Google Sheltering $10B In Bermuda

Granted I'm no expert in tax law but I've skimmed this thread and have yet to see one explanation or argument for why or how the U.S. Fed or State Government would be entitled to profits Google made in other countries. They're a global corporation. Short of that people are going on and on like Google has somehow skirted their domestic tax burden. They have not.
If you take a look about where the tax comes from it's because large multi-nationals can easily move around money to skirt taxes. It was set up to mostly tax companies who are moving money that can be moved out of a higher taxed area into a tax heaven, and the tax is there as a difference between what the tax heaven taxes them to then what the US tax is, ie if they moved money to ireland it gets taxed at what 35%-12.5%= 22.5% when the money is brought back to the US, which as we know doesn't quite work the way it was intended, instead companies just hold them in foreign banks. Really a pure territorial tax system is improbable with how money is treated in this world, any large GDP country that says they use a pure territorial tax system is probably lieing at least when dealing with domestic companies and foreign holdings, most have exceptions on the books although in principal they are set up as such.
 
Lets say you climbed an apple tree you own and you worked very hard to get 10 apples. You get down, happy at your bounty and when you feet hit the floor a government man comes and demand 5 apples to pay "your fair share" and then decides that it wasn't fair that you now have juicy delicious apples and takes another 3 to give to people who do not want to climb a tree because they are happy with getting free apples handed to them. So after all that hard work you now have 2 apples to show for it and you run home before the EPA states that your apple tree is home to a protected beetle an you no longer can eat apples because the beetle would starve.

Are you really suggesting that the government takes 80% of people's income? Eisenhower isn't president anymore...

either by shaming those who disagree into silence, or dehumanizing their opponents until all political disagreement is "war", like "war on women", or "war on the middle class".

You mean like the "war on Christmas" or the "war on Christianity"? Or all the reverse-racism us poor white folk have to suffer through?
 
You mean like the "war on Christmas" or the "war on Christianity"? Or all the reverse-racism us poor white folk have to suffer through?

Except that nobody takes either of those seriously, and you don't have presidential campaigns citing either. Obama's campaign recited both phrases I pointed out like they were going out of style. Try a fair comparison.
 
Except that nobody takes either of those seriously, and you don't have presidential campaigns citing either. Obama's campaign recited both phrases I pointed out like they were going out of style. Try a fair comparison.

Fox News takes them dead seriously, and last I recall Fox News has a lot more viewers than any of the other networks.
 
Fox News takes them dead seriously, and last I recall Fox News has a lot more viewers than any of the other networks.

So now you're comparing a television network that specializes in pop culture news and loud noises at station breaks...to the Obama campaign?

I guess if we consider them both pathetic and obnoxious and full of shit, then sure. You seem to be going out of your way, however, to avoid the fact that the campaign pushed the "war" shit and Romney's, for all its faults(and there were many), didn't. So you can stop the stupid conflation.
 
So now you're comparing a television network that specializes in pop culture news and loud noises at station breaks...to the Obama campaign?

I guess if we consider them both pathetic and obnoxious and full of shit, then sure. You seem to be going out of your way, however, to avoid the fact that the campaign pushed the "war" shit and Romney's, for all its faults(and there were many), didn't. So you can stop the stupid conflation.

Please don't pretend like Fox News isn't an enormous force behind the Republican Party. The Republican Party would likely still be the sane, fiscally conservative one of old rather than the socially conservative lunatic factory it is today if Fox News didn't make so much money scaring old white people.

And I think there is a "war" on women. You can certainly argue that "war" is too strong a word, or devalues actual war, but it doesn't change the fact that the Republican agenda wants to set women back about 60 years.
 
Please don't pretend like Fox News isn't an enormous force behind the Republican Party.

Either stop deflecting or stop responding. Address the fact that the Republican candidate never used the "war on Christmas/Christianity" bullshit in his campaign, and the fact that the Democratic candidate did. You seem to be annoyed at the "war" language as well, as you should be, since the concept is part of what I was talking about: dehumanization of an opposing political stance in order to shut down that opposition through dangerous and inciteful rhetoric.

And I think there is a "war" on women. You can certainly argue that "war" is too strong a word, or devalues actual war, but it doesn't change the fact that the Republican agenda wants to set women back about 60 years.

Never mind. You're fine with the "war" rhetoric because you agree with it. Pat yourself on the back for your contribution to the death of free expression through mob intimidation.
 
I'm starting to think you're a professional troll or something. Why are you so caught up on the word "war"? And you can't separate Romney's campaign from Fox News when they did so much of the campaigning for him. And they use the "war" terminology all the time.

And you didn't tell me why I was wrong on thinking that Republicans want to set women back 60 years. Instead you just focused on the word "war" and basically called me a fascist.
 
I'm starting to think you're a professional troll or something. Why are you so caught up on the word "war"? And you can't separate Romney's campaign from Fox News when they did so much of the campaigning for him. And they use the "war" terminology all the time.

And you didn't tell me why I was wrong on thinking that Republicans want to set women back 60 years. Instead you just focused on the word "war" and basically called me a fascist.
Pretty sure just trolling i just ignored him after he made this comment
Class warfare is an effective tool to manipulate the masses, though. Always has been, unfortunately. Worked quite well about 100 years ago in Russia, as well as Germany.
Anyone who takes the time to link an argument to nazis and communists in the same sentence has to be trolling.
 
I'm starting to think you're a professional troll or something. Why are you so caught up on the word "war"?

You're really going to great lengths to avoid even acknowledging that the current POTUS' campaign used that rhetoric over and over, while continuously whining about rhetoric that his opponent never used.

As to being "caught up" on the word "war", stop being dishonest. You yourself admitted that the word was heavily loaded and so its use can be construed as over the line.

And you can't separate Romney's campaign from Fox News when they did so much of the campaigning for him. And they use the "war" terminology all the time.

If you're going to conflate a media complex with a political candidate because their political agendas match, then I can do the same thing by claiming that Obama has MSNBC, CBS, NBC, and to lesser extents CNN and ABC, as well as the vast majority of the Hollywood media complex.

Why didn't I do the latter? Because it's meaningless partisan bullshit that doesn't answer or solve anything. It just provides one more distraction away from the actions of the actual fucking politicians. You seem to love you some distractions, it seems.

And you didn't tell me why I was wrong on thinking that Republicans want to set women back 60 years. Instead you just focused on the word "war" and basically called me a fascist.

I didn't tell you that you were wrong because you made such a broad, generalized statement that there is no possible way of responding to what amounts to political trolling. I could ask why I'm wrong thinking that Democrats want the US to be just like the USSR. Would you have an intelligent answer to such a statement? So stop acting like you're doing anything more than pushing emotionally-driven rhetoric for one side. I've already said in this forum multiple times that I didn't vote for either Obama or Romney, and that I am fed up, and not a member of, the Republican Party. How about you, champ?

You might respond, you might not. However, once you start accusing me of calling you names when I've done no such thing, I cease caring about your opinion.
 
Anyone who takes the time to link an argument to nazis and communists in the same sentence has to be trolling.

Yes, because it's utterly impossible to discuss politics and have either the Soviet Union or Nazi Germany be relevant, especially when discussing class warfare, which was heavily employed by both nations' founders.

Hint: Godwin's Law was coined to refer to discussions where the concept of Nazism had no bearing whatsoever on the topic. Believe it or not, communism and Nazism actually have relevance in political discussions from time to time, particularly when discussing times of global turmoil and revolution. I know it's chic to scoff whenever someone brings up communism, like it magically vanished from the earth when the Soviet Union fell, but there's lots of stupid attitudes that are chic.
 
As to being "caught up" on the word "war", stop being dishonest. You yourself admitted that the word was heavily loaded and so its use can be construed as over the line.

No, I did not. I said you could argue that it's too strong a word. Please read more carefully.

If you're going to conflate a media complex with a political candidate because their political agendas match, then I can do the same thing by claiming that Obama has MSNBC, CBS, NBC, and to lesser extents CNN and ABC

Those networks don't contribute millions of dollars to the Democratic party like Fox's parent company did to the Republican party.

I didn't tell you that you were wrong because you made such a broad, generalized statement that there is no possible way of responding to what amounts to political trolling.

1. They want to make abortion illegal
2. Transvaginal ultrasounds
3. They oppose equal pay
4. Opposition to birth control being covered by insurance, yet viagra being covered by insurance is perfectly fine, despite birth control having health benefits beyond those just related to sex
5. Defunding Planned Parenthood despite the fact that abortions only make up 3% of what they do, and that all government money is kept separate from money that goes towards abortions

Your posts are incredibly vitriolic. Relax and take it down a notch.
 
You yourself admitted that the word was heavily loaded and so its use can be construed as over the line.

No, I did not. I said you could argue that it's too strong a word.

...and you had the gall to accuse me of trolling. :rolleyes:

1.. They want to make abortion illegal
2. Transvaginal ultrasounds
3. They oppose equal pay
4. Opposition to birth control being covered by insurance, yet viagra being covered by insurance is perfectly fine, despite birth control having health benefits beyond those just related to sex
5. Defunding Planned Parenthood despite the fact that abortions only make up 3% of what they do, and that all government money is kept separate from money that goes towards abortions

I'm not going to go that far off-topic. Not interested in the thread being locked.

Your posts are incredibly vitriolic. Relax and take it down a notch.

You're talking about wars on demographics and evil conspiracies twixt Fox News and the Republican Party like it's the scheme of some volcano-dwelling comic book villain...but I'm the one who needs to relax? Uhhh...kay.
 
Maybe instead of railing against google, some of you should be railing against the tax code that makes a company like google shelter their profits offshore along with other individuals and companies. The US should in and of itself be a tax haven against other countries with higher tax rates than we should be having, yet that isn't the case and we argue about why google is doing this. Or why other companies create shell companies offshore to shelter their profits from the US tax system. This country should have the lowest taxes of any country on earth and yet we don't. Government does nothing but spend, decades of indoctrination have come to fruition against people who generate wealth and jobs in the form of soaking the rich, and all I see is a system of low hanging fruit voters who are to dumb to understand a simple a revenue and profit statement and the argument is still that it's wrong for google and other companies to do this.

What do you want them to do? Just hand over the money they've generated to the government? And for what? So it can spend it for its own largess to make itself fatter still at Google's expense? It's madness.
 
Those networks don't contribute millions of dollars to the Democratic party like Fox's parent company did to the Republican party.

1. They want to make abortion illegal
2. Transvaginal ultrasounds
3. They oppose equal pay
4. Opposition to birth control being covered by insurance, yet viagra being covered by insurance is perfectly fine, despite birth control having health benefits beyond those just related to sex
5. Defunding Planned Parenthood despite the fact that abortions only make up 3% of what they do, and that all government money is kept separate from money that goes towards abortions

Your posts are incredibly vitriolic. Relax and take it down a notch.

You see. This is the kind of farcical talking point that has no basis in relevant meaningful discussion. None of these points are remotely true, but unless you happen to wander the echo chambers of thought that these ideas come from, then they are easy to make as well as say.
 
I'm starting to think you're a professional troll or something. Why are you so caught up on the word "war"? And you can't separate Romney's campaign from Fox News when they did so much of the campaigning for him. And they use the "war" terminology all the time.

And you didn't tell me why I was wrong on thinking that Republicans want to set women back 60 years. Instead you just focused on the word "war" and basically called me a fascist.

The problem is, is that you say these things and believe them. What republican as a matter of public policy wants to set women back 60 years? Abortion is the law of the land, there will be no repeal of it and none has been brought up before SCOTUS that they haven't rejected outright. State legislatures can attempt to circumvent it, but where has any women been denied an abortion? Where has any women been turned away from contraception? Who has blocked them. What law has there been in play to make sure that happens? This idea of yours that republicans want to confiscate women's lady parts, have Mitt Romney clones posted outside of every drug store, pharmacy, and planned parenthood to deny women access is mendacious nonsense. Please stop doing it.
 
The problem is, is that you say these things and believe them. What republican as a matter of public policy wants to set women back 60 years? Abortion is the law of the land, there will be no repeal of it and none has been brought up before SCOTUS that they haven't rejected outright. State legislatures can attempt to circumvent it, but where has any women been denied an abortion? Where has any women been turned away from contraception? Who has blocked them. What law has there been in play to make sure that happens? This idea of yours that republicans want to confiscate women's lady parts, have Mitt Romney clones posted outside of every drug store, pharmacy, and planned parenthood to deny women access is mendacious nonsense. Please stop doing it.

Romney said he wanted Roe v Wade overturned. If he had won the election, it would be perfectly reasonable to think that he would get to appoint a justice or two during his term(s), enough to tip the scales in his favor. It's in the Republican platform that they want abortion banned. Please don't be so obtuse.

Women WERE denied abortions 60 years ago, and some people want to go back to that model. Just because we haven't gone back to that model YET, I can't bring it up as an issue?
 
Romney said he wanted Roe v Wade overturned. If he had won the election, it would be perfectly reasonable to think that he would get to appoint a justice or two during his term(s), enough to tip the scales in his favor. It's in the Republican platform that they want abortion banned. Please don't be so obtuse.

Women WERE denied abortions 60 years ago, and some people want to go back to that model. Just because we haven't gone back to that model YET, I can't bring it up as an issue?

So how about the 50% of women who identify as pro-life, according to Gallup? Are they part of the "war on women"? If so, I think they're going to win, since they outnumber their pro-choice sisters 5 to 4.
 
Romney said he wanted Roe v Wade overturned. If he had won the election, it would be perfectly reasonable to think that he would get to appoint a justice or two during his term(s), enough to tip the scales in his favor. It's in the Republican platform that they want abortion banned. Please don't be so obtuse.

Women WERE denied abortions 60 years ago, and some people want to go back to that model. Just because we haven't gone back to that model YET, I can't bring it up as an issue?

What Romney wanted was irrelevant. Outside of Roe v. Wade being horrible law that was concoted out of whole cloth to begin with, even with a shift in SCOTUS, it most likely would not be overturned. Would there be challenges? Of course, but let's say it was, then most likely states would take up the issue. It wouldn't be federal law anymore. I wasn't being obtuse, I was simply pointing out your irrational thought process that isn't based in policy or law, but rather weak laymen's understandings of either. You can bring it up as an issue, however, it's disingenuous to do it when the reality isn't as you are painting it to be.
 
I'm starting to think you're a professional troll or something. Why are you so caught up on the word "war"?

Here's some people in Michigan who take the word "war" in "war on workers" seriously. Out in front of the Lansing statehouse, a ton of union thugs collapse and stomp a large tent with people inside it, assault people outside the tent, and threaten to kill people.

Notice the "war on workers" sign, and the union thugs shouting "they want a fucking war, they got it!" People like you WANT this kind of crap. It's the only way you can win.
 
Here's some people in Michigan who take the word "war" in "war on workers" seriously. Out in front of the Lansing statehouse, a ton of union thugs collapse and stomp a large tent with people inside it, assault people outside the tent, and threaten to kill people.

Notice the "war on workers" sign, and the union thugs shouting "they want a fucking war, they got it!" People like you WANT this kind of crap. It's the only way you can win.

Those people are from Michigan, what do you expect?
 
Those people are from Michigan, what do you expect?

I notice none of this crap happened during the protests in Madison during the union dust-up last year. Might have had something to do with the heavy media presence. Cowardly criminal filth don't like their antics caught on mainstream news.
 
The mental gymnastics you go through to come up with the conclusion that the government is greedy for asking for taxes and that corporations are not greedy for hiding their money in foreign countries to avoid taxes is really quite impressive.

The US government is not "greedy", rather it is a burdgeoning behemoth full of thousands upon thousands of people working away to some end, spending millions upon millions of dollars wastefully..........while asking for more and more revenue to continue the same practices.

If our government was correctly managed, and ran itself as any other business.....in the black, there would be no need for excessive taxes or increases in same.
Business would continue to bank in the US and pay their fair share, but this is not so now and most likely for the foreseeable future.

As our representatives continue to debate our current economic condition, every day there are more and more entitlement programs removed from debate, less talk about trimming the government expenditures, and only argument about how to squeeze every last dime out of the citizens of this country.

I hope we don't see an agreement reached, and everyone's taxes go up, so that everyone will feel this pain and wake up. The only way we can correct this problem is wit everyone in the game and everyone voting the current government away to more competant fiscal managers.

I applaud Google for their abilities to stash their hard earned cash.....I'd do the same if I was able to.:D
 
The US government is not "greedy", rather it is a burdgeoning behemoth full of thousands upon thousands of people working away to some end, spending millions upon millions of dollars wastefully..........while asking for more and more revenue to continue the same practices.

If our government was correctly managed, and ran itself as any other business.....in the black, there would be no need for excessive taxes or increases in same.
Business would continue to bank in the US and pay their fair share, but this is not so now and most likely for the foreseeable future.

As our representatives continue to debate our current economic condition, every day there are more and more entitlement programs removed from debate, less talk about trimming the government expenditures, and only argument about how to squeeze every last dime out of the citizens of this country.

I hope we don't see an agreement reached, and everyone's taxes go up, so that everyone will feel this pain and wake up. The only way we can correct this problem is wit everyone in the game and everyone voting the current government away to more competant fiscal managers.

I applaud Google for their abilities to stash their hard earned cash.....I'd do the same if I was able to.:D

amen. Couldn't agree with you more.
 
I hope we don't see an agreement reached, and everyone's taxes go up, so that everyone will feel this pain and wake up. The only way we can correct this problem is wit everyone in the game and everyone voting the current government away to more competant fiscal managers.

You are an optimistic sort. That's not a bad thing, usually.
 
The US government is not "greedy", rather it is a burdgeoning behemoth full of thousands upon thousands of people working away to some end, spending millions upon millions of dollars wastefully..........while asking for more and more revenue to continue the same practices.

If our government was correctly managed, and ran itself as any other business.....in the black, there would be no need for excessive taxes or increases in same.
Business would continue to bank in the US and pay their fair share, but this is not so now and most likely for the foreseeable future.

As our representatives continue to debate our current economic condition, every day there are more and more entitlement programs removed from debate, less talk about trimming the government expenditures, and only argument about how to squeeze every last dime out of the citizens of this country.

I hope we don't see an agreement reached, and everyone's taxes go up, so that everyone will feel this pain and wake up. The only way we can correct this problem is wit everyone in the game and everyone voting the current government away to more competant fiscal managers.

I applaud Google for their abilities to stash their hard earned cash.....I'd do the same if I was able to.:D

There's a phrase that has been, er, catching fire recently that I think you should adopt.

Let it burn.
 
Ok. I have to agree a flat tax isn't all that great of an Idea. There are a lot of worthless sponges out there, but that certainly doesn't mean everyone who barely makes enough to live is. Many have physical or mental disabilities and making them dig into their limited food budget to pay taxes feels wrong to me.

You're wrong. Flat tax doesn't necessarily mean the most poor people pay their share like everyone else. There is a bottom and there should be. I am not too sure about the sealing, though.
 
There's a phrase that has been, er, catching fire recently that I think you should adopt.

Let it burn.

I am happy with burning if everyone feels the heat.:D

Unfortunately, the Federal Government has been happily burning through my money for about 40 years now.
 
What the fuck are you talking about? I didn't make anything up.

Sheltering has nothing to do with double taxation. That's what tax treaties are for. Sheltering is for avoiding any taxation.

Yes, you damn well made shit up.
 
Back
Top