GoDaddy Pulls Lavabit's Security Creds

I'll refrain from saying what I really think for fear of being locked up in Gitmo.

  1. Screw the NSA and FBI
  2. Yay GoDaddy for sticking it to them
  3. ?????
  4. Profit?
 
Exactly, thank you.
there is no comparison whatsoever, I pay for say cloud storage a contract between a private person and a private company.. comparison would be snail mail which has proper protections.. Electronic data should be ruled in the same manner, but its not, what is being done is the same as government opening everyones mail.
its wrong.. There is little real argument about it. The arguments in favor here cant fit inside my brain anymore, they seem so absurd to me.

Its based on the interpretation that transmittting something on the internet is the same as standing on your roof and shouting it. When in fact you can't intercept my communication unless you take deliberate and targetted steps to do so. Just like wire tapping my phone or placing a microphone in my home. Which can be done but not with the flip of a switch. Average people can't relate because there this mysterious layer of 'technology' involved to understand it. What the NSA is doing now if analogous to the NSA openning your mail, scanning a copy and storing the scan for future reference. If that happened to the average person they'd go apeshit.
 
If Snoweden is a Traitor, then I'm something worse. Because if I'd been faced with the same decision, I'd have done the very same thing. The difference being that I sure as hell won't give up the land my ancestors died for, and am just as prepared as they were to protect it with lethal force.
 
you should really think profundly about the absurdity you are saying.. The idea of interpreting the constitution is to keep its soul alive alive.. Its very clear what it says.. Govt is not to look into your business without reason, period. All the other convoluted shit you mention is that shit,.. Of course the courts agree and crap the push for planting the seeds of repressive goverment have been going for a long time, its not unprecedented for countries to do clearly wrong moves that are 'legal' .. And clearly we are not above moving towards crappy govt. As we see it in 'other' countries... Sure we can tell ourselfs oooh no we are soooo different, all the while goin down the same we point out as wrong in other countries

I'm being consistent as many people are here. Most folks here style themselves by-the-bootstraps strict constructionists. And strictly speaking my advocatus diaboli reading is valid.

You want to play judicial activism and the "living document" theory, I'm with you. But if you're going to be consistent in that theory, lots of other stuff that you (and most people on [H]) don't like that came courtesy of judicial activism and "living document" comes along for the ride.


Can't have it both ways.
 
I'm much less concerned that we have a "living document" stance, and instead that we follow the spirit of the law, which is much more important.

The words email, meta-data, wire-tapping, security encryption, computer virus, etc... They didn't exist. But if they had, I don't think there's anyone that would disagree that our Founders would have included them, had they known what the hell they were.

Most living document activists are centered primarily in the anti-gun movement. Their goal is to change or erase the second amendment outright. But nothing needs changed or erased in the case of the fourth amendment. The only way you can read it and not come to the conclusion that the physical ideas that they were dealing with then can be applied to the electronic property we deal with now is if you're going out of your way to throw deductive reasoning out the window.
 
Where in the Constitution or the Bill of Rights (or any of the Amendments) is the word "privacy" ever used? Where does it say in the Constitution that domestic espionage is forbidden from the federal government? Where does the Constitution limit the federal government from reading other people's mail? Your country was indeed founded on the Constitution....you should study it sometime, because you are quite wrong.

I'm not saying what the NSA has been doing is ethically right nor am I saying it is good thing...I'm saying that it is not illegal based on the laws we have, and that includes the Constitution, the Declaration of Independence, and the Amendments.



I was speaking WRT programs like PRISM generally.

The constitution says what the Government CAN do, it is not a list of what the Government CANT do.

Here is an example, does the Constitution say that federal employees cant rape anyone at will? nope, so I guess they can do it right?
 
It is pretty clear indeed. The 4th amendment in no way mentions communications digital or otherwise whether they are person-to-person direct or if they are conducted through 3rd and 4th party hardware/software. Especially where the 3rd and 4th parties are known to snoop your communications by themselves.

And the courts agree with me. So if you're "pretty sure" about your conclusion...well you should think it through again.

Actually the courts don't agree with you.
Electronic transfers and telephone conversations are covered by the amendment. So is wire tapping in general. It's been upheld by the court system for a long time now. Electronic communications are considered under the fourth amendment.

If you don't think it is illegal then why don't you try breaking into some E-mail servers? We will see what the judge has to say about it. Be sure to give him that line about everything that goes over the internet is the same as shouting it on a street corner. I'm sure he will agree.
 
It is pretty clear indeed. The 4th amendment in no way mentions communications digital or otherwise whether they are person-to-person direct or if they are conducted through 3rd and 4th party hardware/software. Especially where the 3rd and 4th parties are known to snoop your communications by themselves.

And the courts agree with me. So if you're "pretty sure" about your conclusion...well you should think it through again.

Geez...you are the embodiment of the problem in the USA today.

This: "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects"

Pretty much sums it up...electronic communication can arguably be considered a persons "effects", just like US Post office mail, which is privacy protected as well.
 
Back
Top