Google To Use New Captcha Method

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Google has come up with a new Captcha method that involves rotating images instead of entering text. You can say Google is putting a new “spin” on Captcha. Get it? (*rimshot please*)

Given a large repository of images, such as those from a web search result, we use a suite of automated orientation detectors to prune those images that can be automatically set upright easily. We then apply a social feedback mechanism to verify that the remaining images have a human-recognizable upright orientation.
 
This is brilliant! I haven't seen any good captcha ideas since the hotcaptcha stuff.

Now in terms of the worst, I don't think anyone can top Rapidshare's old "Kitty" captcha. Thank god they ditched that clusterfuck.
 
$10 says this will get defeated in a month
 
\

According to that site the captcha's are defeated using humans. I can only imagine a sweat shop where you get paid $2 for every 1000, sounds like a terrible job.

Yes, but apparently the accuracy is "way more better" that way. :rolleyes:
 
These'll be cheaper, only $1.50/1000. You can use illiterate indian peasants to crack them.
 

The issue with that is cost / captcha. How much CPU time and bandwidth does it take to build the 3d models and transfer the image to the user? That's why the majority of captchas you see are simple text with simple colors (8bpp [bits per pixel] in recaptcha's verison compaired to a normal 24 bpp in most jpegs).

The image rotators is a neat concept but does it use flash to show the captcha? or some advanced javascript? Do you get multiple chances on the same image or if you're off once you get a new one? I'd like to see this captcha in the wild before we talk about how awesome it is.
 
The real trick is to ALTER the images that you must pick for the match. Altered in a manner that a human mind can easily distinguish yet an automated program couldn't match.

Just rotating the exact image can be dealth with by automatic means. Changing contrast, colors, blurring, reversing, etc can easily be overcome by the human mind.... even an idiots... while completely snarfling any software program.

"Please enter the selection for the 'best match' of the image above", could be infinitely more difficult for captcha cracking methods currently used.
 
I'm a fan of text-based captchas that sk you to do something simple, for example:

"Please type in the third word
of the second line of this
paragraph."

Easy for computers to generate; difficult for computers to crack (unless someone gets the generation algorithms).
 
These'll be cheaper, only $1.50/1000. You can use illiterate indian peasants to crack them.

Well since these are instruction based and can be used for learning, it's just a matter of time before elementary school teachers decide to make a little side income.
 
\

According to that site the captcha's are defeated using humans. I can only imagine a sweat shop where you get paid $2 for every 1000, sounds like a terrible job.

No they don't get paid nearly that much, the things are subcontracted out a few times. Decaptcher charges $2/1000, which is a lot for that sort of thing.
 
Back
Top