Google Sues Polish Poets

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Here we go again, another lawsuit over the gmail name. Apparently the poets have the domain gmail.pl and Google doesn’t like it too much. The article doesn’t say how long the group has had the name but it makes you wonder how the hell Google doesn’t own all these domains in the first place?

Izabela Krawczyk of GMAiL -- the "Grupa Mlodych Artystow i Literatow," or Group of Young Artists and Writers -- told AFP that Google had turned to the country's IT and telecommunications tribunal to try to stop them using the Web site address www.gmail.pl. Google charges that GMAiL has no rights to the name, which resembles the US firm's internationally known email service www.gmail.com.
 
I've pretty much lost all faith in google. Their motto is "don't be evil," yet they bully the small guy and censor what people upload to google video.

I'm switching all my boxes to metacrawler.com for the home page. Google has been infiltrated. :eek:
 
According to whois records gmail.pl was created Nov 1, 2006, so long after Google's GMail was started.

The thing is there are similarities to the Cisco-iPhone suit.

I am surprised a company can even have rights to a single letter added to a literate description of their product.
 
Well, Google certainly has gotten ODD lately. Turning over identities of bloggers and such in China, Brazil etc. etc. Handing over information to other countries to do business there...I'm not real keen on that. All the lawsuits over the names...it's not like a bunch of starving Polish poets wouldn't take some cash...I know they said other wise, but you KNOW they would. ;)
 
That doesn't tell us how long the GMAIL group has been active in Poland. They could've been around long before google registered gmail in the US.

Google has been acting like a bunch of assholes lately. Did they go public recently or something?
 
These kind of legal actions have more to do with the way intellectual property laws work in the US than anything else. If you ever choose not to defend your IP, you set a precedent that can be used against you in a future suit you wish to file. In other words: you can't choose to give one party a pass while filing against another.


I'm sure Google doesn't care whether they win or lose the case, the simple action of filing shows Google's active defense of their IP and assures them of the ability to protect the IP in the future.

That and the domain was created well after Google created GMail.
 
I know the concept is evil, but i'm pretty sure they have every right to protect there name. I believe the courts said you need to protect something to keep or make reasonable efforts. I know it seems nitpickky, but I do see there point.
 
Beaten to it multiple times:p

The thing that bothers me about this is that this group doesn't appear to be abusing or misrepresenting the gmail name at all. My polish isn't so good, so I don't know for sure :p but I think it would be a totally different case if they were a commercial website that might benefit from people stumbling upon gmail.pl attempting to sign up for email.
 
Back
Top