Gyroscope effect on laptop harddrives?

Sly

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Aug 17, 2004
Messages
5,749
I saw a video of a guy demonstrating the gyroscoping effect in zero gravity using a CD player, and i tried doing it on my external DVD drive. I have moved it while it's running before but i've always kept it level. When i tried turning it, i was just a few degrees off level and i could already hear the DVD start scraping the sides (It was angled away from the lens so no worries).

The problem is, i have this habit of flipping a laptop over when i'm leaving it on a soft surface to keep the vents in the open (Sofa, bed, mantel, carseat, etc.). I've been doing it ever since my sister laptop burned out (as in smoke came out) after she left it on her bed.

How do laptop harddrives handle gyroscopic effects? I'm hoping that what happened to the DVD doesn't happen to the harddrive since it's solidly secured but the drive head is also a lot closer to the platter and it's moving atleast 7,000 rpm.

The demo of the laptop crashing after being subjected to a vibrator has the drive head banging up and down on the platter. I don't jostle the laptop so there's not much chance of that happening, but what i'm worried about is the platter hitting the drive head when i flip it. :confused:
 
Im curious to know as well. I move my laptop around quite a bit and walk with it while powered on. If you have an external hard drive and you try to move/twist it around while it's powered, you will clearly feel a strong gyro effect. But I suspect the thing to be most concerned about would be a head crash. The platters are likely to be stiff enough that they wont warp or flex too much.
 
Hard disk platters are much more secure than a dvd (infact even laptop DVD/CD drives are much more secure than a desktop dvd/cd drive as the disk actually clips onto the tray instead of just sitting there).

Nothing to worry about, the platters aren't going to be moving around in there, they aren't just sitting, they are rather well secured.. G-Forces damage hard drives, vibrations are sudden changes in motion (and acceleration) THAT is what damages drives as it causes the heads to hit the platter. Flipping a laptop over isn't going to cause high g-forces (unless you proceed to drop it on a hard surface). I used to flip my laptop over all the time.

HOLY SH*T! It's actually strong enough to hold up the unit from the inside! That can't be good.
Why does that scare you? Ever ridden a bike?
 
Last edited:
You should have no problems moving a drive like that during operation. Just don't drop it or you may have a problem

Or you can just get SSD' drives and then treat your laptop like shit :)
 
HDDs are recommended to be operated in either a vertical or horizontal position, any other position will work too, but will probably degrade performance (takes more time to align the heads or so). There should be no issues moving a working HDD about as one'd encounter with an optical drive, if only because a HDD spins so much faster and the platters are well-secured :)
 
Nothing to do with RPM, all to do with the fact that they are well secured.
 
HDDs are recommended to be operated in either a vertical or horizontal position, any other position will work too, but will probably degrade performance (takes more time to align the heads or so). There should be no issues moving a working HDD about as one'd encounter with an optical drive, if only because a HDD spins so much faster and the platters are well-secured :)

There is no relation to the axis mounting of a drive to its lifespan.
 
You should have no problems moving a drive like that during operation. Just don't drop it or you may have a problem

Or you can just get SSD' drives and then treat your laptop like shit :)

I have to say that it's much more comfortable handling a laptop when you know there's no moving parts in it :)
 
Was I saying that?

Actually yes you were...


HDDs are recommended to be operated in either a vertical or horizontal position, any other position will work too, but will probably degrade performance (takes more time to align the heads or so). There should be no issues moving a working HDD about as one'd encounter with an optical drive, if only because a HDD spins so much faster and the platters are well-secured :)

There is no relation of its axis position to longevity or performance.
 
Actually yes you were...




There is no relation of its axis position to longevity or performance.

I was just repeating what I had heard years ago, with some guesswork thrown in :)

Maybe it was true for older HDDs?
 
Back
Top