Good drives for RAID 5/6?

dgingeri

2[H]4U
Joined
Dec 5, 2004
Messages
2,830
I've recently been given (love the perks of being a test lab admin) a couple LSI SAS controllers for my personal use. One 8 internal port controller and one 2X4 external port controller. Both have capability for RAID 5 and 6.

I tried using Caviar Black drives for a RAID 5 a little while ago, and had nothing but problems. Performance was great, but having a drive drop off the array every week kind of takes the shine off 300MB/s.

I don't want to duplicate that issue, so I hope you guys could tell me what SATA drives still work well for RAID. I know WD Caviar Black aren't useful, and from what I've heard, Velociraptors are bad for the same reason. (TLER) Did Seagate and Hitachi do the same with their drives? Do I have to spend 40% more to get RAID capable drives? If not, what drives would be a balance of reliable, inexpensive, and fast?
 
Hitachi, Samsung. But your best bet will be enterprise drives

Yeah, I was hoping to avoid enterprise level drives. If I go that way, I'd rather go with the WD RE3 drives, but they're so darned expensive. 750's are $110 each. The Hitachi equal are $139 for 1TB drives.

I was hoping to get something around $80 for 750GB.
 
BTW, my WD blacks are running for 9 moths already and no issues (not yet)..........
 
I bought a server with 12 1TB hitachi deskstar drives and an areca RAID card. Been working great for months [like 6?]

I'd roll with the hitachi drives.
 
No experience with them but Samsung F1 1TB RAID class drives can be had for about $100 each.
 
Back
Top