Good Deal Or a Mistake?

Joined
Mar 25, 2006
Messages
562
Well, first of all, I know most of you wouldn’t go down this road. Didn’t think I would either. But before I ask I need to give a brief background of my situation.

A few months ago I bought a Dell Optiplex PC and at the time I didn’t really think I would get into gaming. I bought it mainly for business apps. But then I got interested after seeing a friends system and the cool 3-D graphics. Then, to my surprise, I discovered my system isn’t very expandable. Good 3-D video cards need a lot of power and I couldn’t seem to find a PSU to upgrade my Dell. So I went on Newegg and found what I thought was a compatible video card with my system that had decent 3-D specs. I bought an XFX 7600GS and if you look at the system requirements it says 300 watt PSU. But when it arrived it says on the box 350 watt PSU minimum. My Dell has a 305 watt PSU. Ugh!

Well now I thought, why not just use the Dell for what I intended (office apps and stock market trading) and just build a nice system for gaming? So I did some reasearch here and read some other posts. But guess what I just did? Yep, another Dell. But I think this is a good deal. But of course I'd like to see what some veteran gamers and expert system builders on here have to say.

Here's what I bought (and by the way, there's a few more of these left).

I bought a Barebones Dell XPS 600 off eBay. The system comes in the original Dell box with Win XP, all the case fans and cables, plus a 650 watt PSU and a SLI compatible mobo. Also has a year warranty through Dell. And since I already have a decent video card that I bought from NewEgg (that I can't use in my current Dell), now all I need is an Optical drive, HDD, Memory and a CPU and I have a a sweet gamng rig (for way less than if I bought one of these new).

And before I bought this, I went on Newegg and checked out the cost of a nice case, a premium SLI Mobo, a high-end PSU and Win XP OS. Impossible to buy all those high-end components and an OS for the price of $249 (which is what the barebones dell XPS 600 cost). So I thought it seems like a good deal and so far, here's what I picked out at Newegg to complete the system:

CPU: Cant decide if i should get the Intel Pentium D 940 or the Pentium D 930 Worth $67 extra for the 940?
HDD: I want plenty of storage space so I'm considering the Seagate Barracuda 320GB
Memory: Thinking a Gig of this Mushkin Memory will do nicely.
Optical Drive: I thought this Lite-On DVD Burner seemed cool.

So there's the system I'm considering. What would you do different? Would like your input, be it good or bad.
 
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
did u try that video card in your dell? Or did I miss something? Dell makes some nice PSUs rated higher than some of the garbage you see being sold all over the place.


...as for your dell decision, I'm not feeling it--even if it meets what you are looking for. I'd start from scratch and save yourself some of the uncertainty that comes from buying from Ebay.

GL
 
Depending on the specs on the Dell Optiplex PC it might have been easier and cheaper to just replace the power supply.
 
EQTakeOffense said:
Depending on the specs on the Dell Optiplex PC it might have been easier and cheaper to just replace the power supply.

Well I have the Optiplex GX620 minitower and I've searched and searched. There is no upgrade. pcpowerandcolling makes upgraded PSUs for Dell systems but not for my model. My model is not listed on their website so I called them and they told me sorry, not available.

One thing i did notice in my search for a PSU or a compatible video card with my system was is you read in the second paragraph of this 7600GS Review it states the card only uses 30 watts of power. Why does the box indicate a 350 watt power supply as a minimum system requirement?

As far as eBay goes, true that it can be a crap-shoot at times. But I do everything I can to avoid scams and bypass deals that "seem to good to be true". This guy I bought this from answered several emails I sent promptly, and he has excellent feedback. Plus he offers a refund if not satisfied. Also, I always pay through PayPal with a credit card so I have several buyer protection policies working for me. And lastly, it's not like I spent a grand on this. After I seen how much a case, sli-mobo, psu and an OS would cost this doesn't seem like a bad way to go.

And to be honest, I'm not all that comfortable doing it from scratch. Assembling the mobo into a bare case seems a bit out of my league. But I'm confident I can install some ram, hdd, video card and dvd burner. A little intimidated bout installing the CPU though. I looked on the Dell Support site and there's a ton of info on how to remove and install the components. Just wondering how well the components I selected will mesh with this system.
 
if you are confident you can install a video card/ram etc, then you can screw a mobo to the case trust me. It's almost easier.
 
I read so many bad reviews and posts about different mobos. Some say this, some say that... Just difficult to tell what I'd need with so many choices and conflicting posts. To cut through all the hooplah, I would guess just buy a premium board such as a Foxconn 975X7AA or a ASUS P5N32-SLI Deluxe ?

OK, so it's nothing more than mounting it in the case. Sounds easy enough. But those mobos almost cost as much as the Dell XPS case I bought that comes with a NVIDIA® nForce4 SLI X16 Motherboard/ 650 Watt Power Supply and includes OEM Win XP CD. How is that a mistake? I'm not trying to justify my purchase to y'all. I'd just like to know, if what I bought looks like new and operates like it was designed to, why some of you would opt to spend up for a new case,mobo,psu and OS.

With the parts I listed in my original post, won't I have a screaming fast gaming system? Most parts brand new and all parts under warranty for under $900. New, an XPS 600 cost twice as much. Or is it that most of y'all just hate Dell and would rather buy non-dell parts no matter what the price?
 
I, personally, wouldn't have bought a Dell or Gateway, or HP or any major OEM like that. The biggest thing for me is that they tend to lock the system down cutting your options. Also, there's the pride of having a machine come alive after spending an hour or ten assembling it from scratch. However, I have bought OEM machines before just to give a jumpstart into whatever I was doing and later upgraded them to something better.

In your case however, as long as the end result for you is a gaming system you like and are happy with, then you made a good decision. You can always upgrade later if you find that there's something lacking.

As for the CPU the Pentium-D 930 will do you nilcely, I don't personally believe that thery's $67 woth of performance in the 940.

As far as the ram goes also look at G.Skill, Corsair, or Kingston. They tend to be cheaper than Mushkin and still as good. Go for 2GB, some games will thank you.

One more thing, If you want to run the lastest games with all the eye candy turned on, then I make the suggestion that you spring for at least a nVidia 7900GT instead of a 7600GS, but that's your call.
 
ryan_975 said:
Me, personally, wouldn't have bought a Dell or Gateway, or HP or any major OEM like that. The biggest thing for me is that they tend to lock the system down cutting your options. Also, there's the pride of having a machine come alive after spending an hour or ten assembling it from scratch. However, I have bought OEM machines before just to give a jumpstart into whatever I was doing and later upgraded them to something better.

Yeah I totally understand the pride thing. As far as a major OEM machines go, I have already been bitten by the lockdown bug that limited my options of video cards I can run in my first Dell (Optiplex GX620 no upgrade available for PSU). This particular unit though, for now, needs no major upgrades that I can see. It has a very powerful PSU (650 watts and designed to run SLI) and the mobo is an Nvidia SLI design. And I think the case looks really cool as well. Hopefully with some quality components I'll be all set. Plus, it has the Win XP CD. So I just thought for the price its a deal because Win XP alone at Newegg would have cost me about $90. Thus, I look at it as I got a case, sli-mobo and a 650 watt PSU for about $150. (and I kind of think the XPS 600 will look sweet next to my Optiplex GX620).


ryan_975 said:
In your case however, as long as the end result for you is a gaming system you like and are happy with, then you made a good decision. You can always upgrade later if you find that there's something lacking.

Very true. As I stated it's not like I sunk a lot of moo-lah into this. If it turns out to not be what I want, back on eBay it goes and I'll get what ever I can for it and use the funds to buy better. I love eBay, can really find some deals and also a great outlet to liquidate junk I don't want/need anymore.


ryan_975 said:
As for the CPU (you said PSU by the way) the Pentium-D 930 will do you nilcely, I don't personally believe that thery's $67 woth of performance in the 940.

I was wondering about that myself. That's why I asked. I was wondering if I'd even notice any difference at all because they're both fast. That's what's so great about this forum, I read a lot of other posts to get a feel for things and like to see if others agree or disagree with my suspicions. You've backed up my thoughts and I think the D 930 is better bang for the buck. (I fixed the typo for PSU, it now says CPU)


ryan_975 said:
As far as the ram goes also look at G.Skill, Corsair, or Kingston. They tend to be cheaper than Mushkin and still as good. Go for 2GB, some games will thank you.

I was concerned about cas latency. Not sure how much it matters but just thought I should go with the best memory type out there and from what I understand, lower latency numbers are better. Or is this another scenario where if I go with memory with a cas latency of 4, rather than 3, I'm not going to notice much difference?


ryan_975 said:
One more thing, If you want to run the lastest games with all the eye candy turned on, then I make the suggestion that you spring for at least a nVidia 7900GT instead of a 7600GS, but that's your call.

Excellent suggestion. Now that I'm going to have plenty of power from the PSU I can certainly run a better video card. I have yet to open the box of the 7600GS and I got a deal on it anyway, plus a rebate. I could off it on eBay and get a 7900GT.

There's so many different 7900 series and all in different price ranges. 7900 series is available in GT, GT extreme, GTX, GTX extreme and even a 7950 GTX2 with a GB of GDDR3 memory on board! Again, I'm just wondering how much difference I'm really going to notice between a 7900 GT and a 7900GTX which costs almost twice as much. Am I going to get twice the performance? I doubt it. I was also wondering, that since I can do sli and I already have a 7600GS, would two 7600GS in sli be better than one 7900GT?
 
From what I've read, two 7600's is still outperformed by a single 7900GT and yet cost more. The 7950GX2 is two 7900GT video cards in one package. It is in fact two PCB linked to a single PCIe X16 slot. You could theoretically get two 7950GX2's and do quad SLI, but there's no driver support as of yet. As far as it having a gig of ram, it really doesn't. Each GPU has access to only 512MB each. So after all's said and done you still only have a 512MB framebuffer.

I don't really think CAS 3 is wortht he extra in terms of price/performance. I think you'll be plenty happy with CAS 4.

Also you might want to look into a WD Raptor hard drive for your OS and Apps/games. and then a 250-320GB hard drive for documents/music/whatever files. You'll get the best of both worlds that way.
 
I'm looking at the pictures of the barebones system, and I am confused.
Where exactly is the 650W psu? Is it in the red circle? the thing in the red circle somewhat resembles a radiator with some heatpipes.

Also, the yellow circle looks to be the place where the power cord plugs into the pc, which has a black wire running up to the front of the case.
The motherboard power connector (located bottom right of red circle) also looks like it has wires running to the front of the case, unless it goes directly up, (into the red circle) and the other power cords are coming out of the right of the red circle.

If that is indeed the psu, I don't see any capacitors or circuitboard, which are always found in psus.

 
I believe the PSU is in the very bottom of the case. that photo doesn't show it too well though.

Here's a link to a review of it on another site with better/more pictures.
 
Gravestone Doji said:
Would like your input, be it good or bad.

you said you use your PC for : "office apps and stock market trading"


i don't know any poor people who trade on the stock market......... therefore use your money and buy a proper PC...........spend a few grand.......... don't be cheap...........

FORGET DELL !!!!
 
Jaap74 said:
you said you use your PC for : "office apps and stock market trading"


i don't know any poor people who trade on the stock market......... therefore use your money and buy a proper PC...........spend a few grand.......... don't be cheap...........

FORGET DELL !!!!

That's probably the most ignorant response I've ever read on these forums.

Anyway, it sounds like you have it all pretty much figured out, and like you said, if it doesn't work out how you want it to, you can always pawn the stuff off on ebay.
 
It's also possible to overclock a P4 630 3.0GHz to 4.0GHz in the XPS 600. Last time I checked most games were taking much of advantage of dual core so this might end up being faster if gaming is your main purpose. Send me a private message if you need more info.
 
Dude...you got a dell!!!

Actaully, thats not a bad machine at all and you bought it the right way.
 
Field Service Engineer for Dell for 5years w/ DCSE (Dell Certified Service Expert on portables and desktops), employee number F0361... DELL sucks! all cheap ass components, period! but working for them was good while it lasted- pays the bills.
wink.gif


anyways, if you are going for gaming, you are better off building or configuring your own system. ask around, alot of people here would help you for free.
the difference between an OEM system and your own build is this: MOBO overclocking is locked in BIOS! if you are going to put new mobo in, your mobo wouldn't fit. and NO ENOGUH ROOM FOR UPGRADE for the next game you'd want to play, that would make you go out and buy another barebone from eBay.
here's what happens to people who got into gaming:
1-- they saw a friends nice game w/ 3-d....NICE!
2-- they dive into gaming themselves, they buy one game first
3-- gets another game...
4-- gets another game
5-- gets the latest game
(gaming is so addictive more than nicotine)
and by the time you are on your next game you'd find out that the system you now have doesn't have a lot of headroom for the next one. And if you go for gaming INTEL CPU is not the best way to go. You can configure a gaming rig that can run all the latest 3-D game for under $600.(w/o monitor,kb,mouse of course).

And now you are discussing of getting a nice video card (7900 series), w/c by the way is not compatible w/ your CPU w/c is a P4. Sure you can run the game but your cpu will bottleneck the performance of your Video Card, and you can see a HUGE performance difference.
 
in all complete honesty, i think you made a mistake. I built my first computer when i was 14. it ran like a champ. If you have the patience to read and take input (which you seem to have demonstrated already) then you can build a computer. Buying the xps just doesn't seem like the best way to start ur system. while it seems like a good deal, the only thing for me that makes it seem like one is the xp. just cuz its a so and so watt psu, its still a dell, i will never trust them. who knows.
 
Back
Top