Google Sued For Using Android Name

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It is amazing that a company like Google, with almost unlimited resources, didn’t know someone had a trademark on the Android name. Whoops. Well, it will all be hammered out in court now…or with a fat stack o' cash. I'm guessing the latter.

Hold on to your positronic caps, readers. It seems our little green robo-friend may be in for a little bit of legal trouble. Erich Specht has sued Google and seemingly every company that has ever thought about using its mobile OS for infringing use of the name "Android." He's the owner of the trademark for Android Data Corporation, granted way back in October of 2002.
 
So, Android Data Corporation has a brand called "Android Data", which is described as a "computer e-commerce software to allow users to perform electronic business transactions via a global computer network". Google's Android if an operating system for mobile devices.

Both software, sure, but is there an overlap here? Nah. Android Data Corp. doesn't even have a website. I have absolutely no clue how to contact Android Data Corp. and buy Android Data. It probably isn't even a real product. The company's been around for 11 years and has absolutely nothing to show for its existence other than a lawsuit against Google and others over the Android trademark?
 
Please could you stop the noise, I'm trying to get some rest
From all the unborn chicken voices in my head
What's this? (I may be paranoid, but not an android)
What's this? (I may be paranoid, but not an android)

When I am king, you will be first against the wall
with your opinion which is of no consequence at all
What's this? (I may be paranoid, but no android)
What's this? (I may be paranoid, but no android)

Ambition makes you look pretty ugly
Kicking, squealing, gucci little piggy
You don't remember
You don't remember
Why don't you remember my name?
Off with his head, man
Off with his head, man
Why don't you remember my name? I guess he does...

Rain down, rain down
Come on rain down on me
From a great height
From a great height... height...
Rain down, rain down
Come on rain down on me
From a great height
From a great height... height...
Rain down, rain down
Come on rain down on me

That's it sir
You're leaving
The crackle of pigskin
The dust and the screaming
The yuppies networking
The panic, the vomit
The panic, the vomit
God loves his children, God loves his children, yeah!
 
Looking at the timing of this, I hope the guy doesnt get anything. He's had all the time until now to throw a fit over the name, but he waited until he could not only go after Google, but other companies using the OS.

Yeah, no. This guy is just an assshole for doing it.
 
Android sounds like a generic name anyways, like Windows and Apple.

Somehow I doubt if Android Data Corp will win this one.
 
Android sounds like a generic name anyways, like Windows and Apple.

Somehow I doubt if Android Data Corp will win this one.

Kind of like Monster too, but well.....you know.
They like to sue for their "rights" to the word monster.
 
The main problem is that there is only a finite number of nouns in the English language, plus by definition Android is closely linked to computers/ robots.

I agree with phide the two brands have nothing in common.
 
I have a lawsuit in progress that involves me suing every single day company in the world that ever used the word "Wednesday."

It's a day of the week. I copyrighted it. Eat it, bitches.
 
I had to name my company whargbleschnausage TM to avoid being able to be sued by anyone.

Seriously, this crap is retarded. It's a damn word in the english language, nobody 'owns' it. I doubt the suit will go anywhere, but some of these people need to grow a damn brain cell.
 
I had to name my company whargbleschnausage TM to avoid being able to be sued by anyone.

Seriously, this crap is retarded. It's a damn word in the english language, nobody 'owns' it. I doubt the suit will go anywhere, but some of these people need to grow a damn brain cell.

wtf that's the name of my computer repair business! See you in court buster!

:D
 
I doubt the suit will go anywhere, but some of these people need to grow a damn brain cell.
I just hope Google doesn't end up settling just to placate shareholders. This is something Google should most absolutely fight.
 
Someone beat me to the Radio head +1 for that.


Based on this they don't even have a prima facia for it, so this will probably go away quietly into the night (aka google gives them some small amount of money to STFU)
 
Looking at the timing of this, I hope the guy doesnt get anything. He's had all the time until now to throw a fit over the name, but he waited until he could not only go after Google, but other companies using the OS.

Yeah, no. This guy is just an assshole for doing it.

How do you know that he and his lawyer haven't spent the last 6 months in negotiations with Google?

Answer is you don't.

This guy has a legit trademark infringement complaint. Google got denied a trademark for Android because this guy already had it!!
 
"Google came around and filed a trademark application for Android five years later and, wait for it, had that trademark application denied due to confusion with Mr. Specht's."

And Google went ahead and used it anyway.

And now they're getting sued.

Why is everyone siding with Google here??
 
More than likely it will not hold up. The word Android has been around for a while and likely can not be just claimed by someone. Only Apple and Windows have enough layers to get away with that... and Monster I guess. It should be thrown out.
 
Why is everyone siding with Google here??

Because the products/services in question are unrelated, at least in the context that there is not competition between the two.

Trademark doesn't (or shouldn't, I am not a lawyer) mean that you simply flat out own the rights to use that word in any business context whatsoever.
 
Because the products/services in question are unrelated, at least in the context that there is not competition between the two.

Trademark doesn't (or shouldn't, I am not a lawyer) mean that you simply flat out own the rights to use that word in any business context whatsoever.

But they're both clearly computer-related. I can't introduce a new operating system called, say, Oracle.

Google is clearly using Android in the same field that Android Data Systems is/was using the trademark. The only chance I see for Google here is to argue that Android is not currently using the trademark.
 
But they're both clearly computer-related. I can't introduce a new operating system called, say, Oracle.

Google is clearly using Android in the same field that Android Data Systems is/was using the trademark. The only chance I see for Google here is to argue that Android is not currently using the trademark.

So nothing at all related to 'computers' is allowed to use the same word in any of the business names and/or products? Simply being computer related is not enough. The have to actually be competing products / businesses, in the sense that people could be confused as to which is which.

What if a company wants to actually use the word android for what it means? Like say they make ai software for robotics. You think google or ADS should be able to sue them simply because their work in part has something to do with computers? Everything has something to do with computers. :rolleyes:
 
But they're both clearly computer-related. I can't introduce a new operating system called, say, Oracle.

Google is clearly using Android in the same field that Android Data Systems is/was using the trademark. The only chance I see for Google here is to argue that Android is not currently using the trademark.

The only way that Android Data System could use "android" is if they public recognition of the name, which they don't.

strait out of one of law text books.
"
A trademark is deemed distinctive when it is either inherently distinctive or has an
acquired distinctiveness through a secondary meaning. As previously mentioned,
suggestive, arbitrary, and fanciful trademarks are inherently distinctive.
Trademarks made up of common or ordinary words are not distinctive. People’s
names, geographic terms, and descriptive names are generally not distinctive and
cannot be registered. However, a person’s name that has acquired a
“secondary
meaning” (e.g., Michael Jordan) may be protected by registration, as he has acquired
great public recognition beyond the world of basketball. “Calvin Klein” was once a
nondistinctive trade name that has acquired
a valuable secondary meaning.
"
 
The only chance I see for Google here is to argue that Android is not currently using the trademark.
They've probably had it for a number of years and have never used it. Just Google up "Android Data Corporation" -Google if you want a pretty good indication of how much said corporation has accomplished in 11 years. Do the same in any other search engine and get similar results.

As far as I can tell, they've: A) created a corporation, Android Data Corporation B) defined a brand, Android Data C) filed for a trademark, as Android or Android Data. Other than that, I have absolutely no idea. I highly doubt the software itself exists. Someone registered androiddata.com in 2007, but not Android Data Corp.

They may or may not have also designed a web page in the past for a real estate agent named Wendy Murphy, according to Yahoo's cache. Whoop-de-fuckin'-doo.
 
Back
Top