Google Sets Roadblocks To Stop Distracted Driver Legislation

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Even though Google has a ton of money to spread around, I honestly think the company might be fighting a losing battle with this one. What do you think?

Google Inc has deployed lobbyists to persuade elected officials in Illinois, Delaware and Missouri that it is not necessary to restrict use of Google Glass behind the wheel, according to state lobbying disclosure records and interviews conducted by Reuters.
 
I can't help but think that measures like this will be used as precedent to accelerate the integration of fully autonomous vehicles on the road in the future...
 
The problem is they "ARE" a distraction and shouldn't be allowed. While I generally don't like regulation on things like this, the reality is most people are stupid and selfish. If it only endangered them, then I say let them kill themselves, unfortunately these selfish idiots also endanger my family and I.
 
Lots of people shouldn't even be allowed to talk on a hands free head set while driving. Seriously the things people are willing to do in cars are ridiculous, what would you accomplish with google glass while driving?
 
Lots of people shouldn't even be allowed to talk on a hands free head set while driving. Seriously the things people are willing to do in cars are ridiculous, what would you accomplish with google glass while driving?

GPS HUD... Future tech... So BMW can do it but not Google? Such hypocrisy in the tech world.
 
Google has a lip lock on Barry's butt, or other parts. I refuse to use Google for anything, direct pipeline to the FEDs. "Barry and Google" I am invincible, I can do anything I want. I have a pen and all the money.
 
GPS HUD... Future tech... So BMW can do it but not Google? Such hypocrisy in the tech world.

BMW hud can't be used to post tweets, read facebook, watch videos and other stupid shit that you damn well know will be done. Oh sure it sounds all find saying "But I want to use it as a GPS", but you know as well as anyone else that isn't what the overwhelming majority will do with it.
 
I'd think the idea of a little HUD GPS via Google Glass would be awesome and actually be more safe than people taking their eyes off the road constantly to look at their dash GPS (which is legal) or god forbid their cell phone laying in the seat next to them or sitting in the cup holder. (also legal)

You can't legislate people into paying attention while driving. Shit, even if someone is eyes forward on the road, it doesn't mean they are paying attention. I space out and daydream all the time while driving, especially on long drives.

Distracted driving legislation has thus far proven ineffective at reducing the rate at which people use their cell phones in cars, let alone meaningfully reducing traffic accidents. People simply see the risk of a ticket as the cost of doing business and in turn it becomes little more than a stupidity tax on something people will continue to do anyway.

Adding more legislation won't do shit, and SHOULD be fought.
 
BMW hud can't be used to post tweets, read facebook, watch videos and other stupid shit that you damn well know will be done. Oh sure it sounds all find saying "But I want to use it as a GPS", but you know as well as anyone else that isn't what the overwhelming majority will do with it.

I present to you Ford, that allows this and no one bitches... More legislation for the lemmings only hurts the educated.
 
The problem is they "ARE" a distraction and shouldn't be allowed. While I generally don't like regulation on things like this, the reality is most people are stupid and selfish. If it only endangered them, then I say let them kill themselves, unfortunately these selfish idiots also endanger my family and I.

Yeah, pretty much this stuff. I don't want me or my cat to get hurt while I'm on the way to the vet because the horrible awful person who bought Glass is using it while they're driving. It's not fair that innocent people that are being responsible by not owning Glass should get put in danger because someone is addicted to being an eyeball into the world for Google. They should be totally illegal and Google shouldn't be allowed to sell them in the US.
 
Google spends more on lobbying these days than even large defense contractors.
They buy the laws they want.
 
Distracted driving legislation has thus far proven ineffective at reducing the rate at which people use their cell phones in cars, let alone meaningfully reducing traffic accidents. People simply see the risk of a ticket as the cost of doing business and in turn it becomes little more than a stupidity tax on something people will continue to do anyway.

Adding more legislation won't do shit, and SHOULD be fought.
I'd like to see where you're getting this from
 
I'd like to see where you're getting this from

The same place anyone gets any information, the Internet. A search for "distracted driving laws ineffective" or "distracted driving laws hard to enforce" ought to help you out.

If you seriously think nanny legislation is effective at anything other than generating revenue via fines and votes via 'think of the children' pleas, I've got a bridge to sell you.

The penalties for drunk driving are huge, it can even be a felony, and people still do it in staggering numbers. Distracted driving is just as dangerous, perhaps more so because at least drunk driving someone is TRYING to pay attention. But the penalty is a ticket. Why? Because it's difficult to prove. The tickets can be contested very easily, and don't get handed out all that often to begin with. Making it a criminal matter would never fly because no prosecutor could make a case stick except in very rare cases. There's no breathalyzer for stupid.

Adding items to the list of things you can't use while in a car is pointless, because those same people ignoring the laws regarding cell phones are going to ignore the laws regarding Google Glass.
 
I can't wait till I get my hands on Google Glass so I can watch tranny porn at 100 mph and choking myself with the seatbelt at the same time.

What a rush!
 
Took a course under this professor, and a take away was (not a direct quote) 'driving under normal conditions while speaking on a phone, even hands-free, results in ~20x increase to the likelihood of an accident.' Below is the professor and a list of his published work.

http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Matthew_Romoser/publications/

This guy studies specifically (all regarding driving) effects of distraction, differences in age and training viability regarding driving. Also on methods of improving the tools available to collect data related to drivers' attention overall.
 
I can't wait till I get my hands on Google Glass so I can watch tranny porn at 100 mph and choking myself with the seatbelt at the same time.

What a rush!

At least you're wearing your seatbelt.
 
I'm consistently amazed at how many people I see texting while driving. I'm usually on my motorcycle, so I've always got my head on a swivel and see what people are doing. Fully 60% of people I see at lights and 15% of people I see while moving at speed are texting or looking at their phones. Not just talking on their phones - but looking at it. It's absolutely disgusting. Granted those numbers are highly subjective and Los Angeles may be different from other areas, but it's really, really bad here.

The penalties need to be stronger, but really - people just need to be made aware of | witness the physics of a 45 mph (let alone 80 mph) accident. 3,000 lbs of steel at speed is a dangerous thing that we take way too lightly.
 
So Google has at least accepted that their "Don't be Evil" slogan has been completely abandoned.

Nice.
 
The same place anyone gets any information, the Internet. A search for "distracted driving laws ineffective" or "distracted driving laws hard to enforce" ought to help you out.

If you seriously think nanny legislation is effective at anything other than generating revenue via fines and votes via 'think of the children' pleas, I've got a bridge to sell you.

The penalties for drunk driving are huge, it can even be a felony, and people still do it in staggering numbers. Distracted driving is just as dangerous, perhaps more so because at least drunk driving someone is TRYING to pay attention. But the penalty is a ticket. Why? Because it's difficult to prove. The tickets can be contested very easily, and don't get handed out all that often to begin with. Making it a criminal matter would never fly because no prosecutor could make a case stick except in very rare cases. There's no breathalyzer for stupid.

Adding items to the list of things you can't use while in a car is pointless, because those same people ignoring the laws regarding cell phones are going to ignore the laws regarding Google Glass.
Using the logic you've outlined here you would conclude that we should not have laws against driving under the influence and more people do it than don't. Bots conclusions are incorrect. I wrote I'd like to see where you're getting your data from so I can evaluate it. If you're simply making it up I'll consider it with the same weight as the rest of the anecdotal evidence that May or may not be accurate.
 
Took a course under this professor, and a take away was (not a direct quote) 'driving under normal conditions while speaking on a phone, even hands-free, results in ~20x increase to the likelihood of an accident.' Below is the professor and a list of his published work.

http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Matthew_Romoser/publications/

This guy studies specifically (all regarding driving) effects of distraction, differences in age and training viability regarding driving. Also on methods of improving the tools available to collect data related to drivers' attention overall.
Mythbusters did a segment on this topic too but I don't have a link for you.
 
I can't wait till I get my hands on Google Glass so I can watch tranny porn at 100 mph and choking myself with the seatbelt at the same time.

What a rush!


I would totally hold the wheel for you.
 
Using the logic you've outlined here you would conclude that we should not have laws against driving under the influence and more people do it than don't. Bots conclusions are incorrect. I wrote I'd like to see where you're getting your data from so I can evaluate it. If you're simply making it up I'll consider it with the same weight as the rest of the anecdotal evidence that May or may not be accurate.

On the contrary, if you'll read more carefully, you'll see the contrast I made between drunk driving laws and distracted driving laws. Drunk driving laws are more effective: They are enforceable because the activity is more easily proven. The legislation in that case isn't a waste of time, despite the fact that people ignore the law. (People ignore every law.)

Distracted driving is equally dangerous but the practicality behind enforcing such laws is minimal, so further unenforceable legislation is a waste of time.

Further, one could argue it's actually more dangerous to have this legislation because it gives the illusion that the problem is solved or that progress is being made, when it isn't. So people become complacent and blind to other possible solutions.
 
I see people do a lot of stupid shit on the road, but the only common denominator I see is that the majority of them are NOT using mobile devices at the time.

Personally I think the whole distracted driving hubbub is just trying to solve a problem that we don't actually have. Poor driving skill is a far greater danger, but nobody seems concerned with stopping that.
 
I see people do a lot of stupid shit on the road, but the only common denominator I see is that the majority of them are NOT using mobile devices at the time.

Personally I think the whole distracted driving hubbub is just trying to solve a problem that we don't actually have. Poor driving skill is a far greater danger, but nobody seems concerned with stopping that.

You hit the nail on the head. The problem is that fixing poor driver skill by creating rigorous mandatory driving education and frequent re-testing is expensive and unpopular with the public. But some ineffective ban on electronic devices makes Neo-Luddites feel good and actually MAKES the state money via fines. A win-win!
 
You hit the nail on the head. The problem is that fixing poor driver skill by creating rigorous mandatory driving education and frequent re-testing is expensive and unpopular with the public. But some ineffective ban on electronic devices makes Neo-Luddites feel good and actually MAKES the state money via fines. A win-win!

HERE HERE!

Totally agree, there some really dumb drivers on the road. I think the big problem with this is that everyone thinks the road is only for them and fuck everyone else. This kind of attitude is what causes alot of traffic problems and accidents.
 
You hit the nail on the head. The problem is that fixing poor driver skill by creating rigorous mandatory driving education and frequent re-testing is expensive and unpopular with the public. But some ineffective ban on electronic devices makes Neo-Luddites feel good and actually MAKES the state money via fines. A win-win!
wait...which is it? these laws are either unenforceable because it's difficult to ascertain someone is using devices in their vehicles *or* they are making the state lots of money via fines

you're undercutting your own argument
 
wait...which is it? these laws are either unenforceable because it's difficult to ascertain someone is using devices in their vehicles *or* they are making the state lots of money via fines

you're undercutting your own argument

I never said "lots of money." But they make money off fines nonetheless. It costs them virtually nothing to actually sell the public on the law and get it into the books.

That's basically the hallmark of any bad legislation. If it's making the state money, it's probably not very effective legislation. Fixing problems costs money. If your supposed solution doesn't cost the taxpayers anything, then it's just feel-good legislation rather than a real fix.

Also you've made no points, assertions, or arguments of any kind. You're just being intentionally pedantic and contributing nothing.
 
I'm just pointing out that you're wrong. I asked where you obtained your data and you said, "the internet."

Then you argue that tickets don't get written very often because the behavior is difficult to prove (both assertions are factually incorrect) and concluded from that people must ignore the law frequently without consequence (both claims again factually incorrect).

You simultaneously argue that ticket writing is making the state lots of money, which is a direct contradiction that tickets aren't written often and that they don't hold up in court.

Tickets *do* get written often (at least as often as officers observe the behavior and we can't really ask for anything more than that) and they *do* stick in court. They also *do* prevent those drivers from doing that behavior again because, not only are they expensive, they add points to one's driving record and repeat offenses aren't resolvable via traffic court. Insurance rates go up...and in fact that's one of the sources you could (and should) be using instead of "the internet" for the basis of data on whether drivers are being cited for this behavior and how it impacts their future behavior while driving.

I'm pointing out the incoherencies in your own examples so when you think through them you'll reconsider the incorrect positions you are simultaneously holding. That's neither pedantic nor is it contributing nothing. Pedantic would be if I was sitting here arguing semantics with you or flaunting my knowledge of the things purely for the reason of being superior. You present an unfounded *opinion* and I'm refuting it. That's the nature of a discussion board.
 
You present an unfounded *opinion* and I'm refuting it. That's the nature of a discussion board.

You haven't refuted anything. Saying "You're wrong." with no supporting data isn't a refutation, it's a disagreement. And for someone who apparently wants everyone to include a reference page with their posts, you haven't provided any of your own. According to the US governments own website on distracted driving, usage of electronic devices has held steady since 2010.
 
I see people do a lot of stupid shit on the road, but the only common denominator I see is that the majority of them are NOT using mobile devices at the time.
Could be because a majority of drivers are smart enough not to use mobile devices. No one is saying using devices like this is the only thing that leads to shitty driving, however it absolutely will lead to shitty driving. To anyone saying "well I can drive and text just fine" fuck you, no you can't you're an idiot who's just biding time until you kill someone (hopefully yourself first).
 
Here's another page from an insurance industry safety organization.

Despite any effects on phone use and texting, there is little evidence so far that banning hand-held phone use or texting reduces crashes. A 2009 analysis found that hand-held bans had no effect on insurance collision claim rates. 35 Researchers compared rates of claims for crash damage in three states and the District of Columbia before and after hand-held phone use bans went into effect and found no significant change in claim rates for two jurisdictions relative to comparison states and small, but significant, increases in claim rates in the other two.

A 2010 study examined rates of insurance claims filed for damage to vehicles before and after driver texting bans were enacted in four states. 36 There was no significant change in one state relative to comparison states and significant increases of 7-9 percent in three states. Increases in claim rates also were found for drivers 25 and younger in these three states.
 
You haven't refuted anything. Saying "You're wrong." with no supporting data isn't a refutation, it's a disagreement. And for someone who apparently wants everyone to include a reference page with their posts, you haven't provided any of your own. According to the US governments own website on distracted driving, usage of electronic devices has held steady since 2010.
It "held steady" from 2010-2011 according to that cite.

The study you referenced actually points out that both answering and making calls (slightly) *dropped* from 2010-2011.

It's also important to note that those are national averages counting both states with and without laws prohibiting the behavior.

Lastly, neither of those references state that the laws do nothing (which is the claim I asked you to support) and neither argue that we should simply abolish them.
 
Could be because a majority of drivers are smart enough not to use mobile devices. No one is saying using devices like this is the only thing that leads to shitty driving, however it absolutely will lead to shitty driving. To anyone saying "well I can drive and text just fine" fuck you, no you can't you're an idiot who's just biding time until you kill someone (hopefully yourself first).
And enforcing it is simply too difficult to make much of a dent in the behavior.

So the obvious solution IMO is to create legistlation that requires the manufacturers to simply disable hands-on functionality while the device is in rapid motion. Yes, it will mean passengers in a car or guys riding a train will have limited functionality while in rapid motion, but somehow society survived before smartphones, so they too can find a way to survive.

EVERY SINGLE TIME I am run off the road on my motorcycle (I commute to work in Houston from the burbs to downtown), its always an a-hole on their cellphone, I haven't found an exception yet.

And I have no problem with hands-free, but looking down to dial a number or thumb through contacts or program in an address for google maps while driving at 70mph is batshit stupid.
 
And I have no problem with hands-free, but looking down to dial a number or thumb through contacts or program in an address for google maps while driving at 70mph is batshit stupid.

About as stupid as riding a motorcycle.

HEYOOOOOO!!!!

Sorry, had to. :p
 
I can't help but think that measures like this will be used as precedent to accelerate the integration of fully autonomous vehicles on the road in the future...

That was a good SciFi novel!...if only I could remember *which* SciFi novel it was out of the 10,000 SciFi novels I've read that included "autonomous vehicles" somewhere in their stories...:D

(***Pardons for the length here! But you opened up a *fun* subject, and so I didn't stint in commenting, evidently!)...

In all the most interesting stories, "autonomous vehicles" are captained by a sentient AI of some kind--and never merely by a garbage-in, garbage-out computer (which is the only kind we know how to presently build.) An automated vehicle that we *could* build today is not actually "autonomous" at all as it has at least one human driver controlling the vehicle at all times...the human programmer(s) who wrote the code that through the on-board computer is driving the car in real time. No "sentient, aware AI" is driving the "autonomous vehicle" (because such a thing is impossible for us at the moment)--just a computer program running in the on-board systems, much like the Infotainment DVD system in the car, etc. IMO, if you trust your life, the lives of your family, and the lives of the people in the other "autonomous vehicles" running down the freeway @ 80 mph to this brand of "autonomy"--I'd say it's fairly obvious that you've got a strong death wish...;) I *might* trust the efficacy of such a program to play a game of chess, maybe, but that's as far as it goes. The only sentient intelligence in an autonomous vehicle is the living human being riding in it, and, hopefully, driving it! I thought everyone knew that. Non-sentience has no place in driving a car on a crowded freeway. We, as actual, living, sentient intelligences, learned how to drive a car via various means--practice, information, etc.

A present-technology computer cannot do that--it is impossible, it cannot ever *learn* as you and I may learn how to do something. At best, because it is not alive and/or sentient, a computer must be *programmed* to drive a car, programmed by a human being(s) who both knows how to drive and how to program a particular machine to drive. Thus the automated car can only act as its program tells it to act. Whereas a human intelligence can adjust for error or changed circumstances in milliseconds, and *correct for/react to* it in milliseconds, a garbage-in/out computer can only *ever* act as it is programmed.

For instance, if a human is driving the car and a large tree falls into the road directly ahead then the human will reflexively stand on the brakes, swerve, do whatever is needed--because those particular reflexive responses have been *learned* and some are even instinctive. Computers are essentially blind, deaf, and dumb, cannot learn anything because they lack life and sentience, and will only do what they have been programmed to do--without reflex, without instinct, etc. If the tree falls in front of the "autonomous vehicle" cruising the freeway, the computer will drive the car straight into the tree @ 80 mph, guaranteed, *unless* the computer has been programmed to do something else, instead.

So suppose the computer has been programmed to rely on a forward-facing visual-spectrum sensor, or radar, or both, and then has been programmed to do a series of things should those sensors suddenly detect a large object in the road which is blocking the vehicle's forward progress. Here are some possibilities of what might happen to the autonomous vehicle under computer control that most likely would never happen with a healthy, alert human driver behind the wheel:

1) At the very moment the tree falls across the road ahead, lightning crackles and flashes and the freakish electronic interference it creates causes the forward sensors to glitch at the worst possible time, for under a second, and during the nanoseconds the on-board computer is taking to rifle through its programmed options in just such a scenario, it runs smack into the tree @ 80 mph destroying both car and passenger.

2) The sensors spot the tree, and per programmed instructions, the brakes are applied in a manner designed to minimize skidding, and yet the car sill is unable to stop before hitting the tree so, according to programming, the automobile swerves to the right seeking a shoulder in order to avoid the tree as it continues to slow to a stop, and in the process simply runs clean off of the shoulder which without warning has run out and opened into an 80-foot-deep canyon drop. On the way down, although the programming valiantly spins the rear wheels backwards in an effort to reverse direction, the autonomous car falls straight down anyway and the impact instantly kills the driver and destroys the car, yet again.

We could do this all day long, but the point that needs to be emphasized is that even though sentient human drivers can be very poor drivers, themselves, even the worst ones are far better at handling split-second decisions than any computer we manufacture at the present time that would be inexpensive enough, tough enough, and powerful enough to put into a so-called "autonomous car." I doubt very much you will see an "autonomous" highway full of computer-driven automobiles with completely uninvolved human passengers in your lifetime, if ever. At least until the "sentient AI" moves from pure fantasy fiction into reality, if that actually ever happens.

OK, yes...I'm well aware that computerized rockets take men to the moon and back, but there are some major differences between a rocket and an autonomous car....;) A couple:

1) An autonomous car doesn't cost $10B and have a dedicated facility in Houston, Texas, perpetually on the wireless horn and staffed with hundreds of engineers being paid to help the sentient beings in the rocket out of all the jams that inevitably develop that the on-board computers cannot handle themselves. And, unlike the autonomous car, the rocket is nowhere near autonomous and was not designed to run and steer itself without *any* human participation while the on-board sentients do nothing at all, except maybe play cards, etc.

2) Rocket-travel lanes in space are far wider and much less congested than earthbound freeways for automobiles--which means the on-board ship computers and the astronauts and the Houston engineers sometimes have minutes, hours, days, or even weeks to solve approaching problems. In the autonomous car on the freeway, a split second's wrong decision can destroy the car and every sentient human in it. No time to buzz Houston or the engineers, if they were available for consultation, which they are *not*, of course, in the case of the "autonomous car."

3) In all of the SciFi stories I've read about "autonomous vehicle travel," in every case a *sentient intelligence* of some kind, other than human, is involved. Reality: no one on earth has the remotest idea how to build a sentient AI. Eg, Google glasses have nothing at all to do with sentient AI's....;) It would be interesting to see how you formulated such a connection with "autonomous cars," if you'd care to elaborate...;)
 
Back
Top