Good widget replacement for Windows 8?

MrCrispy

2[H]4U
Joined
May 14, 2007
Messages
4,001
Windows 8 got rid of widgets, and IMO the tiles in Start Screen are not a substitute. I don't want to have to open Start every time to glance at the widget stats, and its not the same thing at all - e.g. I used to have 3 different clocks for different cities. You can only have 1 tile per app, so to get the same thing I have to install 3 separate clock apps and hope they all support tile view!

No idea why they removed this feature, it was present in earlier builds and did no harm. What's the best option - Rainmeter, Yahoo Widgets?
 
Windows 8 got rid of widgets, and IMO the tiles in Start Screen are not a substitute. I don't want to have to open Start every time to glance at the widget stats, and its not the same thing at all - e.g. I used to have 3 different clocks for different cities. You can only have 1 tile per app, so to get the same thing I have to install 3 separate clock apps and hope they all support tile view!

This isn't true. While an app can only have one tile added during installation, the app can add as many tiles as it wants. Live tiles don't have all of the capabilities of desktop widgets, they are not functional equivalents though they can to many of the same things. Large numbers of live tiles are much more practical than widgets and widgets do have a good deal of overhead.

From my perspective its a wash overall. Live tiles are much more scalable and lighter weight and better integrated into the OS, widgets are more technically more functional. But widgets were removed to improve performance and battery life and I think that's of more use to people than widget functionality.
 
I assume DesktopX from Stardock will be updated to run on Windows 8 at some point. Not free but maybe a possibility when things start getting updated for 8. Looks like Yahoo Widgets has also been discontinued. Not a lot of love going around out there for widget fans.
 
Microsoft officially put out an announcement that they recommended all users remove widgets due to security vulnerabilities, and that they were no longer supporting widgets. This was before the introduction of Windows 8.

Rainmeter looks really interesting to me, you might want to try it out.
 
This isn't true. While an app can only have one tile added during installation, the app can add as many tiles as it wants. Live tiles don't have all of the capabilities of desktop widgets, they are not functional equivalents though they can to many of the same things. Large numbers of live tiles are much more practical than widgets and widgets do have a good deal of overhead.

From my perspective its a wash overall. Live tiles are much more scalable and lighter weight and better integrated into the OS, widgets are more technically more functional. But widgets were removed to improve performance and battery life and I think that's of more use to people than widget functionality.

To bad Metro can't communicate with win32 thus any communication with subsystem in the os can't be displayed. Unless you will look at endless RSS, social media, weather, Live tiles are pretty useless.
 
There is an option to install widgets on 8. Havent tried it.

Titles on that pathetic metro screen are not replacement.
 
Back
Top