Google Charitable Donations Set Record

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It's nice to see companies doing stuff like this, especially during the holidays. Obviously not all companies can afford to match employee donations like this but, the big companies that can, should.

Google's third annual Global Giving Week netted $24 million, double what it raised last year, as employees spread the wealth. Some 1,200 Google employees shared stories about their support for organizations and a third of Google employees pledged donations to 750 nonprofits around the world, the Internet giant said.
 
Matching gift stuff can be cool. I've a poor opinion of it in the work place. I've worked one place where they'd match to any 501c3 (which eventually got shitcanned because it was TOO popular), but for the most part, it seems to be about what the management approves of (or more often, has monetary or familial interests in), and turns into a lot of office politics about not enough giving the to 2-3 approved charities. But other than the aforementioned we'll match anything company after they gave up on that, I haven't even seen a big name charity with a good overhead percentages.

Matching a money pit that pays 80% to overhead and some c-level suit's family member gets a huge check cut from that doesn't strike me as worthwhile.

So have I jsut owrked shit places for giving, or is this common?
 
Matching gift stuff can be cool. I've a poor opinion of it in the work place. I've worked one place where they'd match to any 501c3 (which eventually got shitcanned because it was TOO popular), but for the most part, it seems to be about what the management approves of (or more often, has monetary or familial interests in), and turns into a lot of office politics about not enough giving the to 2-3 approved charities. But other than the aforementioned we'll match anything company after they gave up on that, I haven't even seen a big name charity with a good overhead percentages.

Matching a money pit that pays 80% to overhead and some c-level suit's family member gets a huge check cut from that doesn't strike me as worthwhile.

So have I jsut owrked shit places for giving, or is this common?
I actually work at a non-profit that I don't want to share the name of, and our staff does cost some 70% of our expenses. But the staff are people too and are providing valuable services. I'll guarantee that none of us are getting rich over here.
 
I actually work at a non-profit that I don't want to share the name of, and our staff does cost some 70% of our expenses. But the staff are people too and are providing valuable services. I'll guarantee that none of us are getting rich over here.

That's nice, but if my goal is to help whatever you try to help, that's not very effective unless your staff in itself IS the help. If the staff is 70% of expenses and their job is simply to raise more money to pay the ongoing 70% of expenses, your non-profit is exactly who I don't want to give money to. Doubly so if I have John Q. Fucktard over on mahogany row threatening my position at work if I don't give to you because his wife gets the biggest paycheck of all of you. Doesn't matter to me if the wage is on par with the position in a private sector for profit business or less. It's basically workplace extortion to fund something that barely gets money to the people/thing/etc in need of said money. As I said, I may have had a shittier run of luck with that than most people. Google gave to things like second harvest. They have a pretty good track record and most branches hit the 90% ratio or better (i.e. 10% or less to admin and fund raising) I'd do matching to something like that if there ever were something like that on a matching program at my workplace. That hasn't been the case for the most part.

I've been able to find big and small charities that keep administrative costs and fund raising to 25% or less of revenue, so unless the staff IS the aid (in which case, the various charity accountability organizations probably don't count the payroll as administrative ofr fund raising), I don't see it as a good move unless the need is great and there is nobody beating you at the margins. Even then, I'm dealing with limited funds and can't give to everyone, so I'll likely give to some place with a better ratio.

When you have things like project red and SUsan G Komen where the bulk of revenue is spent on XXX is bad mmmkay I find it a gross misuse of charitable donations.
 
That's nice, but if my goal is to help whatever you try to help, that's not very effective unless your staff in itself IS the help. If the staff is 70% of expenses and their job is simply to raise more money to pay the ongoing 70% of expenses, your non-profit is exactly who I don't want to give money to.
That sounds completely reasonable. We are mostly preschool childcare (actually teaching. the teachers get pissed if i say daycare) for lower income families, but also have before and after school and summer programs for kids up to 13. We have on-site therapists of all sorts (speach, play, mental, etc.) we have social workers that try to help the families. We have a food pantry and a warehouse of donated furniture and appliances and household stuff. There is also some utility assistance but I'm not sure what all the qualifications are. There's also therapy and classes for parents. One thing I do know is that it's tough to help people and not make them dependent on you. It's not cool to see second or even third generation children needing the same services. The problem is that it's hard to punish irresponsible parents while not punishing their innocent kids.

edit: also, you can write on your donation what you want the money spent on. I don't think it's mandatory it's spent that way (I'm not in accounting or non-profit politics), but we at least are likely to do that.
 
Last edited:
I'd rather Google on-shore all of it's tax-haven sheltered profits. Think of all the good and charitable works that could be done with those many, many billions of dollars?
 
Google gave to things like second harvest. They have a pretty good track record and most branches hit the 90% ratio or better (i.e. 10% or less to admin and fund raising) I'd do matching to something like that if there ever were something like that on a matching program at my workplace.

I donate a good chunk of my income to charity and always make use of http://www.charitynavigator.org/ when making donations. Like you said, I'm not going to give money to an organization that is basically just a front to make someone rich.
 
Back
Top