Google, Microsoft, Apple Sued over Preview Icons

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Networking company Cygnus Systems filed a patent infringement lawsuit against Google, Microsoft, and Apple over the use of document-preview icons in operating systems. No word on how the giants plan on fighting back.

Cygnus describes the technology covered by the patent as "methods and systems for accessing one or more computer files via a graphical icon, wherein the graphical icon includes an image of a selected portion or portions of one or more computer files."
 
This patent system is absolutely ridiculous. Everyone's trying to make a buck it seems, through easy lawsuits.

Cygnus was granted the patent in March 2008, according to the lawsuit, although it first applied for it back in 2001 as a continuation to a 1998 application
Pretty sure we had this prior to that. In which case, The Big 3 can simply point that fact out, and if they wanted to, even claim Cygnus is infringing on them ;)
 
No word on how the giants plan on fighting back.

I bet anything, they will hire this group to fight back for them.
ateam.jpg

I pity the attorney who thinks he can get away with this Jibber Jabber Foo Nonsense for a lawsuit
 
That's BS. Cygnus is a horrible company and is only getting negative press over this. Cygnus, stop being so stupid at once.
 
I could see someone trying to patent something this for document previews, but the truth is that this wouldn't hold up in court because thumbnail previews have been around for a long time for images. One could argue that these icons are thumbnails, and that images, documents, and folders are simply forms of data.
 
LOL. Someone has to have big balls to even consider trying to sue Microsoft, Apple, and Google at the same time. Pretty humurous :p
 
Is cyngus a publicly traded company? I'd love to see MS, A, and G declare a temporary cease fire to conduct a joint hostile takeover....
 
Wow, really?

Patent system needs some reform, imo. It's getting pretty stupid these days. I mean, really? Patenting the idea of having window previews before you switch?

Reminds me of when people were trying to... I can't remember if it was patent, or trademark, or what. But they were trying to claim ownership of varying DNA sequences and parts of the chain.
 
Patent 2.0: It's not about making anything, it's about making sure that if anyone actually makes something remotely similar to some random idea you had on the crapper, then theys gots ta pay!
 
LOL. Someone has to have big balls to even consider trying to sue Microsoft, Apple, and Google at the same time. Pretty humurous :p

Yeah, kinda like Germany attacking east and west at the same time in the 1940s, it's a suicide mission. (L2 pull & crowd control, noobs)
 
Thank you United States, I knew I couldn't get through just one single day without hearing about some individual or company trying to get rich quick.

Hey Cyngus Systems, about 1 day before your company name got set, I had a company with the initials CS, of which your mom and sister were members. I want to sue you too! Sorry, just annoyed this crap even gets to us, another problem in this country; the media system.
 
Previewing a document, wow how original. Every program uses this for images and pdf's for ages, lawsuit is dumb, I hope they get countersued.
 
That's BS. Cygnus is a horrible company and is only getting negative press over this. Cygnus, stop being so stupid at once.

Sarcasm?

Anybody that sues Microsoft is awesome, Microsoft never paid the piper for all the unethical business practices they've done throughout the years.
 
Sarcasm?

Anybody that sues Microsoft is awesome, Microsoft never paid the piper for all the unethical business practices they've done throughout the years.
While this may be true. At least let the lawsuits be for legitimate reasons not BS.
 
Patent 2.0: It's not about making anything, it's about making sure that if anyone actually makes something remotely similar to some random idea you had on the crapper, then theys gots ta pay!

Kind of like the original tech-bubble where people had built huge, enormous companies around ideas that were never tangible and where 20 somethings skateboarded around, had party breaks, played frisbee and just thought about doing stuff with all of that venture capital money just to watch it burst in 2000. Yeah, I can see the parallels.
 
Sarcasm?

Anybody that sues Microsoft is awesome, Microsoft never paid the piper for all the unethical business practices they've done throughout the years.

Come on man, you really expect people to fall for this little bit of dangling bait? Too easy.
 
Once again... "Obvious under the art" ... and the broken PTO just approves it and lets the courts settle it.

Actually INDUSTRY should be seriously pissed about this whole Reagan/Republican PTO pay as you go, pay to play, budget from maintainence fee's bullshit.

It costs Industry hundreds of millions in legal costs per year, where simply paying taxes to run a quality PTO without the incentive-to-grant program, would cost a tiny fraction of this abortion.

Just another in the long, infinitely long, list of unfunded mandates and fucked up good intensions government "tweaks". 212 years of it works fine, so we have to "improve it" "optimize it" "free market it", etc, etc. And now like most of the rest of government.... it don't work.

It also floods the civil court system with mountains of frivolous bullshit patent suits, wasting time and money of all parties and interfering with other legit court cases.

Go back to the original system THAT WORKED, quality people, well paid experts in the fields, who make the call of BULLSHIT before any patent is ever granted.

Obvios under the art, derivitive, etc, etc... DENIED.

90% of all "soft" ware patents are utter bullshit, obvious to anyone, patented just because it was worked on/used in a project.... something ANYONE doing the same type of project would have coded because it is OBVIOUS UNDER THE ART.
 
This is like jumping in a cage of 3 800lb gorillas wanting to fight.
 
I read this and just had this vision of three balrogs sitting around a table playing poker when this hobbit walks in and demands a fee for using a deck of cards that might resemble one he may have had a hand in designing at one point in the past.
 
Ah the Reagan years just keep on giving!

Shocking I know, but there are in fact things the free market can't do.
 
Patent 2.0: It's not about making anything, it's about making sure that if anyone actually makes something remotely similar to some random idea you had on the crapper, then theys gots ta pay!

I think you have your stereotypes mixed up. Its fat fats in business suits doing this, not Uncle Leroy. You do realize that the first step into placing blame is to recognize who is to blame right?
 
I read this and just had this vision of three balrogs sitting around a table playing poker when this hobbit walks in and demands a fee for using a deck of cards that might resemble one he may have had a hand in designing at one point in the past.

Wow you are a dork. LOL
 
Back
Top