Generally what will be cheaper, prebuilt or self built?

Status
Not open for further replies.
So here is my current shopping list, if anyone sees anything out of place feel free to show me up :p

Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 Conroe 2.4GHz 4M shared L2 Cache LGA 775 Processor - $226
G.SKILL 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory - $84.99
SAPPHIRE 100176L Radeon X1950PRO 256MB 256-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 HDCP Video Card - $145.99
MSI P6N SLI-FI LGA 775 NVIDIA nForce 650i SLI ATX Intel Motherboard - $109.99
CORSAIR CMPSU-520HX ATX12V v2.2 and EPS12V 2.91 520W Power Supply - 96.25
Lian-Li PC-V1000B PlusII - 179.99
Arctic Silver 5 Thermal Compound 12g - $8.99

A grand total of $852.2, and with taxes and shipping probably around $900

The only thing that bothers me is the video card, I kinda wanted a DX10 card. If I get this one now, I won't want to upgrade and waste more money for at least 2 years. I wonder if it's worth waiting a month or 2 and seeing if the ATI cards finally come out...
 
Well supposedly ATI is releasing their DX10 cards on May 14. So if you can wait just a few days, we'll see how good those ATI DX10 cards are. Just two more days!

anyway, build looks good to me. Roll with it.
 
I can wait 2 days with ease, that sure is good news...

I hope that they aren't uberly priced and from what I understand that even the cheapest one will perform much better than most top end DX10 ones.

IMO when they come out there should be a 1 day sale of $50 for their top end DX10 card, smart move IMO... *wishes some more*
 
lol... don't we all?

anyhow, newegg likes to raise prices on the weekend, lol... them bastids, lol. yah, i hope the r600 pushes those nvidia cards lower. whether the cards outperform the 8800 series or not should be irrelevant. If they're better, NVIDIA will lower their prices to compete. If they're worse, ATI/AMD will intro with lower prices to compete, forcing NVIDIA to lower prices to compete... unless they make that backalley deal to screw us all over :(
 
$627 for better or equal parts to the Dell...

$480 vs $600... 'nuff said.

Some people just don't understand english. "Always" and "Never" are continued to be misused/misunderstood.
Excuse my post but you were such a piece of work I couldn't let this rest. I'm not sure why you have so much sand up your privates but it's really unbecoming man and does nothing but hurt the board.

Antec NSK4400 - $26.99

Corsair DDR 667 - $37
4400 X2 x/ nforce 6100 mobo - $98.99
19" widescreen Samsung w/ DVI - $175
160 gb WD - $45.81
Vista Home Basic upgrade - $20
Pioneer DVD Burner - $30

Total:
$433.79

So for less money I got you a faster processor, superior DVD burner vs your DVDROM drive (sorry, I had soooo much money left over I splurged), better PSU (the most important component of any build IMO), non-proprietary build that saves money on upgrades in the long run, a widescreen monitor with half the response time AND with DVI as opposed to your analogue, and I still have room left over to either upgrade the video card, sound card, water cool, or , if you continue to be an ignorant parts snob, you could even do as everyone on here does and hock the motherboard on ebay and buy a new one which would STILL come in for less than your deal. The name of the game with building is patience and if you bought that Dell a few weeks before the AMD price drops it's your own damn fault. Now, do yourself a favor and crawl back into whatever hole you came from and let this topic rest.
 
Your statement about DIY PCs is always cheaper is true if you add the following words at the end:

Building will always be cheaper, always, for gaming PCs

For the regular work PCs where the most you'll do on it is word processing and web browsing, prebuilt PCs will generally be cheaper than DIY However, if you're talking about a gaming PC, the building it yourself will always be cheaper than prebuilt.

Dell Deals happen regularly. And in many of their deals, you can't beat their price with a DIY system. So your statement about building it yourself ALWAYS being cheaper is false. If you look carefully at the parts list you wrote out, you'll see some holes:

Case: Already sold out and this deal does not happen regularly.
CPU: Only good if you have a Fry's nearby. Dell Deals are for anyone in the U.S.
CompUSA: Only good if your CompUSA isn't closed already. Also how many times can a store close? So this deal happens not that often.
 
I just built a new system for my brother-in-law for $1100-$1200. We configured a system at dell, then wen't shopping at newegg. I was able to get him a much better videocard, twice as much ram, and a faster processor by building it ourselves. But I would say that a grand is the cutoff. Much less than that, and, from my experience, you're better off buying a prebuilt.
 
Your statement about DIY PCs is always cheaper is true if you add the following words at the end:



For the regular work PCs where the most you'll do on it is word processing and web browsing, prebuilt PCs will generally be cheaper than DIY However, if you're talking about a gaming PC, the building it yourself will always be cheaper than prebuilt.
That PC I linked is hardly a gaming rig. Nice try.

Dell Deals happen regularly.
Browse the Deals subforum, deals on ALL parts happen regularly.

Case: Already sold out and this deal does not happen regularly.
CPU: Only good if you have a Fry's nearby. Dell Deals are for anyone in the U.S.
CompUSA: Only good if your CompUSA isn't closed already. Also how many times can a store close? So this deal happens not that often.
Let's not forget the fact that my cheaper system was also superior in many ways.
Case: the regular price is $15 more and B-stock cases at Antec are always available.
CPU: then go to a microcenter or hit any of a dozen websites that list similar deals every week. Again, you guys obviously don't browse the deals page often
CompUSA, you're right, CompUSA's don't close every day and that was a one time deal but look around, screaming deals on non Dell bloated OS's pop up every day.

Again, every time I offer some sort of proof to back up my statements you guys hem and haw and make excuses. DIY's are always cheaper, always. You point to a deal in March, I'll point to a Deal in May. Read the Deals forum, there are far more deals on component parts than there are proprietary systems. Take in the fact that future upgrades from DIY systems are that much cheaper in the long run the difference only gets greater. It's a matter of staying on top of the deals page and taking some time to piece it together. It's not that hard but apparently some people aren't good at building systems on a budget. You guys are the Dell Marketing Department's wet dream. I've proved my point here, good luck with your build OP.
 
But I would say that a grand is the cutoff. Much less than that, and, from my experience, you're better off buying a prebuilt.

I would say 500 dollars is the cutoff. There are some pretty crappy 700 dollar systems out there. Most of them are Sony. :D One of my buddy's got a Vaio... I literally laughed at the system specs. :D
 
Excuse my post but you were such a piece of work I couldn't let this rest. I'm not sure why you have so much sand up your privates but it's really unbecoming man and does nothing but hurt the board.

Antec NSK4400 - $26.99

Corsair DDR 667 - $37
4400 X2 x/ nforce 6100 mobo - $98.99
19" widescreen Samsung w/ DVI - $175
160 gb WD - $45.81
Vista Home Basic upgrade - $20
Pioneer DVD Burner - $30

Total:
$433.79

So for less money I got you a faster processor, superior DVD burner vs your DVDROM drive (sorry, I had soooo much money left over I splurged), better PSU (the most important component of any build IMO), non-proprietary build that saves money on upgrades in the long run, a widescreen monitor with half the response time AND with DVI as opposed to your analogue, and I still have room left over to either upgrade the video card, sound card, water cool, or , if you continue to be an ignorant parts snob, you could even do as everyone on here does and hock the motherboard on ebay and buy a new one which would STILL come in for less than your deal. The name of the game with building is patience and if you bought that Dell a few weeks before the AMD price drops it's your own damn fault. Now, do yourself a favor and crawl back into whatever hole you came from and let this topic rest.

Antec NSK4400 - $26.99
look at the link...the deal is dead, and u are travelling to ohio to buy the case?
--------------------------------------------------------------------
4400 X2 x/ nforce 6100 mobo - $98.99
This deal is dead man.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
19" widescreen Samsung w/ DVI - $175
last post was on 28/3
--------------------------------------------------------------------
i wouldnt touch a refurbished hard drive
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Vista Home Basic upgrade - $20
edit: nevermind
---------------------------------------------------------------------

Browse the Deals subforum, deals on ALL parts happen regularly
nah, not really...
 
look at the link...the deal is dead, and u are travelling to ohio to buy the case?
last post was on 28/3
edit: nevermind
Take a look at enginurd's price reference post. That deal's been dead for months. My links were posted around the general time frame his deal was active and was an example of how a cheaper system could be built over an acceptable period of time. Next time think before you post.

i wouldnt touch a refurbished hard drive
Why not? Nevermind, I don't care what you think. The fact is the normal price of the drive is only a few dollars more.....oooohhh, WAY overbudget :rolleyes:

nah, not really...
Bwahahaha, ok, whatever. Both enginurd's deals and mine were found on the deals subforum....2-0 deals page.
 
i hate involving myself in those stupid debates. yes i obviously didnt know u were comparing to engi's old post...anyways, he posted the deal on 27/3/07. lets look at the starting dates of the components u listed

Antec NSK4400 - $26.99 (11/5/07)
Corsair DDR 667 - $37 (8/5/07)
4400 X2 x/ nforce 6100 mobo - $98.99 (18/4/07)
19" widescreen Samsung w/ DVI - $175 (20/12/06) okay :)
160 gb WD - $45.81 (current pricing)
Vista Home Basic upgrade - $20 (7/5/07) and the guy was lucky to get it at that price
Pioneer DVD Burner - $30 (current pricing)


and besides, u mentioned a windows vista UPGRADE, which afaik requires xp to be already installed. thats an extra $90 on your budget...or at the least buy windows vista home basic oem for $90. so now your build actually costs 434-20+90=$503, even with the 'new' prices. uh btw, u forgot to include the KB+mouse, the shipping costs...going through the tiresome building process, and troubleshooting any troubles u face by yourself
 
and besides, u mentioned a windows vista UPGRADE, which afaik requires xp to be already installed. thats an extra $90 on your budget...or at the least buy windows vista home basic oem for $90. so now your build actually costs 434-20+90=$503, even with the 'new' prices. uh btw, u forgot to include the KB+mouse...and the shipping costs too
If he's posting on this forum he's able to upgrade Vista so no, he doesn't need to buy XP on top of that :rolleyes: As far as the monitor, yes, that's an old deal but if you don't like it get a standard 19" LCD, still heads and shoulders above the one in his deal, for that price all day long on Newegg. I also didn't add shipping because he didn't ad tax which Dell's website often ads not to mention ZZF has free shipping and at any given time NE had free shipping codes posted on the Deals page. As far as KB and mouse, again, he's posting here so I doubt he needs it....it's not like Dell's mice and keyboards are anything special but if you're going to nitpick your way to the bank feel free to downgrade my DVD-R drive to a DVD-ROM like the Dell has and use the extra money to get a mouse. The bottom line is for less than Dell's price you're getting a better PSU, better monitor, better memory, non proprietary motherboard, unbloated OS, etc etc. I'm absolutely dumbfounded that we're still having this conversation at this point. Again, the bottom line is I was told I couldn't build for less than that Dell system using quality parts and it's obvious that if I were in the market for a computer at the time of that deal I would have. End of discussion.
 
To quell the debate I should also note that I already have a 19'' flat panel and a legit version of XP :)
 
Oh wow, you think you beat it?! Congratulations! Now do it without the price drop. Use deals around the time of the Dell deal, not deals from MAY, lol. Besides, a refurb HDD is worse than a dell, not better nor equal. Abu's right, you need to add the price of a full version of windows, too.

It doesnt matter what "HE" needs, what matters is whats included in the dell deal, lol. The dell doesnt include an UPGRADE, it includes a FULL version. Ad that to the mix, and you're still wrong, even with your refurbed HDD and no KB/mouse (which the dell deal includes, too, lol).

We're all just laughing at your inability to just admit that you can't always beat a dell deal, lol. You keep trying so hard, but you just cant. Poor Blown, he's dumbfounded. :( You don't realize that, for the most part, you're right... but its that one word that fuct your statement... "always."
 
No. That RAM is only good for overclocking, which you say you won't do. So there's no point to buy that set. Next, most mobos perform the same, at least in the eyes of the average persion, at stock speeds. So there's no point in going with a non-overclocking board when there is an overclocking board thats of the same price and allows to attain some pretty sweet overclocks.

So stick with your current shopping list now but wait for ATI's DX10 cards.
 
Wouldn't it be cheaper to get a non-sli board?
Or is a none-sli gonna run be about the same?

Also this is the exact words of my friend who said about using an ati video card with an nvidia chipset.

Also keep in mind… if you have an nvidia nforce you ideally want to use an nvidia card because then your mobo doesn’t have to spend an extra clock cycle for each instruction to convert from an ati instruction to nvidia.. and you can’t always guarantee a perfect translation.. thus it work as well as an nvidia/nvidia combo or a ati/ati combo.
 
Wouldn't it be cheaper to get a non-sli board?
Or is a none-sli gonna run be about the same?

Also this is the exact words of my friend who said about using an ati video card with an nvidia chipset.

yes but u wont be able to sli on an ati board and vice versa
wait: i read it wrong lol. wut your friend said is bs
 
Wouldn't it be cheaper to get a non-sli board?
Or is a none-sli gonna run be about the same?

Also this is the exact words of my friend who said about using an ati video card with an nvidia chipset.

They're roughly the same price actually.

As for your friend's statement, it's still false. For one thing, Nvidia and ATI cards have to use the same instructions or standards otherwise neither will work well with Intel, Nvidia, or ATI chipsets. Even if what your friend says is true, the extra clock cycle will be totally unnoticiable and even with the same chipsets a perfect translation isn't guaranteed to happen. And yes what your friend said is BS.
 
You keep trying so hard, but you just cant.
Considering that I just listed a complete build around the time of your Dell deal I'd say the only one who's making an ass of himself is you. My proof just a few posts up

Now do it without the price drop.
Haha. Your unbeatable Dell deal was just a few weeks before the price drops, anyone who couldn't wait three weeks to buy a system is an idiot.
 
Haha. Your unbeatable Dell deal was just a few weeks before the price drops, anyone who couldn't wait three weeks to buy a system is an idiot.
lmao

just for kicks, i actually made a very decent $500AR build (i was bored lol)
$59 - AMD Athlon 64 X2 3600+ Brisbane 1.9GHz 2 x 512KB L2 Cache Socket AM2 Processor - OEM
$19 - ARCTIC COOLING Freezer 64 Pro CPU Fan For AMD CPU
$80 - BIOSTAR TFORCE 550 Socket AM2 NVIDIA nForce 550 MCP ATX AMD Motherboard - Retail (LESS $10MIR)
$45 - WINTEC AMPO 1GB (2 x 512MB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory - Retail
$73 - BFG Tech BFGW6600GTOCX GeForce 6600GT 128MB 128-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 Video Card - OEM (LESS $40MIR)
$55 - Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 ST3160815AS 160GB 7200 RPM 8MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - OEM
$34 - LITE-ON Black 16X DVD+R 8X DVD+RW 8X DVD+R DL 16X DVD-R 6X DVD-RW 12X DVD-RAM 16X DVD-ROM 48X CD-R 32X CD-RW 48X CD-ROM 2MB Cache SATA DVD Burner with Replaceable White Front Panel - Retail
$148 - 18.1" LCD Flat Panel Display w/ Speakers - Black (LESS $60MIR)
$90 - windows xp home / vista basic
$17 - Microsoft CA9-00001 Black 103 Normal Keys 3 Function Keys PS/2 Standard Basic Keyboard and Mouse Included - OEM
-----------------------------------------------------------------
$620 - $110MIR = $510 + shipping and taxes
-----------------------------------------------------------------

the 3600+ should oc to 2.4GHz at the least, and might reach 3GHz
the only components left are the case + psu, which can be bought for free AR when one of those deals comes around. engi is gonna hate me for that one...
 
Considering that I just listed a complete build around the time of your Dell deal I'd say the only one who's making an ass of himself is you. My proof just a few posts up

Regardless of when those deals were, you still didnt add a full version of windows to your build, therefore, you proved me right. Yes, I'm an ass for getting a kick out of debating the meaning of the word, "always," with some guy who has no clue as to what it means.

Haha. Your unbeatable Dell deal was just a few weeks before the price drops,

And yet you couldn't beat it without the price drops!!! Which proves my point: it is NOT ALWAYS cheaper to build it yourself than to buy a good Dell DEAL. You really need to go back to grammar school and learn what "always" and "never" mean.

anyone who couldn't wait three weeks to buy a system is an idiot.

This statement, alone, qualifies you as an idiot. I had a coworker leaving for the UK in one week. Why would he wait 3 weeks to order something if he won't even be there to receive it? FYI, prices in the UK are far more expensive than here. You're trying to tell me he's an idiot for ordering that dell deal before he left? You really have no clue, do you? LOL. This is so hilarious. You should be on that 5th grader TV show!!! Just unsubscribe already, like you said you would. I'm tired of trying to teach you the meaning of the word, "always."




Also this is the exact words of my friend who said about using an ati video card with an nvidia chipset.

Also keep in mind… if you have an nvidia nforce you ideally want to use an nvidia card because then your mobo doesn’t have to spend an extra clock cycle for each instruction to convert from an ati instruction to nvidia.. and you can’t always guarantee a perfect translation.. thus it work as well as an nvidia/nvidia combo or a ati/ati combo.

Wow, where did your friend read this? I'd love to see the review of this, to see if he misinterpretted it wrong or something. Regardless of the motherboard brand, all devices work off of drivers. These drivers allow your CPU to send instructions to your GPU. The motherboard chipset is irrelevant, because, as Danny mentioned, everything conforms to a standard instruction set.
 
Regardless of when those deals were, you still didnt add a full version of windows to your build, therefore, you proved me right.
The OP has a working copy of XP as does just about everyone and their mothers right now, there's no need to buy a full version of Vista when the upgrade does the EXACT SAME THING.

Yes, I'm an ass for getting a kick out of debating the meaning of the word, "always," with some guy who has no clue as to what it means.
So far you've done an absolutely terrible job of proving your point.

And yet you couldn't beat it without the price drops!!! Which proves my point: it is NOT ALWAYS cheaper to build it yourself than to buy a good Dell DEAL. You really need to go back to grammar school and learn what "always" and "never" mean.
The price drops happened three weeks after your Dell deal you retard. It's not like we're talking 6 month time spans. Building a DIY will ALWAYS, repeat A-L-W-A-Y-S be cheaper and I've proved my point by building a system a measly three weeks later for less that Dell. building systems has been, and always will be, about patience and deal hunting.....I stated that in my first damn post Mr. "Nobody But Me Understands English."

You're trying to tell me he's an idiot for ordering that dell deal before he left?
Yes, that's exactly what I'm telling you.

Like I said, I've offered you proof numerous times and you've retaliated with nothing but insulting backtalk. You should re-evaluate your approach before you tell people they should be on a 5th grader tv show. Judging by the lack of any real argument on your part I'm starting to think the only thing you're concerned with at this point is having the last word. Somehow, in your mind, that makes you right I guess.
 
I've been hearing that a lot of motherboards still have trouble with Vista.
What are the common issues and is there a way to find out of a motherboard is compatible or not.
 
We keep going in circles now. Its simple:
your build + full version of XP costs more than the dell deal.

The price drops happened three weeks after your Dell deal you retard. It's not like we're talking 6 month time spans. Building a DIY will ALWAYS, repeat A-L-W-A-Y-S be cheaper and I've proved my point by building a system a measly three weeks later for less that Dell.

Last I checked, 3 weeks is longer than 1 week. If someone was leaving for the UK in one week, your suggestion to him would be to wait 3 weeks? :rolleyes: LOL.

Yes, DIY for the most part could be cheaper, but its NOT ALWAYS cheaper. You already proved that for me with your build minus full xp version. At that point in time... that instance... it was NOT cheaper, and therefore the word "always" cannot be applied. Its as simple as that. Do you need a dictionary? Until you post something new that can prove that fact wrong, I won't respond. Going in circles is useless.

I've been hearing that a lot of motherboards still have trouble with Vista.
What are the common issues and is there a way to find out of a motherboard is compatible or not.

Most vista problems are driver related. The good thing about this is, since its software, the manufacturers can continue to work on the drivers until a stable version is out. And even if there were a hardware incompatibility, they would replace the hardware if was rather new and within warranty. FYI, most boards come with a 3+ yr warranty.
 
The OP has a working copy of XP as does just about everyone and their mothers right now, there's no need to buy a full version of Vista when the upgrade does the EXACT SAME THING.
the OP also had a KB, a mouse, a monitor, a dvd-rom drive (who doesnt nowadays?)....a whole computer actually. otherwise he wouldnt have been able to post in these forums. if he upgraded from the the xp he already has, his old rig will not have an OS, right?

The price drops happened three weeks after your Dell deal you retard. It's not like we're talking 6 month time spans. Building a DIY will ALWAYS, repeat A-L-W-A-Y-S be cheaper and I've proved my point by building a system a measly three weeks later for less that Dell. building systems has been, and always will be, about patience and deal hunting.....I stated that in my first damn post Mr. "Nobody But Me Understands English."
regardless of wut was going on by then (i wasnt there), there are further price drops next month from intel. people, however may not have the patience to wait that long....

We keep going in circles now. Its simple:
your build + full version of XP costs more than the dell deal.

Yes, DIY for the most part could be cheaper, but its NOT ALWAYS cheaper. You already proved that for me with your build minus full xp version. At that point in time... that instance... it was NOT cheaper, and therefore the word "always" cannot be applied. Its as simple as that. Do you need a dictionary? Until you post something new that can prove that fact wrong, I won't respond. Going in circles is useless.

enginurd: u managed to limit his argument by forcing him to a certain specific build 2 months ago. blown89, however does have a point
$59 - AMD Athlon 64 X2 3600+ Brisbane 1.9GHz 2 x 512KB L2 Cache Socket AM2 Processor - OEM
$19 - ARCTIC COOLING Freezer 64 Pro CPU Fan For AMD CPU
$80 - BIOSTAR TFORCE 550 Socket AM2 NVIDIA nForce 550 MCP ATX AMD Motherboard - Retail (LESS $10MIR)
$45 - WINTEC AMPO 1GB (2 x 512MB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory - Retail
$73 - BFG Tech BFGW6600GTOCX GeForce 6600GT 128MB 128-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 Video Card - OEM (LESS $40MIR)
$55 - Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 ST3160815AS 160GB 7200 RPM 8MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - OEM
$34 - LITE-ON Black 16X DVD+R 8X DVD+RW 8X DVD+R DL 16X DVD-R 6X DVD-RW 12X DVD-RAM 16X DVD-ROM 48X CD-R 32X CD-RW 48X CD-ROM 2MB Cache SATA DVD Burner with Replaceable White Front Panel - Retail
$148 - 18.1" LCD Flat Panel Display w/ Speakers - Black (LESS $60MIR)
$90 - windows xp home / vista basic
$17 - Microsoft CA9-00001 Black 103 Normal Keys 3 Function Keys PS/2 Standard Basic Keyboard and Mouse Included - OEM
$0 - Free AR case and PSU
-----------------------------------------------------------------
$620 - $110MIR = $510 + shipping and taxes
-----------------------------------------------------------------
now please link me to any $500 deal offered by dell or any other builder that outperforms my setup. u most probably wont.
so wut have i proved so far? at the $500 range, DIY CAN outperform a dell setup if tweaked properly.
now on to the second part: find me the cheapest build available at dell with an lcd monitor........................ not so far from the $500 mark, huh? also worth noting that at this price range, u would be much better off buying used components, right?

btw, this is discussion is getting quite ridiculous, dont u think? nobody round here is intending to buy a low-end $500 system atm.
 
So I'm thinking of going Nvidia and getting BFG Tech BFGR88320GTSOC2E GeForce 8800GTS 320MB 320-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 Video Card

Any thoughts on this card and any other DX10 card for that matter?

This is what I want from my video card

I would rather get a DX10 Nvidia card, but maybe I don't need one for what I want to do.

I'm a big gamer, but I never go all out on the settings (this is probably because my other cards and PC builds couldn't handle it)

The resolution I play on is usually 1280x1024, but I would go a bit higher on my new system build since it would be able to manage it, I doubt I would do anything close to 1600x1200. The only 2 games I have lined up to play when I get my new PC is World of Warcraft and Spider-Man 3, but I very much plan on getting new games as they are coming out. I might get things like FEAR and other high end games now since I can play them well.
 
I'm a very impulsive buyer, but with something as expensive as this I'm taking my time.

I'm 100% sure on every component except the motherboard.

Motherboard: I'm really liking the Commando, but I'm searching through the lists for another mobo maybe a little cheaper that's just as good. Since I don't care about OCing...

This is as narrowed down as I can get it
Narrowed down list

Basically I need another confirmation that:

1. "Yes get the Commando and stop asking already"
2. "This motherboard <insert motherboard here> is cheaper and while it isn't made for OCing runs very well"

I commend you for lasting through my barrage of questions :)
 
Ok what exactly do you need in a motherboard? Please list everything.
 
SATA Raid 0
4+ USB ports
Will not OC
Will not use SLI
IEEE would be nice, not that important
Onboard LAN and audio, I've read a few reviews of boards where the audio is bad or produces static. I don't plan on a audio card, so it should work well.

That's about it, let me know of any other things you need to know.
 
First of all, OC motherboards are getting so cheap these days that one does not ahve to settle with a non-OC board. In some cases, the OC mobos are cheaper than their Non-OC brethren. Second, just because you have an OC mobo doesn't mean you HAVE to OC. It's just a little option in case you do want to OC in the future.

So with that in mind, I still recommend either the DS3 from clubit.com for $116 or this mobo: EVGA 122-CK-NF66-T1 NVIDIA nForce 650i Ultra Motherboard - $110

The only problem with these boards is lack of firewire. If you really need Firewire, then go with Asus P5B-E for $146. NOTE: That means you're paying an extra $30 for a single firewire port. when you can get a cheap Firewire add-on card for about $9 to $15 that comes with two or more Firewire ports. Take your pick.
 
So I finally purchased the build and after a few hiccups I got it up and running.
So far it runs like a dream, I've only tried Spider-Man 3 at fairly high settings and it runs as fast as the lowest settings.

Thank you to everyone who helped me in this thread.
 
Well, it seems as though it is cheaper to build your own than to get a pre-built.
I just ordered parts for 3 machines from newegg and compared them to similiarly equipped Dells and the ones I built are much cheaper with the same specs.
PC 1 & 2 are identical Intel E4300 based machines with 1 gig of ram, Win XP Pro SP2 OEM, $1078 shipped for both from newegg. the same configured ones from Dell was $1890 with tax (free shipping).

PC 3 is a medium performance gaming machine, E6400 based with Asus mobo, 8600GTS 256meg, 2Gig DDR800, WinXP Pro SP2 OEM. $975 shipped from newegg, and $1940 with tax (free shipping) from Dell.
 
I'm sorry enginurd but after reading this entire thread you've, A) Made a 2 page post into a 6 page post. B) Proved nothing. C) Kinda looked like a clownpenis.

That being said Dell makes crappy parts and I would take a ECS board over a dell board any day. Oh and the ECS board will have infinite more options then the dell's boards because, well because dell has none! Just please leave this shit for Halo 2 xbox live or Guild Wars team speak.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top