GRRRraaaagh!! (Or: I hate video cards sometimes)

Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
996
Ok. So I'm working on a friends computer.

Here's the gist of the problem:

Tested the machine with an ATI card initially and everything was fine.
He dropped off an Nvidia card that he wanted me to check out and it was
working fine as well (didn't do any Driver Cleaner stuff between that swap).

Tested the nvidia card and it does seem to have problems, so I pulled it out and put the ATI card back in (again, didn't do the drivercleaner; just the standard add/remove old drivers install new drivers).

Turn on the system: garbage on the screen. "ho hum"

So, I slap the nvidia card back in (with no drivers installed I might add) and it boots up fine and I uninstall everything and try again.

Still no good, so I go through with the whole process of cab and driver cleaning with drivercleaner. Initially, still bad, but at one point it was a little better and I could see enough to navigate the system (with the ATI card installed). Tried installing the drivers and get a black screen after it's installing them . GAH!!!

I'm currently in the process, yet again, of running driver cleaner and I'm just gonna clean out everything remotely related to Nvidia and ATI and every one of the cabs listed in the drop down menu.

If this doesn't work, I'm gonna find an ATI employee to shoot! :mad:

Seriously though. Anyone have any additional tips on this? It seems like I always run into this problem going from having an Nvidia card installed, to trying to install an ATI card. Don't know or care if it's Nvidia's fault or ATI's fault.
 
that was pretty dumb, you had to excpect problems like that. PCI-e 16X slots arnt really plug-n-play.

but yeah i donno. the only thing i can see you doing is removing all drivers, both the ones for your ATI card and your NV card, and reinstalling the driver for what ever card your using.
 
First of all, it's an AGP system. Also, it's not dumb. It's not like drivercleaner has been around as long as video card swapping has been. :rolleyes:

Anyway, nope. Still didn't help going through the whole process again and cleaning every cab and every bit of ATI and Nvidia.

Here's a pic if it helps anyone, for whatever reason.

http://img144.imageshack.us/img144/8758/pict0001wl6.jpg
 
MrWizard6600 said:
that was pretty dumb, you had to excpect problems like that. PCI-e 16X slots arnt really plug-n-play.

but yeah i donno. the only thing i can see you doing is removing all drivers, both the ones for your ATI card and your NV card, and reinstalling the driver for what ever card your using.

That response made absolutely no sense.
 
From the picture, it looks like you did something to mess up the card. I have swapped cards hundreds of times and can say your problem is not from drivers.
 
thats messed... maybe you should try just booting into safe mode witth a windows install disk in the drive...could it maybe be a ps issue? Good luck to ya though, i had a similar problem with a previous build for a friend, was waiting on a nvidia video card and was just using an ati to install apps, games...when the nvidia card arrived had all sorts of problems with getting it to work properly. I ended up downloading an ati driver remover utility and everything worked fine after.
 
From your first post it seems as if your saying that the screen is corrupted as soon as you power on and start POST. If so, then the ATI card is toast. POST happens before any drivers are loaded, and there'd be no "residual driver" stuff until Windows loaded the desktop/logon screen.
 
ryan_975 said:
From your first post it seems as if your saying that the screen is corrupted as soon as you power on and start POST. If so, then the ATI card is toast. POST happens before any drivers are loaded, and there'd be no "residual driver" stuff until Windows loaded the desktop/logon screen.


No. POST is fine. And the Windows splash screen is fine too (except for the little animated bar at the bottom. That's the first place I can tell that the video is still messed up)
 
rfwinters77 said:
No. POST is fine. And the Windows splash screen is fine too (except for the little animated bar at the bottom. That's the first place I can tell that the video is still messed up)

hmmm. that bar is being driven by the 16-color VGA driver. I think. If I remmeber correctly the ATI drivers don't take over until just before the Welocme screen pops up. So I'd say the card is toast. Do you have any way to test it in another machine?
 
ryan_975 said:
hmmm. that bar is being driven by the 16-color VGA driver. I think. If I remmeber correctly the ATI drivers don't take over until just before the Welocme screen pops up. So I'd say the card is toast. Do you have any way to test it in another machine?


Yeah. I pulled it out of another (working) system to test my friends machine.

I'll pop it back in the other system to double check, but I don't see how it would have just died out of the blue.

Worth checking out though.
 
I had an issue with an ATI card on my friends machine. It would not do exactly what you are saying, but when running anything 3D it would crap out and make the picture go crazy.

It turned out one of the transistors/resistors/whatever on the board had a solder joint loose, just loose enough that it was still on, but could wiggle and come undone. I simply electrical taped (ghetto I know, but the solder was under the piece so i could not solder it) it (to keep it solid) and it has been working fine.

It seems some ATI cards are just not made as well and break easily, that was the 2nd time that has happened to me on an ATI card....

Moral of my little story, take the card out and take a good look at all the transistors/resistors/stuff on the board and make sure they are solidly connected. That is if it does not work in the other machine you test it in.
 
Weirder and weirder.

So I tested the card in the machine I pulled it from and sure enough it's working fine. It does do one odd thing though. During boot, between the windows splash screen and actually getting the windows desktop, it seems the signal is lost for a second because my screen gives that standard error, but works fine aside from that.

What's weird about my friends system now, is I slapped an older Radeon 7200 in just to check it out and it works fine. (The card that wasn't working is a Radeon 9550).

Now I'm even more stumped. I've thought about doing the system restore thing since it seems like there are multiple restore points from basically when the system was first set up.

I was thinking of rolling it back to before the ATI drivers were installed and see if things will work on a cleaner system.
I've never used the restore point thing though, so I'm a bit hesitant.
 
Got a possible solution.

Check both cards gold connectors on the bottom for any damage, dirt, or grime. If it's dirt or grime, take a Q-Tip with some alcohol on it and clean it with that. There's a chance that some sludge got inside your AGP slot as well, so I recommend unplugging your PSU and cleaning that AGP slot as well. You'd be amazed what a bit of dust could do to an expansion slot.

Post again if this solves your problem or not.
 
Perhaps this is not a software issue. The ati card may have been damaged in the removal.
 
Back
Top