Gaming at custom resolution: works only sometimes?

euskalzabe

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
May 9, 2009
Messages
1,478
I've been using a 40" 4K TV as my monitor for the past couple years. It's a good middle ground between 16/9 or productivity and 21/9 forced resolution for gaming. I set the Nvidia Control Panel to scale the aspect ratio on the GPU and override any other instruction, and most of the time 2560x1080 works perfectly fine:

DOOM
upload_2018-8-23_18-28-33.png

MEA
upload_2018-8-23_18-28-58.png

However, in some games this doesn't work. Most mysteriously, these are games that I know support 21/9. The panel clearly has no issue forcing 2560/1080 or any other sub-4K 21/9 resolution. And yet, Assassin's Creed Syndicate and Shadow of the Tomb Raider don't work properly on my custom ultrawide resolution: they look weirdly squished. Both these games support 21/9 so why wouldn't it just render a nice 21/9 image with proper aspect ratio:

Squishing in ACS:
upload_2018-8-23_18-28-42.png

Squishing in STR:
upload_2018-8-23_18-28-50.png

Anyone has any ideas as to what's going on? I prefer the flexibility of 16/9-21/9 for work/play plus the 4K definition of text, and the 6000:1 contrast ration of my TV's VA panel, but I'd contemplate buying a cheap 29" ultrawide this next black friday just so I can play these games in the ultrawide aspect ratio.
 
Strange. I tried to test it myself, but this new TV I got doesn't handle custom resolutions well, either that or something is messed up with AMD drivers or Windows.

I can select 3840x1620 (not custom, it came with the TV) but if I run games it's locked at 30fps. Also contributing, the TV always shows as running at full 3840x2160 @ 60Hz.

A recent Windows update disables setting the TV to resolutions directly, unless at common ones like 1080p or 1440p. If you set a 21:9 custom resolution, the "active signal resolution" in Windows is still 3840x2160.

I tried for a weekend to disable this "feature" Microsoft added and I found no way to disable it. I think if I could set the TV resolution directly it would work, not whatever funny business Windows is doing behind the scenes.

Not sure if this has anything to do with what you're seeing, but it might be.
 
Last edited:
Have you tried messing around with the scaling settings in the NVIDIA control panel?
I've been using a 40" 4K TV as my monitor for the past couple years. It's a good middle ground between 16/9 or productivity and 21/9 forced resolution for gaming. I set the Nvidia Control Panel to scale the aspect ratio on the GPU and override any other instruction, and most of the time 2560x1080 works perfectly fine:

DOOM
View attachment 98516

MEA
View attachment 98519

However, in some games this doesn't work. Most mysteriously, these are games that I know support 21/9. The panel clearly has no issue forcing 2560/1080 or any other sub-4K 21/9 resolution. And yet, Assassin's Creed Syndicate and Shadow of the Tomb Raider don't work properly on my custom ultrawide resolution: they look weirdly squished. Both these games support 21/9 so why wouldn't it just render a nice 21/9 image with proper aspect ratio:

Squishing in ACS:
View attachment 98517

Squishing in STR:
View attachment 98518

Anyone has any ideas as to what's going on? I prefer the flexibility of 16/9-21/9 for work/play plus the 4K definition of text, and the 6000:1 contrast ration of my TV's VA panel, but I'd contemplate buying a cheap 29" ultrawide this next black friday just so I can play these games in the ultrawide aspect ratio.
Assassin's Creed and Tomb Raider are being stretched horizontally, not squished vertically. It is still using the 16:9 aspect ratio. Try aspect ratio scaling on the video card instead of the display for these games.
 
I used to do something similar, except I would create custom resolutions of 3840x1260 for example and force 1:1 in the NVidia display settings... never had a problem. I would think aspect ratio would work just as good.

If you try 1:1 but still use 2560x1080, does it still squish? Obviously it won't be playable that way, but might indicate that it's at least a windows / nvidia issue and not the game.
 
Strange. I tried to test it myself, but this new TV I got doesn't handle custom resolutions well, either that or something is messed up with AMD drivers or Windows.

AMD drivers may be at fault. I had an RX480 and I constantly had trouble forcing 21/9 on any 16/9 display, it's pretty much the reason I sold it - for a profit, during the mining craze - and got a 1060 instead. NCP has an option to override any program's settings.

Try aspect ratio scaling on the video card instead of the display for these games.

Sorry, I thought I had mentioned that in my original post. I'm already using NCP for this:

upload_2018-8-24_9-41-59.png

That's actually what makes it so strange - it should work right. It does in some games, and others like ACS and STR it doesn't. I can't explain it, as everything's setup correctly.

If you try 1:1 but still use 2560x1080, does it still squish?

I'm not sure I follow. You mean to set it to No scaling? Which I guess would give me a 2560x1080 box in the center of the screen. I'll try it.
 
AMD drivers may be at fault. I had an RX480 and I constantly had trouble forcing 21/9 on any 16/9 display, it's pretty much the reason I sold it - for a profit, during the mining craze - and got a 1060 instead. NCP has an option to override any program's settings.



Sorry, I thought I had mentioned that in my original post. I'm already using NCP for this:

View attachment 98768

That's actually what makes it so strange - it should work right. It does in some games, and others like ACS and STR it doesn't. I can't explain it, as everything's setup correctly.



I'm not sure I follow. You mean to set it to No scaling? Which I guess would give me a 2560x1080 box in the center of the screen. I'll try it.
What happens if you try display scaling, instead?

Yes, that is what he means. Trying to eliminate any other factors like Microsoft constantly messing with the WDDM.
 
I'm not sure I follow. You mean to set it to No scaling? Which I guess would give me a 2560x1080 box in the center of the screen. I'll try it.
Yes this would be the result. I suspect if you still see the squishing then it's the game and not NVidia / windows.
 
What happens if you try display scaling, instead?

I've tried display scaling and no scaling. Overriding the application's preference and not doing so. It all looks the same to me, stretched. Unless I've forgotten what correct human proportions look like, or I'm seeing things, this can't be right:


upload_2018-8-24_11-0-57.png

DSC_2310.jpg
 
I've tried display scaling and no scaling. Overriding the application's preference and not doing so. It all looks the same to me, stretched. Unless I've forgotten what correct human proportions look like, or I'm seeing things, this can't be right:


View attachment 98791

View attachment 98792
Nope, that is definitely stretched. Try disabling fullscreen optimization for the games' executables. Find the executable and go into its properties on the Compatibility tab and check that option.
 
Nope, that is definitely stretched. Try disabling fullscreen optimization for the games' executables. Find the executable and go into its properties on the Compatibility tab and check that option.

OK good, so at least I'm not crazy. Thanks for the suggestion, I hadn't thought of doing any of that. I tried all these options in a variety of combinations:

upload_2018-8-24_12-37-9.png

Nothing. It all looks stretched. DX11, DX12, it doesn't matter (I thought maybe the new API was giving problems. Nope). I'm at a complete loss. I can also confirm it is not the TV/display, because I just plugged in an actual monitor and the same stretching happens.

There's no reason I can think of for this. Any other ideas to try?
 
OK good, so at least I'm not crazy. Thanks for the suggestion, I hadn't thought of doing any of that. I tried all these options in a variety of combinations:

View attachment 98816

Nothing. It all looks stretched. DX11, DX12, it doesn't matter (I thought maybe the new API was giving problems. Nope). I'm at a complete loss. I can also confirm it is not the TV/display, because I just plugged in an actual monitor and the same stretching happens.

There's no reason I can think of for this. Any other ideas to try?
It's got to be game-specific. Assassin's Creed Syndicate has a "Stretching" parameter in the config file. Do you know what that does?
 
I've been using a 40" 4K TV as my monitor for the past couple years. It's a good middle ground between 16/9 or productivity and 21/9 forced resolution for gaming. I set the Nvidia Control Panel to scale the aspect ratio on the GPU and override any other instruction, and most of the time 2560x1080 works perfectly fine:

Anyone has any ideas as to what's going on? I prefer the flexibility of 16/9-21/9 for work/play plus the 4K definition of text, and the 6000:1 contrast ration of my TV's VA panel, but I'd contemplate buying a cheap 29" ultrawide this next black friday just so I can play these games in the ultrawide aspect ratio.

From my own past experience having to set custom resolutions for triple monitor setups, often times there is a display config ini file for the game that you have to go in and specifically edit. Even then it is not a fool proof method.
 
It's got to be game-specific. Assassin's Creed Syndicate has a "Stretching" parameter in the config file. Do you know what that does?

Already tried enabling and disabling, no effect, sadly.

Yes, if you haven't you'll want to make friends with the Widescreen Gaming Forum.
http://www.wsgf.org

I thought that was more for actual 21/9 monitors, but it may be worth another look. Last time I tried something like flawless widescreen I could not figure it out.
 
Yeah, some games will require Flawless Widescreen to work, or at least a manual ini config change. To the game it looks the same as an actual 21:9 screen so it should require the same tricks.
 
Already tried enabling and disabling, no effect, sadly.



I thought that was more for actual 21/9 monitors, but it may be worth another look. Last time I tried something like flawless widescreen I could not figure it out.
Some newer games are getting the aspect ratio from the display instead of the requested resolution, so you need to tell it otherwise. Other than that, there are fixes for all widescreen issues out there on that site. One of the most common issues with 16:9 is games using Vert-, and I use WSGF and their resources to resolve these issues all the time. On a side note, I do not agree with their new designation of "Vert+" for games that are "developed" for 16:9 but add vertical fov for narrower aspect ratios.
 
Some newer games are getting the aspect ratio from the display instead of the requested resolution, so you need to tell it otherwise.
Yeah, that's what I was talking about. Open Displays in Windows and click Advanced display settings.

upload_2018-8-27_19-52-45.png


Microsoft changed this a few months ago with an update, notice the Desktop resolution (21:9) is not the same as the Active signal resolution. This is what is causing me problems.
 
Yes, if you haven't you'll want to make friends with the Widescreen Gaming Forum.
http://www.wsgf.org

Hey, so I did try to check WSGF like you suggested, and turns out, ROTR is known for this kind of squishing bug. There's a whole thread of people complaining about the same thing that I see, with different aspect ratios. Good to know, because I was starting to think the TV was more limited in resolution for some reason and was contemplating getting a cheap $200 29" ultrawide just to sidestep this kind of issue. Clearly it's the game. So, your suggestion just saved me $200 :D I'm really trying to avoid getting a new monitor until I can get 29/34" ultrawides with %95 DCI-P3 for less than $400 (I've given up on HDR on the PC, it's a mess that seems like it'll take a while to sort out... I can enjoy HDR on the PS4 meanwhile, which just works).

So, mystery solved. When the custom res doesn't work, it's the game's fault, not windows or the display (at least in my case). #themoreyouknow :)
 
Back
Top