Google Is Abusing Its Play Power

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Google is once again using its power to <insert alleged abuses here> to maintain its stranglehold over <insert market Google competes in>.

"The European Commission has been very active in detecting situations of abuse of a dominant position," Aptoide co-founder and CEO Paulo Trezentos told CNET. "We believe that our case is strong and that can help the EC to work with Google to correct these practices."
 
And Apple's app store isn't worse than the Play Store?
Those assholes in the EU are just looking for any excuse to fine American companies.
Sheesh!
 
So, I can't watch/view my movie, book, and music purchases from iTunes on a device of my choosing ... but a store that sells android apps for android devices is an evil monopoly.

Whatever.

I want to watch my iTunes movies on my PS3/XBox360/Android device. FFS, its 2014 ... how hard is it to make an app that checks with iTunes that you actually own the content you are attempting to access.
 
And Apple's app store isn't worse than the Play Store?
Those assholes in the EU are just looking for any excuse to fine American companies.
Sheesh!

Well if they fined Apple, they would be fining an American company too... (not sure if serious...)
 
I will use the same argument that I have defended MS with in the Past.

Why should they be forced to promote a "Competitors" product in their own product?

1) Internet Explorer - Inside Windows a MS product. I feel it is completely unreasonable to force MS to promote other browsers inside Their Product. I say that as someone who abhors IE.

2) Safari/Apple App Store Inside iOS - See above, why should apple be forced to promote competitors products?

3) Google play - Android..noticing a pattern here?

Their Operating System..While I would say they should be forced not to outright "Block" or disable a competitors service. The idea of forcing them to actively Advertise is outright stupid. All this goes back to the shit Opera stirred up with suing to get MS to advertise their browser when they couldn't compete legitimately.
 
And Apple's app store isn't worse than the Play Store?
Those assholes in the EU are just looking for any excuse to fine American companies.
Sheesh!

I guess you missed the bit where they didnt say anything about fines because instead they said they want to "work with Google to correct these practices".
Sort of the opposite :p
 
I'm almost sure their way to correct it is to get Google out of the market, so they can dominate more.

Quick skim through, looks like it is another bundle coplaint, like Microsofts.
 
I loved this quote...

The Aptoide CEO also wants major alternative app stores to be classified as 'trusted sources' in the Android OS.

What? Really? I am willing to bet they also don't want to pay google anything either to be "trusted". Would they be willing to take financial responsibility and risk for every app on their store? Even if they do, Google is still on the hook in the public eye anyways and they STILL allow alt stores to install.

The way I see it, google allows the installation, with a simple settings change. That is more than other companies allow. What more can be asked, of course they don't say exactly why the current side loading process is problematic other than it just is.

I guess I don't really understand why alt stores are really used, I get Amazon's they are building their own platform and monetizing it. Yet I haven't heard too many stories of Google being restrictive or cost preventative in their policies. I just looked it up it cost literally $25 up front to upload and use the store and 30% of all transaction.

OK 30% seems a bit steep but they are providing a large platform and infrastructure of distribution. I have no clue what cut Steam etc get but I did see the 30% number thrown about so maybe that is sort of standard?
 
This is utter bullshit. Not only does stock Android allow the installation of any app (from Brand X Sudoku to any full third-party app store) with a single setting change, it will walk the user through doing it when a non-Play install is attempted (IOW, the user doesn't have to hunt down instructions).

As for putting other app stores in their own store, that's just dumb. Should Best Buy have to include advertisements for Wal-Mart in their stores? I can see the dialog box now: "Are you sure you want to download Brand X Sudoku from Google Play when you could get it for less from Amazon?"

If this boner wants to get more users, he can always do what Amazon has done: Roll his own Android. This isn't closed-source Windows after all, nor, as pointed out, is it Apple's iron grip on IOS. If the EU punishes Google in any way based on this crap, it'll be insane.
 
Translation of the EU position: We're looking for some more money from Google because we need to prop up the PIIGS.
 
I'm almost sure their way to correct it is to get Google out of the market, so they can dominate more.

Quick skim through, looks like it is another bundle coplaint, like Microsofts.
More like they are jacking with the 'open source' side of android. Android's adoption outside the US was heavily reliant on alternate app stores in other parts of the world being able to serve localized language needs and a place for regional developers to serve regional needs. Now that its entrenched, Google is turning its back on that and the alleged 'open source' nature of AOSP. A bait and switch weaselly thing to do, but not sure it was illegal.
 
Aren't Android and Google free? If this wasn't about money, I'd incorporate Google in the Maldives and tell everyone they can use it if they want, or GTFO.
 
With Android you...
1. Go to Settings
2. Click security
3. Check allow unknown sources
4. Download and run market apk
Done!
Google isn't locking out shit or making anything difficult for anybody. Anyone that claims otherwise is fishing for an antitrust lawsuit plain and simple. If you want your app store default on Android that damn bad, make your own tablet and ship it with your store on it! How many companies already do that? I don't hear Amazon crying.
How much easier does it have to be? Its not like you have to jailbreak the damn thing and install Cydia before you can do anything BUT use the default store.
 
Translation - I want to piggyback on the work of another company with the least amount of work and risk possible ... Good thing the EU is fostering such a culture of high achievement ... It is no wonder that so many great innovations come out of their market instead of the USA ... Oh wait, they don't :p
 
Translation - I want to piggyback on the work of another company with the least amount of work and risk possible ... Good thing the EU is fostering such a culture of high achievement ... It is no wonder that so many great innovations come out of their market instead of the USA ... Oh wait, they don't :p

No kbrickley! Just no! You're downplaying the importance of tea time, Big Ben, scones, bland food, and those adorable English accents! Plus, there's the BBC and they make some awesome drama. I <3 Jane Eyre remakes!
 
I guess you missed the bit where they didnt say anything about fines because instead they said they want to "work with Google to correct these practices".
Sort of the opposite :p

I guess you missed where it is the EU and their end game is always a lawsuit.
 
I guess you missed where it is the EU and their end game is always a lawsuit.

I agree that they do a lot of fucktard things, but keep the complaint relevant otherwise the message gets lost in a sea of trolling.
 
I will use the same argument that I have defended MS with in the Past.

Why should they be forced to promote a "Competitors" product in their own product?

1) Internet Explorer - Inside Windows a MS product. I feel it is completely unreasonable to force MS to promote other browsers inside Their Product. I say that as someone who abhors IE.

2) Safari/Apple App Store Inside iOS - See above, why should apple be forced to promote competitors products?

3) Google play - Android..noticing a pattern here?

Their Operating System..While I would say they should be forced not to outright "Block" or disable a competitors service. The idea of forcing them to actively Advertise is outright stupid. All this goes back to the shit Opera stirred up with suing to get MS to advertise their browser when they couldn't compete legitimately.

While I agree with you in principal, I can't help think that turnabout is fair play here. It was Google that complained to the EU when MS didn't include chrome on windows 7's browser ballot. MS got fined 3/4 of a Billion for that mistake.

If Google is going to use the EU as a bludgeoning tool against its competition, they shouldn't be surprised or angry when it happens to them.
 
I will use the same argument that I have defended MS with in the Past.

Why should they be forced to promote a "Competitors" product in their own product?

1) Internet Explorer - Inside Windows a MS product. I feel it is completely unreasonable to force MS to promote other browsers inside Their Product. I say that as someone who abhors IE.

2) Safari/Apple App Store Inside iOS - See above, why should apple be forced to promote competitors products?

3) Google play - Android..noticing a pattern here?

Their Operating System..While I would say they should be forced not to outright "Block" or disable a competitors service. The idea of forcing them to actively Advertise is outright stupid. All this goes back to the shit Opera stirred up with suing to get MS to advertise their browser when they couldn't compete legitimately.

Yep, this is ridiculous. Just the fact that MS, Apple, and Google all have similar infrastructure in place proves that there is competition in all of these departments. Not to mention successful smaller competitors for any one item on the list. I don't see anything anti-competitive (at least on the surface of this.)

Also, as people have said in the past, just stop selling your products to the EU, and see how long this lasts when nobody can get them.
 
I will say, for all app stores involved, taking such a huge cut, 25%, 30%, whatever, of a companies transactions earned is ridiculous. Talk about extracting rents.
 
Don't defend companies, they don't deserve it.

We're just dealing with a big scale here. Say you opened a one man software company, and were lucky enough to be the only one in your particular field. Let's say your company is wildly successful overnight, and you decide to add some features to your product. Now there are copy-cats out there due to your success, but they aren't doing quite as well as you, especially with one of their own features. Now imagine that Europe decides to make you include your competitor's product (or a link to it) in yours, or makes you pull one of your features out or pay hefty fines to THEM no your competitor. This is a VERY rough example, but you're a business owner. Do you not wish someone spoke up as to how ridiculous these impositions are? Or maybe you don't care. I don't know. I wouldn't want someone telling me which features I could or couldn't include in my own product, or that I had to give some of my knowledge away to someone else to help them catch up. Or pay fines to a completely irrelevant party if I didn't comply because "they said so."

Maybe if it's for something that might advance civilization or something, but an app store, a browser, a (whatever the flavor of the week is)?

Maybe Europe should develop their own successful businesses and compete.

I'm no American capitalist apologist either, I just think certain actions like this are fairly ridiculous.
 
I will say, for all app stores involved, taking such a huge cut, 25%, 30%, whatever, of a companies transactions earned is ridiculous. Talk about extracting rents.

I agree completely. However, it may balance out from exposure in some ways. Is there anything stopping someone from selling an app privately that needs to be manually loaded? (this is an honest question as I'm not familiar with the policies around side-loading and such)

If you take PCs as an example, you could sell your game on Steam, give up a percentage to Valve, but your game is infinitely more exposed to the public. Or you could sell it from your own web site, not give up that percentage, but who's going to see it?

Trade-offs I guess..
 
The issue is that they are using their dominance in one market to force a dominance in another market.
 
I agree completely. However, it may balance out from exposure in some ways. Is there anything stopping someone from selling an app privately that needs to be manually loaded? (this is an honest question as I'm not familiar with the policies around side-loading and such)

If you take PCs as an example, you could sell your game on Steam, give up a percentage to Valve, but your game is infinitely more exposed to the public. Or you could sell it from your own web site, not give up that percentage, but who's going to see it?

Trade-offs I guess..

That's true, but still, think about that same example applied in any other way. I think that while software can be "game changing" and "disruptive" and all the other Silicon Valley buzzwords (working at a startup now, hear them non-stop :rolleyes:); that doesn't mean we should ignore thousands of years of human history and learning in how markets work, economics, etc.

I would be more understanding of a system in which you start off at the obscene 30% cut, as you do get some type of marketing and infrastructure, but that scale slides down substantially once you "pay back" Google/Apple over time.

E.g., 30% of first $25k in transactions, 20% up to $50k, 10% to $100k, 5% after.
 
That's true, but still, think about that same example applied in any other way. I think that while software can be "game changing" and "disruptive" and all the other Silicon Valley buzzwords (working at a startup now, hear them non-stop :rolleyes:); that doesn't mean we should ignore thousands of years of human history and learning in how markets work, economics, etc.

I would be more understanding of a system in which you start off at the obscene 30% cut, as you do get some type of marketing and infrastructure, but that scale slides down substantially once you "pay back" Google/Apple over time.

E.g., 30% of first $25k in transactions, 20% up to $50k, 10% to $100k, 5% after.

A system like that makes sense, and would be pretty attractive I think.
 
Also, as people have said in the past, just stop selling your products to the EU, and see how long this lasts when nobody can get them.

If there was no money to be made, you bet those companies would have pulled out a long time ago. So, those same companies are bound by their own greed, rather than a never existing sense of integrity!
They could have, but their being drawn by mountains of cash make them behave like the lowliest of sex workers.

The real shame is how the EU levies taxes and fees and punitive damages and those sums of money rarely see the pockets of those who got hurt by those corporations' practices.
 
Can you imagine if Microsoft took a cut of every software sold on its system back in the 90s? They probably would have been broken up via anti-trust laws.
 
Just because Android is Open Source doesn't mean Google doesn't own it and has to make it able to openly modified on the fly. They should probably sue LG, Samsung and all the others who make their own branded ROMs for it also as they are contributing to Google's delinquencies.

MS and Apple lock their stuff down from 3rd party app stores too.

Then when some user gets malware from some sketchy 3rd party providing app store, Google will have to pay out there too and then people will scream about a lack of security mechanisms (which Android already has enough of in that regard as well).
 
Back
Top