty of people that carry MBPs all day long and I doubt they think they are bricks.

Absolutely brick like if you intend to use it as a lightweight reader. I have no interest in a MBP either.

If you wan an iPad then get an iPad. I am simply correcting your errors and mischaracterizations of something you've never seen is all.

???? No one was talking about your laptop until you showed up to proselytize. It's like we can't have an iPad discussion without you shooting it down and hawking your HP. OCD much?
 
Absolutely brick like if you intend to use it as a lightweight reader. I have no interest in a MBP either.



???? No one was talking about your laptop until you showed up to proselytize. It's like we can't have an iPad discussion without you shooting it down and hawking your HP. OCD much?

You posted a message today in this thread and bought this subject back up. I simply corrected your errors. If 4.5 lbs is a brick then its a brick to you. If you want an iPad get an iPad. Why do insist on mischaracterizing everything? When you do, I will correct you. Gee, you even keep calling a convertible tablet a laptop.

If I were to mischaracterize something I'm sure that you would correct me. OCD? You keep replying. Pot, kettle, black.
 
Yeah, sound like attacks on an iPad.

You join every thread and list a bunch of reasons why your Tm2/Tx2 is better, that is when you are not saying things like this:

http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1035307373&postcount=17
Damn beat me to it? I was planning on doing a side by side video review of the tm2 culminating in the destruction of an iPad.

You haven't even touched one yet, but your goal is to get one so you can do a negative (forgone conclusion) review and then destroy it. Likely giving you some twisted pleasure by upsetting those who want an iPad.

That looks like a fairly malignant obsession you have.
 
You join every thread and list a bunch of reasons why your Tm2/Tx2 is better, that is when you are not saying things like this:

http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1035307373&postcount=17


You haven't even touched one yet, but your goal is to get one so you can do a negative (forgone conclusion) review and then destroy it. Likely giving you some twisted pleasure by upsetting those who want an iPad.

That looks like a fairly malignant obsession you have.

Talk about obsession and no sense of humor. Do you REALLY think I'm going to spend $500 just to destroy an iPad? Come on dude, hell I'd rather give it to YOU!

And if you look through my comments you'll see where I have said many times I thought the iPad would sell well and I want it to do well, just not dominate the market because, yes, I think that Tablet PCs are better devices. Less lock in and more flexibility. But some people like the Apple pre-packaged experience.

So once again, I will respond in kind to your mischaracterizations and set the record straight. You must be the one with OCD to pull up a post I totally forgot about!:p
 
I just don't think Tablet PC (which is technically dead -- let's say "Windows convertible tablets" now) really stands a chance, not that it exactly competes in the same space.

A TouchSmart tm2 is 4.7 pounds. That's light by notebook standards, but it's far too heavy to be useful for reading e-books and isn't all that great for very casual positions (we're talking the propped-up-on-the-couch situation).

Not to mention that it's really just Windows 7 with a few touchscreen elements on top. You aren't likely to get an e-book app that actually takes advantage of the screen; the browser, e-mail and most everything else is still built on the assumption that there's a trackpad and a big hardware keyboard grafted on.

I do hope Apple puts multitasking into iPhone 4.0, since it needs that for the iPad to be considered a computer by some and not just a media consumption device. But it's far, far more interesting than a netbook for what some people do, especially since it's often half the weight and thickness. I'd just make sure to get that case/stand combo so it can sit at a more comfortable angle when on a desk.
 
Is the ipad its own independent system or is it networkable? I can see it being useful for management and things
 
I just don't think Tablet PC (which is technically dead -- let's say "Windows convertible tablets" now) really stands a chance, not that it exactly competes in the same space.

A TouchSmart tm2 is 4.7 pounds. That's light by notebook standards, but it's far too heavy to be useful for reading e-books and isn't all that great for very casual positions (we're talking the propped-up-on-the-couch situation).

Not to mention that it's really just Windows 7 with a few touchscreen elements on top. You aren't likely to get an e-book app that actually takes advantage of the screen; the browser, e-mail and most everything else is still built on the assumption that there's a trackpad and a big hardware keyboard grafted on.

I do hope Apple puts multitasking into iPhone 4.0, since it needs that for the iPad to be considered a computer by some and not just a media consumption device. But it's far, far more interesting than a netbook for what some people do, especially since it's often half the weight and thickness. I'd just make sure to get that case/stand combo so it can sit at a more comfortable angle when on a desk.

Actually the tm2 is 4.5 lbs, I weighed it myself, not that its a big deal. But that's STILL lighter than a medium sized college text book. Sure 1.5 is 3 lbs lighter but honestly, how long are you going to actually hold even an iPad and use it while holding it? It'll often been in a desk on in your lap. I was doing a field test of the tm2. I took it to the mall looking for a decent slip case. And honestly I've carried much heavier books. When you take into consideration to that you have a keyboard, a web cam, and a SD card slot to upload pictures from a camera, something like a tm2.

My point is that an iPad is light, but there are trade offs for that lightness. And if you are going on a business trip and need a keyboard, connectivity to devices, etc, that 1.5 lbs becomes much more and less convenient than an all in one device. Why carry a MacBook AND an iPad when you could carry just ONE device that did everything you need.

The iPad's 3 fewer pounds doesn't tell the whole story. And yes, a Tablet PC and an iPad don't necessarily serve the same purpose, but they easily could. At any rate $500 for a device that buy Apple's own admission doesn't replace a laptop when one could just have a laptop is more compelling than I think many think.

If you need a laptop, why not get one that does what an iPad does too? I'm not saying that some people would want the separate device. Maybe that want the extra screen read on and use the laptop for something else.

There are ALREADY eBook apps that take advantage of the touch screen, Kindle and eReader. I use them all the time on my tablets and they work fine on a touch tablet. Are they pretty, right now, no. The Kindle PC reader though is supposed to get all the polish of the iPad. Remember, HP has a Slate on the way and there plenty of support coming down the pipe for pretty and richer touch experiences on Windows 7. But all the functionality to do ebooks, media play back, etc, is ready there and working with touch.

And lastly, the tm2 is GREAT from propping up on a couch or resting in a lap. Actually in some cases its size could help. Plus if you want to watch a movie, just unfold it back into laptop mode. That's going to be BETTER than an iPad much of the time.

Last but not least, I know I harp on this a lot, but there's just so much Flash stuff out there, I just don't know how that's supposed to work with this device. An app per Flash web site I guess.

I've seen a lot of tablets over the years and really you don't want to frustrate people. When stuff they want to do doesn't even work, they'll toss these things aside I'm telling you. Mark my words. The iPad will do well I think, but Apple has its work cut out for it.
 
Is the ipad its own independent system or is it networkable? I can see it being useful for management and things

Well of course its networkable. But you can't deploy you own apps without Apple's approval so you could go web based, but then any tablet device would do there.
 
Back
Top