Groups File Complaint Against AT&T for Blocking FaceTime

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It looks like things are just getting worse for AT&T and this whole FaceTime debacle. You'd think the company would relent and quit blocking FaceTime, especially since its competitors allow it for free.

“AT&T’s decision to block FaceTime unless a customer pays for voice and text minutes she doesn’t need is a clear violation of the FCC’s Open Internet rules,” said Free Press Policy Director Matt Wood. "It’s particularly outrageous that AT&T is requiring this for iPad users, given that this device isn’t even capable of making voice calls. AT&T's actions are incredibly harmful to all of its customers, including the deaf, immigrant families and others with relatives overseas, who depend on mobile video apps to communicate with friends and family."
 
It was good until they pulled the discrimination card. Then, they lost me.

I can understand that they dropped it, but to do it to force a higher plan? Not cool. Pretty soon, Skype will be on the list, too (or other VoIP programs). Anything that circumvents the 'normal' route of phone calls will require a higher plan.

I don't care if it is harmful to deaf, immigrants or the Average Joe. They are ripping off customers. Playing the discrimination card just seems to put me off a bit. Desperate.
 
First mistake was getting a new iPhone while still under AT&T. You should have switched carriers before locking yourself in with them. Second mistake was buying an iPhone. Piratically all carriers hate them for consuming the most resources on their network.
 
What we really need is a gov that can't be bought and leveraged to reinforce monopolies. The free market would then flourish through innovation, quality of service and price.
 
What, you don't like it when disabilities are leveraged as weapons? You must hate the disabled, etc., etc.!
 
ATT has been doing this since the dawn of the iPhone. When will people learn?? :rolleyes:
 
What we really need is a gov that can't be bought and leveraged to reinforce monopolies. The free market would then flourish through innovation, quality of service and price.

A discussion for the SoapBox. Humans are just that humans, and our fellow species members have shown repeatedly over the years that we can't trust our fellow man to behave ethically and not to screw us at every turn.

AT&T blocking FaceTime has less to do with regulation, and has everything to do with most carriers not wanting to spend money on improving their infrastructure.
 
I would have chosen a carrier that offered the services I required.

Well unfortunately you have to choose the lesser of two evils. I have sprint and sure it may be unlimited but the connection speed is abysmal. My EVO 4G and my wife's Epic can't connect to 4G in Dallas / fort worth. There's either not enough signal strength or the speed is non existent if you do connect. So I was glad when I got an iPhone 4S since it doesn't support 4G they dropped the mandatory $10 per month 4G charge. But now I get terrible 3G speeds. Usually I'm at about 20Kb/sec (150msec) and occasionally it may hit 100KB/sec. Siri doesnt even work half the time. So now I'm looking at AT&T.

I regularly have people at work on different carriers do speed tests at the same time as me and usually get 10x the speed.
 
A discussion for the SoapBox. Humans are just that humans, and our fellow species members have shown repeatedly over the years that we can't trust our fellow man to behave ethically and not to screw us at every turn.

That's part of the "survival of the fittest" insticts right there. You are programmed to a degree by nature to hoard as many resources that you can get away with.

Today, however, this survival instinct has become greed at the expense of anyone you can throw under the bus.
 
There are no phone companies anymore, only wireless ISPs... FCC rules should follow suit.
 
What we really need is a gov that can't be bought and leveraged to reinforce monopolies. The free market would then flourish through innovation, quality of service and price.

a truly free market allows the gov't to be bought and sold
 
i think if you read the AT&T terms of service it says your data plan can only be used for emails, web browsing, etc - simple things. things like face time, siri, etc. are technically not allowed by the contract the user signs. buyer beware, you agreed to it, you're stuck
 
i think if you read the AT&T terms of service it says your data plan can only be used for emails, web browsing, etc - simple things. things like face time, siri, etc. are technically not allowed by the contract the user signs. buyer beware, you agreed to it, you're stuck

that's why you pay for tethering too
 
What we really need is a gov that can't be bought and leveraged to reinforce monopolies. The free market would then flourish through innovation, quality of service and price.

Or you fall into a comfortable oligopoly like we have now that still charges high prices.
 
That's part of the "survival of the fittest" insticts right there. You are programmed to a degree by nature to hoard as many resources that you can get away with.

Today, however, this survival instinct has become greed at the expense of anyone you can throw under the bus.

That has got to be the best way to describe/define/explain greed. Kudos.
 
What, you don't like it when disabilities are leveraged as weapons? You must hate the disabled, etc., etc.!

I know that's sarcasm, but that it the way some people think. You don't like a policy by Obama? You're racist.

I just don't like it when people pull that card when it has absolutely nothing to do with it other than a card to pull to make your argument look stronger (it doesn't).
 
a truly free market allows the gov't to be bought and sold
What an ignorant comment. If the government has no control over the free market, there would be no reason to invest in buying them in the first place.

Laissez faire economics is not perfect, but it certainly has virtually eliminated corruption in politics historically.

The more control the government has over private industry, the more incentive there is to not even buy the legistlator with heavy lobbying and campaign contributions, but ot actually EMPLOY the legistlator. A great example of this is with the corn industry. The same top executives from the corn and pesticide industry are the ones holding office and then going back to the business, rinse and repeat. The excuse is that its because they are the "industry experts", but the real reason is that they are bankrolled in with connections with the expectation they create legistlation in favor of the mega-corporations that put them in office, and following their stint they naturally return to the company well rewarded for their efforts.

Get the government completely out of it, acting only as a monopoly-buster when warranted (basically police force) and the incestuous relationship ends overnight.
 
I know that's sarcasm, but that it the way some people think. You don't like a policy by Obama? You're racist.

I just don't like it when people pull that card when it has absolutely nothing to do with it other than a card to pull to make your argument look stronger (it doesn't).

I totally agree with you however the "disability" card is fairly justified being pulled in on this case. AT&T does offer a specialized phone plan (TAP) and now if I am required to buy a voice plan in order to use the FaceTime, that flies against the common sense and the service they provide to people like me who uses TAP.

Now - I don't have an iPhone so this does not really apply to me nonetheless but my wife does have an iPhone and she's always on wifi so this is a m00t point for us both. Just wanted to point out that when one offers a plan that specifically targets an audience and then now requires them to buy unlimited voice when it won't benefit them at all could be looked at as a discrimination. Now, the only thing is the TAP is not required or anything, it is being offered on AT&T's own behalf so they could just jerk it off the shelves for us all too.

I am not going to bitch much when I pay 35 bucks for 2gb/mo data and unlimited text.
 
Someone should buy AT&T a pet cat. Cats tend to moderate human behaviour or make them sneeze a lot if they're allergic.

Anyhow, I completely support these groups going after AT&T for blocking Facetime because it seems pretty stupid. Yeah, it makes it hard to communicate for people with disabilities too, but video chat applications like Facetime haven't been broadly available on cellular phones for very long. It makes stuff like this:

...depend on mobile video apps to communicate...

make me wonder what we did like three years ago to communicate..you know, before mobile phones had front-facing cameras if we depend on them now. How did we get used to something that just became widely available?
 
Someone should buy AT&T a pet cat. Cats tend to moderate human behaviour or make them sneeze a lot if they're allergic.

Anyhow, I completely support these groups going after AT&T for blocking Facetime because it seems pretty stupid. Yeah, it makes it hard to communicate for people with disabilities too, but video chat applications like Facetime haven't been broadly available on cellular phones for very long. It makes stuff like this:



make me wonder what we did like three years ago to communicate..you know, before mobile phones had front-facing cameras if we depend on them now. How did we get used to something that just became widely available?


If memory serves FaceTime video chat was available over cellular networks in the EU for LONG before the iPhone "pioneered" it and wowed people in the USA...catch being that US telecoms have simply chose to block that protocol since it became available. The telecoms didn't want to have to spend on their infrastructure for its use, so they simply chose to not enable the ability on their networks.
 
If memory serves FaceTime video chat was available over cellular networks in the EU for LONG before the iPhone "pioneered" it and wowed people in the USA...catch being that US telecoms have simply chose to block that protocol since it became available. The telecoms didn't want to have to spend on their infrastructure for its use, so they simply chose to not enable the ability on their networks.

Facetime (the name anyway) was purchased by Apple for the release of their software in 2010. (source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FaceTime) The company they bought it from didn't really have anything to do with video chat applications on cell phones and changed its name to Actiance, Inc. (source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Actiance)

AT&T and this discussion is mostly about the US deployment of Facetime which wasn't something that was available to the US market before 2010.

I'm not trying to be apologetic about the TELCOs since...well...they suck, but they're having problems getting their hands on the frequencies they want to expand the capacity of their networks. A lot of those problems go back to the FCC, but some of those problems are self-invented ones too. Personally, I don't think that the carriers have a way of magically waving a wand to improve the capacity of their network. That kinda stuff is very expensive and happens over time (usually not at the speed that the common person thinks is reasonable). Yeah, they're serving themselves profits, but I'm sure they understand the strategic importance of network and infrastructure upgrades in relationship to the long-term survival of their companies.

Anyhow, Skirbbels say we're, as a species, too quick to make ourselves dependent on a certain thing like video chat. Or, at the very least, we're too quick to claim that we're dependent in order to better leverage our arguments with a supportive basis. Civilization existed for like eleventy-gajillion years before video chat happened over mobile phones. It's a nice feature that I think _should_ be available to everyone under the terms of their current phone plans, but I'm not ready to go waving a pitchfork and torch at anyone without petting my cat and thinking about it first.
 
Im curious, what did the deaf and others listed by the groups do before cellphones and smartphones were around? And will they then bitch about having to pay data overages if/when they get Facetime unrestricted? I have yet to see Facetime work even remotely good over AT&T's network.
 
Can they not figure out how to use Skype or am I missing something else?
 
Well unfortunately you have to choose the lesser of two evils. I have sprint and sure it may be unlimited but the connection speed is abysmal. My EVO 4G and my wife's Epic can't connect to 4G in Dallas / fort worth. There's either not enough signal strength or the speed is non existent if you do connect. So I was glad when I got an iPhone 4S since it doesn't support 4G they dropped the mandatory $10 per month 4G charge. But now I get terrible 3G speeds. Usually I'm at about 20Kb/sec (150msec) and occasionally it may hit 100KB/sec. Siri doesnt even work half the time. So now I'm looking at AT&T.

I regularly have people at work on different carriers do speed tests at the same time as me and usually get 10x the speed.

You must be on a different sprint than everyone else in the nation because the $10 charge is for all data plans and has been for a very long time. The 4G claim only took place for a short time when they first ran 4G they quickly added that charge to all data plans.
 
Also the cell companies have always and still do limit what you can do on a phone. Personally I think this is wrong but any change in the ATT policy on facetime will not help the rest of us where it really counts. Look at simple things like VOIP, simply put AFAIK there is no good VOIP solution on mobile phones. And the only reason I can think of is that the phone companies are pulling strings, limiting software and blocking data to make that happen. Isnt it ironic that I can call anyone in the world for free most of the time and usually less than 2 cents a minute on my PC, but on my android phone the only way to get that service running is to do some wonky call back thing where I connect to a local number. Look into betamax VOIP providers.

This is why all of you should actually start pushing for phone plans where you pay for data at a rate, if this was the case phone companies would want you to use data, and they would open everything up, maybe even give you hotspots etc...
 
Well,

If ATT is using 4GLTE technology on spectrum they purchased, they are not allowed to block anything, period.

Same reason Verizon was told they are not allowed to block tethering and fined.
 
Their network cant handle it. They already get enough flack and rank lower than Verizon on a continual basis.
 
Im curious, what did the deaf and others listed by the groups do before cellphones and smartphones were around?
Shut your cake hole! Right now, this is NO PLACE for logic and reason. Stop being so damn selfish and think of the immigrant families (especially the illegal ones)! Discrimination!
 
Personally, while I think it's dumb for AT&T to be charging for facetime on 3G, I think this complaint is equally dumb. Clearly AT&T is doing this to encourage grandfathered people off their old plans, but at the same time, this isn't discriminatory to people with disabilities, immigrants, or overseas people. AT&T isn't blocking ALL video chat over 3G options--just this one particular service. There are others that are entirely free for video chat, such a s Skype.

All that being said, I'm flabbergasted that Apple is allowing this. Apple had apparently fought tooth and nail with AT&T since the iPhone came out on their network, dictating what they can or cannot do, and was always explicit that the provider could not interrupt the user experience. Surprised that Apple hasn't spoken about this to AT&T yet.
 
Personally, while I think it's dumb for AT&T to be charging for facetime on 3G, I think this complaint is equally dumb. Clearly AT&T is doing this to encourage grandfathered people off their old plans, but at the same time, this isn't discriminatory to people with disabilities, immigrants, or overseas people. AT&T isn't blocking ALL video chat over 3G options--just this one particular service. There are others that are entirely free for video chat, such a s Skype.

All that being said, I'm flabbergasted that Apple is allowing this. Apple had apparently fought tooth and nail with AT&T since the iPhone came out on their network, dictating what they can or cannot do, and was always explicit that the provider could not interrupt the user experience. Surprised that Apple hasn't spoken about this to AT&T yet.

I think apple figured out years ago that AT&T could sell an iphone case full of used junkie's needles and the phones would still sell out.
 
Back
Top