Google Gadget Malware Coming

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
At the Black Hat Conference on Aug. 6, two security experts plan on demonstrating a zero-day vulnerability that affects Google Gadgets. Called “Gmalware,” it exploits Gadget vulnerabilities like information theft, content spoofing, and authentication issues. What’s annoying is that they told Google about it and Google didn’t do anything about it.

"We alerted them to that and what they came back with was this is the expected behavior of this domain," said Hansen. "Both Tom and I found that to be a fairly contentious attitude. We alerted them to it and they decided not to fix it and now we're just demonstrating what we found."
 
This is why I dont touch anything google except their search engine :)
 
This is why I dont touch anything Google except their search engine :)

Because they provide a vast array of free services that eventually produced a piece of software that you can allow you to choose to add a malicious gadget?

iGoogle gadgets are just pieces of software that can interact with Google services. All they've done is write programs that do things that you might not want them to do. Google looked at them and came up with the conclusion that the ability to write bad programs isn't exactly an exploit.

Though, honestly, I love your blanket statement that really means nothing whatsoever and is clearly only there to poorly reverse-validate some decision to avoid a service. :rolleyes:
 
I think the result of this will depend on how these gadgets are managed. If there is a repository for such gadgets, then Google can essentially weed out malicious ones. If it's pretty much FFA, like desktop applications, then this could mean security trouble.
 
Because they provide a vast array of free services that eventually produced a piece of software that you can allow you to choose to add a malicious gadget?

iGoogle gadgets are just pieces of software that can interact with Google services. All they've done is write programs that do things that you might not want them to do. Google looked at them and came up with the conclusion that the ability to write bad programs isn't exactly an exploit.

Though, honestly, I love your blanket statement that really means nothing whatsoever and is clearly only there to poorly reverse-validate some decision to avoid a service. :rolleyes:

Something tells me you didnt get anything from post #1.
When a security advisory appears you ignore it because they "are just pieces of software that can interact with Google services"?
Sensible.

Googles track record isnt exemplary.
Google desktop exposed peoples private information and not just once.
Not a great way to get users to trust your products.
 
Something tells me you didnt get anything from post #1.
When a security advisory appears you ignore it because they "are just pieces of software that can interact with Google services"?
Sensible.

No, unfortunately I took the noob way out and read the article rather then the summary.

Hansen said that the underlying problem is that Google's security architecture allows an attacker to put pretty much whatever he or she wants inside Google Gadgets.

The security flaw is that programmers can program things that you don't want.
 
The security flaw is that programmers can program things that you don't want.
No the security flaw is that there is a method available for malicious programmers to exploit that can be removed.
Personally I see the value in fixing it.
 
No the security flaw is that there is a method available for malicious programmers to exploit that can be removed.
Personally I see the value in fixing it.

I don't think you're understanding what nemesis is telling you. Like he said, the flaw is that the gadget programmer has a lot of flexibility and freedom to do what he wants. That is not necessarily a flaw. Just like any programming language, there is a tremendous amount of freedom to write software that does malicious things. Fortunately, we have several tools at our disposal to help us become more secure. As for Google Gadgets, it's up to Google to provide this flexibility and oversee how it will prevent security issues from occurring.
 
and who knows what things will not be able to be done anymore when sealing said "vulnerabilities".

Its kinda like how on the iPhone/iPod Touch apple is strict with what they allow to happen on the device, but this also makes for less functionality as the limits in place also block good things!
 
A free world doesnt work too well with humans.
We need better security not more ways to be exploited.
Granted there is a trade off between functionality and security but Google should at least make it harder to exploit their code.
Thats what the article is about.

If there was no need to make code more secure, then why has just about every piece of software out there been subject to or the effects of security updates of some form.
Its a harsher world behind the scenes.
 
A free world doesnt work too well with humans.
We need better security not more ways to be exploited.
Granted there is a trade off between functionality and security but Google should at least make it harder to exploit their code.
Thats what the article is about.

If there was no need to make code more secure, then why has just about every piece of software out there been subject to or the effects of security updates of some form.
Its a harsher world behind the scenes.

Yes, let's also remove C's ability to read or write files, interact with the screen or keyboard, or use network devices. That'll help with security!!!

They're claiming BASIC FEATURES of gadget as a vulnerability. The ability to read from your email contact list. The ability to interact with your Google accounts, etc.
 
Yes, let's also remove C's ability to read or write files, interact with the screen or keyboard, or use network devices. That'll help with security!!!

They're claiming BASIC FEATURES of gadget as a vulnerability. The ability to read from your email contact list. The ability to interact with your Google accounts, etc.

OTT, there has to be a trade off between security and functionality as mentioned in the post you quoted, regardless of whether its basic features or complex structure that will suffer.
The penalty is often speed which isnt a problem with modern CPU's so I dont see a reason why Google cannot incorporate better security into their code.
 
I agree, they should use the same software that they have that automatically identifies viruses and malware that eliminates the need for definitions.

Oh wait, it doesn't exist.
 
Overreaching lawsuit seeking insane damages from Sergey and Brin in 5... 4... 3... 2...

Seriously, anyone who actually believes Google "does no evil" needs to stop taking their stupid pills with the koolaid. Google would sell out your mother if it made them money - read their privacy policies in full sometime. It's just with the DoubleClick purchase, they only need to sell her between departments.
 
Google's software development process is a joke. It's like watching a bunch of college kids crank out demo ware year after year. If MSFT did this it'd be on every news channel and the haters would be screaming.

Does Google even have a security response team? Their cavalier attitude is pretty amazing. Oh well they want to replace MSFT as top dog, looks like they're gonna repeat all of MSFTs mistakes on the way there.
 
Google's software development process is a joke. It's like watching a bunch of college kids crank out demo ware year after year. If MSFT did this it'd be on every news channel and the haters would be screaming.

Does Google even have a security response team? Their cavalier attitude is pretty amazing. Oh well they want to replace MSFT as top dog, looks like they're gonna repeat all of MSFTs mistakes on the way there.

Its the way the pendulum always swings. Company kicks ass, gets complacent, next new kid comes along and kicks prior company's ass, then they get complacent, rinse and repeat. Every now and then a great company will actually react after said complacency and come back swinging with products and services that are better than before.

This is why competition is good. :)
 
Google's software development process is a joke. It's like watching a bunch of college kids crank out demo ware year after year. If MSFT did this it'd be on every news channel and the haters would be screaming.

Does Google even have a security response team? Their cavalier attitude is pretty amazing. Oh well they want to replace MSFT as top dog, looks like they're gonna repeat all of MSFTs mistakes on the way there.

Have you worked at Google? That seems like a one-sided outlook on things, without even knowing half of the picture, much less the full picture.
 
Back
Top