Gaming Store Showdown: Steam vs. GOG

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
Here’s a write-up that compares the strengths and weaknesses of each. In an unfair world where you were only allowed to use one service, which one would you pick?

For years, Steam has been the only game (ha) in town for buying games and managing your library. Last year, though, GOG introduced its own library client called GOG Galaxy. Both platforms are aiming to be a general purpose, multi-publisher library with a whole surrounding community.
 
GOG does essentially what everyone wishes all online game shops would do, they just don't have nearly the selection as Steam unfortunately. I always try to get the GOG version of a game when it's an option.
 
GOG does essentially what everyone wishes all online game shops would do, they just don't have nearly the selection as Steam unfortunately. I always try to get the GOG version of a game when it's an option.

Yep in many ways GOG is better, but if I had to "pick one" it would have to be Steam because they have a much better selection of newish games. They probably always will too. I doubt most developers are just going to give up on DRM.
 
Both are better then exclusives like Origin and Uplay though right?

Origin is surprisingly not-terrible. The UI isn't entirely awful, and the client generally stays out of the way of actually playing games. If it weren't for the intrinsic negative of it being an EA service, I'd say there's actually less to complain about than there is with Steam

uPlay, on the other hand, is a complete dumpster fire. Sluggish UI slathered with so much achievement and uPlay Point nonsense as to render it impenetrable, and shoddily coded such that its overly is suspect number one when a Ubisoft game crashes on start. Also, Ubisoft.
 
Yep in many ways GOG is better, but if I had to "pick one" it would have to be Steam because they have a much better selection of newish games. They probably always will too. I doubt most developers are just going to give up on DRM.

Exactly. Most major developers will never release their games DRM free. GOG is great for indie and classic games, but for AAA titles, we'll have to go to the likes of Steam and Origin.
 
To me, I rate them in order:

1. Steak (selection and massive sales)
2. GOG (DRM free and decent sales)
3. UPlay (lots of game franchises that interest me like Splinter Cell and Far Cry)
4. Origin (always last, because that what EA deserves based on their conduct)
 
I like both, but prefer GOG because it has a vast library of older classics that Steam doesn't, and GOG games tend to be DRM free. I have noticed that a lot of older games that GOG acquires eventually turn up on Steam and Origin, but it seems like GOG's the one making the effort to acquire those licenses and optimize the games so that they run on modern hardware and operating systems
 
I don't like how GOG installs stuff, but I do like that it's drm free, and also don't require you to keep a connection. Steam is blocked at work, and I hibernate a lot, so when I turn on my laptop at work, it asks for a refresh, when I wish it would just keep disconnected until it can connect or auto switch to offline mode.
 
Actually, I probably don't like how steam does it either, but since I can see how GoG does it, it bothers me more.
 
Galaxy looks interesting. For small things normal browser downloads are fine, but for huge games I prefer something like Steam. Auto patching and hopefully cloud saves will make it better. Didn't fully read the article, maybe it has a cloud save option. Finding game save locations is a pain these days.
 
Actually I have no problems with origin, it works well.

I can't say the same about uplay however. That seems like it was put together haphazardly just for the sake of being. It serves no purpose whatsoever, over it's own existence, it's just there to annoy me. I mean when you download a game from uplay it downloads the damn 1.00 version that was on the first print. And then you have to download all the incremental patches one by one. The damn thing doesn't even checks for an update for your games, to discover there is a patch you have to start the game itself. As I said it has no purpose.
 
Ah yes I am always watching and waiting for the Christmas Steak sale, nothing better than bargain or indy steaks.

Steam for me as it has worked well and been reliable for many years with lots of nice features.
GoG is ok but Ustankplay and Origin are completely off my buy list, to many other good choices to be fooling with there cr@p.
 
I would hope everyone who has heard of GOG goes to GOG first to get their games, and then checks Steam if they can't find what they want.

Origin and UPlay don't count.
 
My major gripe with both is EARLY ACCESS games.
There needs to be some oversight on the part of Steam and GOG.
Many of these games are rip-off, and they may look good in the advertisement videos, they fail as a playable game. Yes, you are signing up for a game in the works; but they end up in the works for YEARS.
Because there is NO pressure on the developers to deliver anything, give them an out to deliver nothing or just plain crap.
I would LOVE to see a notice saying "Steam has stopped distribution of GameX because development is behind schedule" Or something like that.

If there was a filter setting to BLOCK early access games when browsing steam; It would be set to BLOCK them. When the game is completed, I would be ready to buy.
 
I love steam and I've never used gog and I don't plan to start now.
 
My major gripe with both is EARLY ACCESS games.
There needs to be some oversight on the part of Steam and GOG.
Many of these games are rip-off, and they may look good in the advertisement videos, they fail as a playable game. Yes, you are signing up for a game in the works; but they end up in the works for YEARS.
Because there is NO pressure on the developers to deliver anything, give them an out to deliver nothing or just plain crap.
I would LOVE to see a notice saying "Steam has stopped distribution of GameX because development is behind schedule" Or something like that.

If there was a filter setting to BLOCK early access games when browsing steam; It would be set to BLOCK them. When the game is completed, I would be ready to buy.

I agree with you but the early access games in steam are clearly marked. I just don't buy them
 
F DRM! Just yesterday I found out GFWL will no longer install correctly on Win8.1, then there is Microsoft all of a sudden deciding Securom is a security risk. Microsoft have robbed me of some of my games so I will now forever despise them and grudgingly use Windows. Yea, I have Linux installed too already.
 
I looked at that launcher app but why is that better than my categorized Start menu, which is free?
 
I agree with you but the early access games in steam are clearly marked. I just don't buy them

I've purchased 1 early on and got burned. That was StarForge.

But there are a lot of them on there and if you read the players comments you will see again and again, the game is crap, they are not fixing the bugs, the promised content has not been delivered on . Some will say there has been no update in years.

You are beholding to the developers to deliver what they promised but there is NOTHING concrete accept honesty on their part that will make them deliver it.
Sadly many of the people starting Early Access games are piss poor at game development and cannot deliver on what they promised.
What would be a GOOD thing is when Steam or GOG sees this trend, they put marketing and distribution on hold until they start delivering on their promises.
 
This whole premise is asinine. GoG and Steam play nicely, there is no reason to debate which is better, aside from internet lulz. I prefer GoG for their lack of needed client and DRM free titles, but wont complain if I have to use Steam instead.
 
Back
Top