Hands on IPad

CrazyCuz2k

Gawd
Joined
Sep 22, 2008
Messages
684
http://www.engadget.com/2010/01/27/apple-ipad-first-hands-on/

I know there's a bunch of people hating on the iPad because of it's limited functionality and features but for me... a power user... it's perfect when I'm sitting on front of my tv surfing the web. After sitting at my desk at work all day typing on a computer, there are nights I don't want to be near my comp... instead I like "resting" my brain in front of my TV while going through this forum on my old G4 powerbook. Suffice to say... laptops are a pain in the ass and there isn't a good "lounging" position to type in... it's either sitting upright or having it teetering on my lap or arm browsing about.

This video shows why features are lacking... for battery time and user experience with the technology at hand, I think they made compromises they made to get to a certain price point and user experience that the masses could enjoy. Granted I am on the [Hard]Forum where most users aren't the masses and we prefer our hardware bigger, better, and faster... but at the end of the day... after I've reinstalled Windows for the uptenth time, taken apart and put together my watercooled rig, I still end up sitting on my couch watching the "game" on my 46" lcd or 92" screen and surfing the web more time than not.

Suffice to say... even for a [Hard] user, I definitely envision the iPad as the perfect device that will replace my laptop for what I do more than anything... read, research, discuss, and debate.

Just my oped on this very controversial device.
 
I'd replace my netbook with one of those ipads since I use my netbook for web surfing and watching the occasional tv show or movie.
 
Having used tablet computers for a long time I feel you. I've been doing for years with my Windows tablets though admittedly heavier and bulkier but the functionality and experience to a large degree has been there and that's why the iPad is ho hum to me. And a lot of people will do there couch surfing on their phones today. The iPad is squeezed below from phones and above from tablets. If you actually holding the device with your hands then sure, the iPad is a great form factor.

But see this the problem with ALL tablet devices. How long are you actually going to hold it. It's still much heavier than a phone and on a desk a laptop or convertible is much better. And that those 24" monitors are even better for real taks.

Apple folks have called me annoying when I bring up this long standing and common sense issue and I have no idea why.
 
Last edited:
But see this the problem with ALL tablet devices. How long are you actually going to hold it. It's still much heavier than a phone and on a desk a laptop or convertible is much better. And that those 24" monitors are even better for real taks.

Apple folks have called me annoying when I bring up this long standing and common sense issue and I have no idea why.

I agree for productivity, the iPad makes no sense... but after being "semi-productive" all day at work... being productive is the least of my concerns... but for multi-tasking and productivity, I have my main system with it's 23" IPS LCD and 19" CRT.

As for holding it... my blackberry is way too slow, small for surfing, browsing... and if I can hold up my "lightweight" powerbook :D with one hand and type with the other... I don't think I'll have a problem with the iPad. Point is... I really want to get away from a keyboard for surfing, watching videos, and reading. I wouldn't use it for anything else... it's just "another" device that fits perfectly for what I want it to do at the right price point. I don't care about webcams, multitasking, or a sophisticated software/applications... I want it to a better job than what I'm currently using.

I'll admit it... I'm addicted to the internet and the unlimited pool of information it offers and this is this device is perfectly suited to feed my addiction. ;)
 
I agree for productivity, the iPad makes no sense... but after being "semi-productive" all day at work... being productive is the least of my concerns... but for multi-tasking and productivity, I have my main system with it's 23" IPS LCD and 19" CRT.

As for holding it... my blackberry is way too slow, small for surfing, browsing... and if I can hold up my "lightweight" powerbook :D with one hand and type with the other... I don't think I'll have a problem with the iPad. Point is... I really want to get away from a keyboard for surfing, watching videos, and reading. I wouldn't use it for anything else... it's just "another" device that fits perfectly for what I want it to do at the right price point. I don't care about webcams, multitasking, or a sophisticated software/applications... I want it to a better job than what I'm currently using.

I'll admit it... I'm addicted to the internet and the unlimited pool of information it offers and this is this device is perfectly suited to feed my addiction. ;)

And I think that is exactly the type of thing Apple is catering this device towards. When people look at it in that perspective, it starts to make a lot more sense.
 
I agree for productivity, the iPad makes no sense... but after being "semi-productive" all day at work... being productive is the least of my concerns... but for multi-tasking and productivity, I have my main system with it's 23" IPS LCD and 19" CRT.

As for holding it... my blackberry is way too slow, small for surfing, browsing... and if I can hold up my "lightweight" powerbook :D with one hand and type with the other... I don't think I'll have a problem with the iPad. Point is... I really want to get away from a keyboard for surfing, watching videos, and reading. I wouldn't use it for anything else... it's just "another" device that fits perfectly for what I want it to do at the right price point. I don't care about webcams, multitasking, or a sophisticated software/applications... I want it to a better job than what I'm currently using.

I'll admit it... I'm addicted to the internet and the unlimited pool of information it offers and this is this device is perfectly suited to feed my addiction. ;)

I get you perfectly. See I use my TPC in the bed on my side all the time so I totally understand the issue. A slate form factor computer works great in this situation. The main thing that bums me out about the iPad is no ink.

It's MUCH easier to write emails and posts with ink. I guess iPhoners can type 100 WPM with one had on a touch screen keyboard. I can't. It's just much easier to whip out a pen and write.

But honestly beyond this particular scenario for me personally a slate computer with no pen becomes laptop with a missing keyboard. That's not a rag. It's from a person that's used tablets for a long time and understand how they work for me.

Most people who buy these thing initially haven't thought about the ergonomic issues of input type and device position for a second.
 
This video shows why features are lacking... for battery time and user experience with the technology at hand, I think they made compromises they made to get to a certain price point and user experience that the masses could enjoy.
lol, that's a good one. You'd think that if they really cared about the user's experience they'd put in some of the features people all over the world are complaining about, even if it eats into their $200-odd net profit per iPad?
 
The iPad isn't about power user productivity. It's about something else entirely.

None of this stuff is new. I've been preaching about non-traditional computing environments for decades. When I pull out my tablet or talk about I tell people that I like to use it in the bed to read.

TBH, most people I've talked to saw little value in a slate. Many would say "I can use my laptop just as easily" or "I can just do that on my phone". Steve Jobs says that its cool and useful now so I feel totally vindicated.

The Apple loyal see the light now I guess, but I'm telling you folks from the rich to poor, old to young, most people see little value in a computer that works well in only particular settings that costs $500.
 
I agree. I plan on using it for reading, casual browser/gaming while watching TV/movies and various tasks at work. One of the remote desktop apps available will make this extremely handy for certain work situations. Also using it in meetings will be good. I often need to access several documents during meetings, but don't need a full notebook to do that. If I need to share something, I can connect the iPad to the projector.

We had a short brainstorming session at work where we identified 3 departments that would GREATLY benefit from the iPad. Its lack of advanced features is actually a good thing for those specific uses.
 
None of this stuff is new. I've been preaching about non-traditional computing environments for decades. When I pull out my tablet or talk about I tell people that I like to use it in the bed to read.

TBH, most people I've talked to saw little value in a slate. Many would say "I can use my laptop just as easily" or "I can just do that on my phone". Steve Jobs says that its cool and useful now so I feel totally vindicated.

The Apple loyal see the light now I guess, but I'm telling you folks from the rich to poor, old to young, most people see little value in a computer that works well in only particular settings that costs $500.

I'm not an apple loyalist and for years I've wanted a tablet PC... but they were just that... a PC. The price point wasn't there and the UI sucked. I'm sorry but Windows XP wasn't developed for the touch screen devices. The iPhone OS on the other hand was built from the ground up for touchscreen input. The video I have linked above is proof the in the pudding. The UI is awesome, it's intuitive, responsive, and the os is simple and not bulky.

I don't know what so "called" millions of people want... but I'm sure you can get your HP slate or lenova pad for $1,500. You can get all the power you want in your internet device. As for me.... I'll be perfectly content with my jailbroken iPad that can surf the web, watch streaming mkv's from my WHS, and read the occasional book/magazine with content that I can't already get on-line.
 
The problem is my leisure time involves web surfing and watching videos online. The iPad fails miserably at watching online videos.

Fix that and I will probably buy one, but I don't think they are going to fix it and instead just bash Adobe.
 
http://www.engadget.com/2010/01/27/apple-ipad-first-hands-on/

I know there's a bunch of people hating on the iPad because of it's limited functionality and features but for me... a power user... it's perfect when I'm sitting on front of my tv surfing the web. After sitting at my desk at work all day typing on a computer, there are nights I don't want to be near my comp... instead I like "resting" my brain in front of my TV while going through this forum on my old G4 powerbook. Suffice to say... laptops are a pain in the ass and there isn't a good "lounging" position to type in... it's either sitting upright or having it teetering on my lap or arm browsing about.

This video shows why features are lacking... for battery time and user experience with the technology at hand, I think they made compromises they made to get to a certain price point and user experience that the masses could enjoy. Granted I am on the [Hard]Forum where most users aren't the masses and we prefer our hardware bigger, better, and faster... but at the end of the day... after I've reinstalled Windows for the uptenth time, taken apart and put together my watercooled rig, I still end up sitting on my couch watching the "game" on my 46" lcd or 92" screen and surfing the web more time than not.

Suffice to say... even for a [Hard] user, I definitely envision the iPad as the perfect device that will replace my laptop for what I do more than anything... read, research, discuss, and debate.

Just my oped on this very controversial device.

Absolutely, but the problems lie herein:

1) Price
2) Flash

Price is OK, but it will not netbook territory.

Flash is not OK, it will be utterly useless in many scenarios.
 
I'd replace my netbook with one of those ipads since I use my netbook for web surfing and watching the occasional tv show or movie.

How are you going to watch the occasional TV show or movie? Flash based websites?
 
Having used tablet computers for a long time I feel you. I've been doing for years with my Windows tablets though admittedly heavier and bulkier but the functionality and experience to a large degree has been there and that's why the iPad is ho hum to me. And a lot of people will do there couch surfing on their phones today. The iPad is squeezed below from phones and above from tablets. If you actually holding the device with your hands then sure, the iPad is a great form factor.

But see this the problem with ALL tablet devices. How long are you actually going to hold it. It's still much heavier than a phone and on a desk a laptop or convertible is much better. And that those 24" monitors are even better for real taks.

Apple folks have called me annoying when I bring up this long standing and common sense issue and I have no idea why.

Well, I don't think you are going to hold it. You'll have it on your lap or whatever. It is slightly better than a netbook/laptop, but much better for reading books.

Ipad has great potential, I have no doubt that like the Iphone, version 2 and version 3 will come with a year apart and make the first generation obsolete.
 
I'm not an apple loyalist and for years I've wanted a tablet PC... but they were just that... a PC. The price point wasn't there and the UI sucked. I'm sorry but Windows XP wasn't developed for the touch screen devices. The iPhone OS on the other hand was built from the ground up for touchscreen input. The video I have linked above is proof the in the pudding. The UI is awesome, it's intuitive, responsive, and the os is simple and not bulky.

I don't know what so "called" millions of people want... but I'm sure you can get your HP slate or lenova pad for $1,500. You can get all the power you want in your internet device. As for me.... I'll be perfectly content with my jailbroken iPad that can surf the web, watch streaming mkv's from my WHS, and read the occasional book/magazine with content that I can't already get on-line.

Do you mean your WHS can stream over the internet to your Ipad (anywhere you get WiFi?). That would be pretty neat.
 
Absolutely, but the problems lie herein:

1) Price
2) Flash

Price is OK, but it will not netbook territory.

Flash is not OK, it will be utterly useless in many scenarios.

The ultimate web browsing experience in this day and age HAS to support Flash. Period. Apple could get away with it on iPhone, at least up until now because mobile phone Flash support sucked. But Adobe is fixing that problem and Flash will be on ALL platforms EXCEPT the iDevices.

For me I use my TPC in bed and watch Flash based stuff ALL of the time. Without Flash this device is 1.5 lbs paper weight for one of my primary slate usage environments and patterns.
 
Well, I don't think you are going to hold it. You'll have it on your lap or whatever. It is slightly better than a netbook/laptop, but much better for reading books.

Why is the iPad better for reading books than other netbooks/laptops?
 
http://www.engadget.com/2010/01/27/apple-ipad-first-hands-on/

I know there's a bunch of people hating on the iPad because of it's limited functionality and features but for me... a power user... it's perfect when I'm sitting on front of my tv surfing the web. After sitting at my desk at work all day typing on a computer, there are nights I don't want to be near my comp... instead I like "resting" my brain in front of my TV while going through this forum on my old G4 powerbook. Suffice to say... laptops are a pain in the ass and there isn't a good "lounging" position to type in... it's either sitting upright or having it teetering on my lap or arm browsing about.

This video shows why features are lacking... for battery time and user experience with the technology at hand, I think they made compromises they made to get to a certain price point and user experience that the masses could enjoy. Granted I am on the [Hard]Forum where most users aren't the masses and we prefer our hardware bigger, better, and faster... but at the end of the day... after I've reinstalled Windows for the uptenth time, taken apart and put together my watercooled rig, I still end up sitting on my couch watching the "game" on my 46" lcd or 92" screen and surfing the web more time than not.

Suffice to say... even for a [Hard] user, I definitely envision the iPad as the perfect device that will replace my laptop for what I do more than anything... read, research, discuss, and debate.

Just my oped on this very controversial device.
I'm with you on that. I don't plan on getting one right away, but I can definitely see the merits of having one around the house (or for work) instead of my netbook.

I love my mini, but they're not always easy to use in a majority of the situations I use it for (browsing in bed, on the bowl, on the couch watching TV, etc). It's nice to have a full computer at your fingertips, but they're pretty worthless/anemic for most modern PC software and games. If I need a full keyboard or a machine for processor intensive tasks, I have my desktop
 
I get you perfectly. See I use my TPC in the bed on my side all the time so I totally understand the issue. A slate form factor computer works great in this situation. The main thing that bums me out about the iPad is no ink.

It's MUCH easier to write emails and posts with ink. I guess iPhoners can type 100 WPM with one had on a touch screen keyboard. I can't. It's just much easier to whip out a pen and write.

for some reason I have a feeling that using the OSK will be much faster than writing, but regardless, I read that apple is adding hand writing recognition to the OS (or there are references to it in the latest SDK)... possibly before launch. :)
 
for some reason I have a feeling that using the OSK will be much faster than writing, but regardless, I read that apple is adding hand writing recognition to the OS (or there are references to it in the latest SDK)... possibly before launch. :)

OSK vs writting depends on the indivudual. Few people realize just how good the HW recognition is in Windows 7. It's almost perfect. I know I can't type faster with one hand than write. I imagine most people can't but think that can unless they can type with with at least two fingers simultaneously.

As for HW recognition, Windows 7 league HW recognition would be VERY CPU intensive. Plus without a stylus it would pointless.

But yes, I know Apple has the technology. I owned a Newton. But it would need to be CONSIDERABLY better than anything I've seen on a Mac like Inkwell to not be completely embarrassing to Apple.
 
I also will be getting one, while it does not really blow my mind from a hardware standpoint, I know I will enjoy web browsing with it.

But mainly, it will make viewing PDF files and my online textbooks much easier. 3 of my 4 textbooks this semester are though coursesmart. Here is a video of what they are working on for the iPad.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSjXO7Odh9E

e-books are much more reasonable, I spent about 400 instead of about 800.

Oh and also, lots of textbooks just are not available for the kindle.
 
The ultimate web browsing experience in this day and age HAS to support Flash. Period. Apple could get away with it on iPhone, at least up until now because mobile phone Flash support sucked. But Adobe is fixing that problem and Flash will be on ALL platforms EXCEPT the iDevices.

For me I use my TPC in bed and watch Flash based stuff ALL of the time. Without Flash this device is 1.5 lbs paper weight for one of my primary slate usage environments and patterns.

Personally I don't watch flash based videos... so it's a non-issue for me, but I can see how it affects the hundreds of millions of flash based videos/games. The problem with flash is I don't think the A4 proc can handle it. Flash is incredibly CPU intensive and I don't believe with their current proc it can handle 720p videos through flash. What mobile phone can? And this is what the iPad is... an ipod touch XL. I'm not sure nvidia's tegra 2 platform can handle it. And until a couple of months ago... Adobe hadn't written code for it to be hardware accelerated to offload usage on the CPU. Unless you want a 3lb brick with a 4 hour battery life tablet which is what the HP and Thinkpad's going to be... then this is what we have to compromise with what's currently available. Hopefully by gen 3 we'll have something that can approach $500 and still do everything we want.

As for nettops... wouldn't be caught dead with one... cheap or not... it's a really weak laptop... last decades OS... why would I use that when my laptop is 10X better even though it's 5 years old??? (As I type on my G4 powerbook now) :D
 
Personally I don't watch flash based videos... so it's a non-issue for me, but I can see how it affects the hundreds of millions of flash based videos/games. The problem with flash is I don't think the A4 proc can handle it. Flash is incredibly CPU intensive and I don't believe with their current proc it can handle 720p videos through flash. What mobile phone can? And this is what the iPad is... an ipod touch XL. I'm not sure nvidia's tegra 2 platform can handle it. And until a couple of months ago... Adobe hadn't written code for it to be hardware accelerated to offload usage on the CPU. Unless you want a 3lb brick with a 4 hour battery life tablet which is what the HP and Thinkpad's going to be... then this is what we have to compromise with what's currently available. Hopefully by gen 3 we'll have something that can approach $500 and still do everything we want.

As for nettops... wouldn't be caught dead with one... cheap or not... it's a really weak laptop... last decades OS... why would I use that when my laptop is 10X better even though it's 5 years old??? (As I type on my G4 powerbook now) :D

Its not a performance issue. I can run Flash on my Windows Touch Pro 2 Phone actually surprisingly well in a little free browser for WinMo call Skyfire. I an iPad eats a TP2 for lunch in terms of performance.

Apple doesn't want Flash apps on iDevices. Plain and simple. BTW the HP Slate is going to be about the weight of an iPad from what I'm hearing.
 
I'm not an apple loyalist and for years I've wanted a tablet PC... but they were just that... a PC. The price point wasn't there and the UI sucked. I'm sorry but Windows XP wasn't developed for the touch screen devices. The iPhone OS on the other hand was built from the ground up for touchscreen input. The video I have linked above is proof the in the pudding. The UI is awesome, it's intuitive, responsive, and the os is simple and not bulky.

I can agree with your comments in regards to Windows XP but 7 is a completely different matter. While not overall as touch friendly as the iDevices it's a VAST improvement over XP. All of the core stuff you'd do like web browser, play media, launch apps, are completely touch friendly, IE 8 is pretty touch friendly out of the box and even FF is very touch friendly with a couple of add ons.
 
Last edited:
I still think it is too expensive for what I get. If it was a bit cheaper, had Flash and multitasking I would be getting in line to buy one.
 
Have you tried reading a book on a computer or laptop?

This is a huge reason Kindle exists.

I've used a Kindle and the Sony eReader. If you're talking about the display, for what ever reason its harder for me. I guess I've been in front of screens to long but for me personally, reading from a lighted display is easier. But I understand that makes me an odd ball.

But I've talked to other people about readers and its not a slam dunk. Plenty of people live the Kindle display, I understand that. Plenty of people don't seem to have a preference.
 
I still think it is too expensive for what I get. If it was a bit cheaper, had Flash and multitasking I would be getting in line to buy one.

It WILL be getting cheaper pretty fast like the iPhone. These prices are for the Apple faithful.
 
Have you tried reading a book on a computer or laptop?

This is a huge reason Kindle exists.


Yes there is. And that reason is because its the same deal as a modern automatic transmission front wheel drive car. Its easy. You turn it on and it works. Kindle is more of an appliance than a computing platform, your comparing apples to oranges. The ONLY, and I mean ONLY way from an ergonomics standpoint that a flat surface wins is when laying flat on your back. I have been a heavy netbook user for a while now , and I find it very rare I open the screen more than 90 degrees, other than laying in bed on my back. I think all Apple has done is built a netbook with a fixed screen that supports touch, bundled it in a nice package, and proclaimed to have invented the next greatest thing ( Steve Jobs modus operandi ) I like it, but its not that innovative and I am not willing to pay the apple tax for anything. Honestly, go get yourself a 1.5 lb book , and walk around holding it up so you can read it. Its gonna be a real neck killer tilting your head down to see it, or a wristkiller trying to hold it up.
 
Most of my hardcover books weigh over 1.5 lbs. You're netbook probably weighs twice as much.. and my laptop 3-4 times heavier. Like I said when I began this thread... this device isn't for everyone... it isn't going to replace a laptop/desktop/smartphone/mp3 player. It's an internet browser... as for eink vs lcd... I stare at a screen at work for 8-10 hours... go home and stare at my tv/lcd/crt for another couple of hours if I'm not out and about.

You can have you're nettop and view the internet that way, keyboard and all... I'd rather use a tablet pc for browsing... if vendors release tablets that are competitive pricewise with similar features to the ipad then I'll be interested in those devices as well. But those devices are way down the line and based on chrome os and nvidia tegra 2 platform which will be 4 steps behind apple since the iphone OS is polished. You can hate apple all you want but for the most part, they just work... granted they control the hardware and software which makes programming infinitely easier but for certain situations I just want something to work. No patches, no driver updates, no codecs, nothing... I want it like most of my CE devices, to be able to turn it on and have it work. Only for certain situations. I like most members in the forum like to open things up, tear it apart, push it to it's limits, break it, and do it all over again... but when I need to "do" something... I use my 7 year old powerbook because it just works. It doesn't need the fastest processor, the latest apps, hell it can't even do HD... but it works. It's been through sandstorms and 130 degree days in the iraqi summer and suffered enumerable drops but it's still where I store my pics and my important docs because I know it won't crash on me. All this is to say that I am hoping with apple's record that the iPad can replace my aging laptop and just work. For this I am willing to pay the "apple" tax.
 
Its not a performance issue. I can run Flash on my Windows Touch Pro 2 Phone actually surprisingly well in a little free browser for WinMo call Skyfire. I an iPad eats a TP2 for lunch in terms of performance.

Apple doesn't want Flash apps on iDevices. Plain and simple. BTW the HP Slate is going to be about the weight of an iPad from what I'm hearing.

I think skyfire transcodes it somehow... I did a quick test and looked CPU util on my C2D with a 4850 with flash 10.1 and the latest ATI drivers with support for flash HW acceleration on my utilization would peak at 70+%. Granted you're prob not watching 1080P material but that's not the point. The point is flash is very CPU intensive and would drain battery life off portable devices so much quicker.
 
I think skyfire transcodes it somehow... I did a quick test and looked CPU util on my C2D with a 4850 with flash 10.1 and the latest ATI drivers with support for flash HW acceleration on my utilization would peak at 70+%. Granted you're prob not watching 1080P material but that's not the point. The point is flash is very CPU intensive and would drain battery life off portable devices so much quicker.

I do think that you are right about Skyfire, but there are native players coming for ALL phones. Flash isn't not on the iDevices though for reasons that aren't technical.
 
Most of my hardcover books weigh over 1.5 lbs. You're netbook probably weighs twice as much.. and my laptop 3-4 times heavier. Like I said when I began this thread... this device isn't for everyone... it isn't going to replace a laptop/desktop/smartphone/mp3 player. It's an internet browser... as for eink vs lcd... I stare at a screen at work for 8-10 hours... go home and stare at my tv/lcd/crt for another couple of hours if I'm not out and about.

You can have you're nettop and view the internet that way, keyboard and all... I'd rather use a tablet pc for browsing... if vendors release tablets that are competitive pricewise with similar features to the ipad then I'll be interested in those devices as well. But those devices are way down the line and based on chrome os and nvidia tegra 2 platform which will be 4 steps behind apple since the iphone OS is polished. You can hate apple all you want but for the most part, they just work... granted they control the hardware and software which makes programming infinitely easier but for certain situations I just want something to work. No patches, no driver updates, no codecs, nothing... I want it like most of my CE devices, to be able to turn it on and have it work. Only for certain situations. I like most members in the forum like to open things up, tear it apart, push it to it's limits, break it, and do it all over again... but when I need to "do" something... I use my 7 year old powerbook because it just works. It doesn't need the fastest processor, the latest apps, hell it can't even do HD... but it works. It's been through sandstorms and 130 degree days in the iraqi summer and suffered enumerable drops but it's still where I store my pics and my important docs because I know it won't crash on me. All this is to say that I am hoping with apple's record that the iPad can replace my aging laptop and just work. For this I am willing to pay the "apple" tax.

The buzz in the Tablet PC world is the HP tm2 that came out last month. I and a bunch of guys over on tabletpcreview.com have one on order or on the way. This looks to be the first consumer level convertible tablet that's gotten it almost perfect. Great performance, 5.5 hours of battery life from the real world reports that are coming in, low heat and metal chassis at about 4.5 lbs. Now the iPad is 1.5 lbs and on paper 10 hours. So the iPad is much lighter but until we see real world numbers I'll have to wait on the battery life.

For course the tm2 has a 12.1" 1280x800 screen and you have the keyboard there. Really, if you were going to pack up an iPad and take accessories the weight difference for carrying in a bag wouldn't even be noticed.

Honestly 99% of the time unless your moving a device like an iPad say from room to room, its going to be laying in your lap or on a table. When walking around people are going to use their phones which are much lighter than even iPads.

At any rate can't wait to get it. And the thing is that the base model isn't that expensive. The high end iPad is $829 with 3G. The base tm2 with 3G is about $1100.

Apple folks are Apple folks. They love glitz are are willing to give a LOT of freedom and functionality so I wouldn't even bother to try to push a Windows tablet on them.

But for someone in the market for a laptop that wasn't an Apple die hard that needed a Windows laptop and was thinking about an iPad, the tablet is a better value. And while lacks certain things an iPad has, it has a lot the iPad doesn't have.

iPads could be the best thing to happen to the convertible tablet since they came out. But of course Microsoft and OEMs won't market them which makes no sense. These are among the most expensive laptops on the market and the iPad can now justify that price premium. Two for the price of one. And Flash support!;)

For the person who just wants an tablet to lay in bed with, surf the web on the couch, read eBook, these things would be perfect without spending money twice.
 
@Crazy, perhaps I was a tad unclear, I apologize. I wasnt trying to "hate" on Apple. Just stating that I wouldnt pay the premium for it, the main point of my post was that ergonomically, this is not gonna be quite as great as everyone thinks. I will admit, a tablet sitting on a table is really nice. Especially if we assume its got a nice readable display. But the whole if I'm gonna use it on the couch I have to either hold it or lay it in my lap and bend my neck down to look at it concerns me. I think not being able to convert it to a notebook type setup ( heavy part at the lowest point, and screen up, therefore increasing stability and giving it the ability for me to read it without actually having to have one hand on the machine at all times) and the poor handwriting recognition are what are crippling the pure tablet genre in general. Given Apples ability to make outstanding software, I have no doubts they will nail the OS and apps department, but still, what good is a great thing, that hurts you to use?


Also, I have a Windows box that uses a 300 Mhz processor. It "just works" too. The problem with a lot of Windows boxes is we have choices when it comes to software, too many in most cases. ;)
 
I'm buying into the hype day 1. :p

Nah, in all reality, this is going to be a better platform for what I do with my netbook. (Or try to do, depending upon how you look at it)

First Apple product I've purchased in years.
 
As others have mentioned before I think it's all in how you envision yourself using the device, many people use their netbook/laptop in different ways. For the people who can get by with just an iPhone OS to do simple couch surfing the iPad offers a bit better experience.

However for myself I use quite a bit of flash when I am couch surfing and completely eliminating flash from the entire platform means the iPad is not even a consideration for me. If it had flash I might be able to look past Apples DRM and closed system and grab one on impulse. Without Flash its a concrete NO.
 
I'm impressed... a civic discussion on the merits of the product instead of blatant market induced negative quips. Who could have thought that would apply on any product on a [H]ardForum much less an apple product with so many fanboi's out vehemently defending or accusing to justify his/her own purchases. Thank you everyone for your honest opinions. I wrote the oped because I was tired of all the ridiculous iPad bashing in mainstream media and in public opinion expecting a company to produce a product that would be leaps and bounds ahead of what's available technically today without sacrificing battery life and price. Granted the iPhone set a high bar.

Personally I think the iPad is a going to be great for the industry... spurning a move towards computers with a better more intuitive interface and a PC that can no longer be identified as a PC. Obviously there are limitations to the iPad and that's where intelligent deisgners and OEM's can step in and fill the void and take that market share. But I hope we all realize that we're the minority, power users, the vast majority of consumers don't care about power, they don't care about function, they care about a pretty device that gets them to their facebook, twitter, and youtube as fast and as efficient as possible while still looking good. I have a feeling at that price point and with the appeal and UI, the iPad is going to make a killing.

I'm not saying my reasons are not as impure... haha... but at least I'm aware of why I would be in the market
 
How are you going to watch the occasional TV show or movie?
You can rent and buy movies and TV show episodes right on the iPad. Yes, it costs money, but it's also commercial-free.

There's also the DVD/Blu-ray-to-iPad route as well. Getting content on the iPad with Handbrake, DVD HD Decrypter/AnyDVD HD and iTunes isn't difficult at all.

Why is the iPad better for reading books than other netbooks/laptops?
Watch the keynote (or some of the iPad hands on videos on YouTube). Kindle for Windows is a competent e-reader, but there is some appeal in being able to interactively turn pages and having an attractive "bookshelf" feature. I have a reader app for my iPhone that offers similar functionality and it works pretty well. Makes reading books more "fun".

Apple folks are Apple folks. They love glitz are are willing to give a LOT of freedom and functionality
I think the distinction that needs to be made is that there is functionality and there is functionality you actually use. The typical user may not need the functionality of a comparatively expensive Windows-based tablet and may only require the functionality the iPad offers. Rather than buy a Windows-based tablet that's more expensive, the iPad might seem the more logical choice.

The iPad is for that person. It's not for you -- you've made that obvious -- but for the person who might need or want a more simplistic, straight-forward device. And relatively speaking, it's inexpensive assuming you don't need/want the overpriced 3G-enabled version (which is ridiculously priced).

But for someone in the market for a laptop that wasn't an Apple die hard that needed a Windows laptop and was thinking about an iPad, the tablet is a better value.
Well, if someone obviously needs a Windows machine, then a Windows tablet is the logical choice (sort of goes without saying).
 
Back
Top