Gaming only, HyperThreading @ 4600mhz or 5000 MHz without?

Marcdaddy

2[H]4U
Joined
Feb 21, 2003
Messages
3,636
Guys my friend and I have a disagreement, I'm running my 2600k @ 5000 MHz no HyperThreading he is at 4600 MHz with it on, So better with it or without, gaming only and the only thing benefiting is 3dmark and that's a benchmark.
 
Im not familiar with really any game on the market that can use more than 4 cores, so the extra 400 MHZ would def be the better deal.
 
Doesn't really matter either way TBH. Personally I'd leave it on and stick with 4600 MHz though. With that said though it's not like you're really gimping yourself with a 4 core i7 beast running at 5 GHz
 
It's going to depend on the game. If the game is more sensitive to the CPU, then higher speed will help. However, as with most modern games, the GPU is the ultimate determining factor in game performance and player experience.

There are almost no games right now that can take advantage of either more than four cores or Hyperthreading, so whomever has the stronger GPU will get better gaming performance.
 
I'd imagine with a 400Mhz difference you're not going to make a big difference either which way. As for which is better that all depends on the game as DejaWiz already said. Something like Battlefield 4 may give HT a boost, while a game like SC2 would take a hit.

I remember feeling like a badass doing my first 1Ghz OC on a quad core (Q9550) and the performance boost was utterly disappointing. Can't imagine it has got much better, in fact probably will continue to get worse as IPC improvements are the only thing pushing performance. Clock rate isn't really a factor unless we were talking Stock w/ HT vs OC'd w/No HT.
 
Oh, wait, can he get a better overclock by turning it off?

What's the real debate? I think 5GHz vs 4.6 in a game the proc speed will help more than HT ever would, and I'm surprised anyone would even consider that debateable. I do think I score a little higher in 3dmark with HT on, but having it on or off doesn't make my chip more or less overclockable.
 
To the OP it will depend entirely of the game as mentioned.. some games will love HyperThreading as Crysis 3 (mentioned in the below link).. and some will just hate it as battlefield 4.. BTW in your Triple SLI setup HT its really beloved, in the past when i was in Tri-SLI of 660TI in general most games simply loved Hyperthreading not only for performance mode but as a fluidity in games.. so who can tell you if worth hyperthreading ON at 4600mhz or hyperthreading OFF at 5000mhz, well.. only you can really know that answer how? test it.. you have at 4600mhz then just disable hyperthreading for a couple of days and do son everyday task + everyday gaming and you will immediately notice the changes..

I'd imagine with a 400Mhz difference you're not going to make a big difference either which way. As for which is better that all depends on the game as DejaWiz already said. Something like Battlefield 4 may give HT a boost, while a game like SC2 would take a hit.

I remember feeling like a badass doing my first 1Ghz OC on a quad core (Q9550) and the performance boost was utterly disappointing. Can't imagine it has got much better, in fact probably will continue to get worse as IPC improvements are the only thing pushing performance. Clock rate isn't really a factor unless we were talking Stock w/ HT vs OC'd w/No HT.

you are kinda wrong.. not in those days, but in actually days the scalability with CPU speeds (specially after Sandy bridge) its just GREAT.. specially talking with heavy CPU games like Crysis 3, BF4 and so on... Check the Crysis 3 behavior with CPU speeds

Oh, wait, can he get a better overclock by turning it off?

What's the real debate? I think 5GHz vs 4.6 in a game the proc speed will help more than HT ever would, and I'm surprised anyone would even consider that debateable. I do think I score a little higher in 3dmark with HT on, but having it on or off doesn't make my chip more or less overclockable.

since the first gen i7 its very known that at the moment you disable Hyper threading the chip will drawn less voltage thats mean higher overclockability, its a way to reach higher speeds by using the same amount of voltage than a lower speed + hyperthreading..
 
Well... depends on the video card, game and resolution. But my gut says it doesn't matter, and the heat output you'll save by disabling HT will be good for all that overclocking.
 
I think the only game that benefits from HT is BF4.

Even if you had 4600 with HT/on. I still think you would have higher framerate @ 5000mhz.

I run my 6core @ 4.6ghz HT off. I see no point in it.

Just my 0.02c

P.S. If you are still running Tri-Sli 780's at that high rez, then 5ghz is more benficial. If you really want more cores go with a 6core.
 
OFF. The higher clock speed is obviously better unless I'm mistaken all your cores are running at 5000mhz? Where hyperthreading is one core being sped up? Why would it be better to have all your cores running slower? That is assuming you want raw speed.

EDIT-looks like I may be a little off in my understanding of HT but based on what I've read as answers I still think 5000mhz would be the way to go.
 
I think the only game that benefits from HT is BF4.

Even if you had 4600 with HT/on. I still think you would have higher framerate @ 5000mhz.

I run my 6core @ 4.6ghz HT off. I see no point in it.

Just my 0.02c

P.S. If you are still running Tri-Sli 780's at that high rez, then 5ghz is more benficial. If you really want more cores go with a 6core.

Why did you decide to turn it off though? You see no point... then why not leave it on?
Something made you decide to turn it off... less heat? More stable OC? What was the reason you said "I think I'll turn this off"?
 
Why did you decide to turn it off though? You see no point... then why not leave it on?
Something made you decide to turn it off... less heat? More stable OC? What was the reason you said "I think I'll turn this off"?

Because in some games HT lowers performance, Also it uses more volts to run, and causes more heat.
 
The reason I turn it off is I can get a higher stable overclock with less Voltage and less hear, I'm at 5 Ghz on air too. He is stuck at 4.6 even after turning his HyperThreading off he is hitting a wall. I actually think my BF4 plays smoother with it off and the extra 400 MHz is probably helping my 3 780s breath ( they are at 1180 core ) doing some testing games are higher FPS , know I get to hear from him that I'm wasting the CPUs potential without HP. Funny thing is I've had this chip since the Launch of it and didn't realize I could get a much better OC turning it off until about 6 months ago. I'm going to see if I can get another 200 MHz out of it. I'm sitting at 1.4 volts, idle 34c , load while gaming 60c to 64c.
 
The reason I turn it off is I can get a higher stable overclock with less Voltage and less hear, I'm at 5 Ghz on air too. He is stuck at 4.6 even after turning his HyperThreading off he is hitting a wall. I actually think my BF4 plays smoother with it off and the extra 400 MHz is probably helping my 3 780s breath ( they are at 1180 core ) doing some testing games are higher FPS , know I get to hear from him that I'm wasting the CPUs potential without HP. Funny thing is I've had this chip since the Launch of it and didn't realize I could get a much better OC turning it off until about 6 months ago. I'm going to see if I can get another 200 MHz out of it. I'm sitting at 1.4 volts, idle 34c , load while gaming 60c to 64c.

If you are 5ghz @ 1.4v with 64c max....Well you still have more headroom. I was at my wall on my 2700k @ 5ghz with 1.45v.

Also it will depend on the motherboard as well. Some do not like to go above the 50x multi.

Good luck and overclock more!
 
Thanks DASHIT, I just got back home and im gonna reboot know and go to 5100 Mhz and up the Voltage, Whats the max Load Temps?
 
Thanks DASHIT, I just got back home and im gonna reboot know and go to 5100 Mhz and up the Voltage, Whats the max Load Temps?

My personal limit is 80c. Some say 75c, some say 90c. Also Real temp shows your limit of how hot you can get before you throttle too. I think its 100c.
 
I'd rather have the extra threads than 400Mhz

In certain programs I would I agree. For gaming, It usually does nothing or lowers your performance (other then BF4 and maybe BF3).

I do know a dualcore Intel with HT would benefit from it though.
 
In certain programs I would I agree. For gaming, It usually does nothing or lowers your performance (other then BF4 and maybe BF3).

I do know a dualcore Intel with HT would benefit from it though.

4.6GHz vs 5GHz isn't going to give you a noticeable increase in gaming performance

HT on vs off isn't going to give you a noticeable decrease in performance in games that can't use it HT well

HT on vs off can give you an appreciable difference in fps consistence in games that can, particularly in multi-gpu setups.

My preference is to keep it on. IMO it does more good than harm.
 
4.6GHz vs 5GHz isn't going to give you a noticeable increase in gaming performance

HT on vs off isn't going to give you a noticeable decrease in performance in games that can't use it HT well

HT on vs off can give you an appreciable difference in fps consistence in games that can, particularly in multi-gpu setups.

My preference is to keep it on. IMO it does more good than harm.

It would give you more performance if you are running 3 780's and running eyefinity/surround. So you are wrong in that aspect.

Marcdaddy is running 3 780's and surround so 400mhz will help his framerate, otherwise he would be CPU limited.
 
It would give you more performance if you are running 3 780's and running eyefinity/surround. So you are wrong in that aspect.

Marcdaddy is running 3 780's and surround so 400mhz will help his framerate, otherwise he would be CPU limited.

As would HT in games that can use more than 4 threads. So you're wrong in that respect.

We can nitpick all day about special case scenario where one of us would be wrong, it matters not.

I'd rather have the additional thread capacity, that may not be the best solution for you and that's perfectly fine. I'm not trying to change yours or anyone else's mind. HT on is my configuration preference for my personal computers.
 
In certain programs I would I agree. For gaming, It usually does nothing or lowers your performance (other then BF4 and maybe BF3).

I do know a dualcore Intel with HT would benefit from it though.

Nope.. In fact.. Battlefield 3 and 4 hate hyper threading in multiplayer mode in pure performance.. BF3 and BF4 like more cores yes, it like more threads for performance? Nope.. Now in terms of smooth gaming, hyper threading help from night to day, really shinning in multi GPU setups... For single GPU does not really matter.. But from 2 to 3 gpus HT its a great benefit to enjoy a better gaming experience (Check the link i've posted above and read a bit over hyperthreading in BF3 and BF4 i cant repost now bc im on my phone ATM)..
 
Nope.. In fact.. Battlefield 3 and 4 hate hyper threading in multiplayer mode in pure performance.. BF3 and BF4 like more cores yes, it like more threads for performance? Nope.. Now in terms of smooth gaming, hyper threading help from night to day, really shinning in multi GPU setups... For single GPU does not really matter.. But from 2 to 3 gpus HT its a great benefit to enjoy a better gaming experience (Check the link i've posted above and read a bit over hyperthreading in BF3 and BF4 i cant repost now bc im on my phone ATM)..

Funny in this link http://www.anandtech.com/show/6934/choosing-a-gaming-cpu-single-multigpu-at-1440p/5

It shows hardly any increase between a 2500k and 2600k. And in some cases the 2500k doing better then the 2600k.

Like Ramon said nit picking.
 
Nope.. In fact.. Battlefield 3 and 4 hate hyper threading in multiplayer mode in pure performance.. BF3 and BF4 like more cores yes, it like more threads for performance? Nope.. Now in terms of smooth gaming, hyper threading help from night to day, really shinning in multi GPU setups... For single GPU does not really matter.. But from 2 to 3 gpus HT its a great benefit to enjoy a better gaming experience (Check the link i've posted above and read a bit over hyperthreading in BF3 and BF4 i cant repost now bc im on my phone ATM)..

Thats essentially what I was getting at as well. I played around with BF4 and HT and found the frames to be far more consistent with HT on even if the maximum frames were essentially the same. GPU utilization chart across my 680's was much closer to a straight line vs having a lot of peaks and valley's with HT off.
 
Thats essentially what I was getting at as well. I played around with BF4 and HT and found the frames to be far more consistent with HT on even if the maximum frames were essentially the same. GPU utilization chart across my 680's was much closer to a straight line vs having a lot of peaks and valley's with HT off.

It also depends on your OS.

http://www.hardocp.com/article/2013...ows_7_vs_81_performance_review/5#.UzkRmKi-2Cc

I am running windows 7. It is possible HT helps in Win 8.1 with BF4.

Of course it all depends on the program or game. Like you said nit picking.
 
Back
Top