Good TV Tuner?

Hale

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 8, 2004
Messages
150
I'm looking at getting a good TV Tuner soon. I'm wondering what is a good one? I'm running a Biostar IDEQ 200v with an AMD XP-M 2200+@2.08GHz, 512mb DDR400, and a Radeon 8500 128mb. As of right now I should have room for an internal one as the 8500 uses a rather slim fan.

I'm considering of getting rid of my TV and just using my PC and Monitor to watch TV. As my TV is only a 19" and my Monitor is a 17" Flat CRT so the monitor has just a little less acutal viewing room. And getting rid of the TV will free up some space in my room.
 
The leadtek PVR2000 Deluxe is quite popular and well supported. I have one and I can say that it is a very good card. Its also only like 50 bux.

About getting rid of the TV though - realize that watching TV on your monitor is not like watching tv on your TV. First off, there is the low quality picture that will be exacerbated by the high res nature of your montior. However, there is the availablity of PVR software, which is a huge boon IMO. However, i would evaluate the quality issue and see if it bothers you before ditching the TV.

Also, IMO movies are just more fun to watch on TV than on a monitor. Don't know why.
At school i would run a cable from my comp to my tv to watch movies on my 19 inch horribly round tv over my 17inch diamnondtron flat screen CRT.
 
I got an ATI TV Wonder PRO and I am still having troubles installing it. I might return it and go for a Hauppage. After spending hours trying to get the card to work, I feel like swimming in a pool of plastic grocery sacks.
 
Get rid of them both and get a 19 inch flat CRT!

TV2000XP is a little cheaper and decent I hear. Remote and all. I might get one

Also you might consider an HDTV tuner.
 
Spetsnaz Op said:
Get rid of them both and get a 19 inch flat CRT!

TV2000XP is a little cheaper and decent I hear. Remote and all. I might get one

Also you might consider an HDTV tuner.


i can't get rid of my monitor...and I might just buy a big tv whenever I move...like a 52" hdtv widescreen. seen a few of those getting cheap at around 1000. and i've used my tv-out using my tv before and it doesn't look that much better than using my monitor. however, i was also reconsidering keeping my tv and use that in the living room of the apartment and get a tuner for my bedroom since the computer will be in there.

guess i'll figure it out after i move.
 
rygy said:
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=15-116-308&depa=1 I think I will be buying one of these soon. It uses the same hardware MPEG 2 encoding chip that the Hauppauge 250 does and many people profess that the image quality is at least equal to that of the Hauppauge card. As well, it is almost 1/2 the price.

Check out these threads:
http://htpcnews.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=5883&hl=low+profile
http://htpcnews.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=5980&st=0

Make sure you notice the price on that monster tuner, Hauppuage has a low profile 250 I'd say that it'll show up in the sub $99 range but probably around $50 or $75.
 
I have the Hauppuage PVR-350 and love it. If I did it again I would get the PVR-250, I just haven't used the features of the 350. I also have Snapstreams BeyondTV product.

You can get BeyondTV and the 250 from snapstream.com. Both A++ products.
 
A half-height Hauppauge card would be quite similar to the E-home would it not? Plus at around $75 it would be similarily priced. I dunno, I just like ATi :).
 
Hauppuage is a much better card then anything by ATI. I have used an AIW before and didn't like it. The Hauppuage has hardware encoding so you don't use the CPU to encode the TV stream to MPEG-2
 
I am assuming you have never read anything about the ATi e-home wonder because it utilizes the EXACT same hardware MPEG-2 encoding chip that the Hauppauge PVR (250) cards use. Check out this thread at HTPCnew.com. Some people like the ATi card, others prefer the Hauppauge card because of it is already established.
 
Doc Holiday said:
Hauppuage is a much better card then anything by ATI. I have used an AIW before and didn't like it. The Hauppuage has hardware encoding so you don't use the CPU to encode the TV stream to MPEG-2
Yes the AIWs are next to trash when it comes to an HTPC (only saving grace is if you want to hook up a game console system) but the ATI E-Home Wonder is a very nice card that uses the same "Blackbird" reference design as the Hauppuage "Rosalyn" card, quality is pretty much the same of the 250MCE. Its pretty good, around $75 (about $25 cheaper then the 250MCE) and has the awesome Theater 200 chip that ATI uses with their AIWs for video in. :D It's a great deal.

But...(you had to know there was one ;) ) there is some problems with software support (not all apps fully support it) and the drivers can be flaky. The software support is getting better but I'm not sure when the last time the drivers were updated.
 
rygy said:
I am assuming you have never read anything about the ATi e-home wonder because it utilizes the EXACT same hardware MPEG-2 encoding chip that the Hauppauge PVR (250) cards use. Check out this thread at HTPCnew.com. Some people like the ATi card, others prefer the Hauppauge card because of it is already established.

I thought you would say this. I haven't looked in to the e-home nor did I know it was even out. I just saw ATI and thought about the TV-Wonder and the AIW's. From those threads it looks to be a good card. I say go for it. The driver and software support have got to be better than Hauppauge.

On a sidenote, I haven't had any problems with my PVR-350 that I can speak of. It works great with BeyondTV. Which IMHO is the best PVR software on the market. I have also tried SageTV but I like BeyondTV's 10ft. interface much better.
 
Doc Holiday said:
The driver and software support have got to be better than Hauppauge.
You would think so but they do require some work before you can use them, my 250MCEs are pretty much good to go.

The E-Homes are good cards but you have to know what your in for before you get one. Moral of the story is that you have to do your research.
 
hey could someone who has one of these "Blackbird" reference design Hauppuage "Rosalyn 250MCE cards walk me through the installation process?

I bought it OEM and can't seem to install it
 
I have a two real 250MCEs cards and I use SageTV with them. The Rosyln is pretty good (no different quality wise then my cards) but they do have some software compatablity problems (since it's a new design). On the plus side it might be possible to turn off "Live MPEG" stuff so that you can hookup a game console and play it in realtime.
 
CrimandEvil said:
I have a two real 250MCEs cards and I use SageTV with them. The Rosyln is pretty good (no different quality wise then my cards) but they do have some software compatablity problems (since it's a new design). On the plus side it might be possible to turn off "Live MPEG" stuff so that you can hookup a game console and play it in realtime.

Got any links to the software issues? I was probably going to use SageTV.

Not sure what Live MPEG stuff is. I will mostly be using it to record football games.
 
It doesn't really matter since most of the issues have been worked out with driver updates and software updates, SageTV works with them out of box too but I could probably dig up some links up for you.

The 250 cards record everything into MPEG2 so if you hookup something to the A/V or svideo inputs all that gets turned into MPEG2, the Rosylns are able to "turn off" that recording feature so you don't get a delay of three seconds or so since it has a different layout then the 250/250 cards.
 
hmm well I was also just thinking about a HDTV card. Are those worth it?
 
IMO no since your pretty much screwed with them. Your limited to either over the air HD broadcasts or use the Fusion 3 QAM version which lets you tune HD over cable but your still limited to channels that you cable company doesn't encrypt (basic cable so no ESPN or such). I'd wait til a tuner comes out supporting a feature called "cable card" comes out, cable card will let you tune digital channels.

But if you do want to get an HD card then you should go with the Fusion 3 QAM.
 
For $55 you can get the compro videomate gold plus w/ built in fm radio at new egg. Im watching it right now and has far exceded my expectations and it can remotely power up and turn off the comp to record shows when you are away and the picture quality is great, you can even get the ultra model which is even better. But I still wouldn't get rid of my TV :)
 
ScreamingBroccoli said:
For $55 you can get the compro videomate gold plus w/ built in fm radio at new egg. Im watching it right now and has far exceded my expectations and it can remotely power up and turn off the comp to record shows when you are away and the picture quality is great, you can even get the ultra model which is even better. But I still wouldn't get rid of my TV :)

Does this card do hardware audio and video encoding?
 
I just nabbed me a refurbed Ati E-Home Wonder for $56 shipped @ newegg. Has TV/FM with the same hardware encoder as the Hauppauge cards use, although it isn't as supported (for example BTV doesn't support it below 3.5beta). Sold out now (there was only one) but I hear they go in stock every once in a while, usually in the evenings.
 
Back
Top