[H]'s Video Card Review Method

Well I havent read ALL 5 pages of this thread so hope I'm not repeating anyone here....

The main reason I've always liked the HardOCP reviews about anything they do is becuase its always been a down-to-earth this is what the player is gunna get style review which suits me perfectly.

The only other review site I'd normally read would be TomsHardware but I've found HardOCP reviews to be much more accurate for the everyday user rather than the person who just likes reading the 'it does this on paper' style review so I'm more than happy with the way that they have been reviewing graphics cards.
 
love the site, hate the video card reviewing system, although I do respect the fact that they are staying away from 3dmark.

Im not an nvidia/ati fanboy either way, at the end of the day all that matters to me is the price to power&image quality ratio.
 
fwiw, I don't think using fraps to review video cards is a worthwhile way to do it. if you can't tell the difference between 60 fps and 80 fps, or 50 fps and 60 fps, then what difference does it make that it's running at the higher versus the lower? my ideal review would be a person who is not at all sensitive to framerate, a person for whom it matters some, and a person who dies if it goes under 60. then have them give their opinions of which card worked better, without telling them which is which. call it "card a" and "card b". this might or might not be reproducible on multiple test runs, but if it is, then it's the best way for me. i don't care whether i'm running at 50 or 60 fps, as long as i can't tell the difference. some games run better at low fps, some you'll only want higher. i'm playing through zelda:eek:ot right now on a n64 emulator, and it only runs at 20fps. however, i still get an enjoyable experience with that game. halo runs about the same if i crank up the detail (radeon 9000 :( ) but is much less playable at this framerate. [h]'s reviews are a step in the right direction, but the "overall" playability is more important to me than the playability at 10.36 seconds into the time demo.
 
Back
Top