Google Paying Professors for Academic Influence?

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
The origins of this article are posted at the Wall Street Journal, but is behind a paywall. This summation at NY Mag hits the high points however, and this article at Fox Business has a bit more of a deep dive. The gist of research shows that Google has paid professors in academia, from Harvard to Berkeley, in order to harvest favorable information that props up its lobbying desires, and that relationship is not often exposed when the information is presented.

Google has paid professors whose papers, for instance, declared that the collection of consumer data was a fair exchange for its free services; that the company didn't use its market dominance to improperly steer users to Google's commercial sites or its advertisers; and that it hasn't unfairly quashed competitors. Several papers argued that Google's search engine should be allowed to link to books and other intellectual property that authors and publishers say should be paid for -- a group that includes News Corp, which owns the Journal. News Corp formally complained to European regulators about Google's handling of news articles in search results.

Google has funded roughly 100 academic papers on public-policy matters since 2009, according to a Journal analysis of data compiled by the Campaign for Accountability, an advocacy group that has campaigned against Google and receives funds from Google's rivals, including Oracle Corp. Most mentioned Google's funding.
 
As I've mentioned in previous posts, the pharmaceutical industry pays professors for favorable papers. The energy industry pays professors for favorable papers. The insurance industry pays professors for favorable papers. The dairy industry pays professors for favorable papers. And so on.

If you are an academic and you accept money from a company to conduct research, that's perfectly acceptable as long as you disclose you received funding for the research and are transparent about your potential conflict of interest. Taking money from a company to do research is not necessarily unethical.
 
As I've mentioned in previous posts, the pharmaceutical industry pays professors for favorable papers. The energy industry pays professors for favorable papers. The insurance industry pays professors for favorable papers. The dairy industry pays professors for favorable papers. And so on.

If you are an academic and you accept money from a company to conduct research, that's perfectly acceptable as long as you disclose you received funding for the research and are transparent about your potential conflict of interest. Taking money from a company to do research is not necessarily unethical.
Agreed, this is how a lot of researchers get started.....private funds get used to start a research project often times before government grants are issued. I'm not surprised.....nor am i surprised a rival paid to research these practices about Google.....just another facet of competition?
 
Agreed, this is how a lot of researchers get started.....private funds get used to start a research project often times before government grants are issued. I'm not surprised.....nor am i surprised a rival paid to research these practices about Google.....just another facet of competition?

Yep. In my own field of anatomy, right now there is controversy over whether what's called the "gender-specific knee" prosthetic is better for women than the traditional knee implant. Succinctly, women's knees and men's knees are not the same anatomically, but the traditional knee implant for women is just a scaled-down (i.e., smaller) men's knee. None of that is controversial - those are all facts. What's controversial is whether the gender-specific knee implant is better than the traditional knee implant. In other words, are the anatomical differences between men's and women's knees (besides size) really relevant in a clinical context?

If I told you a lot of research supporting the gender-specific knee is funded by the company that holds the gender-specific knee patent, and a lot of research not supporting the gender-specific knee is funded by companies that do not hold the gender-specific knee patient, then would you be surprised?

If you want to learn more about conflicts of interest, ghostwriting, non-publication of negative results, etc. in scientific research, then http://www.badscience.net/about-dr-ben-goldacre/ is a great place to start - Goldacre is the go-to authority on the topic.
 
Agreed, this is how a lot of researchers get started.....private funds get used to start a research project often times before government grants are issued. I'm not surprised.....nor am i surprised a rival paid to research these practices about Google.....just another facet of competition?

nor am i surprised a rival paid to research these practices about Google.....just another facet of competition? Nailed it!
 
Yep. In my own field of anatomy, right now there is controversy over whether what's called the "gender-specific knee" prosthetic is better for women than the traditional knee implant. Succinctly, women's knees and men's knees are not the same anatomically, but the traditional knee implant for women is just a scaled-down (i.e., smaller) men's knee. None of that is controversial - those are all facts. What's controversial is whether the gender-specific knee implant is better than the traditional knee implant. In other words, are the anatomical differences between men's and women's knees (besides size) really relevant in a clinical context?

If I told you a lot of research supporting the gender-specific knee is funded by the company that holds the gender-specific knee patent, and a lot of research not supporting the gender-specific knee is funded by companies that do not hold the gender-specific knee patient, then would you be surprised?

If you want to learn more about conflicts of interest, ghostwriting, non-publication of negative results, etc. in scientific research, then http://www.badscience.net/about-dr-ben-goldacre/ is a great place to start - Goldacre is the go-to authority on the topic.

Things always get screwy when money gets too involved.

When accurate data gets suppressed, it hurts everyone. It's counter to research and a detrimental to our understanding of how the world actually works.

It's sad how much of our world doesn't work in reality but the perception of reality.
 
Is Jeff Jarvis one of these paid shills? I'm no Google hater in the least, but man I can't even understand that guy with Google's dick constantly in his mouth.
 
This is not shocking at all really, and it isn't new at all either.

Just take something like climate change, now without pointing to one side or another you have to admit there are plenty of actual scientific papers on both sides of the argument (and a metric shit ton of internet armchair scientists who think because they can use google that they're just as knowledgeable... but that's another discussion). Then it comes to an argument of logic, who has more money to influence their side? Solar panel using hippies with an agenda? Or energy companies?

This is why I roll my eyes whenever a study comes out that says XXXX is good for you, where XXXX is wine, or dark chocolate.... sure they all point at antioxidants but instead of telling you to just eat fruit that is super high in it they want you to know booze and candy can help too!!!
 
Back
Top