Gateway,HP or Dell?

AMDude

Limp Gawd
Joined
Nov 30, 2005
Messages
188
Which do you think have the best overall product and performance? Just trying to get ideas for future reference.

Thanks
 
i would say hp. Dell used to make great computers back in the day. now they are trash.
 
One good thing about hp and some gateway models is that if it fucks up you can take it to someone in town to fix insted of staying on the phone with tech support to have them mail you a part. HP has the program called rapid repair(at compusa, not sure if other places do it) where for there desktops they let the store pull store stock to do a lot of the repairs. It was nice to have them put a brand new hard drive off the floor in my friends hp media center insted of ordering a refurb from hp. Made me feel better as I hate refurb drives. Gateways warranty seems to be more limited as many stores can only work on gateway towers that were sold in retail but it is still something to consider. One thing I really like about hp too is if something breaks out of warranty you can order the part off hps web site. This is a bigger plus for notebooks as there parts are harder to come by but with dell you have to call a parts line and order it. I like being able to get a part number off hps website with there price then I can search around to see if I can find it cheaper. I hate calling dell on the phone and trying to get a price. Personaly I would go with HP followed by Gateway with Dell holding up the rear.
 
We've tested Gateway and Dell.

Gateway has scored an 8.5/10 and 8.9/10 vs. Dell's 4/10.
 
I would like to point out that it is possible to get Athlon 64 and X2 processors with HP systems.
 
Yeah, I don't like Dell.....in my experience, their tech support is horrible.....my in-laws bought one of those really cheap models (the 400-500 dollar ones) with Windows XP, celeron processor,and 128mb of RAM....they ended up calling tech support because their computer was slow.....the tech told them to defrag the drive......Basically I snuck in a 512mb stick and the problem was solved. I'd suggest Emachines over any of those, to be totally honest.
 
swatbat said:
HP has the program called rapid repair(at compusa, not sure if other places do it) where for there desktops they let the store pull store stock to do a lot of the repairs.

we do this at best buy as well for desktops, Compaq, Hp, Emachines, Gateway. We just pull a comparable part from the sales floor and install it. For laptops we only do harddrives, half the time the customer ends up getting a larger hdd cause at least at my store we only carry 60gb and 100gb drives, so if you got a 40 you get a 60, got a 80 you get a 100
 
Javelin3o4 said:
we do this at best buy as well for desktops, Compaq, Hp, Emachines, Gateway. We just pull a comparable part from the sales floor and install it. For laptops we only do harddrives, half the time the customer ends up getting a larger hdd cause at least at my store we only carry 60gb and 100gb drives, so if you got a 40 you get a 60, got a 80 you get a 100

Yea thats what I thought. This is something to consider when getting a machine. It is always nice to get a new part then a refurb.
 
i'd go with gateway. a friend of mine has one of the 9100's and uses it for gaming. i have a 820GM with a 6600GT w/zalman VF700Cu on it, and you should love it for performance. airflow is better in gateway's even though dell uses the btx to but, you ever notice there isn't an exhaust fan on the dells? pretty cheap to me, and i just don't like the layout they used e.g. where they put their hard drives, dumb place to me. gateway's is all tool less, quiet, quite customizable, i've added a new psu, gpu, fans, soundcard, speakers, mouse, keyboard, and i've almost had it a year. so, based on my gateway experience, even with their service, you can chat online with them for free which i've used many times to ask questions, i'd go with gateway.
 
HP/Compaq always gets a bump in my book for providing *OPTIONS* with their processors. For just about everything but laptops, I go with AMD. Since neither Gateway nor Dell give me that option they are generally excluded when I recommend systems to people.
 
Actually, for GAMING computers, all of these companies are thoroughly OUTCLASSED by some of the boutique system builders; in price, performance, support and repair. If you want a budget system, look at these three and make your choice acccording to what is the best value at the time. If you want a superior (and cheaper) gaming system look at some of the boutique companies that put performance (Monarch, Puget) above marketing (Voodoo, Alienware). Do your homework and don't assume that bigger will get you more for your dollar.

Also, remember that every component that Dell and the others buy is purchased primarily on price. The price is significantly impacted by expected mean time to failure. They expect that a certain percentage of the CPUs, PSUs, HDDs, etc they buy WILL FAIL before the warranty expires. As long as the failure rate is below the expected replacement and support budget, they don't care. Will you when it is your motherboard that fails?
 
my warranty on my gateway from a year expired and it's still running fine. they use western digital hard drives, intel cpus, and intel motherboards. :confused:
 
Back
Top