Gaming Server Project

Mith

Weaksauce
Joined
Nov 3, 2004
Messages
68
Hello,

My clan has been running our own game server for about the last 3 years, but sadly new games have started encroaching on it's limit. A couple weeks ago we noticed that a 26 man red orchestra server took 50% of our cpu, which was a little bit scarry. Everything is running fine now, and I think we could last for at least another six months. But we'd like something that is a bit more future proof. We've had the luxury for a long time of being able to host any game we want on a dedicated server anytime we want. Though now as games are becoming more and more demanding we are realizing that our server wont be able to cut it for much longer. Basically it looks like we're going to need to build from the bottom up, as it's not worth upgrading the current setup for a minimal gain.

Now we can't afford the best of the best, but we do want something that will last us for at least another 3 years+. Price range is in the neighborhood of $1200<, anywhere between 800 -1k would be optimal

I personally do not have any experience building servers, but have built many desktops. I'm assuming that they aren't very different. However I'm not clear on what the difference in the parts are. Xeon vs Core2 Duo, ECC memory ect...
So what I have been doing is piecing together desktops that I thought might run well as server.

What we we're looking for is:

Case: looking at rackmounts 2u would be preferable
Motherboard: Server or desktop? It's hard to find desktop boards with onboard video
Memory: 2gigs of ddr2 667 or 800?
Hard Drives: We don't need much storage. 250-300gb would be enough SATA II. Going to raid 1 them for data protection.
Processor: Would prefer Intel as their new line of CPU's have proven to be very nice. Xeon of some sort or Core2 Duo e6600?
Video Card: Not needed unless the mobo doesnt have onboard video
PSU: I'm assuming we wont need as much power as a desktop seeing as there wont be a video card. Still I'm not sure how much power we will need.

Like I said this is for a gaming server, so we dont need storage and we don't need a video card. The current server is running 2 cpu's. Would one dual core cpu be comparible? I don't believe that we have the money to go Dual CPU this time. I know I'm leaving out some info, but I can't think of anything else atm. Any and all help would be really appreciated.

Thanks
Mith
 
Motherboard= GIGABYTE GA-7DPXDW-P
cpu's= AMD Athlon MP 2600+ (2 of em)
memory= 2 gigs (1 gig x2) PC2100 ECC DDR
Hard Drives= 2 WD Caviar IDE 7200 RPM 80 Gig
cd drive
floppy drive
2 U rackmount case
vantec tornado fans
 
This what you need to focus on when you are trying to replace a server or if you think you need to.

Run performance system monitor and run a log for the CPU and the ram. Find out what is getting pegged out

Based on what you find, you base your upgrades on that.

Since your budget is so low, might as well forget about Xeons.

Think about the future, not today.
 
Hard Drives: We don't need much storage. 250-300gb would be enough SATA II. Going to raid 0 them for data protection.


You want to RAID 1 (mirror) them for data protection. RAID 0 is striping.

If this thing is only going to be a server, get server hardware. Take a look at some TYAN boards and see if you like any of them, then find a processor to match the board. If you're serious about your uptime, you'll also want to invest in a redundant PSU to fit in your 2U.
 
Honestly check Dell Buisness. They have some awsome server deals from time to time. A duel Xenon system with a gig of ram for 600. On board video all of that. It wasn't rack mount but heck.. that's just a chassi and airflow and power... hrm.. well maybe they will have a good rackmount design too?
 
Do you guys have any suggestions on a good 2u rackmount?

This is what I have so far:

CPU: http://www.newegg.com/product/product.asp?item=N82E16819117103
Mobo: http://www.newegg.com/product/Product.asp?item=N82E16813131136
Memory: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16820134337
PSU: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16817104157
HD's: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16822144417
Case: Need some advice here. I don't know who makes good rackmount servers.
W/O case comes in at $933.38 shipped

Do you think that just the one CPU would be enough to do what we wanted for a while, or would a dual cpu setup be a more viable.

Thanks
 
what kind of activity does you recieve on the server now?

what is the max amount of connections?

what games do you play?
 
If you guys are serious, then look @ Dell rackmount servers the 1U 860 starts @ $700 with a celeron. It jumps up to about $1000 with a dual core xeon.
 
We host our website, FTP, TS, 3-5 Call of duty Servers, a red orchestra server, and a raven shield server. But most of these are usually empty until we all hop on them for public play or matches. When we get on there can be anywhere between 15-20 players on them.
 
Poweredge 860 1u

Dual Core Intel® Pentium®D 915, 2.8GHz, 2x2MB Cache, 800MHz FSB

2GB DDR2, 533MHz, 2x1GB Dual Ranked DIMMs

On-Board Dual Gigabit Network Adapter, No TOE

Add-in SAS5iR (SATA/SAS Controller) which supports 2 Hard Drives - RAID 1

Duel 80 gig sata II drives.

Your looking at 1246 from Dell.
 
We would honestly rather build it then jump through hoops with dell. Putting it together and taking it to the data center would be no problem.
 
Case: Need some advice here. I don't know who makes good rackmount servers.

Do you think that just the one CPU would be enough to do what we wanted for a while, or would a dual cpu setup be a more viable.

Thanks


Supermicro, iStar, and Antec would all be good choices. You can probably find a nice case with a decent non-redundant PSU included for 200-250.

Do you want a dual CPU setup or a single CPU with dual core? They are not the same thing. A single Xeon will do just fine for your purposes but I think a dual-core proc will give you the most bang for the buck and take you at least a few years into the future.
 
Do you want to dual CPU setup or a single CPU with dual core? They are not the same thing. I think a dual-core proc will give you the most bang for the buck and take you at least a few years into the future.

That is what I have been wondering. So it would give us better performance with 2 separate CPU's? If so could you suggest processors/motherboard?

On another note, is the redundant PSU absolutely necessary, and are we going to need over 400 watts to power this thing?
 
That is what I have been wondering. So it would give us better performance with 2 separate CPU's? If so could you suggest processors/motherboard?

On another note, is the redundant PSU absolutely necessary, and are we going to need over 400 watts to power this thing?
I'm pretty sure redundant power supplies are fail over, not additional power. Meaning if one fails, the other one is there supplying the power needed to keep the machine running.
 
That is what I have been wondering. So it would give us better performance with 2 separate CPU's? If so could you suggest processors/motherboard?

On another note, is the redundant PSU absolutely necessary, and are we going to need over 400 watts to power this thing?

Dual proc used to be the way to go, but you'd be better off with a dual core these days. More compact, single HSF, etc.

I'm pretty sure redundant power supplies are fail over, not additional power. Meaning if one fails, the other one is there supplying the power needed to keep the machine running.

On the money. It's basically two PSUs, but only one provides power at any given time. If the primary fails or underpowers, the backup takes over without your server crashing. It's not a necessary thing, and they aren't cheap, but if your server is running 24/7 it's a good failsafe.
 
Ok so going with the setup I mentioned earlier, would it be better to go with the Xeon 3050 or with a C2D e6600. Would the e660 give me more bang for my buck with the 4mb L2 cache? Besides the e660 seems to be identical to the Xeon 3060 which happens to be out of stock. It just seems like I would be paying for the Xeon name.
 
On the money. It's basically two PSUs, but only one provides power at any given time. If the primary fails or underpowers, the backup takes over without your server crashing. It's not a necessary thing, and they aren't cheap, but if your server is running 24/7 it's a good failsafe.

Does it tell you when you've lost one? Otherwise how do you know when one has gone down?
 
Ok so going with the setup I mentioned earlier, would it be better to go with the Xeon 3050 or with a C2D e6600. Would the e660 give me more bang for my buck with the 4mb L2 cache? Besides the e660 seems to be identical to the Xeon 3060 which happens to be out of stock. It just seems like I would be paying for the Xeon name.

If this will be a server only, Xeon 3060 is the server-grade version of the E6600, which means it's more error tolerant and it runs cooler. For the extra 10 bucks or so I'd say go with the Xeon.
 
A standard ATX PSU isn't meant for rackmount cases. It's best if you get at 2U PSU to match. i-Star, Chenbro, Antec, Supermicro. I'm sure there are others but these are the ones I know. Take your pick.
 
Back
Top