Gmail and Hotmail CAPTCHAs Defeated

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
ArsTechnica has the scoop on how the CAPTCHA systems for both Gmail and Hotmail have been beaten and what the industry is doing to make sure it stays beaten. Ugh.

…New findings indicate that both Gmail and Windows Live Hotmail have been compromised again, this time via a more-streamlined attack process. With two of the largest webmail providers once again vulnerable, CAPTCHAs clearly aren't meeting the security needs of either company, and it may be time to reevaluate the use of them altogether.
 
Yay, now they will probably make them like rapidshare or other sites where no one can friggin read them.
 
Looks like they will have to start charging a one time sign up fee then. That should slow them down some. Hmm. Maybe like $1 or so.:confused:
 
they would go out of business for free e-mail because I will never pay for it and so many other people would not either
 
I could be just "off my box" here....

But one would think that if they (hotmail, gmail, etc) actually persued prosecution
means a bit more aggressively (which *should* include proportionately stiffer results)...

The whole subject wouldn't be such a "worthwhile" target for the would be
"numbers racketeers".

OTOH...

If the advertising model could be overhauled... *sigh*

There seems to be no easy fix. :mad:

The only real way to stop it all, is to make the "carrot unpalatable for the rabbit".
 
I'd pay $1 to sign up for gmail. One dollar is practically nothing. I've been using gmail as my personal email address for over 4 years.
 
I would pay $1 as well. In fact, I'd pay more, if that was the price of "spam-free". Although, right now, I'm almost entirely spam free with my gmail. That said, paying for email is not a good solution unless all the major providers makes you pay a small fee.
 



My friend sent me this on msn when he was complaining about looking for cats on rapidshare. I laughed heartily
 
I think the solution is a one dollar sign-up fee.

Even a 50 cent sign-up fee would immediately make these free accounts unprofitable for mass sign-ups...
 
^^ Agreed. I just hope that doesn't create a slippery slope to $ charges PER email.
Though something like that would double-whammy the spammers...I can't imagine the costs for business or even personal. I dunno.
 
just find the spammers, take all their money and put their balls in vices. it will stop soon after. problem solved.
 
Couldn't they have some sort of limit per IP address on how many creations you could have in an hour or something? The way I am picturing this is a bunch of people in some sort of computer warehouse cranking away and if that's the case id assume they are under a similar IP or even do some mac address filtering?
 
Really? You wouldn't pay a dollar to sign up for Gmail or MSN? :rolleyes:

fixed: Proof reading FTW. In all fairness I was not sober. I was on the same stuff that congress was on when they passed the new Bailout bill. Boy I think we can all sleep easier now that we know our children can buy wooden arrows with no extra tax. Too bad they couldn't tack on some kind of anti spam legislation. Talk about saving some big corporations some money.;)
 
If they charged 1-5 dollars for an email account but provided you with some benifits such as free pop services, remote clients, or large file transfers... why not?!

It's a crap filter, it works wonders for hardocp.
 
If they charged 1-5 dollars for an email account but provided you with some benifits such as free pop services, remote clients, or large file transfers... why not?!

It's a crap filter, it works wonders for hardocp.

Well Hotmail DO have a paid email service where you get Hotmail access in Outlook and extra storage and a few small benefit. Can't remember what it's called but my mother's a paid member because she loves her Outlook client :D
 
Well I know I WON'T continue to use Hotmail if I gotta pay for it D:

Can you read? We are talking about a ONE TIME sign-up fee. You are already signed up thus you wouldn't have to pay anything.

The idea is to combat erroneous account creation by overseas captcha breakers. Right now they make a small fee for how many accounts they can setup. The one dollar sign up fee would make the whole model unprofitable.
 
Well Hotmail DO have a paid email service where you get Hotmail access in Outlook and extra storage and a few small benefit. Can't remember what it's called but my mother's a paid member because she loves her Outlook client :D

Yeah, I've been a hotmail member since before Microsoft owned it, so I have outlook access grandfathered in.

You know, $1 one-time fees wouldn't be a bad idea at all. I don't think there would be much complaining.... well, maybe at first.
 
Why, given that many email service or software providers can perform pretty accurate spam-checking on incoming email, can they not simply check outgoing mail and not allow the spam to be sent at all? Or limit the amount of emails that can be sent? Or the number of users mailed within a time period? Captchas are a decidenly lazy answer and a short-sighted one - they will only get easier to beat as software gets smarter. Why not use that smarter software to check and block spam more efficiently?
 
Back
Top